Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physica Scripta

Quantum and classical optics–emerging links

Joseph H. Eberly, Xiao‐Feng Qian, Asma Al-Qasimi, Hazrat Ali, Miguel Angel Alonso, Rodrigo Gutiérrez–Cuevas, Bethany Little, John C. Howell, Tanya Malhotra, A. Nick Vamivakas

Published May 9, 2016• 74 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum optics and classical optics are linked in ways that are becoming apparent as a result of numerous recent detailed examinations of the relationships that elementary notions of optics have with each other. These elementary notions include interference, polarization, coherence, complementarity and entanglement. All of them are present in both quantum and classical optics. They have historic origins, and at least partly for this reason not all of them have quantitative definitions that are universally accepted. This makes further investigation into their engagement in optics very desirable. We pay particular attention to effects that arise from the mere co-existence of separately identifiable and readily available vector spaces. Exploitation of these vector-space relationships are shown to have unfamiliar theoretical implications and new options for observation. It is our goal to bring emerging quantum–classical links into wider view and to indicate directions in which forthcoming and future work will promote discussion and lead to unified understanding.

DOI
10.1088/0031-8949/91/6/063003

Related papers

Theoretical Perspectives on Quantum Optics and Theoretical Foundations: An Integrative Review

Zen Revista, 10 PHYSICS

This narrative review examines the current state of knowledge regarding Quantum Optics within the broader context of Physics. We survey the theoretical foundations, methodological approaches, and key findings that have shaped the field, identifying major themes and tracing the evolution of ideas over time. The review synthesizes evidence from multiple research traditions and highlights both established conclusions and areas of ongoing debate. Particular attention is given to recent advances that have opened new avenues for investigation and to the practical implications of theoretical developments. We conclude with a discussion of the most promising directions for future research, emphasizing the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration and methodological innovation.

•Aug 30, 2026•0 citations

Classical and Quantum Interference

Z. Ficek, Mohamed Ridza Wahiddin

Optical interference is regarded as a classical phenomenon and is usually completely described in classical terms, in which optical fields are represented by classical waves. Does it mean that optical interference, which is fundamentally ascribable to the phenomenon of a superposition of wave amplitudes, cannot be applied to test quantum phenomena? The superposition principle is at the heart of quantum physics and one could expect that it should distinguish the quantum nature of light from thewave nature. Our experience based on extensive theoretical analysis and experimental observations shows that classical and quantum theories of optical interference readily explain the presence of an interference pattern resulting from the first-order coherence. However, there are interference effects involving the higher order (second-order) coherence that distinguish the quantum (photon) nature of light from the wave nature. Quantum interference has recently returned to prominence because of its utility in manipulating spontaneous emission and other radiative properties of atomic systems. In this chapter, we present elementary concepts and definitions of both the classical and quantum theory of optical interference and discuss similarities and differences between these two approaches [80].

•Apr 19, 2016•0 citations

The Correlationhedron: Spacetime as Projections of Quantum Correlations

Agostino Russo

We propose a unified geometric framework in which space and time emerge as observer-dependent projections of quantum correlations embedded in the universal wavefunction. In this approach, we formulate six axioms (including a duality between entanglement and time) that establish a correspondence between correlation structures and effective spacetime geometry. We introduce the "correlationhedron", a convex geometric object representing the set of all permissible correlation vectors of a given state, and show how different observer "slicings" (modeled by projection maps) yield distinct emergent spacetimes from this object. An emergent metric is defined on each observer's spacetime via the second derivative of a correlation density (analogous to a Fisher information metric), linking gradients in quantum entanglement to curvature. This paper establishes the conceptual foundations of this approach as the first in a planned series of investigations. We illustrate the framework with conceptual and quantitative examples, including an explicit calculation of the emergent geometry for a two- qubit system in both separable and entangled states. Connections to holography (AdS/CFT) (Maldacena1998, Ryu2006), tensor networks (Swingle2012), and relational quantum approaches (Rovelli1996) are discussed, along with experimental signatures (such as curvature variations with entanglement) that could support the theory. Finally, we outline the limitations of the framework, particularly regarding dynamics and observer-dependent causality, to guide future investigations. This kinematic framework establishes the conceptual skeleton of emergent spacetime; detailed constructions, proofs of smoothness, and dynamical laws will appear in forthcoming work.

•Apr 21, 2025•0 citations

Emerging Connections: Classical and Quantum Optics

Xiao‐Feng Qian, A. Nick Vamivakas, Joseph H. Eberly

Quantum optics and classical optics have coexisted for nearly a century as two distinct, self-consistent descriptions of light. What influences there were between the two domains all tended to go in one direction, as concepts from classical optics were incorporated into quantum theory's early development. But it's becoming increasingly clear that a significant quantum presence exists in classical territory-and, in particular, that the quintessential quantum attribute, entanglement, can be seen, studied and exploited in classical optics. This blurring of the classical-quantum boundary has opened up a potential new direction for frontier work in optics.

arXiv:1712.10040•Optics and Photonics News•Sep 27, 2017•31 citations

The classical limit of quantum optics: not what it seems at first sight

Yakir Aharonov, Alonso Botero, SHMUEL NUSSINOV +3 more

What light is and how to describe it has always been a central subject in physics. As our understanding has increased, so have our theories changed: geometrical optics, wave optics and quantum optics are increasingly sophisticated descriptions, each referring to a larger class of phenomena than its predecessor. But how exactly are these theories related? How and when wave optics reduces to geometric optics is a rather simple problem. Similarly, how quantum optics reduces to wave optics has also been considered to be a very simple business. It is not so. As we show here the classical limit of quantum optics is a far more complicated issue; it is in fact dramatically more involved and it requires a complete revision of all our intuitions. The revised intuitions can then serve as a guide to finding novel quantum effects.

arXiv:1305.0168•New Journal of Physics•Sep 3, 2013•16 citations

Quantum Entanglement In Fundamental Tests Of Physics

Roy Barzel

Relativistic quantum information investigates the interplay between quantum mechanics and relativity and is becoming increasingly relevant for future quantum technologies operating over large distances or in gravitational fields. This dissertation studies how relativistic effects influence the storage, transmission, and interference of quantum states of light, with particular emphasis on quantum memories and frequency-entangled photons. A theoretical framework is developed to describe relativistic transformations of photonic quantum states and their interaction with realistic quantum memories. Special attention is given to the influence of gravitational redshift and relativistic motion on quantum coherence, entanglement, and Hong–Ou–Mandel interference. The resulting models provide quantitative predictions for experimentally accessible scenarios and identify conditions under which relativistic effects become relevant for quantum communication and distributed quantum information processing. The presented results contribute to the emerging field of relativistic quantum information by connecting concepts from quantum optics, quantum communication, and general relativity. Beyond their fundamental significance, they provide theoretical tools for the development of future space-based quantum networks and relativistic quantum technologies. Beyond the results presented in this dissertation, the developed framework points toward a broader research program centered on the **Nonlinear Separability Problem**. This problem is proposed as a unifying mathematical perspective for investigating the limits of distinguishability, classification, and information processing in both classical and quantum systems. Its formulation naturally connects to a wide range of contemporary research areas, including computational complexity theory (e.g., P versus NP), quantum information processing, machine learning, optimization, information theory, quantum foundations, and mathematical physics. In particular, the framework suggests new approaches to studying the role of nonlinearity in quantum state discrimination, quantum communication protocols, and the mathematical structure of high-dimensional information spaces. While many of these directions remain to be explored, the present work establishes a conceptual and mathematical basis for future investigations. It is anticipated that further development of the Nonlinear Separability Problem may contribute to a deeper understanding of fundamental questions across mathematics, computer science, and quantum technologies, thereby opening new interdisciplinary avenues of research.

•Apr 24, 2026•0 citations
Quantum optics and classical optics are linked in ways that are becoming apparent as a result of numerous recent detailed examinations of the relationships that elementary notions of optics have with each other. These elementary notions include interference, polarization, coherence, complementarity and entanglement. All of them are present in both quantum and classical optics. They have historic origins, and at least partly for this reason not all of them have quantitative definitions that are universally accepted. This makes further investigation into their engagement in optics very desirable. We pay particular attention to effects that arise from the mere co-existence of separately identifiable and readily available vector spaces. Exploitation of these vector-space relationships are shown to have unfamiliar theoretical implications and new options for observation. It is our goal to bring emerging quantum–classical links into wider view and to indicate directions in which forthcoming and future work will promote discussion and lead to unified understanding.
This narrative review examines the current state of knowledge regarding Quantum Optics within the broader context of Physics. We survey the theoretical foundations, methodological approaches, and key findings that have shaped the field, identifying major themes and tracing the evolution of ideas over time. The review synthesizes evidence from multiple research traditions and highlights both established conclusions and areas of ongoing debate. Particular attention is given to recent advances that have opened new avenues for investigation and to the practical implications of theoretical developments. We conclude with a discussion of the most promising directions for future research, emphasizing the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration and methodological innovation.
Optical interference is regarded as a classical phenomenon and is usually completely described in classical terms, in which optical fields are represented by classical waves. Does it mean that optical interference, which is fundamentally ascribable to the phenomenon of a superposition of wave amplitudes, cannot be applied to test quantum phenomena? The superposition principle is at the heart of quantum physics and one could expect that it should distinguish the quantum nature of light from thewave nature. Our experience based on extensive theoretical analysis and experimental observations shows that classical and quantum theories of optical interference readily explain the presence of an interference pattern resulting from the first-order coherence. However, there are interference effects involving the higher order (second-order) coherence that distinguish the quantum (photon) nature of light from the wave nature. Quantum interference has recently returned to prominence because of its utility in manipulating spontaneous emission and other radiative properties of atomic systems. In this chapter, we present elementary concepts and definitions of both the classical and quantum theory of optical interference and discuss similarities and differences between these two approaches [80].
We propose a unified geometric framework in which space and time emerge as observer-dependent projections of quantum correlations embedded in the universal wavefunction. In this approach, we formulate six axioms (including a duality between entanglement and time) that establish a correspondence between correlation structures and effective spacetime geometry. We introduce the "correlationhedron", a convex geometric object representing the set of all permissible correlation vectors of a given state, and show how different observer "slicings" (modeled by projection maps) yield distinct emergent spacetimes from this object. An emergent metric is defined on each observer's spacetime via the second derivative of a correlation density (analogous to a Fisher information metric), linking gradients in quantum entanglement to curvature. This paper establishes the conceptual foundations of this approach as the first in a planned series of investigations. We illustrate the framework with conceptual and quantitative examples, including an explicit calculation of the emergent geometry for a two- qubit system in both separable and entangled states. Connections to holography (AdS/CFT) (Maldacena1998, Ryu2006), tensor networks (Swingle2012), and relational quantum approaches (Rovelli1996) are discussed, along with experimental signatures (such as curvature variations with entanglement) that could support the theory. Finally, we outline the limitations of the framework, particularly regarding dynamics and observer-dependent causality, to guide future investigations. This kinematic framework establishes the conceptual skeleton of emergent spacetime; detailed constructions, proofs of smoothness, and dynamical laws will appear in forthcoming work.
Quantum optics and classical optics have coexisted for nearly a century as two distinct, self-consistent descriptions of light. What influences there were between the two domains all tended to go in one direction, as concepts from classical optics were incorporated into quantum theory's early development. But it's becoming increasingly clear that a significant quantum presence exists in classical territory-and, in particular, that the quintessential quantum attribute, entanglement, can be seen, studied and exploited in classical optics. This blurring of the classical-quantum boundary has opened up a potential new direction for frontier work in optics.
What light is and how to describe it has always been a central subject in physics. As our understanding has increased, so have our theories changed: geometrical optics, wave optics and quantum optics are increasingly sophisticated descriptions, each referring to a larger class of phenomena than its predecessor. But how exactly are these theories related? How and when wave optics reduces to geometric optics is a rather simple problem. Similarly, how quantum optics reduces to wave optics has also been considered to be a very simple business. It is not so. As we show here the classical limit of quantum optics is a far more complicated issue; it is in fact dramatically more involved and it requires a complete revision of all our intuitions. The revised intuitions can then serve as a guide to finding novel quantum effects.
Relativistic quantum information investigates the interplay between quantum mechanics and relativity and is becoming increasingly relevant for future quantum technologies operating over large distances or in gravitational fields. This dissertation studies how relativistic effects influence the storage, transmission, and interference of quantum states of light, with particular emphasis on quantum memories and frequency-entangled photons. A theoretical framework is developed to describe relativistic transformations of photonic quantum states and their interaction with realistic quantum memories. Special attention is given to the influence of gravitational redshift and relativistic motion on quantum coherence, entanglement, and Hong–Ou–Mandel interference. The resulting models provide quantitative predictions for experimentally accessible scenarios and identify conditions under which relativistic effects become relevant for quantum communication and distributed quantum information processing. The presented results contribute to the emerging field of relativistic quantum information by connecting concepts from quantum optics, quantum communication, and general relativity. Beyond their fundamental significance, they provide theoretical tools for the development of future space-based quantum networks and relativistic quantum technologies. Beyond the results presented in this dissertation, the developed framework points toward a broader research program centered on the **Nonlinear Separability Problem**. This problem is proposed as a unifying mathematical perspective for investigating the limits of distinguishability, classification, and information processing in both classical and quantum systems. Its formulation naturally connects to a wide range of contemporary research areas, including computational complexity theory (e.g., P versus NP), quantum information processing, machine learning, optimization, information theory, quantum foundations, and mathematical physics. In particular, the framework suggests new approaches to studying the role of nonlinearity in quantum state discrimination, quantum communication protocols, and the mathematical structure of high-dimensional information spaces. While many of these directions remain to be explored, the present work establishes a conceptual and mathematical basis for future investigations. It is anticipated that further development of the Nonlinear Separability Problem may contribute to a deeper understanding of fundamental questions across mathematics, computer science, and quantum technologies, thereby opening new interdisciplinary avenues of research.