Creating Cryptographic Challenges Using Multi-Party Computation: The LWE Challenge
Johannes A Buchmann, Niklas Büscher, Florian Göpfert, Stefan Katzenbeisser, Juliane Krämer, Daniele Micciancio, Sander Siim, Christine van Vredendaal, Michael Walter
Practical hardness results are necessary to select parameters for cryptographic schemes. Cryptographic challenges proved to be useful for determining the practical hardness of computational problems that are used to build public-key cryptography. However, several of these problems have the drawback that it is not known how to create a challenge for them without knowing the solutions. Hence, for these problems the creators of the challenges are excluded from participating. In this work, we present a method to create cryptographic challenges without excluding anyone from participating. This method is based on secure multi-party computation (MPC). We demonstrate that the MPC-based approach is indeed feasible by using it to build a challenge for the learning with errors (LWE) problem. The LWE problem is one of the most important problems in lattice-based cryptography. The security of many cryptographic schemes that have been proposed in the last decade is directly based on it. We identify parameters for LWE instances that provide the appropriate hardness level for a challenge while representing instances used to instantiate encryption schemes as close as possible. The LWE challenge is designed to determine the practical hardness of LWE, to gain an overview of the best known LWE solvers, and to motivate additional research effort in this direction.
Practical hardness results are necessary to select parameters for cryptographic schemes. Cryptographic challenges proved to be useful for determining the practical hardness of computational problems that are used to build public-key cryptography. However, several of these problems have the drawback that it is not known how to create a challenge for them without knowing the solutions. Hence, for these problems the creators of the challenges are excluded from participating. In this work, we present a method to create cryptographic challenges without excluding anyone from participating. This method is based on secure multi-party computation (MPC). We demonstrate that the MPC-based approach is indeed feasible by using it to build a challenge for the learning with errors (LWE) problem. The LWE problem is one of the most important problems in lattice-based cryptography. The security of many cryptographic schemes that have been proposed in the last decade is directly based on it. We identify parameters for LWE instances that provide the appropriate hardness level for a challenge while representing instances used to instantiate encryption schemes as close as possible. The LWE challenge is designed to determine the practical hardness of LWE, to gain an overview of the best known LWE solvers, and to motivate additional research effort in this direction.
Since its proposal by Regev in 2005, the Learning With Errors (LWE) problem was used as the underlying problem for a great variety of schemes. Its applications are many-fold, reaching from basic and highly practical primitives like key exchange, public-key encryption, and signature schemes to very advanced solutions like fully homomorphic encryption, group signatures, and identity based encryption. One of the underlying reasons for this fertility is the flexibility with that LWE can be instantiated. Unfortunately, this comes at a cost: It makes selecting parameters for cryptographic applications complicated. When selecting parameters for a new LWE-based primitive, a researcher has to take the influence of several parameters on the efficiency of the scheme and the runtime of a variety of attacks into consideration. In fact, the missing trust in the concrete hardness of LWE is one of the main problems to overcome to bring LWE-based schemes to practice. This thesis aims at closing the gap between the theoretical knowledge of the hardness of LWE, and the concrete problem of selecting parameters for an LWE-based scheme. To this end, we analyze the existing methods to estimate the hardness of LWE, and introduce new estimation techniques where necessary. Afterwards, we show how to transfer this knowledge into instantiations that are at the same time secure and efficient. We show this process on three examples: - A highly optimized public-key encryption scheme for embedded devices that is based on a variant of Ring-LWE. - A practical signature scheme that served as the foundation of one of the best lattice-based signature schemes based on standard lattices. - An advanced public-key encryption scheme that enjoys the unique property of natural double hardness based on LWE instances similar to those used for fully homomorphic encryption.
The Learning with Errors (LWE) problem has been used as a underlying problem of a variety of cryptographic schemes. It makes possible constructing advanced solutions like fully homomorphic encryption, multi linear map as well as basic primitives like key-exchange, public-key encryption, signature. Recently, developments in quantum computing have triggered interest in constructing practical cryptographic schemes. In this thesis, we propose efficient post-quantum public-key encryption and commitment schemes based on a variant LWE, named as spLWE. We also suggest related zero-knowledge proofs and LWE-based threshold cryptosystems as an application of the proposed schemes. In order to achieve these results, it is essential investigating the hardness about the variant LWE problem, spLWE. We describe its theoretical, and concrete hardness from a careful analysis.
Abstract. The Learning with Errors (LWE) problem has gained a lot of attention in recent years leading to a series of new cryptographic applications. Specifically, it states that it is hard to distinguish random linear equations disguised by some small error from truly random ones. Interestingly, cryptographic primitives based on LWE often do not exploit the full potential of the error term beside of its importance for security. To this end, we introduce a novel LWE-close assumption, namely Augmented Learning with Errors (A-LWE), which allows to hide auxiliary data injected into the error term by a technique that we call message embedding. In particular, it enables existing cryptosystems to strongly increase the message throughput per ciphertext. We show that A-LWE is for certain instantiations at least as hard as the LWE problem. This inherently leads to new cryptographic constructions providing high data load encryption and customized security properties as required, for instance, in economic environments such as stock markets resp. for financial transactions. The security of those constructions basically stems from the hardness to solve the A-LWE problem. As an application we introduce (among others) the first lattice-based replayable chosen-ciphertext secure encryption scheme from A-LWE.
With the possibility of quantum computers making an appearance, possibly capable of breaking several well established and widespread crytposystems (especially those that implement public key cryptography), necessity has arisen to create new cryptographic algorithms which remain safe even against adversaries using quantum computers. Several algorithms based on different mathematical problems have been proposed which are considered to be hard to solve with quantum computers. In recent years, a new lattice-based mathematical problem called Learning With Errors (and its variant Ring - Learning With Errors) was introduced, and several cryptosystems based on this problem were introduced, some of which are becoming practical enough to compete with traditional schemes that have been used for decades. The primary focus in this work is the implementation of two Ring - Learning With Errors based schemes (one key exchange mechanism and one digital signature scheme) on the TLS protocol via the OpenSSL library as a way of checking their overall viability in real-world scenarios, by comparing them to classical schemes implementing the same functionalities.
Ever since the appearance of quantum computers, prime factoring and discrete logarithm-based cryptography have been questioned, giving birth to the so-called post-quantum cryptography. The most prominent field in post-quantum cryptography is lattice-based cryptography, protocols that are proved to be as difficult to break as certain hard lattice problems like Learning with Errors (LWE) or Ring Learning with Errors (R-LWE). Furthermore, the application of cryptographic techniques to different areas, like electronic voting, has also nourished a great interest in distributed cryptography. In this work, we will give two original threshold protocols based in the lattice problem R-LWE: one for key generation and one for decryption. We will prove them both correct and secure under the assumption of hardness of some well-known lattice problems. Finally, we will give a rough implementation of the protocols in C to give some tentative results about their viability, in particular our model generates keys in the order of 103 ms and decrypts and encrypts in the order of 102 ms.
The Learning with Errors (LWE) problem is a special average-case lattice problem, which has proved to be as hard as worst-case lattice problems. By this property, it has become the cornerstones for a series of cryptographic applications under the security assumption of worst-case lattice problems. However, the efficiency of these applications are not high. Therefore, how to improve the efficiency of cryptographic applications based on LWE is an urgent problem to be solved. In this paper, a new variant of LWE is proposed. By using trapdoor composed by lattice-based matrix and its dual orthogonal matrix, we construct a more efficient public key encryption (PKE) scheme based on the variant. Furthermore, by the hardness of the variant problem, we prove the new PKE scheme is chosen plaintext attack (CPA) secure. At last, we analyze the homomorphism property of the new PKE scheme.