Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IS QUANTUM MECHANICS A UNIVERSAL THEORY?

Bernard d’Espagnat

Published Nov 1, 2001• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The reason for believing quantum mechanics to be universal – which seems convincing – is that it is the theory of atoms, and that atoms constitute everything. In fact, this reason is most questionable since "orthodox" quantum mechanics is not descriptive of "things," but only predictive of observations. Yet, the experimental confirmations of decoherence theory indicate that, as such, quantum mechanics is universal.

DOI
10.1142/9789812799593_0016

Related papers

The fundamental obscurity in quantum mechanics. Could the problem be considered universal?

А. В. Никулов

The contemporary controversy about the fundamental obscurity in quantum mechanics keeps on the old one about the aim of science, which was between the founders of the quantum theory. The orthodox quantum mechanics could be created only at the cost of renunciation of reality as the aim of natural science. The description only of phenomena, i.e. results of observation, should not be universal if no one believes that these phenomena are manifestation of a unique reality. Such belief concerning quantum mechanics is quite unacceptable because of irremediably conflict with special relativity. Nevertheless the quantum mechanics was developed and apprehended by most physicists as a universal theory of a quantum world. This fundamental discrepancy between the essence of the orthodox quantum mechanics and its history of development and studying has resulted both to an illusion about the aim of its description among most physicists and to the consideration of its fundamental obscurity as a universal problem among experts in quantum foundation. The aim of this paper is to show that quantum phenomena can not be described universally. It is indicated that rather the Schrodinger's than Born's interpretation of the wave function is valid for description of many quantum phenomena. The fundamental obscurity with which we are faced at the description, for example, macroscopic quantum phenomena differs fundamentally from the one with which the founders of the quantum theory were faced on atomic level.

arXiv:1012.4413•Dec 20, 2010•2 citations

Quantum mechanics and the question of determinism in science

CO Akpan

Classical science and in fact Post-Newtonian science up till the early twentieth century were mired in a deterministic interpretation of realities. The deterministic hypothesis in science holds that everything in nature has a cause and if one could know the antecedent causes, he could predict the future with certainty. But quantum mechanics holds that sub-atomic particles, though the ultimate materials from which all the complexity of existence in the universe emerges, do not obey deterministic laws, hence, their activities are causally indeterminate and could only be understood with probability. This paper argues that quantum mechanics can not totally be free from determinism, for it has subtly conceded to determinism in holding that the sub-atomic particles are the building blocks of the macro world, and that there is interconnection between entities in the universe, even at the nonmanifest level. The probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics only betray our human limitation of the knowledge of nature, which, I believe still have lots of tricks in our sleeves over mankind. Sophia: An African Journal of Philosophy Vol. 8(1) 2005:72-79 Keywords: Keywords:

Sophia An African Journal of Philosophy•Dec 20, 2006•0 citations

Do we finally understand Quantum Mechanics?

Alberto C. de la Torre

The ontology emerging from quantum field theory and the results following from Bell's theorems allowed the development of an intuitive picture of the microscopic world described by quantum mechanics, that is, we can say that we understand this theory. However there remain several aspects of it that are still mysterious and require more work on the foundations of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1605.00672•May 2, 2016•4 citations

An operational interpretation of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics

Willis E. Lamb

WHAT IS QUANTUM MECHANICS? A remarkable feature of the 1968 conference of Nobel prize winners in physics at Lindau is that it was possible for me to ask such a question in the presence of two of the founders of quantum mechanics, Werner Heisenberg and P.A.M. Dirac, more than 30 years after the discovery, in a lecture attended by 400 students who had recently begun their study of the subject. Several answers to the question are possible. The only easy one is that quantum mechanics is a discipline that provides a wonderful set of rules for calculating physical properties of matter. For such simple systems as hydrogen and helium atoms the calculated energy levels agree with experiment to fantastic accuracy. In more complicated cases the computations are difficult and the accuracy is lower, but it is reasonable to believe, in principle at least, that the theory would be adequate if only the calculational problems could be overcome.

Physics Today•Apr 1, 1969•122 citations

Seven Steps Toward the Classical World: The Problem of the Classical Limit in Quantum Mechanics

Valia Allori

Quantum mechanics is the most powerful of the theories developed by the human beings. In fact, it is able to predict successfully the experimental results with an impressive degree of accuracy. For this reason, the majority of physicists tends to believe that quantum mechanics has no problem and that we are close to finding a real ”theory of everything”. As it has been underlined many times, starting from the famous Bohr–Einstein debate and finally arriving at the writing of John Bell, it is far from being true.

•Aug 27, 2001•0 citations

Is Quantum Mechanics a Complete Theory?: A Philosophical Defense of Einstein's Position

U O Egbai

In 1935, Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen published their thought experiment I a paper entitled, “Can Quantum – Mechanical Description of Physical Reality be considered complete?”. At that time, Bohr, Heisenberg, and the proponents of the Copenhagen interpretation of Quantum mechanics, were saying that Quantum theory is a complete and the last theory in physics event though it does not provide any picture of the world separate from our observations of it. The message Einstein conveyed to his colleagues was that the quantum theory is not a “complete” theory because it does not describe certain important aspects of reality which are physically real event if they are not observed. In sympathy with Einstein's position, this paper argues that, the real nature of physical reality cannot be explained “at once” by a single theory. Reality is still unfolding and a new theory that will surpass the predictive ability of Quantum Mechanics will soon emerge. SOPHIA: An African Journal of Philosophy Vol. 8 (2) 2006: pp.14-19

Sophia An African Journal of Philosophy•Aug 24, 2007•0 citations
The reason for believing quantum mechanics to be universal – which seems convincing – is that it is the theory of atoms, and that atoms constitute everything. In fact, this reason is most questionable since "orthodox" quantum mechanics is not descriptive of "things," but only predictive of observations. Yet, the experimental confirmations of decoherence theory indicate that, as such, quantum mechanics is universal.
The contemporary controversy about the fundamental obscurity in quantum mechanics keeps on the old one about the aim of science, which was between the founders of the quantum theory. The orthodox quantum mechanics could be created only at the cost of renunciation of reality as the aim of natural science. The description only of phenomena, i.e. results of observation, should not be universal if no one believes that these phenomena are manifestation of a unique reality. Such belief concerning quantum mechanics is quite unacceptable because of irremediably conflict with special relativity. Nevertheless the quantum mechanics was developed and apprehended by most physicists as a universal theory of a quantum world. This fundamental discrepancy between the essence of the orthodox quantum mechanics and its history of development and studying has resulted both to an illusion about the aim of its description among most physicists and to the consideration of its fundamental obscurity as a universal problem among experts in quantum foundation. The aim of this paper is to show that quantum phenomena can not be described universally. It is indicated that rather the Schrodinger's than Born's interpretation of the wave function is valid for description of many quantum phenomena. The fundamental obscurity with which we are faced at the description, for example, macroscopic quantum phenomena differs fundamentally from the one with which the founders of the quantum theory were faced on atomic level.
Classical science and in fact Post-Newtonian science up till the early twentieth century were mired in a deterministic interpretation of realities. The deterministic hypothesis in science holds that everything in nature has a cause and if one could know the antecedent causes, he could predict the future with certainty. But quantum mechanics holds that sub-atomic particles, though the ultimate materials from which all the complexity of existence in the universe emerges, do not obey deterministic laws, hence, their activities are causally indeterminate and could only be understood with probability. This paper argues that quantum mechanics can not totally be free from determinism, for it has subtly conceded to determinism in holding that the sub-atomic particles are the building blocks of the macro world, and that there is interconnection between entities in the universe, even at the nonmanifest level. The probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics only betray our human limitation of the knowledge of nature, which, I believe still have lots of tricks in our sleeves over mankind. Sophia: An African Journal of Philosophy Vol. 8(1) 2005:72-79 Keywords: Keywords:
WHAT IS QUANTUM MECHANICS? A remarkable feature of the 1968 conference of Nobel prize winners in physics at Lindau is that it was possible for me to ask such a question in the presence of two of the founders of quantum mechanics, Werner Heisenberg and P.A.M. Dirac, more than 30 years after the discovery, in a lecture attended by 400 students who had recently begun their study of the subject. Several answers to the question are possible. The only easy one is that quantum mechanics is a discipline that provides a wonderful set of rules for calculating physical properties of matter. For such simple systems as hydrogen and helium atoms the calculated energy levels agree with experiment to fantastic accuracy. In more complicated cases the computations are difficult and the accuracy is lower, but it is reasonable to believe, in principle at least, that the theory would be adequate if only the calculational problems could be overcome.
Quantum mechanics is the most powerful of the theories developed by the human beings. In fact, it is able to predict successfully the experimental results with an impressive degree of accuracy. For this reason, the majority of physicists tends to believe that quantum mechanics has no problem and that we are close to finding a real ”theory of everything”. As it has been underlined many times, starting from the famous Bohr–Einstein debate and finally arriving at the writing of John Bell, it is far from being true.
In 1935, Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen published their thought experiment I a paper entitled, “Can Quantum – Mechanical Description of Physical Reality be considered complete?”. At that time, Bohr, Heisenberg, and the proponents of the Copenhagen interpretation of Quantum mechanics, were saying that Quantum theory is a complete and the last theory in physics event though it does not provide any picture of the world separate from our observations of it. The message Einstein conveyed to his colleagues was that the quantum theory is not a “complete” theory because it does not describe certain important aspects of reality which are physically real event if they are not observed. In sympathy with Einstein's position, this paper argues that, the real nature of physical reality cannot be explained “at once” by a single theory. Reality is still unfolding and a new theory that will surpass the predictive ability of Quantum Mechanics will soon emerge. SOPHIA: An African Journal of Philosophy Vol. 8 (2) 2006: pp.14-19