Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Journal of Physics

The road to matrix mechanics: II. Ladenburg’s quantum interpretation of optical dispersion

L. Crivellari

Published Jun 30, 2016• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract This paper reviews Ladenburg’s development of the phenomenological theory of radiative transitions between the stationary states of an atom put forward by Einstein in 1917. The historical background as well as the far reaching outcomes of his work are considered and discussed; among them the Kramers–Heisenberg quantum dispersion theory that paved the way to Heisenberg’s formulation of matrix mechanics and the quantum-mechanical calculation of the spectral line profiles.

DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/37/5/055405

Related papers

The road to matrix mechanics: I. Classical interpretation of the anomalous optical dispersion

L. Crivellari

Abstract This paper is the first one of a series of two on the role of the optical dispersion in the historical development of early quantum mechanics. As preparation for the successive paper on Ladenburg’s development of the phenomenological theory of radiative transitions between the stationary states of an atom by Einstein, we present here the current theories on optical dispersion between the second half of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century.

European Journal of Physics•Jun 30, 2016•0 citations

Dispersion Theory in the Old Quantum Theory

Anthony Duncan A, Michel Janssen B

Abstract This chapter covers the history of dispersion theory starting from the classical theories of the late nineteenth century, involving charged harmonic oscillators with resonance frequencies at the absorption frequencies of the dispersing materials to account for anomalous dispersion, the phenomenon that the index of refraction decreases rather than increases with frequency around the absorption frequencies. It then covers dispersion theories formulated in the context of the old quantum theory, in which the link between radiation frequencies and orbital frequencies is severed. Drawing on these efforts, especially by Ladenburg and Reiche in the early 1920s, and using Bohr’s correspondence principle and other ingredients of the old quantum theory, Kramers found a successful quantum formula in late 1923. He only published a full treatment of his new dispersion theory in a paper with Heisenberg in early 1925. This paper played a key role in laying the foundations of matrix mechanics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Aug 17, 2023•0 citations

Planck’s radiation law and the Einstein coefficients

R. Loudon

Abstract Another main stream in the initial formulation of the quantum theory was concerned with the interpretation of atomic spectral lines. The interaction of electromagnetic radiation with atoms was discussed by Einstein f4] in 1917. His theory of the absorption and emission of light by an atom depends upon simple phenomenological considerations but it leads to predictions that are reproduced by the more formal quantum mechanics developed later. The use of quantum theory is, of course, essential for even a gross description of the nature of the states of an atom and the theory is outstandingly successful in its ability to predict the finest details of atomic energy-level structures.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 7, 2000•61 citations

Werner Heisenberg’s Path to Matrix Mechanics

Barry R. Masters

In 1925, Werner Heisenberg—through a combination of intuition and sometimes brilliant guesswork, and strongly influenced by the previous works of Einstein, Ladenburg and Kramers—created his inchoate version of quantum mechanics.

Optics and Photonics News•Jul 3, 2014•1 citation

The BKS Theory and the Light-Quantum Hypothesis: Virtual Entities and Transitions to Intermediate States, But in Different Conceptual Frameworks (1923–1925)

Markus Ehberger

Abstract Prior to the development of matrix and wave mechanics, virtual entities figured prominently in the so-called BKS theory. According to some historians, the virtual oscillators of the BKS theory and their mathematical representations are directly connected to the concepts of virtual transitions/states. I will analyse the meaning of the term “virtual” in BKS, discuss the theory’s most important conceptual building blocks and its impact on dispersion theoretic accounts, most importantly the Kramers-Heisenberg paper of 1925. Then I will turn to a development that has nearly faded from sight: Shortly before the development of quantum mechanics, but from a light quantum point of view, physicists developed the idea that scattering and dispersion is composed of successive emission and absorption processes through “intermediate states”. The discussion of both of these strands, BKS and the light-quantum viewpoint, will serve as basis for the further development and for an important question to be answered in the following: Was there a generative connection between virtual oscillators and what came to be known as virtual transitions?

Science networks•Jan 1, 2026•1 citation

Matrix Formulation of Quantum Dynamics

Duojie Jia, Latai You

Quantum mechanics can be formulated either in terms of matrix mechanics or in terms of wave mechanics. This chapter centers on a discussion of the historical origins, mathematical structure, and extension to non-Hermitian quantum theory of matrix mechanics. The development of atomic discrete spectra and the old quantum theory showed that classical mechanics could not account for the discreteness of atomic energy levels and spectral lines, which motivated Heisenberg, Born, Jordan, and others to establish matrix mechanics centered on noncommuting physical quantities. Combining the Bohr atomic model, angular momentum quantization, and radiative transitions, one can see how matrix mechanics describes the energy level structure and quantum transitions of atomic systems, and how the Heisenberg equation of motion gives the fundamental form of quantum dynamics. The example of the harmonic oscillator further shows that the discreteness of the energy spectrum can be obtained directly from the matrix method, thereby establishing a clear connection among transition frequencies, matrix elements, and radiation-induced transitions. The matrix representation corresponds to the operator theory in Hilbert space, where state vectors, inner products, complete bases, and spectral decomposition constitute the fundamental mathematical framework of quantum mechanics. For closed quantum systems, physical observables are generally required to be represented by Hermitian or self-adjoint operators, so as to ensure that their eigenvalues possess the physically acceptable property of being real numbers. The Hermiticity of an operator is also closely related to its domain and boundary conditions, which provides a mathematical possibility for the emergence of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. Based on these discussions, this chapter further explains how non-Hermitian dynamics is connected with open systems, dissipative processes, and special boundary conditions, thereby demonstrating the natural connection between traditional matrix mechanics and modern non-Hermitian quantum theory.

IntechOpen eBooks•Sep 15, 2026•0 citations
Abstract This paper reviews Ladenburg’s development of the phenomenological theory of radiative transitions between the stationary states of an atom put forward by Einstein in 1917. The historical background as well as the far reaching outcomes of his work are considered and discussed; among them the Kramers–Heisenberg quantum dispersion theory that paved the way to Heisenberg’s formulation of matrix mechanics and the quantum-mechanical calculation of the spectral line profiles.
Abstract This chapter covers the history of dispersion theory starting from the classical theories of the late nineteenth century, involving charged harmonic oscillators with resonance frequencies at the absorption frequencies of the dispersing materials to account for anomalous dispersion, the phenomenon that the index of refraction decreases rather than increases with frequency around the absorption frequencies. It then covers dispersion theories formulated in the context of the old quantum theory, in which the link between radiation frequencies and orbital frequencies is severed. Drawing on these efforts, especially by Ladenburg and Reiche in the early 1920s, and using Bohr’s correspondence principle and other ingredients of the old quantum theory, Kramers found a successful quantum formula in late 1923. He only published a full treatment of his new dispersion theory in a paper with Heisenberg in early 1925. This paper played a key role in laying the foundations of matrix mechanics.
Abstract Another main stream in the initial formulation of the quantum theory was concerned with the interpretation of atomic spectral lines. The interaction of electromagnetic radiation with atoms was discussed by Einstein f4] in 1917. His theory of the absorption and emission of light by an atom depends upon simple phenomenological considerations but it leads to predictions that are reproduced by the more formal quantum mechanics developed later. The use of quantum theory is, of course, essential for even a gross description of the nature of the states of an atom and the theory is outstandingly successful in its ability to predict the finest details of atomic energy-level structures.
Abstract Prior to the development of matrix and wave mechanics, virtual entities figured prominently in the so-called BKS theory. According to some historians, the virtual oscillators of the BKS theory and their mathematical representations are directly connected to the concepts of virtual transitions/states. I will analyse the meaning of the term “virtual” in BKS, discuss the theory’s most important conceptual building blocks and its impact on dispersion theoretic accounts, most importantly the Kramers-Heisenberg paper of 1925. Then I will turn to a development that has nearly faded from sight: Shortly before the development of quantum mechanics, but from a light quantum point of view, physicists developed the idea that scattering and dispersion is composed of successive emission and absorption processes through “intermediate states”. The discussion of both of these strands, BKS and the light-quantum viewpoint, will serve as basis for the further development and for an important question to be answered in the following: Was there a generative connection between virtual oscillators and what came to be known as virtual transitions?
Quantum mechanics can be formulated either in terms of matrix mechanics or in terms of wave mechanics. This chapter centers on a discussion of the historical origins, mathematical structure, and extension to non-Hermitian quantum theory of matrix mechanics. The development of atomic discrete spectra and the old quantum theory showed that classical mechanics could not account for the discreteness of atomic energy levels and spectral lines, which motivated Heisenberg, Born, Jordan, and others to establish matrix mechanics centered on noncommuting physical quantities. Combining the Bohr atomic model, angular momentum quantization, and radiative transitions, one can see how matrix mechanics describes the energy level structure and quantum transitions of atomic systems, and how the Heisenberg equation of motion gives the fundamental form of quantum dynamics. The example of the harmonic oscillator further shows that the discreteness of the energy spectrum can be obtained directly from the matrix method, thereby establishing a clear connection among transition frequencies, matrix elements, and radiation-induced transitions. The matrix representation corresponds to the operator theory in Hilbert space, where state vectors, inner products, complete bases, and spectral decomposition constitute the fundamental mathematical framework of quantum mechanics. For closed quantum systems, physical observables are generally required to be represented by Hermitian or self-adjoint operators, so as to ensure that their eigenvalues possess the physically acceptable property of being real numbers. The Hermiticity of an operator is also closely related to its domain and boundary conditions, which provides a mathematical possibility for the emergence of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. Based on these discussions, this chapter further explains how non-Hermitian dynamics is connected with open systems, dissipative processes, and special boundary conditions, thereby demonstrating the natural connection between traditional matrix mechanics and modern non-Hermitian quantum theory.