Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bulletin of the American Physical Society

Applying Model Selection to Quantum State Tomography: Choosing Hilbert Space Dimension

Travis L. Scholten

Published Mar 5, 2015• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Related papers

Lost in (Hilbert) Space - Model Selection for Quantum Tomography.

Travis L. Scholten, Robin Blume-Kohout

•Feb 1, 2015•0 citations

Behavior of the maximum likelihood in quantum state tomography

Travis L. Scholten, Robin Blume-Kohout

Quantum state tomography on a d-dimensional system demands resources that grow rapidly with d.They may be reduced by using model selection to tailor the number of parameters in the model (i.e., the size of the density matrix).Most model selection methods typically rely on a test statistic and a null theory that describes its behavior when two models are equally good.Here, we consider the loglikelihood ratio.Because of the positivity constraint ρ0, quantum state space does not generally satisfy local asymptotic normality (LAN), meaning the classical null theory for the loglikelihood ratio (the Wilks theorem) should not be used.Thus, understanding and quantifying how positivity affects the null behavior of this test statistic is necessary for its use in model selection for state tomography.We define a new generalization of LAN, metric-projected LAN, show that quantum state space satisfies it, and derive a replacement for the Wilks theorem.In addition to enabling reliable model selection, our results shed more light on the qualitative effects of the positivity constraint on state tomography.Determining the quantum state ρ 0 produced by a specific preparation procedure for a quantum system is a problem almost as old as quantum mechanics itself [1,2].This task, known as quantum state tomography [3], is not only useful in its own right (diagnosing and detecting errors in state preparation), but is also used in other characterization protocols including entanglement verification [4-6] and process tomography [7].A typical state tomography protocol proceeds as follows: many copies of ρ 0 are produced, they are measured in diverse ways, and finally the outcomes of those measurements (data) are collated and analyzed to produce an estimate r ˆ.This is a straightforward statistical inference process [8,9], where the data are used to fit the parameters of a statistical model.In state tomography, the parameter is ρ, and the model is the set of all possible density matrices on a Hilbert space  (equipped with the Born rule).However, we do not always know what model to use.It is not always a priori obvious what , or its dimension, is; examples include optical modes [10-14] and leakage levels in AMO and superconducting [15,16] qubits.In such situations, we seek to let the data itself determine which of many candidate Hilbert spaces is best suited for reconstructing ρ 0 .Choosing an appropriate Hilbert space on the fly is an instance of a general statistical problem called model selection.Although model selection has been thoroughly explored in classical statistics [17], its application to state tomography encounters some obstacles.They stem from the fact that quantum states-and therefore, estimates of them-must satisfy a positivity constraint ρ0.(See figure 1.) A similar constraint, complete positivity, applies to process tomography.The impact of positivity constraints on state and process tomography is an active area of research [18][19][20][21], and its implications for model selection have also been considered [22][23][24][25][26][27][28].In this paper, we address a specific question at the heart of this matter: How does the loglikelihood ratio statistic used in many model selection protocols, including (but not limited to) information criteria such as Akaike's AIC [29], behave in the presence of the positivity constraint ρ0?We begin in section 1 by introducing the loglikelihood ratio statistic λ, and outline how it can be used to choose a Hilbert space.In section 2, we show how and why the classical null theory for its behavior, the Wilks theorem, falls apart in the presence of the positivity constraint, because quantum state space does not generally satisfy local asymptotic normality (LAN).We define a new generalization of LAN, metric-projected local asymptotic normality (MP-LAN), in section 3; this generalization explicitly accounts for the positivity constraint, and is satisfied by quantum state space.Using this generalization, we derive a closed-form approximation for λʼs expected value in section 4, thereby providing a replacement for the Wilks theorem that is

arXiv:1609.04385•New Journal of Physics•Feb 23, 2018•23 citations

Complex-Hilbert Rigidity under Solèr, Local Tomography, and Standard Composition A Conditional MTT Reconstruction Theorem

Peter Nero

Solèr's theorem classifies an orthomodular generalized Hilbert space containing an infinite orthonormal sequence as a real, complex, or quaternionic Hilbert space. This classification does not by itself select the complex field. We add a separate finite-composition requirement: a system of dimension d over the selected field has the full self-adjoint matrix space as its unnormalized state/effect space; a composite of dimensions a and b has dimension ab over the same field; and independent product effects are tomographically complete. The resulting dimension identity holds for complex Hermitian matrices and fails, by explicit nonzero defects, for real symmetric and quaternionic Hermitian matrices whenever a and b are both greater than one. Complex Hilbert space is therefore rigid within this declared reconstruction class. The conclusion is conditional and representation-sensitive: complex quantum theory can be realified by adjoining an orthogonal complex-structure operator, and alternative composite rules fall outside the theorem. Applied to MTT, the result identifies exact missing premises rather than deriving them. The current q79 finite quantum model and finite complex polarization are compatible with the complex branch, but MTT has not yet sourced the required infinite orthogonality and standard locally tomographic composition from one physical upper construction.

•Jan 21, 2026•0 citations

Enhancing quantum state tomography: utilizing advanced statistical techniques for optimized quantum state reconstructions

A Jenefa, Edward Naveen VijayaKumar, Manoranjitham Rajendran +5 more

Journal of the Korean Physical Society•Aug 1, 2024•3 citations

Efficient quantum state tomography

M. Cramer, Martin Bodo Plenio, Steven T. Flammia +6 more

arXiv:1101.4366•Nature Communications•Dec 21, 2010•734 citations

Experimental characterization of quantum processes: A selective and efficient method in arbitrary finite dimensions

Quimey Pears Stefano, Ignacio Perito, J. J. M. Varga +2 more

The temporal evolution of a quantum system can be characterized by quantum process tomography, a complex task that consumes a number of physical resources scaling exponentially with the number of subsystems. An alternative approach to the full reconstruction of a quantum channel is the selective and efficient quantum process tomography, a method that allows estimating, individually and up to the required accuracy, each element of the matrix that describes the process, using only a polynomial amount of resources. The implementation of this protocol is closely related to the possibility of building a complete set of mutually unbiased bases (MUBs), whose existence is known only when the dimension of the Hilbert space is the power of a prime number. However, an extension of the method that uses tensor products of maximal sets of MUBs has been recently introduced. Here we explicitly describe how to implement the algorithm for a selective and efficient estimation of a quantum process in a nonprime power dimension and conduct, an experimental verification of the method in a Hilbert space of dimension $d=6$. This is the smallest space for which a complete set of MUBs is not known to exist, but it can be decomposed as a tensor product of two Hilbert spaces of dimensions ${D}_{1}=2$ and ${D}_{2}=3$, in which a complete set of MUBs is already known. The six-dimensional states were codified in the discretized transverse linear momentum of photons. The state preparation and detection stages are dynamically programed with the use of only-phase spatial light modulators, in a versatile experimental setup that allows one to implement the algorithm in any finite dimension.

arXiv:2011.08228•Physical Review A•May 28, 2021•3 citations
Quantum state tomography on a d-dimensional system demands resources that grow rapidly with d.They may be reduced by using model selection to tailor the number of parameters in the model (i.e., the size of the density matrix).Most model selection methods typically rely on a test statistic and a null theory that describes its behavior when two models are equally good.Here, we consider the loglikelihood ratio.Because of the positivity constraint ρ0, quantum state space does not generally satisfy local asymptotic normality (LAN), meaning the classical null theory for the loglikelihood ratio (the Wilks theorem) should not be used.Thus, understanding and quantifying how positivity affects the null behavior of this test statistic is necessary for its use in model selection for state tomography.We define a new generalization of LAN, metric-projected LAN, show that quantum state space satisfies it, and derive a replacement for the Wilks theorem.In addition to enabling reliable model selection, our results shed more light on the qualitative effects of the positivity constraint on state tomography.Determining the quantum state ρ 0 produced by a specific preparation procedure for a quantum system is a problem almost as old as quantum mechanics itself [1,2].This task, known as quantum state tomography [3], is not only useful in its own right (diagnosing and detecting errors in state preparation), but is also used in other characterization protocols including entanglement verification [4-6] and process tomography [7].A typical state tomography protocol proceeds as follows: many copies of ρ 0 are produced, they are measured in diverse ways, and finally the outcomes of those measurements (data) are collated and analyzed to produce an estimate r ˆ.This is a straightforward statistical inference process [8,9], where the data are used to fit the parameters of a statistical model.In state tomography, the parameter is ρ, and the model is the set of all possible density matrices on a Hilbert space  (equipped with the Born rule).However, we do not always know what model to use.It is not always a priori obvious what , or its dimension, is; examples include optical modes [10-14] and leakage levels in AMO and superconducting [15,16] qubits.In such situations, we seek to let the data itself determine which of many candidate Hilbert spaces is best suited for reconstructing ρ 0 .Choosing an appropriate Hilbert space on the fly is an instance of a general statistical problem called model selection.Although model selection has been thoroughly explored in classical statistics [17], its application to state tomography encounters some obstacles.They stem from the fact that quantum states-and therefore, estimates of them-must satisfy a positivity constraint ρ0.(See figure 1.) A similar constraint, complete positivity, applies to process tomography.The impact of positivity constraints on state and process tomography is an active area of research [18][19][20][21], and its implications for model selection have also been considered [22][23][24][25][26][27][28].In this paper, we address a specific question at the heart of this matter: How does the loglikelihood ratio statistic used in many model selection protocols, including (but not limited to) information criteria such as Akaike's AIC [29], behave in the presence of the positivity constraint ρ0?We begin in section 1 by introducing the loglikelihood ratio statistic λ, and outline how it can be used to choose a Hilbert space.In section 2, we show how and why the classical null theory for its behavior, the Wilks theorem, falls apart in the presence of the positivity constraint, because quantum state space does not generally satisfy local asymptotic normality (LAN).We define a new generalization of LAN, metric-projected local asymptotic normality (MP-LAN), in section 3; this generalization explicitly accounts for the positivity constraint, and is satisfied by quantum state space.Using this generalization, we derive a closed-form approximation for λʼs expected value in section 4, thereby providing a replacement for the Wilks theorem that is
Solèr's theorem classifies an orthomodular generalized Hilbert space containing an infinite orthonormal sequence as a real, complex, or quaternionic Hilbert space. This classification does not by itself select the complex field. We add a separate finite-composition requirement: a system of dimension d over the selected field has the full self-adjoint matrix space as its unnormalized state/effect space; a composite of dimensions a and b has dimension ab over the same field; and independent product effects are tomographically complete. The resulting dimension identity holds for complex Hermitian matrices and fails, by explicit nonzero defects, for real symmetric and quaternionic Hermitian matrices whenever a and b are both greater than one. Complex Hilbert space is therefore rigid within this declared reconstruction class. The conclusion is conditional and representation-sensitive: complex quantum theory can be realified by adjoining an orthogonal complex-structure operator, and alternative composite rules fall outside the theorem. Applied to MTT, the result identifies exact missing premises rather than deriving them. The current q79 finite quantum model and finite complex polarization are compatible with the complex branch, but MTT has not yet sourced the required infinite orthogonality and standard locally tomographic composition from one physical upper construction.
The temporal evolution of a quantum system can be characterized by quantum process tomography, a complex task that consumes a number of physical resources scaling exponentially with the number of subsystems. An alternative approach to the full reconstruction of a quantum channel is the selective and efficient quantum process tomography, a method that allows estimating, individually and up to the required accuracy, each element of the matrix that describes the process, using only a polynomial amount of resources. The implementation of this protocol is closely related to the possibility of building a complete set of mutually unbiased bases (MUBs), whose existence is known only when the dimension of the Hilbert space is the power of a prime number. However, an extension of the method that uses tensor products of maximal sets of MUBs has been recently introduced. Here we explicitly describe how to implement the algorithm for a selective and efficient estimation of a quantum process in a nonprime power dimension and conduct, an experimental verification of the method in a Hilbert space of dimension d=6d=6d=6. This is the smallest space for which a complete set of MUBs is not known to exist, but it can be decomposed as a tensor product of two Hilbert spaces of dimensions D1=2{D}_{1}=2D1​=2 and D2=3{D}_{2}=3D2​=3, in which a complete set of MUBs is already known. The six-dimensional states were codified in the discretized transverse linear momentum of photons. The state preparation and detection stages are dynamically programed with the use of only-phase spatial light modulators, in a versatile experimental setup that allows one to implement the algorithm in any finite dimension.