Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Time-driven quantum master equations and their compatibility with the fluctuation dissipation theorem

Jérôme Flakowski, Maksym Osmanov, David Taj, Hans Christian Öttinger

Published Oct 17, 2014• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We contribute to a long-standing debate on the supposed failure of the fluctuation dissipation theorem (FDT) for the Davies master equation (DME), an important class of Lindblad quantum master equations, describing time-driven quantum systems weakly coupled to a heat bath. First we propose two simple and natural criteria on the driving which guarantee compatibility with the FDT. We show through our setting that, contrary to what is often stated in the literature, the DME is fully compatible with the FDT. We thus argue that the cause of the dispute lies in the adopted perturbation scheme, rather than in the Lindblad character of the master equation itself. We confirm our statement by proving that the Grabert master equation, first proposed by Grabert [Projection Operator Techniques in Nonequilibrium Statistical Mechanics (Springer, Berlin, 1982)] as an alternative linear dynamics fulfilling the FDT, is nothing else than the incriminated DME. Our criteria for the FDT can also be used in the analysis of the nonlinear thermodynamical master equation, first obtained in the Brownian motion limit [H. Grabert, Z. Phys. B 49, 161 (1982)] and later independently rediscovered and generalized on purely thermodynamic grounds [H. C. \"Ottinger, Europhys. Lett. 94, 10006 (2011)].

DOI
10.1103/physreva.90.042110

Related papers

Thermodynamic deficiencies of some simple Lindblad operators: A diagnosis and a suggestion for a cure

Jürgen T. Stockburger, Thomas Motz

Master equations of Lindblad type have attained prominent status in the fields of quantum optics and quantum information since they are guaranteed to satisfy fundamental notions of quantum dynamics such as complete positivity. When Lindblad operators are used to describe thermal reservoirs in contact with an open quantum system, the fundamental laws of thermodynamics and the fluctuation‐dissipation theorem provide additional mandatory criteria. We show several examples of innocent‐looking Lindblad operators which have questionable properties in this regard. Compatibility criteria between Hamiltonian and Lindblad terms as well as consequences of their violation are discussed. An alternative stochastic approach to dissipative quantum dynamics is outlined and illustrated through a harmonic‐chain model for which the approach of local Lindblad operators fails.

arXiv:1606.04326•Fortschritte der Physik•Nov 11, 2016•56 citations

Fluctuation Relations for Quantum Markovian Dynamical System

Raphaël Chétrite, Kirone Mallick

We derive a general set of fluctuation relations for a nonequilibrium open quantum system described by a Lindblad master equation. In the special case of conservative Hamiltonian dynamics, these identities allow us to retrieve quantum versions of Jarzynski and Crooks relations. In the linear response regime, these fluctuation relations yield a fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) valid for a stationary state arbitrarily far from equilibrium. For a closed system, this FDT reduces to the celebrated Callen-Welton-Kubo formula.

arXiv:1002.0950•Feb 4, 2010•2 citations

Quantum master equation with dissipators regularized by thermal fluctuations

Arnab Chakrabarti, Rangeet Bhattacharyya

We report an alternate formulation of the quantum master equation (QME) to describe the dynamics of a quantum system weakly coupled to a heat bath, in the presence of weak external driving. A key feature of this approach is the introduction of an explicit Hamiltonian to model the thermal fluctuations in the heat bath. We show that the resulting time coarse-grained dynamical equation for the quantum system has dissipators with a natural regulator, which emerges from an ensemble average over the fluctuations. Importantly, such regularized dissipators arise from the second-order contributions of both the external drive as well as the system-environment coupling. We show that the second-order drive terms, regularized to time-scales set by the fluctuations, result in dynamic drive-induced frequency shifts as well as drive-dependent relaxation phenomena. Considering the specific case of an ensemble of two-level systems, subjected to a linearly polarized external drive, we derive the modified Bloch Equations with such drive-dependent shift and damping terms. The resulting drive-induced frequency shifts converge to the known forms of dynamic frequency shifts, such as the Bloch-Siegert shift or the dynamic Stark shift, in appropriate limits. The Kramers-Kronig pairs of these frequency shifts - manifest as drive-dependent damping terms in the modified Bloch Equations and help explain the Redfield limit of free-induction-decay (FID) rates as well as the non-Bloch decay of Rabi oscillations in isotropic medium. Our method predicts correct orders of magnitudes of non-Bloch decay rates in isotropic medium as well as their observed temperature dependence. The QME reported here, correctly describes all known aspects of the driven-dissipative dynamics up to second-order of an open quantum system with appropriate thermal signatures and as such is expected to provide deeper insights into the study of quantum information processing on real systems.

Physical Review A•Jun 18, 2018•16 citations

Fluctuation-dissipation theorem for non-equilibrium quantum systems

Mohammad Mehboudi, Anna Sanpera, Juan M. R. Parrondo

The fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) is a central result in statistical physics, both for classical and quantum systems. It establishes a relationship between the linear response of a system under a time-dependent perturbation and time correlations of certain observables in equilibrium. Here we derive a generalization of the theorem which can be applied to any Markov quantum system and makes use of the symmetric logarithmic derivative (SLD). There are several important benefits from our approach. First, such a formulation clarifies the relation between classical and quantum versions of the equilibrium FDT. Second, and more important, it facilitates the extension of the FDT to arbitrary quantum Markovian evolution, as given by quantum maps. Third, it clarifies the connection between the FDT and quantum metrology in systems with a non-equilibrium steady state.

arXiv:1705.03968•Quantum•May 24, 2018•22 citations

A field-biased quantum master equation and its Markovian limit

M. Gabriela Boada G., Andrea Delgado, Jose Morales E

We present a non-equilibrium quantum master equation for a driven open quantum system in the presence of a continuously applied electromagnetic field. Starting from a driven Caldeira-Leggett (CL) model in which the external electromagnetic field couples simultaneously to the subsystem and reservoir degrees of freedom, the canonical fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) relations that encode the coefficients of the master equation can no longer be expected to hold. The bath statistics acquire an explicit dependence on the two-time autocorrelation function of the applied field, leading to drive-biased noise correlations and the potential for non-Markovian dynamics. By eliminating the reservoir degrees of freedom at the operator level, we obtain a modified Hu-Paz-Zhang (HPZ) master equation, in which the diffusion coefficients and coherent forces inherit an explicit memory dependence on the external field. We demonstrate that the physically observable resonant frequency remains encoded in the homogeneous Green's function of the Generalized Langevin equation (GLE), while the drive-induced corrections manifest exclusively through modified diffusion and drift terms, should the drive be treated classically. The resultant field-modified HPZ master provides a unified microscopic framework for understanding field-biased open quantum systems with direct pertinence to a wide variety of experiments in quantum optics and microscopic quantum circuits.

quant-pharXiv:2602.22363•Feb 27, 2026•1 citation

Quantum fluctuation theorem for dissipative processes

Gabriele De Chiara, Alberto Imparato

We present a general quantum fluctuation theorem for the entropy production of an open quantum system coupled to multiple environments, not necessarily at equilibrium. Such a general theorem, when restricted to the weak-coupling and Markovian regime, holds for both local and global master equations, corroborating the thermodynamic consistency of local quantum master equations. The theorem is genuinely quantum, as it can be expressed in terms of conservation of a Hermitian operator, describing the dynamics of the system state operator and of the entropy change in the baths. The integral fluctuation theorem follows from the properties of such an operator. Furthermore, it is also valid when the system is described by a time-dependent Hamiltonian. As such, the quantum Jarzynski equality is a particular case of the general result presented here. Moreover, our result can be extended to nonthermal baths, as long as microreversibility is preserved. We present some numerical examples to showcase the exact results previously obtained. We finally generalize the fluctuation theorem to the case where the interaction between the system and the bath is explicitly taken into account. We show that the fluctuation theorem amounts to a relation between time-reversed dynamics of the global density matrix and a two-time correlation function along the forward dynamics involving the baths' entropy alone.

arXiv:2108.05937•Physical Review Research•Jun 21, 2022•13 citations
We contribute to a long-standing debate on the supposed failure of the fluctuation dissipation theorem (FDT) for the Davies master equation (DME), an important class of Lindblad quantum master equations, describing time-driven quantum systems weakly coupled to a heat bath. First we propose two simple and natural criteria on the driving which guarantee compatibility with the FDT. We show through our setting that, contrary to what is often stated in the literature, the DME is fully compatible with the FDT. We thus argue that the cause of the dispute lies in the adopted perturbation scheme, rather than in the Lindblad character of the master equation itself. We confirm our statement by proving that the Grabert master equation, first proposed by Grabert [Projection Operator Techniques in Nonequilibrium Statistical Mechanics (Springer, Berlin, 1982)] as an alternative linear dynamics fulfilling the FDT, is nothing else than the incriminated DME. Our criteria for the FDT can also be used in the analysis of the nonlinear thermodynamical master equation, first obtained in the Brownian motion limit [H. Grabert, Z. Phys. B 49, 161 (1982)] and later independently rediscovered and generalized on purely thermodynamic grounds [H. C. "Ottinger, Europhys. Lett. 94, 10006 (2011)].
Master equations of Lindblad type have attained prominent status in the fields of quantum optics and quantum information since they are guaranteed to satisfy fundamental notions of quantum dynamics such as complete positivity. When Lindblad operators are used to describe thermal reservoirs in contact with an open quantum system, the fundamental laws of thermodynamics and the fluctuation‐dissipation theorem provide additional mandatory criteria. We show several examples of innocent‐looking Lindblad operators which have questionable properties in this regard. Compatibility criteria between Hamiltonian and Lindblad terms as well as consequences of their violation are discussed. An alternative stochastic approach to dissipative quantum dynamics is outlined and illustrated through a harmonic‐chain model for which the approach of local Lindblad operators fails.
We derive a general set of fluctuation relations for a nonequilibrium open quantum system described by a Lindblad master equation. In the special case of conservative Hamiltonian dynamics, these identities allow us to retrieve quantum versions of Jarzynski and Crooks relations. In the linear response regime, these fluctuation relations yield a fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) valid for a stationary state arbitrarily far from equilibrium. For a closed system, this FDT reduces to the celebrated Callen-Welton-Kubo formula.
We report an alternate formulation of the quantum master equation (QME) to describe the dynamics of a quantum system weakly coupled to a heat bath, in the presence of weak external driving. A key feature of this approach is the introduction of an explicit Hamiltonian to model the thermal fluctuations in the heat bath. We show that the resulting time coarse-grained dynamical equation for the quantum system has dissipators with a natural regulator, which emerges from an ensemble average over the fluctuations. Importantly, such regularized dissipators arise from the second-order contributions of both the external drive as well as the system-environment coupling. We show that the second-order drive terms, regularized to time-scales set by the fluctuations, result in dynamic drive-induced frequency shifts as well as drive-dependent relaxation phenomena. Considering the specific case of an ensemble of two-level systems, subjected to a linearly polarized external drive, we derive the modified Bloch Equations with such drive-dependent shift and damping terms. The resulting drive-induced frequency shifts converge to the known forms of dynamic frequency shifts, such as the Bloch-Siegert shift or the dynamic Stark shift, in appropriate limits. The Kramers-Kronig pairs of these frequency shifts - manifest as drive-dependent damping terms in the modified Bloch Equations and help explain the Redfield limit of free-induction-decay (FID) rates as well as the non-Bloch decay of Rabi oscillations in isotropic medium. Our method predicts correct orders of magnitudes of non-Bloch decay rates in isotropic medium as well as their observed temperature dependence. The QME reported here, correctly describes all known aspects of the driven-dissipative dynamics up to second-order of an open quantum system with appropriate thermal signatures and as such is expected to provide deeper insights into the study of quantum information processing on real systems.
The fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) is a central result in statistical physics, both for classical and quantum systems. It establishes a relationship between the linear response of a system under a time-dependent perturbation and time correlations of certain observables in equilibrium. Here we derive a generalization of the theorem which can be applied to any Markov quantum system and makes use of the symmetric logarithmic derivative (SLD). There are several important benefits from our approach. First, such a formulation clarifies the relation between classical and quantum versions of the equilibrium FDT. Second, and more important, it facilitates the extension of the FDT to arbitrary quantum Markovian evolution, as given by quantum maps. Third, it clarifies the connection between the FDT and quantum metrology in systems with a non-equilibrium steady state.
We present a non-equilibrium quantum master equation for a driven open quantum system in the presence of a continuously applied electromagnetic field. Starting from a driven Caldeira-Leggett (CL) model in which the external electromagnetic field couples simultaneously to the subsystem and reservoir degrees of freedom, the canonical fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) relations that encode the coefficients of the master equation can no longer be expected to hold. The bath statistics acquire an explicit dependence on the two-time autocorrelation function of the applied field, leading to drive-biased noise correlations and the potential for non-Markovian dynamics. By eliminating the reservoir degrees of freedom at the operator level, we obtain a modified Hu-Paz-Zhang (HPZ) master equation, in which the diffusion coefficients and coherent forces inherit an explicit memory dependence on the external field. We demonstrate that the physically observable resonant frequency remains encoded in the homogeneous Green's function of the Generalized Langevin equation (GLE), while the drive-induced corrections manifest exclusively through modified diffusion and drift terms, should the drive be treated classically. The resultant field-modified HPZ master provides a unified microscopic framework for understanding field-biased open quantum systems with direct pertinence to a wide variety of experiments in quantum optics and microscopic quantum circuits.
We present a general quantum fluctuation theorem for the entropy production of an open quantum system coupled to multiple environments, not necessarily at equilibrium. Such a general theorem, when restricted to the weak-coupling and Markovian regime, holds for both local and global master equations, corroborating the thermodynamic consistency of local quantum master equations. The theorem is genuinely quantum, as it can be expressed in terms of conservation of a Hermitian operator, describing the dynamics of the system state operator and of the entropy change in the baths. The integral fluctuation theorem follows from the properties of such an operator. Furthermore, it is also valid when the system is described by a time-dependent Hamiltonian. As such, the quantum Jarzynski equality is a particular case of the general result presented here. Moreover, our result can be extended to nonthermal baths, as long as microreversibility is preserved. We present some numerical examples to showcase the exact results previously obtained. We finally generalize the fluctuation theorem to the case where the interaction between the system and the bath is explicitly taken into account. We show that the fluctuation theorem amounts to a relation between time-reversed dynamics of the global density matrix and a two-time correlation function along the forward dynamics involving the baths' entropy alone.