Abstract. Public key exchange protocol is identified as an important application in the field of public-key cryptography. Most of the existing public key exchange schemes are Diffie-Hellman (DH)-type, whose security is based on DH problems over different group-s. Note that there exists Shor’s polynomial-time algorithm to solve these DH problems when a quantum computer is available, we are therefore motivated to seek for a non-DH-type and quantum resistant key exchange protocol. To this end, we turn our attention to lattice-based cryptography. The higher methodology behind our roadmap is that in anal-ogy to the link between ElGamal, DSA, and DH, one should expect a NTRU lattice-based key exchange primitive in related to NTRU-ENCRYPT and NTRU-SIGN. However, this excepted key exchange protocol is not presented yet and still missing. In this paper, this missing key exchange protocol is found, hereafter referred to as NTRU-KE, which is stud-ied in aspects of security and key-mismatch failure. In comparison with ECDH (Elliptic Curve-based Diffie-Hellman), NTRU-KE features faster computation speed, resistance to quantum attack, and more communication overhead. Accordingly, we come to the conclu-sion that NTRU-KE is currently comparable with ECDH. However, decisive advantage of NTRU-KE will occur when quantum computers become a reality.
Abstract. Public key exchange protocol is identified as an important application in the field of public-key cryptography. Most of the existing public key exchange schemes are Diffie-Hellman (DH)-type, whose security is based on DH problems over different group-s. Note that there exists Shor’s polynomial-time algorithm to solve these DH problems when a quantum computer is available, we are therefore motivated to seek for a non-DH-type and quantum resistant key exchange protocol. To this end, we turn our attention to lattice-based cryptography. The higher methodology behind our roadmap is that in anal-ogy to the link between ElGamal, DSA, and DH, one should expect a NTRU lattice-based key exchange primitive in related to NTRU-ENCRYPT and NTRU-SIGN. However, this excepted key exchange protocol is not presented yet and still missing. In this paper, this missing key exchange protocol is found, hereafter referred to as NTRU-KE, which is stud-ied in aspects of security and key-mismatch failure. In comparison with ECDH (Elliptic Curve-based Diffie-Hellman), NTRU-KE features faster computation speed, resistance to quantum attack, and more communication overhead. Accordingly, we come to the conclu-sion that NTRU-KE is currently comparable with ECDH. However, decisive advantage of NTRU-KE will occur when quantum computers become a reality.
A key exchange protocol is an important primitive in the field of information and network security and is used to exchange a common secret key among various parties. A number of key exchange protocols exist in the literature and most of them are based on the Diffie-Hellman (DH) problem. But, these DH type protocols cannot resist to the modern computing technologies like quantum computing, grid computing etc. Therefore, a more powerful non-DH type key exchange protocol is required which could resist the quantum and exponential attacks. In the year 2013, Lei and Liao, thus proposed a lattice-based key exchange protocol. Their protocol was related to the NTRU-ENCRYPT and NTRU-SIGN and so, was referred as NTRU-KE. In this paper, we identify that NTRU-KE lacks the authentication mechanism and suffers from the man-in-the-middle (MITM) attack. This attack may lead to the forging the authenticated users and exchanging the wrong key.
Cryptographic design and analysis play a key role in securing communication through untrusted channels.This need is even more pronounced with the advent of cloud-centric environments.Symmetric encryption techniques can deliver high computational efficiencies only if the distribution and management of keys are secured.Public key cryptographic systems such as RSA and Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC), which have been the mainstay, are at risk due to arrival of quantum computers that can solve the integer factorization and discrete logarithm problems efficiently.Although post-quantum cryptography has made some breakthroughs, the lattice-based schemes still have to contend with difficulties such as heavy computation requirements, difficulty in choosing parameters, high power consumption, and low security-performance tradeoff.If lattices parameters are not properly set, they may not withstand lattice attacks and computational efficiency will also be degraded, limiting factor for their use in cloud environments.This study, in the quest for a solution, recommends the usage of N-th degree Truncated Polynomial Ring Units (NTRU) cryptosystem which is optimized by adjusting key parameters like lattice dimension (N), modulus (q), and small modulus (p) determining a Hermite factor (𝛿)-based approach.A metaheuristic optimization technique, Electric Eel Foraging Optimization (EEFO), is used to effectively balance security strength, correctness, and computational efficiency.Also, a new cryptographically strong and quantum-resistant key exchange capability is provided by the Improved Supersingular Isogeny Diffie-Hellman (ISIDH) protocol.The experiments have shown method to have an encryption strength of 0.95, an average success rate of 93.47%, and reduced energy consumption of 0.00085, thereby proving its efficiency.
The invention of public-key cryptography (PKC) by Diffie and Hellman in 1976 is one of two milestones marking the beginning of modern cryptography. The security of a PKC system requires that it should be infeasible to compute the private key from a given public key, which in turn is typically guaranteed by the difficulty in solving some cryptographic-friendly mathematical problems. Among those problems, the integer factorization and discrete logarithm problems play pivotal roles in the development of public-key cryptography. In particular, the assumption that there is no polynomial time (classical) algorithm that solves the above two problems constitutes the basis for the security of almost all currently used public-key cryptosystems, such as RSA and ElGamal. However, Shor [1] found an efficient quantum solving algorithm for the integer factorization and discrete logarithm problems in 1994, which would destroy the security basis for most real deployed PKC systems if large-scale quantum computers become available. The rapid development of quantum technology in recent years suggests that we are getting closer to the quantum crisis of current PKC systems. As a response to the quantum crisis, the research community has made many efforts to post-quantum cryptography (PQC) that are believed to resist quantum computer attacks. Lattice-based cryptography is one of the main directions in this area, and has become the most promising PQC candidate for standardization. The research of lattice-based cryptography dates back to the seminal work of Ajtai [2], which first based the security of cryptographic primitives on the difficulty of solving some lattice problems such as the approximate shortest vector problem and the closest vector problem. After more than two decades of development, lattice-based cryptography has gained substantial progress. In theory, we have witnessed the construction of many powerful cryptographic primitives that were not known before. In practice, the public key size of lattice-based cryptosystems has been significantly reduced from several gigabytes to a few kilobytes. For current applications and standardization, key exchanges, public-key encryptions (PKEs) and signatures are the most desired lattice-based cryptosystems, where the first two are often used to ensure information secrecy, while the last provides information authentication. Note that public-key encryptions are equivalent to two-round key exchanges, also known as the key encapsulation mechanism (KEM). In the following, we focus on lattice-based PKEs/KEMs. The design principle of lattice-based PKEs/KEMs follows two approaches: a trapdoor one-way function and an approximate commutative one-way function. In the first approach, a trapdoor one-way function f and its trapdoor f−1 are generated as the public key and private key. A plaintext m is encrypted as c = f(m), and the ciphertext is decrypted as m = f−1(c). The NTRU scheme and its variants follow such an approach. In the second approach, an approximate commutative function fs and a random input a are generated, the public key is (a, b = fs(a)) and the private key is s. A plaintext m is encrypted as c1 = gr(a), c2 = gr(b) + E(m), where r is a random element, g is an approximate commutative one-way function and E is the encoding of an error-correction code. The ciphertext (c1, c2) is decrypted as m = D(c2 − fs(c1)), where D is the decoding of an error-correction code. The correctness of decryption is guaranteed by the approximate commutative property (gr(b) = gr(fs(a)) ≈ fs(gr(a)) = fs(c1)) and the error-correction code. Learning with errors (LWE) problem-based PKE/KEM schemes and their variants follow such an approach. The standardization of PQC has received substantial support from national funding agencies, such as the European Union projects PQCrypto and SAFEcrypto. The USA National Institute of Standard and Technology (NIST) started the post-quantum standardization project in 2012, organized a worldwide ‘competition’ in 2016 and plans to deliver draft standards before 2024. After two rounds of evaluation, seven schemes were accepted as the round-three candidates on 22 July 2020, of which five are lattice-based schemes. In 2017, the International organization for standardization started a study project of post-quantum cryptography named SD8. Most LWE-based PKE schemes such as Kyber and LAC follow the Lindner-Peikert framework [3] up to the choices of ring structure, noise distribution and parameters. As the size of noise in lattice-based PKEs/EKMs is typically larger than the lower bits of the ciphertext, many schemes often artificially drop a few lower bits to optimize the practical performance without significantly increasing the final decryption noise. Kyber [4] is one of the most promising PKE/KEM candidates in the NIST PQC standardization, whose security is provably based on the difficulty of so-called module LWE (MLWE) problems. The use of MLWE allowed Kyber to obtain additional flexibility and security advantages, while keeping the same efficiency as those based on the ring-LWE problems. The strategy of dropping some lower bits is used to compress both the public-key and ciphertext sizes. For a targeted 128-bit quantum security, the public-key and ciphertext sizes of Kyber is around a single kilobyte. LAC [5] uses several techniques to reduce the modulus as small as possible: it uses a byte-level modulus, embeds powerful error-correcting codes to maximize the noise-modulus rate, provides a different style of modulus to avoid potential attacks for special polynomial ring structures and optimizes the polynomial multiplication algorithm of the bit-level secret and noise. Based on these techniques, LAC reduces the public key to 544–1056 bytes and the ciphertext to 664–1464 bytes. Meanwhile, it achieves similar computational performance compared with NTT technique schemes. By observing the asymmetries in lattice-based cryptosystems, Zhang and Yu et al. [6] proposed asymmetric MLWE and asymmetric MSIS problems, which yield further size-optimized KEMs and signature schemes to those from standard counterparts. Compared to the seven NIST round-three candidates at Category III security, their KEM scheme has parameters (public key + ciphertext size) smaller than Classic McEliece, CRYSTALS-Kyber, NTRU and Saber; their signature scheme has parameters (public key + signature size) smaller than CRYSTALS-Dilithium and Rainbow, but slightly larger than FALCON, where CRYSTALS-Kyber, NTRU, Saber, CRYSTALS-Dilithium and FALCON are lattice-based schemes. One important application of lattice-based PKEs/KEMs is to build authenticated key exchange (AKE), which could provide additional authentication to the established session key. There are several generic ways to construct AKE from lattice-based PKEs/KEMs. In the PKE setting, Xue and Lu et al. [7] proposed a more compact KEM-based framework via a new primitive named ‘2-key KEM’, which shares some item between different ciphertexts. In the only password setting, Zhang and Yu [8] presented a two-round PAKE framework from the splittable-PKEs that can be instantiated from lattices. The only known AKE that does not rely on lattice-based PKEs/KEMs was given in Ref. [9], which has two-round messages and provides implicit authentication. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (6197239 to X.L.; 62022018 and 61932019 to J.Z.) and the National Key Research and Development Program of China (2018YFB0804105 to J.Z.). Conflict of interest statement. None declared.
The standard public-key cryptosystems used today relies mathematical problems that require a lot of computing force to solve, so much that, with the right parameters, they are computationally unsolvable. But there are quantum algorithms that are able to solve these problems in much shorter time. These quantum algorithms have been known for many years, but have only been a problem in theory because of the lack of quantum computers. But with recent development in the building of quantum computers, the cryptographic world is looking for quantum-resistant replacements for today’s standard public-key cryptosystems. Public-key cryptosystems based on lattices are possible replacements. This thesis presents several possible candidates for new standard public-key cryptosystems, mainly NTRU and ring-LWE-based systems. The latticebased cryptosystems are shown to be very fast and have strong, provable security against quantum computers, but are a lot more complicated than RSA and Diffie-Hellman.
This dissertation examines the NTRU cryptosystem, one of the earliest and most updated lattice-based public key cryptographic schemes. Presented in 1996 by Jeffrey Hoffstein, Jill Pipher and Joseph H. Silverman, NTRU was conceived as an alternative to classical cryptographic protocols such as the RSA cryptosystem and Diffie–Hellman systems, whose security is based upon the computational intractability of integer factorisation and discrete logarithm problems. Although these problems remain infeasible for classical computation, the coming of sufficiently powerful quantum computers would render such schemes helpless through the application of the already existing Shor’s algorithm. By contrast, NTRU derives its security from hard problems in lattice theory, for which no efficient quantum algorithms are currently known, thereby establishing it as one of the foremost candidates for secure communication in the post-quantum era. The first chapter begins with a rigorous introduction to the theory of lattices, displaying their main algebraic and geometric properties together with several fundamental computational problems, most notably the Shortest Vector Problem (SVP) and the Closest Vector Problem (CVP). The computational hardness and infeasibility of these problems constitutes the mathematical foundation upon which NTRU is built. Particular attention is given to the Lenstra–Lenstra–Lovasz (LLL) lattice reduc- ´ tion algorithm. Its theoretical framework, geometric interpretation, and algorithmic behaviour are examined in detail, with special emphasis on its ability to construct reduced lattice bases that mirror some of the properties given by orthogonality, while remaining computationally feasible. The dissertation further explores the decisive role played by lattice reduction techniques in cryptography, both as practical tools for addressing difficult lattice problems and as powerful methods in the analysis of cryptosystems. Following this necessary theoretical development, in the second chapter the NTRU public key cryptosystem is presented and described in detail. The processes of key generation, encryption, and decryption are presented alongside the correct selection criteria of the system’s parameters, required to guarantee both correctness and security. Finally, the third chapter examines the security issues of NTRU through a range of attack models, including conventional attacks and, mainly, sophisticated attacks based on lattice reduction methods, thereby illustrating the deep connection between the security of NTRU and the intrinsic difficulty of solving lattice problems efficiently. Taken together, this dissertation presents a full guide of the mathematical structures underlying the NTRU cryptosystem, highlighting the fundamental role of algebraic tools such as lattice theory in the construction of cryptographic systems capable of withstanding the paradigm shift that is rapidly approaching with the rise of quantum computation.
Summary Key exchange protocols play an important role in securing the network communication over an insecure channel. In literature, a large number of key exchange schemes exist. The security of most of them is based on the Diffie‐Hellman (DH) problems over a group. But these types of DH problems are solvable in the presence of quantum computers. Thus, we require a non‐DH type key exchange scheme that resists to the quantum computers and new modern technologies. In this paper, 2 novel lattice‐based authenticated key exchange (LB‐AKE) protocols, (1) using a signature‐based authenticator and (2) using a signcryption‐based authenticator, are devised in Canetti‐Krawczyk proof model. The security of proposed protocols depends on the hardness of small integer solutions on the lattice. An extensive proof of security to our claim is given. The proposed AKEs characterize faster computation speed and resistance to the modern complex computers.