Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Southwest China Normal University

BOHR'S ORBIT RADIUS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH REDUCED MASS

Zhengtang Guo

Published Jan 1, 1987• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This article points out an error in a large number of wellknown textbooks of modern physics, atomic physics and quantum mechanics. We prove that replacing the electron mass by the reduced mass in Bohr's equation for the radius of the electron does not yield Bohr's orbit radius, but rather the electron (orbit particle)-proton (nucleus) separation. Bohr's orbit radius has nothing to do with reduced mass. In energy formula, it is indeed correct to use the reduced mass. The conclusion also refers to exotic atoms.

Related papers

The Fundament of the Mass: The Variant Mass of Electron at Atom

Giovanni Alcocer

Experimental results: Ionization energy of the electrons at the atom.Bound of the Diatomic Molecules.From Bohr to Schröndiger.Deduction of the radius formula with the analogy of the atom with the blackbody research from Planck and harmonic oscillators.Why the electrons orbit around the nucleus with specific radius for the case of electron as particle.Why the electron doesn´t radiate energy at the stationary levels as a wave and as a particle.Diffraction and Interference for the electron by using the Fourier Approach and Wave Properties

Mediterranean Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences•Jan 1, 2020•6 citations

Bohr Model

James W. Rohlf

The Bohr model is historically important in the understanding of quantum physics. It gives many important results for the hydrogen atom including atomic size and ionization energy. It is sometimes referred to as a semi-classical calculation, because it includes the physics of angular momentum quantization without the full quantum mechanical description of an electron wave. It is tremendously useful for gaining physical intuition of the quantum nature of the atom. In the Bohr model of the hydrogen atom, an electron has a circular orbit with speed v and radius r about the proton. The Bohr quantization condition is that an integer number of electron (de Broglie) wavelengths must fit to the atomic circumference.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 18, 2023•0 citations

Electron Orbits Beyond Bohr Radius

Mohamed E. Kelabi, Elham A. Younes, Ahmed E. Elhmassi

Starting from the classical energy equation of planetary motion and reviewing the refinement picture of Bohr model of hydrogen atom, the orbits of electron around hydrogen nucleus have been determined. The values of eccentricity of electron orbits fall within the range from 0 to 1, indicating that the path of an electron changes from circular to elliptical orbits, hence it continues toward parabolic orbits.

The Libyan Journal of Science•May 20, 2025•0 citations

Bohr Model

Z. Ficek

This chapter illustrates Niels Bohr's ideas in some detail. In the formulation of his model, Bohr assumed that the electron in the hydrogen atom moves under the influence of the Coulomb attraction between it and the positively charged nucleus, as assumed in classical mechanics. The Bohr model was very successful in explaining the discrete atomic spectra of one-electron atoms. The Bohr model is, of course, a theoretical model of an atom. Using Bohr's quantization postulate, find the linear velocity of the electron's sphere. To find the radius of the orbit, Bohr postulated that the angular momentum of the electron is quantized, i.e., it can only take values that are integer multiples of ħ. The chapter begins with considering the classical equation of motion for the electron in a circular orbit, which is based on Newton's laws of motion and Coulomb's law of electric force.

•Mar 3, 2017•0 citations

The Relativistic Bohr Radius and Its Agreement with the Dirac Most-Probable Radius

Espen Gaarder Haug

The Bohr radius is normally presented as a non-relativistic length scale. Less widely discussed is that Bohr’s 1913 work also indicated how the radius formula changes when the orbital velocity is not negligible compared with the speed of light. We revisit this relativistic prescription and show that, for a point nucleus and a one-electron Coulomb field, it gives a0,r(Z)=a0Z1−Z2α2, which is exactly the most-probable radius obtained independently from the Dirac 1s1/2 radial probability density. The two radii are calculated independently and are found to be analytically identical. This equality does not derive the Dirac result from the Bohr model; rather, it shows that Bohr’s relativistic circular-orbit prescription selects the same radial scale as the maximum of the Dirac probability distribution. We also show that the same construction extends to the node-free circular Dirac excited states, for which rmpD(n,κ=−n)=(a0/Z)nn2−Z2α2. We emphasize throughout that most-probable radii are distinct from expectation values and from empirical radii of many-electron atoms.

Atoms•Jul 17, 2026•0 citations

The Hydrogen Atom from a New Angle

V. Tomashau

Turning back to Niels Bohr's model of the hydrogen atom, the paper is trying to resolve one of the issues associated with the model.While N. Bohr in the framework of his model did not find any relation between electron's motion in the atom and radiation emitted, there is a reason to believe that the relation is bound to exist.Furthermore, it is already given by Rydberg's formula that expresses the frequency of radiation as a difference of two other frequencies associated in some manner with electron's rotation.Based on this approach a new value for the radius of the ground stationary orbit is calculated.It appears to be more than Bohr's radius by a factor of 1.588.The question why both values for the radius of the ground stationary orbit (Bohr's radius and a new one) are compatible with Rydberg's formula is considered.Finally, what exactly Niels Bohr overlooked in his model of the hydrogen atom, is discussed.It is established that Rydberg's formula can be derived from the more general parameterized postulates, when Niels Bohr used, regardless of the value of the parameter.

International Journal of Applied Physics and Mathematics•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations
This article points out an error in a large number of wellknown textbooks of modern physics, atomic physics and quantum mechanics. We prove that replacing the electron mass by the reduced mass in Bohr's equation for the radius of the electron does not yield Bohr's orbit radius, but rather the electron (orbit particle)-proton (nucleus) separation. Bohr's orbit radius has nothing to do with reduced mass. In energy formula, it is indeed correct to use the reduced mass. The conclusion also refers to exotic atoms.
Experimental results: Ionization energy of the electrons at the atom.Bound of the Diatomic Molecules.From Bohr to Schröndiger.Deduction of the radius formula with the analogy of the atom with the blackbody research from Planck and harmonic oscillators.Why the electrons orbit around the nucleus with specific radius for the case of electron as particle.Why the electron doesn´t radiate energy at the stationary levels as a wave and as a particle.Diffraction and Interference for the electron by using the Fourier Approach and Wave Properties
The Bohr model is historically important in the understanding of quantum physics. It gives many important results for the hydrogen atom including atomic size and ionization energy. It is sometimes referred to as a semi-classical calculation, because it includes the physics of angular momentum quantization without the full quantum mechanical description of an electron wave. It is tremendously useful for gaining physical intuition of the quantum nature of the atom. In the Bohr model of the hydrogen atom, an electron has a circular orbit with speed v and radius r about the proton. The Bohr quantization condition is that an integer number of electron (de Broglie) wavelengths must fit to the atomic circumference.
This chapter illustrates Niels Bohr's ideas in some detail. In the formulation of his model, Bohr assumed that the electron in the hydrogen atom moves under the influence of the Coulomb attraction between it and the positively charged nucleus, as assumed in classical mechanics. The Bohr model was very successful in explaining the discrete atomic spectra of one-electron atoms. The Bohr model is, of course, a theoretical model of an atom. Using Bohr's quantization postulate, find the linear velocity of the electron's sphere. To find the radius of the orbit, Bohr postulated that the angular momentum of the electron is quantized, i.e., it can only take values that are integer multiples of ħ. The chapter begins with considering the classical equation of motion for the electron in a circular orbit, which is based on Newton's laws of motion and Coulomb's law of electric force.
The Bohr radius is normally presented as a non-relativistic length scale. Less widely discussed is that Bohr’s 1913 work also indicated how the radius formula changes when the orbital velocity is not negligible compared with the speed of light. We revisit this relativistic prescription and show that, for a point nucleus and a one-electron Coulomb field, it gives a0,r(Z)=a0Z1−Z2α2, which is exactly the most-probable radius obtained independently from the Dirac 1s1/2 radial probability density. The two radii are calculated independently and are found to be analytically identical. This equality does not derive the Dirac result from the Bohr model; rather, it shows that Bohr’s relativistic circular-orbit prescription selects the same radial scale as the maximum of the Dirac probability distribution. We also show that the same construction extends to the node-free circular Dirac excited states, for which rmpD(n,κ=−n)=(a0/Z)nn2−Z2α2. We emphasize throughout that most-probable radii are distinct from expectation values and from empirical radii of many-electron atoms.
Turning back to Niels Bohr's model of the hydrogen atom, the paper is trying to resolve one of the issues associated with the model.While N. Bohr in the framework of his model did not find any relation between electron's motion in the atom and radiation emitted, there is a reason to believe that the relation is bound to exist.Furthermore, it is already given by Rydberg's formula that expresses the frequency of radiation as a difference of two other frequencies associated in some manner with electron's rotation.Based on this approach a new value for the radius of the ground stationary orbit is calculated.It appears to be more than Bohr's radius by a factor of 1.588.The question why both values for the radius of the ground stationary orbit (Bohr's radius and a new one) are compatible with Rydberg's formula is considered.Finally, what exactly Niels Bohr overlooked in his model of the hydrogen atom, is discussed.It is established that Rydberg's formula can be derived from the more general parameterized postulates, when Niels Bohr used, regardless of the value of the parameter.