Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Probabilities and physical variables

Robert B. Griffiths

Published Nov 29, 2001• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511606052.006

Related papers

Conditional Probabilities and Measurements

CHRISTOF WETTERICH

Fundamental theories of physics•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Does a Single Spin-1/2 Pure Quantum State Have a Counterpart in Physical Reality? (Accepted Version)

Koji Nagata, Tadao Nakamura

We discuss the fact that a single spin observable $\sigma_x$ in a quantum state does not have a counterpart in physical reality. We consider whether a single spin-1/2 pure state has a counterpart in physical reality. It is an eigenvector of Pauli observable $\sigma_z$ or an eigenvector of Pauli observable $\sigma_x$. We assume a state $|+_z\rangle$, which can be described as an eigenvector of Pauli observable $\sigma_z$. We assume also a state $|+_x\rangle$, which can be described as an eigenvector of Pauli observable $\sigma_x$. The value of transition probability $|\langle +_z|+_x\rangle|^2$ is 1/2. We consider the following physical situation. If we detect $|+_z\rangle$, then we assign measurement outcome as $+1$. If we detect $|+_x\rangle$, then we assign measurement outcome as $-1$. The existence of a single classical probability space for the transition probability within the formalism of the measurement outcome does not coexist with the value of the transition probability $|\langle +_z|+_x\rangle|^2=1/2$. We have to give up the existence of such a classical probability space for the state $|+_z\rangle$ or for the state $|+_x\rangle$, as they define the transition probability. It turns out that the single spin-1/2 pure state $|+_z\rangle$ or the single spin-1/2 pure state $|+_x\rangle$ does not have counterparts in physical reality, in general. We investigate whether the Stern-Gerlach experiment accepts hidden-variables theories. We discuss that the existence of the two spin-1/2 pure states $|\uparrow\rangle$ and $|\downarrow\rangle$ rules out the existence of probability space of specific quantum measurement. If we detect $|\uparrow\rangle$, then we assign measurement outcome as $+1$. If we detect $|\downarrow\rangle$, then we assign measurement outcome as $-1$. This hidden-variables theory does not accept the transition probability $|\langle\uparrow|\downarrow\rangle|^2=0$. Therefore we have to give up the hidden-variables theory. This implies the Stern-Gerlach experiment cannot accept the hidden-variables theory. A single spin-1/2 pure state (e.g., $|\uparrow \rangle\langle \uparrow|$) is a single one-dimensional projector. In other word, a single one-dimensional projector does not have a counterpart in such physical reality, in general. The one-dimensional projectors $|\uparrow\rangle\langle\uparrow|$ and $|\downarrow\rangle\langle \downarrow|$ are commuting with each other. Our discussion shows that we cannot assign the specific definite values ($+1$ and $-1$) to the two commuting operators, simultaneously. We study whether quantum phase factor accepts a hidden-variables theory. We discuss that the existence of two spin-1/2 pure states $|0\rangle=(|\uparrow\rangle+|\downarrow\rangle)/\sqrt{2}$ and $|\theta\rangle=(|\uparrow\rangle+e^{i \theta}|\downarrow\rangle)/\sqrt{2}$ rules out the existence of probability space of a hidden-variables theory. If we detect $|0\rangle$, then we assign measurement outcome as $+1$. If we detect $|\theta\rangle$, then we assign measurement outcome as $-1$. The hidden-variables theory does not accept the transition probability $|\langle 0|\theta\rangle|^2=\cos^2(\theta/2)$. Therefore we have to give up the hidden-variables theory for quantum phase factor. We explore phase factor is indeed a quantum effect, not classical. Our research gives a new insight to the quantum information processing which relies on quantum phase factor, such as Deutsch's algorithm.

•Jun 1, 2015•0 citations

Does a Single Spin-1/2 Pure Quantum State Have a Counterpart in Physical Reality?

Koji Nagata, Tadao Nakamura

We discuss the fact that a single spin observable σx in a quantum state does not have a counterpart in physical reality. We consider whether a single spin-1/2 pure state has a counterpart in physical reality. It is an eigenvector of Pauli observable σz or an eigenvector of Pauli observable σx. We assume a state , which can be described as an eigenvector of Pauli observable σz. We assume also a state , which can be described as an eigenvector of Pauli observable σx. The value of transition probability is 1/2. We consider the following physical situation. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as +1. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as −1. The existence of a single classical probability space for the transition probability within the formalism of the measurement outcome does not coexist with the value of the transition probability = 1/2. We have to give up the existence of such a classical probability space for the state or for the state , as they define the transition probability. It turns out that the single spin-1/2 pure state or the single spin-1/2 pure state does not have counterparts in physical reality, in general. We investigate whether the Stern-Gerlach experiment accepts hidden-variables theories. We discuss that the existence of the two spin-1/2 pure states and rules out the existence of probability space of specific quantum measurement. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as +1. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as −1. This hidden-variables theory does not accept the transition probability . Therefore we have to give up the hidden-variables theory. This implies the Stern- Gerlach experiment cannot accept the hidden-variables theory. A single spin-1/2 pure state (e.g., is a single one-dimensional projector. In other word, a single one-dimensional projector does not have a counterpart in such physical reality, in general. The one-dimensional projectors are commuting with each other. Our discussion shows that we cannot assign the specific definite values (+1 and −1) to the two commuting operators, simultaneously. We study whether quantum phase factor accepts a hidden-variables theory. We discuss that the existence of two spin-1/2 pure states |0_ = ( + )/√2 and = ( + e iθ )/√2 rules out the existence of probability space of a hidden-variables theory. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as +1. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as −1. The hidden-variables theory does not accept the transition probability Therefore we have to give up the hidden-variables theory for quantum phase factor. We explore phase factor is indeed a quantum effect, not classical. Our research gives a new insight to the quantum information processing which relies on quantum phase factor, such as Deutsch’s algorithm.

•Jul 1, 2013•0 citations

Particles, Fields, and Probabilities

WORLD SCIENTIFIC (EUROPE) eBooks•Jun 17, 2021•0 citations

Negative probability

M. S. Bartlett

Summary It has been shown that orthodox probability theory may consistently be extended to include probability numbers outside the conventional range, and in particular negative probabilities. Random variables are correspondingly generalized to include extraordiary random variables; these have been defined in general, however, only through their characteristic functions. This generalized theory implies redundancy, and its use is a matter of convenience. Eddington(3) has employed it in this sense to introduce a correction to the fluctuation in number of particles within a given volume. Negative probabilities must always be combined with positive ones to give an ordinary probability before a physical interpretation is admissible. This suggests that where negative probabilities have appeared spontaneously in quantum theory it is due to the mathematical segregation of systems or states which physically only exist in combination.

Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society•Jun 1, 1945•52 citations

States, Measurements and Probabilities

Emilio d’Emilio, Luigi E. Picasso

Unitext•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations
We discuss the fact that a single spin observable σx\sigma_xσx​ in a quantum state does not have a counterpart in physical reality. We consider whether a single spin-1/2 pure state has a counterpart in physical reality. It is an eigenvector of Pauli observable σz\sigma_zσz​ or an eigenvector of Pauli observable σx\sigma_xσx​. We assume a state ∣+z⟩|+_z\rangle∣+z​⟩, which can be described as an eigenvector of Pauli observable σz\sigma_zσz​. We assume also a state ∣+x⟩|+_x\rangle∣+x​⟩, which can be described as an eigenvector of Pauli observable σx\sigma_xσx​. The value of transition probability ∣⟨+z∣+x⟩∣2|\langle +_z|+_x\rangle|^2∣⟨+z​∣+x​⟩∣2 is 1/2. We consider the following physical situation. If we detect ∣+z⟩|+_z\rangle∣+z​⟩, then we assign measurement outcome as +1+1+1. If we detect ∣+x⟩|+_x\rangle∣+x​⟩, then we assign measurement outcome as −1-1−1. The existence of a single classical probability space for the transition probability within the formalism of the measurement outcome does not coexist with the value of the transition probability ∣⟨+z∣+x⟩∣2=1/2|\langle +_z|+_x\rangle|^2=1/2∣⟨+z​∣+x​⟩∣2=1/2. We have to give up the existence of such a classical probability space for the state ∣+z⟩|+_z\rangle∣+z​⟩ or for the state ∣+x⟩|+_x\rangle∣+x​⟩, as they define the transition probability. It turns out that the single spin-1/2 pure state ∣+z⟩|+_z\rangle∣+z​⟩ or the single spin-1/2 pure state ∣+x⟩|+_x\rangle∣+x​⟩ does not have counterparts in physical reality, in general. We investigate whether the Stern-Gerlach experiment accepts hidden-variables theories. We discuss that the existence of the two spin-1/2 pure states ∣↑⟩|\uparrow\rangle∣↑⟩ and ∣↓⟩|\downarrow\rangle∣↓⟩ rules out the existence of probability space of specific quantum measurement. If we detect ∣↑⟩|\uparrow\rangle∣↑⟩, then we assign measurement outcome as +1+1+1. If we detect ∣↓⟩|\downarrow\rangle∣↓⟩, then we assign measurement outcome as −1-1−1. This hidden-variables theory does not accept the transition probability ∣⟨↑∣↓⟩∣2=0|\langle\uparrow|\downarrow\rangle|^2=0∣⟨↑∣↓⟩∣2=0. Therefore we have to give up the hidden-variables theory. This implies the Stern-Gerlach experiment cannot accept the hidden-variables theory. A single spin-1/2 pure state (e.g., ∣↑⟩⟨↑∣|\uparrow \rangle\langle \uparrow|∣↑⟩⟨↑∣) is a single one-dimensional projector. In other word, a single one-dimensional projector does not have a counterpart in such physical reality, in general. The one-dimensional projectors ∣↑⟩⟨↑∣|\uparrow\rangle\langle\uparrow|∣↑⟩⟨↑∣ and ∣↓⟩⟨↓∣|\downarrow\rangle\langle \downarrow|∣↓⟩⟨↓∣ are commuting with each other. Our discussion shows that we cannot assign the specific definite values (+1+1+1 and −1-1−1) to the two commuting operators, simultaneously. We study whether quantum phase factor accepts a hidden-variables theory. We discuss that the existence of two spin-1/2 pure states ∣0⟩=(∣↑⟩+∣↓⟩)/2|0\rangle=(|\uparrow\rangle+|\downarrow\rangle)/\sqrt{2}∣0⟩=(∣↑⟩+∣↓⟩)/2​ and ∣θ⟩=(∣↑⟩+eiθ∣↓⟩)/2|\theta\rangle=(|\uparrow\rangle+e^{i \theta}|\downarrow\rangle)/\sqrt{2}∣θ⟩=(∣↑⟩+eiθ∣↓⟩)/2​ rules out the existence of probability space of a hidden-variables theory. If we detect ∣0⟩|0\rangle∣0⟩, then we assign measurement outcome as +1+1+1. If we detect ∣θ⟩|\theta\rangle∣θ⟩, then we assign measurement outcome as −1-1−1. The hidden-variables theory does not accept the transition probability ∣⟨0∣θ⟩∣2=cos⁡2(θ/2)|\langle 0|\theta\rangle|^2=\cos^2(\theta/2)∣⟨0∣θ⟩∣2=cos2(θ/2). Therefore we have to give up the hidden-variables theory for quantum phase factor. We explore phase factor is indeed a quantum effect, not classical. Our research gives a new insight to the quantum information processing which relies on quantum phase factor, such as Deutsch's algorithm.
We discuss the fact that a single spin observable σx in a quantum state does not have a counterpart in physical reality. We consider whether a single spin-1/2 pure state has a counterpart in physical reality. It is an eigenvector of Pauli observable σz or an eigenvector of Pauli observable σx. We assume a state , which can be described as an eigenvector of Pauli observable σz. We assume also a state , which can be described as an eigenvector of Pauli observable σx. The value of transition probability is 1/2. We consider the following physical situation. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as +1. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as −1. The existence of a single classical probability space for the transition probability within the formalism of the measurement outcome does not coexist with the value of the transition probability = 1/2. We have to give up the existence of such a classical probability space for the state or for the state , as they define the transition probability. It turns out that the single spin-1/2 pure state or the single spin-1/2 pure state does not have counterparts in physical reality, in general. We investigate whether the Stern-Gerlach experiment accepts hidden-variables theories. We discuss that the existence of the two spin-1/2 pure states and rules out the existence of probability space of specific quantum measurement. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as +1. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as −1. This hidden-variables theory does not accept the transition probability . Therefore we have to give up the hidden-variables theory. This implies the Stern- Gerlach experiment cannot accept the hidden-variables theory. A single spin-1/2 pure state (e.g., is a single one-dimensional projector. In other word, a single one-dimensional projector does not have a counterpart in such physical reality, in general. The one-dimensional projectors are commuting with each other. Our discussion shows that we cannot assign the specific definite values (+1 and −1) to the two commuting operators, simultaneously. We study whether quantum phase factor accepts a hidden-variables theory. We discuss that the existence of two spin-1/2 pure states |0_ = ( + )/√2 and = ( + e iθ )/√2 rules out the existence of probability space of a hidden-variables theory. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as +1. If we detect , then we assign measurement outcome as −1. The hidden-variables theory does not accept the transition probability Therefore we have to give up the hidden-variables theory for quantum phase factor. We explore phase factor is indeed a quantum effect, not classical. Our research gives a new insight to the quantum information processing which relies on quantum phase factor, such as Deutsch’s algorithm.
Summary It has been shown that orthodox probability theory may consistently be extended to include probability numbers outside the conventional range, and in particular negative probabilities. Random variables are correspondingly generalized to include extraordiary random variables; these have been defined in general, however, only through their characteristic functions. This generalized theory implies redundancy, and its use is a matter of convenience. Eddington(3) has employed it in this sense to introduce a correction to the fluctuation in number of particles within a given volume. Negative probabilities must always be combined with positive ones to give an ordinary probability before a physical interpretation is admissible. This suggests that where negative probabilities have appeared spontaneously in quantum theory it is due to the mathematical segregation of systems or states which physically only exist in combination.