The paper of Choi et al. [Phys. Rev. A 84, 012334 (2011)] discusses the use of the Foldy-Wouthuysen mean-spin operator in the theory of relativistic quantum information. However, the paper contains some incorrect statements and misunderstandings.
We give a direct link between covariant description of Dirac particles in the abstract framework of unitary representation of the Poincaré group and description with the help of the Dirac equation. In this context we discuss the spin operator for a relativistic Dirac particle. We show also that the spin operator used in quantum field theory for spin s = 1/2 corresponds to the Foldy-Wouthuysen mean-spin operator. We hope that this formalism will be useful in the theory of relativistic quantum information.
Some years ago Mashhoon [1] made the highly interesting suggestion that there existed a coupling of spin with rotations, just as there exists such a coupling with orbital angular momentum, as seen in the Sagnac effect, for example. Spin being essentially a quantum phenomenon, the obvious place to look for this was by studying the Dirac equation, and Hehl and Ni , in such an investigation [2], indeed found a coupling term of just the type Mashhoon had envisaged. Part of their procedure, however, was to take the nonrelativistic limit, and this was done by performing appropriate Foldy-Wouthuysen (FW) transformations. In the nonrelativistic limit, it is well-known that the spin operators for Dirac particles are in essence the Pauli matrices; but it is also well-known, and indeed was part of the motivation for Foldy and Wouthuysen's paper, that for fully-fledged Dirac particles the (4×4 generalisation of the) Pauli matrices do not yield satisfactory spin operators, since spin defined in this way would not be conserved. The question therefore presented itself: is there a relativistic spin operator for Dirac particles, such that in the relativistic, as well as the nonrelativistic, régime a Mashhoon spin-rotation coupling exists?… Note from Publisher: This article contains the abstract and references.
We have studied the relativistic effect on the spin state of a massive Dirac particle under an arbitrary Lorentz transformation using the Foldy-Woutheysen representation. We have obtained the transformation matrix from the state of a massive Dirac particle with an initial momentum to a state with a transformed momentum under an arbitrary homogeneous Lorentz transformation. We have shown moving observers obtain the consistent monotonic behavior between the concurrence and the maximum value of Bell parameter for the spin state of the pair of particles.
We give a direct link between description of Dirac particles in the abstract framework of unitary representation of the Poincaré group and description with the help of the Dirac equation. In this context we discuss in detail the spin operator for a relativistic Dirac particle. We show also that the spin operator used in quantum field theory for spin s=1/2 corresponds to the Foldy-Woutheysen mean-spin operator.