Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Light Scattering

Lorentz-Compton Paradox and the Designing of a Double-Win Crucial Scattering Experiment

Yongchao Gan

Published Jan 1, 2006• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

From the discussion of whether Compton effect exists in the region of visible light or not to the research of experimental confirmation of whether the quantum theory of light can contain the classical electromagnetic theory of light in classical condition or not,Lorentz-Compton paradox is discovered. For solving this paradox,a feasible,sensitive and double-win crucial experiment is designed on the basis of inverse Compton scattering.

Related papers

The Compton effect: Transition to quantum mechanics

Roger H. Stuewer

Abstract The discovery of the Compton effect at the end of 1922 was a decisive event in the transition to the new quantum mechanics of 1925‐1926 because it stimulated physicists to examine anew the fundamental problem of the interaction between radiation and matter. I first discuss Albert Einstein's light‐quantum hypothesis of 1905 and why physicists greeted it with extreme skepticism, despite Robert A. Millikan's confirmation of Einstein's equation of the photoelectric effect in 1915. I then follow in some detail the experimental and theoretical research program that Arthur Holly Compton pursued between 1916 and 1922 at the University of Minnesota, the Westinghouse Lamp Company, the Cavendish Laboratory, and Washington University that culminated in his discovery of the Compton effect. Surprisingly, Compton was not influenced directly by Einstein's light‐quantum hypothesis, in contrast to Peter Debye and H.A. Kramers, who discovered the quantum theory of scattering independently. I close by discussing the most significant response to that discovery, the Bohr‐Kramers‐Slater theory of 1924, its experimental refutation, and its influence on the emerging new quantum mechanics.

Annalen der Physik•Nov 1, 2000•50 citations

Arthur Compton and the mysteries of light

Erik A. Henriksen

For nearly 20 years, Einstein’s quantum theory of light was disputed on the basis that light was a wave. In 1922 Compton’s x-ray scattering experiment proved light’s dual nature.

Physics Today•Dec 1, 2022•5 citations

Compton Did Not Prove the Photon Exists

James E Beecham

The Compton scattering experiment is widely regarded as one of the great triumphs oftwentieth-century physics. It demonstrated that electromagnetic radiation carries bothenergy and momentum and that these quantities are transferred to matter in accordancewith precise conservation laws. Historically, the experiment is alleged to have providedcompelling support for Einstein's light-quantum hypothesis and contributed significantly tothe acceptance of the photon concept. But modern questions are legitimately raised.An important distinction is frequently overlooked. The Compton experiment does notdirectly observe a photon as a discrete elementary object. Rather, it observes measurablequantities before and after an interaction between electromagnetic radiation and matter.The photon thus remains only an inferred explanatory construct.This paper examines Compton scattering from both its historical interpretation and an SP3conditionable-medium perspective. Two important historical and philosophicalobservations are highlighted: (1) that electromagnetic radiation unquestionably carriesenergy and momentum regardless of the interpretive framework employed, and (2) that noperson has ever directly observed an individual photon itself.These distinctions remain relevant when considering whether momentum transfernecessarily requires an elementary photon particle or may alternatively reflect the actionof a physically real medium occupying space.

•Jul 23, 2026•0 citations

Colloquium: Illuminating the Kapitza-Dirac effect with electron matter optics

Herman Batelaan

The observation of the Kapitza-Dirac effect raises conceptual, theoretical, and experimental questions. The Kapitza-Dirac effect is often described as diffraction of free electrons from a standing wave of light or stimulated Compton scattering. However, for the two-color Kapitza-Dirac effect these two interpretations appear to lead to paradoxical conclusions. The discussion of this paradox deepens our understanding of both of these versions of the Kapitza-Dirac effect.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Jul 13, 2007•128 citations

The Quantum nature of light

J. C. Garrison, R. Y. Chiao

This chapter begins with a survey of early experimental results — the Planck spectrum, the photoelectric effect, and Compton scattering — that are usually presented as evidence for the existence of photons. The photon concept is indeed sufficient to explain these results, but it is not necessary. There are semi-classical models that explain the same data without introducing photons. The crucial experiment, in which light consisting of a single photon reflects from a beam splitter, depends on the essential indivisibility of photons, and it excludes all semi-classical descriptions of light. This discussion is followed by a preview of modern methods of production and detection of individual photons, e.g., spontaneous down conversion and Silicon avalanche-photodiode counters, together with an introduction to the quantum theory of light based on the correspondence principle.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 5, 2008•0 citations

Probing entanglement in Compton interactions

Peter Caradonna, David C. Reutens, Tadayuki Takahashi +2 more

This theoretical research aims to examine areas of the Compton cross section of entangled annihilation photons for the purpose of testing for possible break down of theory, which could have consequences for predicted optimal capabilities of Compton PET systems. We provide maps of the cross section for entangled annihilation photons for experimental verification. We introduce a strategy to derive cross sections in a relatively straight forward manner for the Compton scattering of a hypothetical separable, mixed and entangled states. To understand the effect that entanglement has on the cross section for annihilation photons, we derive the cross section so that it is expressed in terms of the cross section of a hypothetical separable state and of a hypothetical forbidden maximally entangled state. We find lobe-like structures in the cross section which are regions where entanglement has the greatest effect. We also find that mixed states do not reproduce the cross section for annihilation photons, contrary to a recent investigation which reported otherwise. We review the motivation and method of the most precise Compton scattering experiment for annihilation photons, in order to resolve conflicting reports regarding the extent to which the cross section itself has been experimentally verified.

arXiv:1910.05537•Journal of Physics Communications•Oct 11, 2019•29 citations
From the discussion of whether Compton effect exists in the region of visible light or not to the research of experimental confirmation of whether the quantum theory of light can contain the classical electromagnetic theory of light in classical condition or not,Lorentz-Compton paradox is discovered. For solving this paradox,a feasible,sensitive and double-win crucial experiment is designed on the basis of inverse Compton scattering.
Abstract The discovery of the Compton effect at the end of 1922 was a decisive event in the transition to the new quantum mechanics of 1925‐1926 because it stimulated physicists to examine anew the fundamental problem of the interaction between radiation and matter. I first discuss Albert Einstein's light‐quantum hypothesis of 1905 and why physicists greeted it with extreme skepticism, despite Robert A. Millikan's confirmation of Einstein's equation of the photoelectric effect in 1915. I then follow in some detail the experimental and theoretical research program that Arthur Holly Compton pursued between 1916 and 1922 at the University of Minnesota, the Westinghouse Lamp Company, the Cavendish Laboratory, and Washington University that culminated in his discovery of the Compton effect. Surprisingly, Compton was not influenced directly by Einstein's light‐quantum hypothesis, in contrast to Peter Debye and H.A. Kramers, who discovered the quantum theory of scattering independently. I close by discussing the most significant response to that discovery, the Bohr‐Kramers‐Slater theory of 1924, its experimental refutation, and its influence on the emerging new quantum mechanics.
The Compton scattering experiment is widely regarded as one of the great triumphs oftwentieth-century physics. It demonstrated that electromagnetic radiation carries bothenergy and momentum and that these quantities are transferred to matter in accordancewith precise conservation laws. Historically, the experiment is alleged to have providedcompelling support for Einstein's light-quantum hypothesis and contributed significantly tothe acceptance of the photon concept. But modern questions are legitimately raised.An important distinction is frequently overlooked. The Compton experiment does notdirectly observe a photon as a discrete elementary object. Rather, it observes measurablequantities before and after an interaction between electromagnetic radiation and matter.The photon thus remains only an inferred explanatory construct.This paper examines Compton scattering from both its historical interpretation and an SP3conditionable-medium perspective. Two important historical and philosophicalobservations are highlighted: (1) that electromagnetic radiation unquestionably carriesenergy and momentum regardless of the interpretive framework employed, and (2) that noperson has ever directly observed an individual photon itself.These distinctions remain relevant when considering whether momentum transfernecessarily requires an elementary photon particle or may alternatively reflect the actionof a physically real medium occupying space.
This chapter begins with a survey of early experimental results — the Planck spectrum, the photoelectric effect, and Compton scattering — that are usually presented as evidence for the existence of photons. The photon concept is indeed sufficient to explain these results, but it is not necessary. There are semi-classical models that explain the same data without introducing photons. The crucial experiment, in which light consisting of a single photon reflects from a beam splitter, depends on the essential indivisibility of photons, and it excludes all semi-classical descriptions of light. This discussion is followed by a preview of modern methods of production and detection of individual photons, e.g., spontaneous down conversion and Silicon avalanche-photodiode counters, together with an introduction to the quantum theory of light based on the correspondence principle.
This theoretical research aims to examine areas of the Compton cross section of entangled annihilation photons for the purpose of testing for possible break down of theory, which could have consequences for predicted optimal capabilities of Compton PET systems. We provide maps of the cross section for entangled annihilation photons for experimental verification. We introduce a strategy to derive cross sections in a relatively straight forward manner for the Compton scattering of a hypothetical separable, mixed and entangled states. To understand the effect that entanglement has on the cross section for annihilation photons, we derive the cross section so that it is expressed in terms of the cross section of a hypothetical separable state and of a hypothetical forbidden maximally entangled state. We find lobe-like structures in the cross section which are regions where entanglement has the greatest effect. We also find that mixed states do not reproduce the cross section for annihilation photons, contrary to a recent investigation which reported otherwise. We review the motivation and method of the most precise Compton scattering experiment for annihilation photons, in order to resolve conflicting reports regarding the extent to which the cross section itself has been experimentally verified.