Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters

Bose–Einstein condensation in mesoscopic systems: The self-similar structure of the critical region and the nonequivalence of the canonical and grand canonical ensembles

Vl. V. Kocharovsky, Vl. V. Kocharovsky, Sergey V. Tarasov

Published Jan 1, 2016• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The analytical theory of Bose–Einstein condensation of an ideal gas in mesoscopic systems has been briefly reviewed in application to traps with arbitrary shapes and dimension. This theory describes the phases of the classical gas and the formed Bose–Einstein condensate, as well as the entire vicinity of the phase transition point. The statistics and thermodynamics of Bose–Einstein condensation have been studied in detail, including their self-similar structure in the critical region, transition to the thermodynamic limit, effect of boundary conditions on the properties of a system, and nonequivalence of the description of Bose–Einstein condensation in different statistical ensembles. The complete classification of universality classes of Bose–Einstein condensation has been given.

DOI
10.1134/s0021364016010070

Related papers

Self-similarity of the statistics in the critical region of Bose condensation of ideal gas in mesoscopic traps: Canonical and grand canonical ensembles

Sergey V. Tarasov

For an ideal Bose gas confined in a trap of arbitrary dimension and shape, the features of probabilistic distributions of the number of particles at the ground and all excited levels are studied within canonical and grand canonical ensembles. It is shown that in the critical range of system parameters the statistics is self-similar, and its characteristic scales (mathematical expectation, variance, etc.) are independent of an ensemble used in the description. At the same time, the selfsimilar distributions themselves differ for different ensembles.

Bulletin of the Lebedev Physics Institute•Apr 1, 2016•1 citation

Analytical theory of mesoscopic Bose-Einstein condensation in an ideal gas

Vitaly V. Kocharovsky, Vl. V. Kocharovsky

We find the universal structure and scaling of the Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) statistics and thermodynamics (Gibbs free energy, average energy, heat capacity) for a mesoscopic canonical-ensemble ideal gas in a trap with an arbitrary number of atoms, any volume, and any temperature, including the whole critical region. We identify a universal constraint-cutoff mechanism that makes BEC fluctuations strongly non-Gaussian and is responsible for all unusual critical phenomena of the BEC phase transition in the ideal gas. The main result is an analytical solution to the problem of critical phenomena. It is derived by, first, calculating analytically the universal probability distribution of the noncondensate occupation, or a Landau function, and then using it for the analytical calculation of the universal functions for the particular physical quantities via the exact formulas which express the constraint-cutoff mechanism. We find asymptotics of that analytical solution as well as its simple analytical approximations which describe the universal structure of the critical region in terms of the parabolic cylinder or confluent hypergeometric functions. The obtained results for the order parameter, all higher-order moments of BEC fluctuations, and thermodynamic quantities perfectly match the known asymptotics outside the critical region for both low and high temperature limits. We suggest two- and three-level trap models of BEC and find their exact solutions in terms of the cutoff negative binomial distribution (which tends to the cutoff gamma distribution in the continuous limit) and the confluent hypergeometric distribution, respectively. Also, we present an exactly solvable cutoff Gaussian model of BEC in a degenerate interacting gas. All these exact solutions confirm the universality and constraint-cutoff origin of the strongly non-Gaussian BEC statistics. We introduce a regular refinement scheme for the condensate statistics approximations on the basis of the infrared universality of higher-order cumulants and the method of superposition and show how to model BEC statistics in the actual traps. In particular, we find that the three-level trap model with matching the first four or five cumulants is enough to yield remarkably accurate results for all interesting quantities in the whole critical region. We derive an exact multinomial expansion for the noncondensate occupation probability distribution and find its high-temperature asymptotics (Poisson distribution) and corrections to it. Finally, we demonstrate that the critical exponents and a few known terms of the Taylor expansion of the universal functions, which were calculated previously from fitting the finite-size simulations within the phenomenological renormalization-group theory, can be easily obtained from the presented full analytical solutions for the mesoscopic BEC as certain approximations in the close vicinity of the critical point.

arXiv:1511.01610•Physical Review A•Mar 23, 2010•31 citations

Universal scaling in the statistics and thermodynamics of a Bose-Einstein condensation of an ideal gas in an arbitrary trap

Sergey V. Tarasov, Vl. V. Kocharovsky, Vitaly V. Kocharovsky

We analytically calculate the critical phenomena of a Bose-Einstein condensation of an ideal gas in an arbitrary trap with any mesoscopic or macroscopic number of particles and find all universality classes of the system's statistics and thermodynamics. In particular, we find analytically the universal fine structure of the famous discontinuity in the value or/and derivative of the specific heat in the critical region around the $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ point.

Physical Review A•Sep 3, 2014•23 citations

Mesoscopic Effects in Bose-Einstein Condensate Fluctuations of an Ideal Gas in a Box

Konstantin E. Dorfman

The mesoscopic effects in the quantum trapped gases of the Bose atoms constitute\nthe main subject of the present thesis. These effects are the most difficult for\nthe theoretical analysis in the quantum statistical physics since they can’t be seen by\nneither a standard quantum mechanics of the simple microscopic systems of one or\nvery few atoms nor a standard statistical physics of the macroscopic systems that are\ninfinite in the bulk (thermodynamic) limit.\nMost of the experiments on the cold quantum gases performed in the last decade,\nstarting from the first demonstration of BEC in 1995, involve the mesoscopic systems\nof a finite number of atoms. The mesoscopic effects should manifest themselves most\nclearly and easily near a critical temperature of BEC; however, they could be observed\nalso above and below the critical temperature.\nHere I study the quantum and thermal fluctuations of the Bose-Einstein condensate\n(BEC) in a box with the periodic boundary conditions under a particle-number\nconstraint. The above constraint is the only reason for the BEC and is crucial for the\nmesoscopic effects in the BEC fluctuations, especially in the vicinity of the critical\ntemperature in the Bose gas.\nI employ the particle-number conserving operator formalism of Girardeau and\nArnowitt introduced in 1959 to analyze the canonical ensemble fluctuations. I present\nanalytical formulas and numerical calculations for the central moments of the ground\nstate occupation fluctuations in an ideal Bose gas in a box with a mesoscopic number of particles.\nI present the analysis of the BEC statistics both on a temperature at a fixed\nnumber of particles and on a number of particles at a fixed temperature. Both analyses\nare valid for the purpose of understanding the important mesoscopic effects near the\ncritical temperature. I emphasize the non-Gaussian nature of the fluctuations.\nThe presented formalism can be generalized to the case of a weakly interacting\nBose gas in a box in the framework of the Bogoliubov approximation. The work in\nthis direction is in progress but is not included in the present thesis.

•May 15, 2009•0 citations

Self-similar analytical solution of the critical fluctuations problem for the Bose–Einstein condensation in an ideal gas

Vitaly V. Kocharovsky, Vl. V. Kocharovsky

Paper is published in J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 43 (2010) 225001, doi:10.1088/1751-8113/43/22/225001. Exact analytical solution for the universal probability distribution of the order parameter fluctuations as well as for the universal statistical and thermodynamic functions of an ideal gas in the whole critical region of Bose-Einstein condensation is obtained. A universal constraint nonlinearity is found that is responsible for all nontrivial critical phenomena of the BEC phase transition. Simple analytical approximations, which describe the universal structure of the critical region in terms of confluent hypergeometric or parabolic cylinder functions, as well as asymptotics of the exact solution are derived. The results for the order parameter, all higher-order moments of BEC fluctuations, and thermodynamic quantities, including specific heat, perfectly match the known asymptotics outside critical region as well as the phenomenological renormalization-group ansatz with known critical exponents in the close vicinity of the critical point. Thus, a full analytical solution to a long-standing problem of finding a universal structure of the lambda-point for BEC in an ideal gas is found.

arXiv:1511.01893•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 11, 2010•9 citations

The Bose-Einstein condensation in a finite one-dimensional homogeneous system of noninteracting bosons

В. А. Алексеев

Condensation of the ideal Bose gas in a closed volume having the shape of a rectangular parallel-epiped of length L with a square base of side length l ( L ≫ l ) is theoretically studied within the framework of the Bose-Einstein statistics (grand canonical ensemble) and within the statistics of a canonical ensemble of bosons. Under the condition N ( l/L ) 4 ≪ l, where N is the total number of gas particles, dependence of the average number of particles in the condensate on the temperature T in both statistics is expressed as a function of the ratio t = T/T 1 , where T 1 is a certain characteristic temperature depending only on the longitudinal size L . Therefore, the condensation process exhibits a one-dimensional (1D) character. In the 1D regime, the average numbers of particles in condensates of the grand canonical and canonical ensembles coincide only in the limiting cases of t → 0 and t → ∞. The distribution function of the number of particles in the condensate of a canonical ensemble of bosons at t ≤1 has a resonance shape and qualitatively differs from the Bose-Einstein distribution. The former distribution begins to change in the region of t ∼ 1 and acquires the shape of the Bose-Einstein distribution for t ≫ 1. This transformation proceeds gradually that is, the 1D condensation process exhibits no features characteristic of the phase transition in a 3D system. For N ( l/L ) 4 ≫ 1, the process acquires a 3D character with respect to the average number of particles in the condensate, but the 1D character of the distribution function of the number of particles in the condensate of a canonical ensemble of bosons is retained at all N values.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Jun 1, 2002•2 citations
The analytical theory of Bose–Einstein condensation of an ideal gas in mesoscopic systems has been briefly reviewed in application to traps with arbitrary shapes and dimension. This theory describes the phases of the classical gas and the formed Bose–Einstein condensate, as well as the entire vicinity of the phase transition point. The statistics and thermodynamics of Bose–Einstein condensation have been studied in detail, including their self-similar structure in the critical region, transition to the thermodynamic limit, effect of boundary conditions on the properties of a system, and nonequivalence of the description of Bose–Einstein condensation in different statistical ensembles. The complete classification of universality classes of Bose–Einstein condensation has been given.
For an ideal Bose gas confined in a trap of arbitrary dimension and shape, the features of probabilistic distributions of the number of particles at the ground and all excited levels are studied within canonical and grand canonical ensembles. It is shown that in the critical range of system parameters the statistics is self-similar, and its characteristic scales (mathematical expectation, variance, etc.) are independent of an ensemble used in the description. At the same time, the selfsimilar distributions themselves differ for different ensembles.
We find the universal structure and scaling of the Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) statistics and thermodynamics (Gibbs free energy, average energy, heat capacity) for a mesoscopic canonical-ensemble ideal gas in a trap with an arbitrary number of atoms, any volume, and any temperature, including the whole critical region. We identify a universal constraint-cutoff mechanism that makes BEC fluctuations strongly non-Gaussian and is responsible for all unusual critical phenomena of the BEC phase transition in the ideal gas. The main result is an analytical solution to the problem of critical phenomena. It is derived by, first, calculating analytically the universal probability distribution of the noncondensate occupation, or a Landau function, and then using it for the analytical calculation of the universal functions for the particular physical quantities via the exact formulas which express the constraint-cutoff mechanism. We find asymptotics of that analytical solution as well as its simple analytical approximations which describe the universal structure of the critical region in terms of the parabolic cylinder or confluent hypergeometric functions. The obtained results for the order parameter, all higher-order moments of BEC fluctuations, and thermodynamic quantities perfectly match the known asymptotics outside the critical region for both low and high temperature limits. We suggest two- and three-level trap models of BEC and find their exact solutions in terms of the cutoff negative binomial distribution (which tends to the cutoff gamma distribution in the continuous limit) and the confluent hypergeometric distribution, respectively. Also, we present an exactly solvable cutoff Gaussian model of BEC in a degenerate interacting gas. All these exact solutions confirm the universality and constraint-cutoff origin of the strongly non-Gaussian BEC statistics. We introduce a regular refinement scheme for the condensate statistics approximations on the basis of the infrared universality of higher-order cumulants and the method of superposition and show how to model BEC statistics in the actual traps. In particular, we find that the three-level trap model with matching the first four or five cumulants is enough to yield remarkably accurate results for all interesting quantities in the whole critical region. We derive an exact multinomial expansion for the noncondensate occupation probability distribution and find its high-temperature asymptotics (Poisson distribution) and corrections to it. Finally, we demonstrate that the critical exponents and a few known terms of the Taylor expansion of the universal functions, which were calculated previously from fitting the finite-size simulations within the phenomenological renormalization-group theory, can be easily obtained from the presented full analytical solutions for the mesoscopic BEC as certain approximations in the close vicinity of the critical point.
The mesoscopic effects in the quantum trapped gases of the Bose atoms constitute\nthe main subject of the present thesis. These effects are the most difficult for\nthe theoretical analysis in the quantum statistical physics since they can’t be seen by\nneither a standard quantum mechanics of the simple microscopic systems of one or\nvery few atoms nor a standard statistical physics of the macroscopic systems that are\ninfinite in the bulk (thermodynamic) limit.\nMost of the experiments on the cold quantum gases performed in the last decade,\nstarting from the first demonstration of BEC in 1995, involve the mesoscopic systems\nof a finite number of atoms. The mesoscopic effects should manifest themselves most\nclearly and easily near a critical temperature of BEC; however, they could be observed\nalso above and below the critical temperature.\nHere I study the quantum and thermal fluctuations of the Bose-Einstein condensate\n(BEC) in a box with the periodic boundary conditions under a particle-number\nconstraint. The above constraint is the only reason for the BEC and is crucial for the\nmesoscopic effects in the BEC fluctuations, especially in the vicinity of the critical\ntemperature in the Bose gas.\nI employ the particle-number conserving operator formalism of Girardeau and\nArnowitt introduced in 1959 to analyze the canonical ensemble fluctuations. I present\nanalytical formulas and numerical calculations for the central moments of the ground\nstate occupation fluctuations in an ideal Bose gas in a box with a mesoscopic number of particles.\nI present the analysis of the BEC statistics both on a temperature at a fixed\nnumber of particles and on a number of particles at a fixed temperature. Both analyses\nare valid for the purpose of understanding the important mesoscopic effects near the\ncritical temperature. I emphasize the non-Gaussian nature of the fluctuations.\nThe presented formalism can be generalized to the case of a weakly interacting\nBose gas in a box in the framework of the Bogoliubov approximation. The work in\nthis direction is in progress but is not included in the present thesis.
Paper is published in J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 43 (2010) 225001, doi:10.1088/1751-8113/43/22/225001. Exact analytical solution for the universal probability distribution of the order parameter fluctuations as well as for the universal statistical and thermodynamic functions of an ideal gas in the whole critical region of Bose-Einstein condensation is obtained. A universal constraint nonlinearity is found that is responsible for all nontrivial critical phenomena of the BEC phase transition. Simple analytical approximations, which describe the universal structure of the critical region in terms of confluent hypergeometric or parabolic cylinder functions, as well as asymptotics of the exact solution are derived. The results for the order parameter, all higher-order moments of BEC fluctuations, and thermodynamic quantities, including specific heat, perfectly match the known asymptotics outside critical region as well as the phenomenological renormalization-group ansatz with known critical exponents in the close vicinity of the critical point. Thus, a full analytical solution to a long-standing problem of finding a universal structure of the lambda-point for BEC in an ideal gas is found.
Condensation of the ideal Bose gas in a closed volume having the shape of a rectangular parallel-epiped of length L with a square base of side length l ( L ≫ l ) is theoretically studied within the framework of the Bose-Einstein statistics (grand canonical ensemble) and within the statistics of a canonical ensemble of bosons. Under the condition N ( l/L ) 4 ≪ l, where N is the total number of gas particles, dependence of the average number of particles in the condensate on the temperature T in both statistics is expressed as a function of the ratio t = T/T 1 , where T 1 is a certain characteristic temperature depending only on the longitudinal size L . Therefore, the condensation process exhibits a one-dimensional (1D) character. In the 1D regime, the average numbers of particles in condensates of the grand canonical and canonical ensembles coincide only in the limiting cases of t → 0 and t → ∞. The distribution function of the number of particles in the condensate of a canonical ensemble of bosons at t ≤1 has a resonance shape and qualitatively differs from the Bose-Einstein distribution. The former distribution begins to change in the region of t ∼ 1 and acquires the shape of the Bose-Einstein distribution for t ≫ 1. This transformation proceeds gradually that is, the 1D condensation process exhibits no features characteristic of the phase transition in a 3D system. For N ( l/L ) 4 ≫ 1, the process acquires a 3D character with respect to the average number of particles in the condensate, but the 1D character of the distribution function of the number of particles in the condensate of a canonical ensemble of bosons is retained at all N values.