Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Historical Analysis and Open Questions

QUANTUM MECHANICS: THE REAL AND THE POSSIBLE

Giuseppe Boscarino

Published May 1, 2000• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

It is argued that in the history of western culture two traditions of thought, the Italic , or Pythagorean-Democritean, and the Ionic , or Platonic-Aristotelian, have contended the conception of science. The attempt made by many people to base modern science, or quantum mechanics, on the concept of dýnamis - potentia of Aristotelian origin is shown to be fragile and contradictory.

DOI
10.1142/9789812793560_0005

Related papers

La nascita della meccanica quantistica

Salvatore Califano, Vincenzo Schettino

Quantum mechanics constituted a great scientific and cultural revolution that profoundly changed our approach to the study of the microscopic and subatomic world. The birth and evolution of the theories of quantum mechanics are revived through the personal and scientific history of the protagonists, their attempts and their working hypotheses, the discoveries, doubts and discussions. The substantially counterintuitive concepts of the new mechanics have redesigned the meaning of our knowledge of the world of atoms; particular attention is then paid to the impact that this new vision of the microscopic world has had on chemistry and our knowledge of the structure and reactivity of atoms and molecules.

Studi e saggi•Sep 1, 2018•3 citations

From Classical Neurobiological Conception to Quantum One. Critical Revision

Probably no theory in the history of science has produced such a profound cultural and scientific revolution as is determined by quantum mechanics. Founded around 1920 by illustrious physicists, all Nobel Prize winners, it has completely subverted the conception of matter and the universe. The theory that all matter is made up of atoms has already been formulated by Greek philosophers, starting with Democritus. Quantum mechanics provided a description based on a new conception of the elementary structure of atoms, and formulated the fundamental laws to which atoms obey. Quantum theory has obtained the unanimous and shared consent of the scientific world, although some aspects have not been definitively confirmed. Strengthened by the universal acceptance of his theories, quantum mechanics claims its intellectual primacy over all the other sciences, and the scientific world seems to grant it, so much so as to archive all the knowledge and achievements gathered in its thousand-year history. From the epistemological point of view all established theories are worthy of consideration and must be shared and accepted until proven groundless. Dating, quantum mechanics still enjoys the consent of many scientists, but this does not mean that it can claim to be the repository of all truth, based on an unacceptable and anti-scientific syllogism for which: A) all organic and inorganic matter is formed by atoms and molecules; B) quantum mechanics has founded theories and formulas to which atoms and molecules obey; C) accordingly quantum mechanics can control all universal matter. But the presumption of its predominance goes further than willing to dominate living matter. In this article we are going to examine with a sharp criticism, the aberrant and anti-scientific claim of this discipline to dominate not only science but also universal matter. We propose a more moderate and considered vision of the observable natural phenomena and consider them events in continuous evolution, and to adapt our hypotheses and theories with an equal evolutionary approach.

Archives of Health Science•Dec 11, 2023•0 citations

QUANTUM MECHANICS: A PLATONIC INTERPRETATION

James Robert Brown

For more than six decades quantum mechanics (QM) has been a philosophical nightmare. All sorts of good sense have been dashed on the rocks of this brilliantly bizarre bit of physics. So, I am not too sanguine about the prospects of the proposal I’m about to present. Nevertheless, in the spirit of ‘nothing ventured, nothing gained’ I shall outline the philosophical problem (or at least one of the main problems) then try to offer a solution. The proposal is a platonic one, linked to what has been done in earlier chapters. If it works it will support the earlier platonic account of laws and thought experiments. If it doesn’t, then I can only hope it is at least interesting.

Routledge eBooks•Sep 26, 2005•0 citations

Quantum Physics and East-West Rapprochement

C. T. K. Chari

J. P. McKINNEY, his interesting discussion Philosophy East and West for October, 1953, has suggested that it is quantum physics, or wave mechanics, based on Planck's quantum of energy and Heisenberg's Principle of Indeterminacy or Uncertainty, that the real revolution of thought is now seen as having taken place. Here thought has reached back to that in-itself-undifferentiated 'substratum' which is seen as underlying the common world of determinate things time and space.' McKinney has advanced the opinion that in effect, Western thought has been brought round-actually has brought itself round by the inner logical necessity of its own development-to a standpoint which has been the traditional assumption of Eastern thought.2 I think McKinney has overstated his case. If, as he has urged, there are reasons for distrusting the popular idealistic interpretations of relativity, there seem to be no less valid reasons for doubting the exaggerated, quasimystical constructions put on quantum mechanics. At least two important facts must be taken into account: (1) Western scientists do not agree as to what, if any, the metaphysical implications of quantum mechanics are; (2) Western scientists do not agree, even from a scientific point of view, with respect to the proper interpretation of certain crucial aspects of quantum mechanics.

Philosophy East and West•Apr 1, 1955•3 citations

On Religious Faith, Christianity, and the Foundation of Quantum Mechanics

Inge Svein Helland

On several levels, there is now a debate whether the concept of God can be made compatible with modern science. In an attempt to elucidate this debate, I give an account of my own experiences from writing a book on the foundation of quantum mechanics. In my opinion, one can give two independent arguments for the existence of God by taking as departure an epistemic (knowledge-based) interpretation of quantum theory. However, I also argue that any religious belief should be the result of an existential choice governed by each person’s own context (history and culture). In particular, I give my account of Christianity as a religion connected to our western culture, how one as a scientist can relate to the relevant dogmas.

European Journal of Theology and Philosophy•Jan 26, 2022•10 citations

Classical Mechanics

Jeffrey Alan Barrett

Abstract While quantum mechanics is one of the most successful physical theories we have ever had, it is deeply counterintuitive. It must be given the empirical evidence it explains. We consider some of the historical evidence for the theory and the conceptual arguments that led from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics. These considerations illustrate some of the ways in which our commonsense and philosophical intuitions are simply incompatible with the physical world.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 26, 2019•0 citations
It is argued that in the history of western culture two traditions of thought, the Italic , or Pythagorean-Democritean, and the Ionic , or Platonic-Aristotelian, have contended the conception of science. The attempt made by many people to base modern science, or quantum mechanics, on the concept of dýnamis - potentia of Aristotelian origin is shown to be fragile and contradictory.
Quantum mechanics constituted a great scientific and cultural revolution that profoundly changed our approach to the study of the microscopic and subatomic world. The birth and evolution of the theories of quantum mechanics are revived through the personal and scientific history of the protagonists, their attempts and their working hypotheses, the discoveries, doubts and discussions. The substantially counterintuitive concepts of the new mechanics have redesigned the meaning of our knowledge of the world of atoms; particular attention is then paid to the impact that this new vision of the microscopic world has had on chemistry and our knowledge of the structure and reactivity of atoms and molecules.
Probably no theory in the history of science has produced such a profound cultural and scientific revolution as is determined by quantum mechanics. Founded around 1920 by illustrious physicists, all Nobel Prize winners, it has completely subverted the conception of matter and the universe. The theory that all matter is made up of atoms has already been formulated by Greek philosophers, starting with Democritus. Quantum mechanics provided a description based on a new conception of the elementary structure of atoms, and formulated the fundamental laws to which atoms obey. Quantum theory has obtained the unanimous and shared consent of the scientific world, although some aspects have not been definitively confirmed. Strengthened by the universal acceptance of his theories, quantum mechanics claims its intellectual primacy over all the other sciences, and the scientific world seems to grant it, so much so as to archive all the knowledge and achievements gathered in its thousand-year history. From the epistemological point of view all established theories are worthy of consideration and must be shared and accepted until proven groundless. Dating, quantum mechanics still enjoys the consent of many scientists, but this does not mean that it can claim to be the repository of all truth, based on an unacceptable and anti-scientific syllogism for which: A) all organic and inorganic matter is formed by atoms and molecules; B) quantum mechanics has founded theories and formulas to which atoms and molecules obey; C) accordingly quantum mechanics can control all universal matter. But the presumption of its predominance goes further than willing to dominate living matter. In this article we are going to examine with a sharp criticism, the aberrant and anti-scientific claim of this discipline to dominate not only science but also universal matter. We propose a more moderate and considered vision of the observable natural phenomena and consider them events in continuous evolution, and to adapt our hypotheses and theories with an equal evolutionary approach.
For more than six decades quantum mechanics (QM) has been a philosophical nightmare. All sorts of good sense have been dashed on the rocks of this brilliantly bizarre bit of physics. So, I am not too sanguine about the prospects of the proposal I’m about to present. Nevertheless, in the spirit of ‘nothing ventured, nothing gained’ I shall outline the philosophical problem (or at least one of the main problems) then try to offer a solution. The proposal is a platonic one, linked to what has been done in earlier chapters. If it works it will support the earlier platonic account of laws and thought experiments. If it doesn’t, then I can only hope it is at least interesting.
J. P. McKINNEY, his interesting discussion Philosophy East and West for October, 1953, has suggested that it is quantum physics, or wave mechanics, based on Planck's quantum of energy and Heisenberg's Principle of Indeterminacy or Uncertainty, that the real revolution of thought is now seen as having taken place. Here thought has reached back to that in-itself-undifferentiated 'substratum' which is seen as underlying the common world of determinate things time and space.' McKinney has advanced the opinion that in effect, Western thought has been brought round-actually has brought itself round by the inner logical necessity of its own development-to a standpoint which has been the traditional assumption of Eastern thought.2 I think McKinney has overstated his case. If, as he has urged, there are reasons for distrusting the popular idealistic interpretations of relativity, there seem to be no less valid reasons for doubting the exaggerated, quasimystical constructions put on quantum mechanics. At least two important facts must be taken into account: (1) Western scientists do not agree as to what, if any, the metaphysical implications of quantum mechanics are; (2) Western scientists do not agree, even from a scientific point of view, with respect to the proper interpretation of certain crucial aspects of quantum mechanics.
On several levels, there is now a debate whether the concept of God can be made compatible with modern science. In an attempt to elucidate this debate, I give an account of my own experiences from writing a book on the foundation of quantum mechanics. In my opinion, one can give two independent arguments for the existence of God by taking as departure an epistemic (knowledge-based) interpretation of quantum theory. However, I also argue that any religious belief should be the result of an existential choice governed by each person’s own context (history and culture). In particular, I give my account of Christianity as a religion connected to our western culture, how one as a scientist can relate to the relevant dogmas.