Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comment on "Electric dipole interaction in quantum optics"

Edwin Albert Power, T. Thirunamachandran

Published Dec 1, 1980• 21 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is shown that both Hamiltonians, one with $\ensuremath{-}\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\ensuremath{\mu}}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{E}}$ and the other with $\ensuremath{-}\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\ensuremath{\mu}}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{A}}$ as interaction energy between an atom and the electromagnetic field, lead to Maxwell's equations. In contrast to the viewpoint in Mandel's paper, $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{E}}$ is considered to be proportional to the canonically conjugate field of the vector potential.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.22.2894

Related papers

Comment on "Electric dipole interaction in quantum optics"

W P Healy

It is shown that Mandel's argument that the electric dipole interaction in quantum electrodynamics is inconsistent with Maxwell's equations relies on the use of the wrong canonical momenta in the multipolar form of the Hamiltonian; the field conjugate to the vector potential in the Coulomb gauge is proportional to the transverse displacement vector and not, as in the minimal-coupling form of the Hamiltonian, to the transverse electric field, and similarly the canonical momenta of the charged particles differ in the two cases. Some consequences of this for time-dependent perturbation theory are discussed.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1980•28 citations

Electric dipole interaction in quantum optics

L. Mandeļ

It is pointed out that the electromagnetic interaction $\ensuremath{-}\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\mu}}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}\stackrel{^}{E}$ between an atom and a field, in which the atom is modelled as a point dipole of moment $\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ interacting with the electric field $\stackrel{^}{E}$, is not strictly consistent with both quantum mechanics and Maxwell's equations. Quantum mechanics allows magnetic point dipoles but not electric point dipoles.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1979•38 citations

Interaction Hamiltonian of quantum optics

Jay R. Ackerhalt, Peter W. Milonni

We consider the fully quantum-mechanical Hamiltonian for the interaction of light with bound electrons. There are, roughly speaking, two different viewpoints relating the minimal-coupling and electric-dipole forms of the Hamiltonian. We attempt to clarify the situation by showing that either viewpoint is justified. As an example we discuss the Maxwell–Bloch equations and show that the usual derivation of these equations is somewhat misleading. In addition, we find that the Maxwell–Bloch equations appearing in standard texts are inconsistent.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Mar 1, 1984•49 citations

Further remarks on the Hamiltonian of quantum optics

Edwin Albert Power, T. Thirunamachandran

The equations of motion and the class of Hamiltonians for electrodynamics, both classical and quantal, are considered for the interaction of radiation with bound charges within the electric-dipole approximation. It is emphasized that, despite the uniqueness of the equations of motion for physical variables, the form of the Hamiltonian is not unique and that a physical system is associated with an equivalence class of Hamiltonians. Two of the members of this class are the minimal-coupling and multipolar forms extensively used in quantum optics. It is shown that although different choices of Hamiltonians lead to different first-order equations of motion that connect canonical coordinates and momenta, they lead to the same second-order equations of motion for the physical variables and physical electromagnetic fields. In the quantum theory of electrodynamics the role played by the choice of representation for the operators and for the states is analyzed with care. The choice of representation leads to a freedom additional to that provided by canonical transformations in classical electrodyamics, although the two lead to the same operator equations of motion.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Jul 1, 1985•17 citations

The One-electron Quantum Hamiltonian in the Presence of EM Fields

Jochen Autschbach

Abstract The interaction between atoms or molecules and electromagnetic (EM) fields underlies all spectroscopic techniques and a great variety of desirable molecular properties. EM fields and EM waves are introduced via the famous Maxwell equations. The scalar and vector potential are defined, and the gauge freedom is outlined. The Coulomb gauge is adopted. The classical Hamiltonian for a charged particle in an EM field is derived, and from this the ‘minimal substitution’ rules for incorporating the fields in the quantum Hamiltonian are obtained. The operators describing the interaction of an electron with static electric and magnetic fields, including the magnetic fields from nuclear spins, are derived, followed by the derivation of the interaction between an electron and an EM wave.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 21, 2020•0 citations

The interaction of light with neutral systems

Edwin Albert Power, R. Shail

A recent investigation of the interaction between the Maxwell radiation field and neutral atoms or molecules has led us to consider the relation between the straightforward interaction Hamiltonian between particle (k) and the radiation field, and the more physical, and explicitly gauge invariant, couplings of the form q. E and µ. H, etc., where q and µ are the electric and magnetic dipole moments of a system of particles. That these latter form of interaction energies follow from well-formulated approximations for atoms in external fields has been known for many years (Goeppert-Mayer(1); see also Rosenfeld(2)). When the Maxwell field is an internal and dynamical field further discussion is necessary, especially concerning the Coulomb interactions. Their advantage has recently been shown in dealing with dipole interactions in the long range Van der Waals force between two neutral systems where the complete coupling, in dipole approximation, is given by — q.ET for each neutral system, where ET is the transverse electric field. The short-range London limit is contained in this coupling despite the absence of longitudinal electric fields (Power and Zienau (3)). In this note we extend these arguments to higher electric multipoles and magnetic multipoles. We also demonstrate their use in the quantum theory of scattering of light, and in particular the derivations of Stephen (4) of the phase angle between emergent beams in optical double refraction phenomena are shown to follow immediately.

Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society•Jan 1, 1959•12 citations
It is shown that both Hamiltonians, one with \ensuremath−\ensuremathμ\ensuremath→\ifmmode⋅\else\textperiodcentered\fiE\ensuremath→\ensuremath{-}\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\ensuremath{\mu}}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{E}}\ensuremath−\ensuremathμ\ensuremath→​\ifmmode⋅\else\textperiodcentered\fiE\ensuremath→​ and the other with \ensuremath−\ensuremathμ\ensuremath→\ifmmode⋅\else\textperiodcentered\fiA\ensuremath→\ensuremath{-}\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\ensuremath{\mu}}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{A}}\ensuremath−\ensuremathμ\ensuremath→​\ifmmode⋅\else\textperiodcentered\fiA\ensuremath→​ as interaction energy between an atom and the electromagnetic field, lead to Maxwell's equations. In contrast to the viewpoint in Mandel's paper, E\ensuremath→\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{E}}E\ensuremath→​ is considered to be proportional to the canonically conjugate field of the vector potential.
It is shown that Mandel's argument that the electric dipole interaction in quantum electrodynamics is inconsistent with Maxwell's equations relies on the use of the wrong canonical momenta in the multipolar form of the Hamiltonian; the field conjugate to the vector potential in the Coulomb gauge is proportional to the transverse displacement vector and not, as in the minimal-coupling form of the Hamiltonian, to the transverse electric field, and similarly the canonical momenta of the charged particles differ in the two cases. Some consequences of this for time-dependent perturbation theory are discussed.
It is pointed out that the electromagnetic interaction $\ensuremath{-}\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\mu}}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}\stackrel{^}{E}$ between an atom and a field, in which the atom is modelled as a point dipole of moment $\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ interacting with the electric field $\stackrel{^}{E}$, is not strictly consistent with both quantum mechanics and Maxwell's equations. Quantum mechanics allows magnetic point dipoles but not electric point dipoles.
We consider the fully quantum-mechanical Hamiltonian for the interaction of light with bound electrons. There are, roughly speaking, two different viewpoints relating the minimal-coupling and electric-dipole forms of the Hamiltonian. We attempt to clarify the situation by showing that either viewpoint is justified. As an example we discuss the Maxwell–Bloch equations and show that the usual derivation of these equations is somewhat misleading. In addition, we find that the Maxwell–Bloch equations appearing in standard texts are inconsistent.
The equations of motion and the class of Hamiltonians for electrodynamics, both classical and quantal, are considered for the interaction of radiation with bound charges within the electric-dipole approximation. It is emphasized that, despite the uniqueness of the equations of motion for physical variables, the form of the Hamiltonian is not unique and that a physical system is associated with an equivalence class of Hamiltonians. Two of the members of this class are the minimal-coupling and multipolar forms extensively used in quantum optics. It is shown that although different choices of Hamiltonians lead to different first-order equations of motion that connect canonical coordinates and momenta, they lead to the same second-order equations of motion for the physical variables and physical electromagnetic fields. In the quantum theory of electrodynamics the role played by the choice of representation for the operators and for the states is analyzed with care. The choice of representation leads to a freedom additional to that provided by canonical transformations in classical electrodyamics, although the two lead to the same operator equations of motion.
Abstract The interaction between atoms or molecules and electromagnetic (EM) fields underlies all spectroscopic techniques and a great variety of desirable molecular properties. EM fields and EM waves are introduced via the famous Maxwell equations. The scalar and vector potential are defined, and the gauge freedom is outlined. The Coulomb gauge is adopted. The classical Hamiltonian for a charged particle in an EM field is derived, and from this the ‘minimal substitution’ rules for incorporating the fields in the quantum Hamiltonian are obtained. The operators describing the interaction of an electron with static electric and magnetic fields, including the magnetic fields from nuclear spins, are derived, followed by the derivation of the interaction between an electron and an EM wave.
A recent investigation of the interaction between the Maxwell radiation field and neutral atoms or molecules has led us to consider the relation between the straightforward interaction Hamiltonian between particle (k) and the radiation field, and the more physical, and explicitly gauge invariant, couplings of the form q. E and µ. H, etc., where q and µ are the electric and magnetic dipole moments of a system of particles. That these latter form of interaction energies follow from well-formulated approximations for atoms in external fields has been known for many years (Goeppert-Mayer(1); see also Rosenfeld(2)). When the Maxwell field is an internal and dynamical field further discussion is necessary, especially concerning the Coulomb interactions. Their advantage has recently been shown in dealing with dipole interactions in the long range Van der Waals force between two neutral systems where the complete coupling, in dipole approximation, is given by — q.ET for each neutral system, where ET is the transverse electric field. The short-range London limit is contained in this coupling despite the absence of longitudinal electric fields (Power and Zienau (3)). In this note we extend these arguments to higher electric multipoles and magnetic multipoles. We also demonstrate their use in the quantum theory of scattering of light, and in particular the derivations of Stephen (4) of the phase angle between emergent beams in optical double refraction phenomena are shown to follow immediately.