Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Historical Analysis and Open Questions

DO WE NEED "QUANTUM" PROBABILITY?

Romano Scozzafava

Published May 1, 2000• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We discuss the role of probability in quantum physics: it should be that of a general tool guiding induction and must not be restricted only to the empirical interpretation coming from its evaluation by an observed frequency. It is true that in many cases the value of a probability can be sensibly expressed by a suitable frequency, but this does not entail that the latter can be taken as definition of probability. Moreover, we emphasize the role of conditional probability, and we show that looking at it from the right perspective also allows one to avoid classic paradoxical aspects of quantum physics.

DOI
10.1142/9789812793560_0029

Related papers

The role of probability in statistical physics

Romano Scozzafava

In this expository paper we discuss the role of probability in statistical physics: it should be that of a general tool guiding induction and must not be restricted only to the empirical interpretation coming from its evaluation by an observed frequency. It is true that in many cases the value of a probability can be sensibly expressed by a suitable frequency, but this does not entails that the latter can be taken as definition of probability. Moreover, in each situation in which one thinks that probabilities are physically real things and believes that something which is only “very probable” can be regarded as being “practically certain”, some “small” probabilities are actually ignored: this attitude of mind may render illegitimate also the probabilistic interpretation of the relevant physical laws. A “law” which is based on a probabilistic interpretation cannot aim at explaining why a fact that we forecast will occur, but rather at explaining why we forecast that this fact will occur. Finally, we emphasize the role of conditional probability, and we show that looking at it from the right perspective allows to avoids also classic paradoxical aspects of quantum mechanics, without the need to resort to the interpretation based on the dualism “particle-wave”.

Transport Theory and Statistical Physics•Jan 1, 2000•5 citations

Quantum Probability: Conditioning and Inference

Romano Scozzafava

Looking at conditional probability from the right perspective allows one to avoid classic paradoxical aspects of quantum mechanics. We discuss, as an elementary analogue of quan-tum states, a classical example (an urn of unknown composition) with similar (putative) paradoxical situ-ations, despite the fact that there is no quantum effect to which they could be ascribed. A crucial feature is that we look at them from an epis-temic point of view and not from the viewpoint of a (seemingly) ontologi-cal reality.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Probability interpretation of quantum mechanics

Roger G. Newton

The paper draws attention to the frequency meaning of the probability concept and its implications for quantum mechanics. It emphasizes that the very meaning of probability implies the ensemble interpretation of both pure and mixed states. As a result some of the ’’paradoxical’’ aspects of quantum mechanics lose their counterintuitive character.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1980•23 citations

Physical quantum states and the meaning of probability

Michel Paty

We investigate epistemologically the meaning of probability as implied in quantum physics in connection with a proposed direct interpretation of the state function and of the related quantum theoretical quantities in terms of physical systems having physical properties, through an extension of meaning of the notion of physical quantity to complex mathematical expressions not reductible to simple numerical values. We show how the changes occurred in the implication of probabilities in quantum physics, from a penetration tool (probability as statistics and frequencies of occurencies of events) to a theoretical concept (probability given by a physically aimed at «amplitude of probability») actually make this view a somewhat «natural» one.

•Jan 1, 2000•4 citations

Is quantum decoherence reality or appearance?

Fedor Herbut

It has been experimentally demonstrated that quantum coherence can persist in macroscopic phenomena [J.R. Friedman et al.,Nature, 406 (2000) 43]. To face the challenge of this new fact, in this article QM in its standard form is assumed to be extended by one beable (hidden variable), i. e., a quantum observable with always definite values in nature (but usually only statistically given in the quantum state). Localization is taken as the most plausible beable. The paradoxical aspects of conventional QM take now a different form. Suitably defining the notion of "subject" fully within the QM formalism, proving the quantum conditional subsystem-state theorem, and choosing the relative-decoherence interpretation of QM, the paradoxes formally disappear, leaving one with decoherence relative to the definite values of the beable; thus being only appearance, not absolute reality in QM. Relative to a different subject one has perseverance of coherence. Hence, in this approach it is claimed that decoherence and coherence, both exist in reality, but are not "seen" by the same subject, and "subject" is, in this interpretation, indispensable. The two mentioned, apparently contradictory phenomena, are in this way decoupled from each other, contradiction is avoided, and any one of the two can be treated in the way that is usual in QM.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107049•Jul 9, 2001•2 citations

Informational Perspective on QBism and the Origins of Life

Koichiro Matsuno

One interpretation of quantum mechanics dubbed Quantum Bayesianism or QBism in short can be considered as a useful tool for approaching the origins of life as the genuine source matrix of complexity and information on the empirical ground. Any user of quantum mechanics that can assign a probability to whatever event other than itself within the framework of QBism is to occur with the conditional probability of duration approaching unity. Such a user occurring with the probability unity can be equated with the occurrence of the internal observer that can make itself durable. A physical means of making the internal user durable is through the preservation of its own class identity that can remain invariable while being subject to the constant exchange of component atomic elements. The emergence of a durable material organization upon exchanging individual component elements with another ones of the similar kinds can be taken to be an instance related to the origins of life. A concrete empirical case of a durable material organization is a reaction cycle in which each atomic component such as the carbon atom comes to experience the organizational whole from within through the constant replacement of the components. The source of complexity and information is found within the richness of counterfactual conditionals prepared and perceived by the user of quantum mechanics. Biological complexity is unique in appreciating the chemical affinity operating as crossing and integrating different tenses in a sharp contrast to the physical counterpart upon the physical affinity operating in tenseless time.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 24, 2016•0 citations
We discuss the role of probability in quantum physics: it should be that of a general tool guiding induction and must not be restricted only to the empirical interpretation coming from its evaluation by an observed frequency. It is true that in many cases the value of a probability can be sensibly expressed by a suitable frequency, but this does not entail that the latter can be taken as definition of probability. Moreover, we emphasize the role of conditional probability, and we show that looking at it from the right perspective also allows one to avoid classic paradoxical aspects of quantum physics.
In this expository paper we discuss the role of probability in statistical physics: it should be that of a general tool guiding induction and must not be restricted only to the empirical interpretation coming from its evaluation by an observed frequency. It is true that in many cases the value of a probability can be sensibly expressed by a suitable frequency, but this does not entails that the latter can be taken as definition of probability. Moreover, in each situation in which one thinks that probabilities are physically real things and believes that something which is only “very probable” can be regarded as being “practically certain”, some “small” probabilities are actually ignored: this attitude of mind may render illegitimate also the probabilistic interpretation of the relevant physical laws. A “law” which is based on a probabilistic interpretation cannot aim at explaining why a fact that we forecast will occur, but rather at explaining why we forecast that this fact will occur. Finally, we emphasize the role of conditional probability, and we show that looking at it from the right perspective allows to avoids also classic paradoxical aspects of quantum mechanics, without the need to resort to the interpretation based on the dualism “particle-wave”.
Looking at conditional probability from the right perspective allows one to avoid classic paradoxical aspects of quantum mechanics. We discuss, as an elementary analogue of quan-tum states, a classical example (an urn of unknown composition) with similar (putative) paradoxical situ-ations, despite the fact that there is no quantum effect to which they could be ascribed. A crucial feature is that we look at them from an epis-temic point of view and not from the viewpoint of a (seemingly) ontologi-cal reality.
We investigate epistemologically the meaning of probability as implied in quantum physics in connection with a proposed direct interpretation of the state function and of the related quantum theoretical quantities in terms of physical systems having physical properties, through an extension of meaning of the notion of physical quantity to complex mathematical expressions not reductible to simple numerical values. We show how the changes occurred in the implication of probabilities in quantum physics, from a penetration tool (probability as statistics and frequencies of occurencies of events) to a theoretical concept (probability given by a physically aimed at «amplitude of probability») actually make this view a somewhat «natural» one.
It has been experimentally demonstrated that quantum coherence can persist in macroscopic phenomena [J.R. Friedman et al.,Nature, 406 (2000) 43]. To face the challenge of this new fact, in this article QM in its standard form is assumed to be extended by one beable (hidden variable), i. e., a quantum observable with always definite values in nature (but usually only statistically given in the quantum state). Localization is taken as the most plausible beable. The paradoxical aspects of conventional QM take now a different form. Suitably defining the notion of "subject" fully within the QM formalism, proving the quantum conditional subsystem-state theorem, and choosing the relative-decoherence interpretation of QM, the paradoxes formally disappear, leaving one with decoherence relative to the definite values of the beable; thus being only appearance, not absolute reality in QM. Relative to a different subject one has perseverance of coherence. Hence, in this approach it is claimed that decoherence and coherence, both exist in reality, but are not "seen" by the same subject, and "subject" is, in this interpretation, indispensable. The two mentioned, apparently contradictory phenomena, are in this way decoupled from each other, contradiction is avoided, and any one of the two can be treated in the way that is usual in QM.
One interpretation of quantum mechanics dubbed Quantum Bayesianism or QBism in short can be considered as a useful tool for approaching the origins of life as the genuine source matrix of complexity and information on the empirical ground. Any user of quantum mechanics that can assign a probability to whatever event other than itself within the framework of QBism is to occur with the conditional probability of duration approaching unity. Such a user occurring with the probability unity can be equated with the occurrence of the internal observer that can make itself durable. A physical means of making the internal user durable is through the preservation of its own class identity that can remain invariable while being subject to the constant exchange of component atomic elements. The emergence of a durable material organization upon exchanging individual component elements with another ones of the similar kinds can be taken to be an instance related to the origins of life. A concrete empirical case of a durable material organization is a reaction cycle in which each atomic component such as the carbon atom comes to experience the organizational whole from within through the constant replacement of the components. The source of complexity and information is found within the richness of counterfactual conditionals prepared and perceived by the user of quantum mechanics. Biological complexity is unique in appreciating the chemical affinity operating as crossing and integrating different tenses in a sharp contrast to the physical counterpart upon the physical affinity operating in tenseless time.