Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Communications in Theoretical Physics

Comparison Between the Full Quantum Dynamics and the Quantum-Semiclassical Models to Many-Particle Systems

Gao Xian-Long, Wang Ke-Lin, Xu Fei, Shi Yun-Yu

Published Apr 15, 2001• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We consider a simple collinear collision of a "classical" particle with a harmonic oscillator within quantum-semiclassical model and full quantum dynamics model, in which the latter is solved analytically in squeezed state and exact diagonalization methods and acts as the exact solution of such a system. A comparison of these two models for different mass ratios between the "classical" particle and the quantum particle is done, which gives a criterion when using the quantum-semiclassical model.

DOI
10.1088/0253-6102/35/4/509

Related papers

Quantum-classical molecular dynamics as an approximation to full quantum dynamics

Folkmar A. Bornemann, Peter Nettesheim, Christof Schütte

This paper presents a mathematical derivation of a model for quantum-classical molecular dynamics (QCMD) as a partial classical limit of the full Schrödinger equation. This limit is achieved in two steps: separation of the full wave function and short wave asymptotics for its ‘‘classical’’ part. Both steps can be rigorously justified under the same smallness assumptions. This throws some light on the time-dependent self-consistent-field method and on mixed quantum-semiclassical models, which also depend on the separation step. On the other hand, the theory leads to a characterization of the critical situations in which the QCMD model is in danger of largely deviating from the solution of full Schrödinger equation. These critical situations are exemplified in an illustrative numerical simulation: the collinear collision of a classical particle with a harmonic quantum oscillator.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 15, 1996•117 citations

Mixed Quantum-Semiclassical Simulation

Javier Gonzalez-Conde, Andrew T. Sornborger

We study the quantum simulation of mixed quantum-semiclassical (MQS) systems, of fundamental interest in many areas of physics, such as molecular scattering and gravitational backreaction. A basic question for these systems is whether quantum algorithms of MQS systems would be valuable at all, when one could instead study the full quantum-quantum system. We study MQS simulations in the context where a semiclassical system is encoded in a Koopman-von Neumann (KvN) Hamiltonian and a standard quantum Hamiltonian describes the quantum system. In this case, because KvN and quantum Hamiltonians are constructed with the same operators on a Hilbert space, standard theorems guaranteeing simulation efficiency apply. We show that, in this context, $\textit{many-body}$ MQS particle simulations give only nominal improvements in qubit resources over quantum-quantum simulations due to logarithmic scaling in the ratio, $S_q/S_c$, of actions between quantum and semiclassical systems. However, $\textit{field}$ simulations can give improvements proportional to the ratio of quantum to semiclassical actions, $S_q/S_c$. Of particular note, due to the ratio $S_q/S_c \sim 10^{-18}$ of particle and gravitational fields, this approach could be important for semiclassical gravity. We demonstrate our approach in a model of gravitational interaction, where a harmonic oscillator mediates the interaction between two spins. In particular, we demonstrate a lack of distillable entanglement generation between spins due to classical mediators, a distinct difference in dynamics relative to the fully quantum case.

arXiv:2308.16147•Aug 30, 2023•9 citations

Quantum master equations for a system interacting with a quantum gas in the low-density limit and for the semiclassical collision model

Sergey N. Filippov, Georgii Semin, Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen

A quantum system interacting with a dilute gas experiences irreversible dynamics. The corresponding master equation can be derived within two different approaches: The fully quantum description in the low-density limit and the semiclassical collision model, where the motion of gas particles is classical whereas their internal degrees of freedom are quantum. The two approaches have been extensively studied in the literature, but their predictions have not been compared. This is mainly due to the fact that the low-density limit was extensively studied for mathematical physics purposes, whereas the collision models have been essentially developed for quantum information tasks such as a tractable description of the open quantum dynamics. Here we develop and compare both approaches for a spin system interacting with a gas of spin particles. Using some approximations, we explicitly find the corresponding master equations including the Lamb shifts and the dissipators. The low-density limit in the Born approximation for fast particles is shown to be equivalent to the semiclassical collision model in the stroboscopic approximation. We reveal that both approaches give exactly the same master equation if the gas temperature is high enough. This allows to interchangeably use complicated calculations in the low-density limit and rather simple calculations in the collision model.

arXiv:1908.11202•Physical Review A•Jan 16, 2020•15 citations

Exact classical and quantum solutions for a harmonic oscillator with variable mass and frequency

Yurong Li

Using a new simple method, exact solutions of the classical equation of motion and the quantum Schrdinger equation for a harmonic oscillator with variable mass and frequency are obtained.

College Physics•Jan 1, 2003•0 citations

Coupled Harmonic Oscillator in a System of Free Particles

Dmitry N. Makarov

The coupled quantum harmonic oscillator is one of the most researched and important model systems in quantum optics and quantum informatics. This system is often investigated for quantum entanglement in the environment. As a result, such studies are complex and can only be carried out using numerical methods that do not reveal the general pattern of such systems. In this work, the external environment is considered to be two independent particles interacting with coupled harmonic oscillators. It is shown that such a system has an exact analytical solution to the dynamic Schrödinger equation. The analysis of this solution is carried out, and the main parameters of this system are revealed. The solutions obtained can be used to study more complex systems and their quantum entanglement.

Mathematics•Jan 18, 2022•2 citations

Analytic solution for the dissipative anharmonic quantum oscillator and semiclassical analysis

Franz X. Kärtner, Axel Schenzle

The analytic solution of the time evolution of a dissipative nonlinear quantum oscillator in the generalized s-ordered representation is derived. The analytical solution allows for comparsion of the various representations with the classical and semiclassical dynamics. It is shown by the eigenvalue analysis of the evolution operators that in the case of a small nonlinearity a semiclassical analysis is an excellent approximation to the exact quantum dynamics. This is further demonstrated by using the Green's function of the anharmonic oscillator to solve the initial-value problem for a superposition of coherent states.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1993•14 citations
We consider a simple collinear collision of a "classical" particle with a harmonic oscillator within quantum-semiclassical model and full quantum dynamics model, in which the latter is solved analytically in squeezed state and exact diagonalization methods and acts as the exact solution of such a system. A comparison of these two models for different mass ratios between the "classical" particle and the quantum particle is done, which gives a criterion when using the quantum-semiclassical model.
This paper presents a mathematical derivation of a model for quantum-classical molecular dynamics (QCMD) as a partial classical limit of the full Schrödinger equation. This limit is achieved in two steps: separation of the full wave function and short wave asymptotics for its ‘‘classical’’ part. Both steps can be rigorously justified under the same smallness assumptions. This throws some light on the time-dependent self-consistent-field method and on mixed quantum-semiclassical models, which also depend on the separation step. On the other hand, the theory leads to a characterization of the critical situations in which the QCMD model is in danger of largely deviating from the solution of full Schrödinger equation. These critical situations are exemplified in an illustrative numerical simulation: the collinear collision of a classical particle with a harmonic quantum oscillator.
We study the quantum simulation of mixed quantum-semiclassical (MQS) systems, of fundamental interest in many areas of physics, such as molecular scattering and gravitational backreaction. A basic question for these systems is whether quantum algorithms of MQS systems would be valuable at all, when one could instead study the full quantum-quantum system. We study MQS simulations in the context where a semiclassical system is encoded in a Koopman-von Neumann (KvN) Hamiltonian and a standard quantum Hamiltonian describes the quantum system. In this case, because KvN and quantum Hamiltonians are constructed with the same operators on a Hilbert space, standard theorems guaranteeing simulation efficiency apply. We show that, in this context, many-body\textit{many-body}many-body MQS particle simulations give only nominal improvements in qubit resources over quantum-quantum simulations due to logarithmic scaling in the ratio, Sq/ScS_q/S_cSq​/Sc​, of actions between quantum and semiclassical systems. However, field\textit{field}field simulations can give improvements proportional to the ratio of quantum to semiclassical actions, Sq/ScS_q/S_cSq​/Sc​. Of particular note, due to the ratio Sq/Sc∼10−18S_q/S_c \sim 10^{-18}Sq​/Sc​∼10−18 of particle and gravitational fields, this approach could be important for semiclassical gravity. We demonstrate our approach in a model of gravitational interaction, where a harmonic oscillator mediates the interaction between two spins. In particular, we demonstrate a lack of distillable entanglement generation between spins due to classical mediators, a distinct difference in dynamics relative to the fully quantum case.
A quantum system interacting with a dilute gas experiences irreversible dynamics. The corresponding master equation can be derived within two different approaches: The fully quantum description in the low-density limit and the semiclassical collision model, where the motion of gas particles is classical whereas their internal degrees of freedom are quantum. The two approaches have been extensively studied in the literature, but their predictions have not been compared. This is mainly due to the fact that the low-density limit was extensively studied for mathematical physics purposes, whereas the collision models have been essentially developed for quantum information tasks such as a tractable description of the open quantum dynamics. Here we develop and compare both approaches for a spin system interacting with a gas of spin particles. Using some approximations, we explicitly find the corresponding master equations including the Lamb shifts and the dissipators. The low-density limit in the Born approximation for fast particles is shown to be equivalent to the semiclassical collision model in the stroboscopic approximation. We reveal that both approaches give exactly the same master equation if the gas temperature is high enough. This allows to interchangeably use complicated calculations in the low-density limit and rather simple calculations in the collision model.
The coupled quantum harmonic oscillator is one of the most researched and important model systems in quantum optics and quantum informatics. This system is often investigated for quantum entanglement in the environment. As a result, such studies are complex and can only be carried out using numerical methods that do not reveal the general pattern of such systems. In this work, the external environment is considered to be two independent particles interacting with coupled harmonic oscillators. It is shown that such a system has an exact analytical solution to the dynamic Schrödinger equation. The analysis of this solution is carried out, and the main parameters of this system are revealed. The solutions obtained can be used to study more complex systems and their quantum entanglement.
The analytic solution of the time evolution of a dissipative nonlinear quantum oscillator in the generalized s-ordered representation is derived. The analytical solution allows for comparsion of the various representations with the classical and semiclassical dynamics. It is shown by the eigenvalue analysis of the evolution operators that in the case of a small nonlinearity a semiclassical analysis is an excellent approximation to the exact quantum dynamics. This is further demonstrated by using the Green's function of the anharmonic oscillator to solve the initial-value problem for a superposition of coherent states.