Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum theory from one global symmetry

Chris Fields

Published Feb 26, 2014• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Decompositional equivalence is the principle that there is no preferred decomposition of the universe into subsystems. It is shown here, by using simple thought experiments, that quantum theory follows from decompositional equivalence together with Landauer's principle. This demonstration raises within physics a question previously left to psychology: how do human - or any - observers agree about what constitutes a system of interest?

Related papers

Partitions in quantum theory

Augustin Vanrietvelde, Octave Mestoudjian, Pablo J. Arrighi

Decompositional theories describe the ways in which a global physical system can be split into subsystems, facilitating the study of how different possible partitions of the same system interplay, e.g. in terms of inclusions or signalling. In quantum theory, subsystems are usually framed as sub-C*-algebras of the algebra of operators on the global system. However, most decompositional approaches have so far restricted their scope to the case of systems corresponding to factor algebras. We argue that this is a mistake: one should cater for the possibility for non-factor subsystems, arising for instance from symmetry considerations. Building on simple examples, we motivate and present a definition of partitions into an arbitrary number of parts, each of which is a possibly non-factor sub-C*-algebra. We discuss its physical interpretation and study its properties, in particular with regard to the structure of algebras' centres. We prove that partitions, defined at the C*-algebraic level, can be represented in terms of a splitting of Hilbert spaces, using the framework of routed quantum circuits. For some partitions, however, such a representation necessarily retains a residual pseudo-nonlocality. We provide an example of this behaviour, given by the partition of a fermionic system into local modes.

arXiv:2506.22218•Jun 27, 2025•9 citations

Quantum steering is equivalent to state-preserving conditional expectations

Lauritz van Luijk, Amine Marrakchi, Tobias Osborne +2 more

In systems with infinitely many degrees of freedom, fundamental results from quantum information theory can fail. An important example is the uniqueness of purifications: Even when two subsystems, described by commuting von Neumann algebras $A$ and $B$, are tomographically complete, purifications of a state on $A$ need not be related by unitaries in $B$. It was recently shown that this occurs precisely when Haag duality fails, i.e., when the commutant $B'$ is strictly larger than $A$. This raises the question of which fundamental entanglement properties survive in such a setting. We show that, for a pure global state, the ability to steer any ensemble decomposition of the marginal state on $A$ by measurements on $B$ is equivalent to the existence of a state-preserving conditional expectation from $B'$ onto $A$. This establishes a direct connection between quantum steering and subfactor theory. The key observation is that steering is equivalent to the existence of extensions of ensemble decompositions from $A$ to $B'$. Working with general Jordan algebras, we prove that unital positive maps have state-preserving left inverses if and only if ensemble decompositions can be lifted. For the inclusion $A\hookrightarrow B'$, a left inverse is precisely a conditional expectation, yielding the characterization above.

quant-pharXiv:2608.10783•Aug 12, 2026•3 citations

An additive Hamiltonian plus Landauer's Principle yields quantum theory

Chris Fields

It is shown that no-signalling, a quantum of action, unitarity, detailed balance, Bell's theorem, the Hilbert-space representation of physical states and the Born rule all follow from the assumption of an additive Hamiltonian together with Landauer's principle. Common statements of the classical limit of quantum theory, as well as common assumptions made by interpretations of quantum theory, contradict additivity, Landauer's principle, or both.

•Nov 13, 2014•0 citations

Decompositional equivalence

Chris Fields

Both classical and quantum mechanics assume that physical laws are invariant under changes in the way that the world is labeled. This Principle of Decompositional Equivalence is formalized, and shown to forbid finite experimental demonstrations that given pointer states |p1> and |p2> refer to the same physical system S. It is then shown that any extra-theoretical assumption that given pointer states |p1> and |p2> with indistinguishable coefficients in a Schmidt basis for the universe refer to the same physical system S is stronger than the assumption of classicality. Standard interpretations of quantum mechanics make such as assumption in analyzing measurement; hence they are logically inconsistent.

arXiv:1004.1868•Apr 12, 2010•0 citations

Global Consistency of Operational Decomposition in the Intrinsic Observability Framework

Atsushi Okamoto

Operational decomposition has been introduced within the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF) as the structural process through which observation establishes the operational assignment of the latent structure within the observable and hidden domains. However, once multiple observations independently establish their respective operational decompositions, an important question arises: why do these independently established operational assignments remain mutually coherent rather than producing incompatible operational realities? In the present work, we address this problem by introducing the Global Consistency Rule (GCR) for operational decomposition. The GCR states that independently established operational decompositions need not be identical, but their mutual relations must satisfy common consistency conditions that preserve the coherence of operational reality. From this perspective, Relational Access Symmetry (RAS) is interpreted as an ideal relational consistency principle governing the organization of observational structures, whereas Access Transformation Symmetry (ATS) provides the operational consistency realized among physically accessible decompositions. Together, these complementary principles provide the structural basis of the GCR and constrain operational decomposition without eliminating its observational and accessibility dependence. The present formulation does not modify the mathematical formalism or empirical predictions of quantum mechanics. Instead, it provides a structural interpretation of why independently established operational decompositions can differ while remaining mutually coherent. The proposed framework therefore extends the IOF from a theory describing the establishment of operational decomposition to one in which the admissible relationships among multiple operational decompositions are explicitly constrained by a global consistency rule, allowing them to collectively constitute a coherent operational reality.

•Aug 16, 2026•0 citations

On the Equivalence Principle of Quantum Mechanics

J. M. Isidro

A recent concept in theoretical physics, motivated in string duality and M-theory, is the notion that not all quantum theories arise from quantising a classical system. Also, a given quantum model may possess more than just one classical limit. In view of these developments, we analyse some general properties that quantum mechanics must satisfy, if it is not to be formulated as a quantisation of a given classical mechanics. Instead, our approach to quantum mechanics is modelled on a statement that is close in spirit to the equivalence principle of general relativity, thus bearing a strong resemblance with the equivalence principle of quantum mechanics formulated by Faraggi-Matone.

arXiv:quant-ph/0105012•May 3, 2001•4 citations
Decompositional equivalence is the principle that there is no preferred decomposition of the universe into subsystems. It is shown here, by using simple thought experiments, that quantum theory follows from decompositional equivalence together with Landauer's principle. This demonstration raises within physics a question previously left to psychology: how do human - or any - observers agree about what constitutes a system of interest?
Decompositional theories describe the ways in which a global physical system can be split into subsystems, facilitating the study of how different possible partitions of the same system interplay, e.g. in terms of inclusions or signalling. In quantum theory, subsystems are usually framed as sub-C*-algebras of the algebra of operators on the global system. However, most decompositional approaches have so far restricted their scope to the case of systems corresponding to factor algebras. We argue that this is a mistake: one should cater for the possibility for non-factor subsystems, arising for instance from symmetry considerations. Building on simple examples, we motivate and present a definition of partitions into an arbitrary number of parts, each of which is a possibly non-factor sub-C*-algebra. We discuss its physical interpretation and study its properties, in particular with regard to the structure of algebras' centres. We prove that partitions, defined at the C*-algebraic level, can be represented in terms of a splitting of Hilbert spaces, using the framework of routed quantum circuits. For some partitions, however, such a representation necessarily retains a residual pseudo-nonlocality. We provide an example of this behaviour, given by the partition of a fermionic system into local modes.
In systems with infinitely many degrees of freedom, fundamental results from quantum information theory can fail. An important example is the uniqueness of purifications: Even when two subsystems, described by commuting von Neumann algebras AAA and BBB, are tomographically complete, purifications of a state on AAA need not be related by unitaries in BBB. It was recently shown that this occurs precisely when Haag duality fails, i.e., when the commutant B′B'B′ is strictly larger than AAA. This raises the question of which fundamental entanglement properties survive in such a setting. We show that, for a pure global state, the ability to steer any ensemble decomposition of the marginal state on AAA by measurements on BBB is equivalent to the existence of a state-preserving conditional expectation from B′B'B′ onto AAA. This establishes a direct connection between quantum steering and subfactor theory. The key observation is that steering is equivalent to the existence of extensions of ensemble decompositions from AAA to B′B'B′. Working with general Jordan algebras, we prove that unital positive maps have state-preserving left inverses if and only if ensemble decompositions can be lifted. For the inclusion A↪B′A\hookrightarrow B'A↪B′, a left inverse is precisely a conditional expectation, yielding the characterization above.
Both classical and quantum mechanics assume that physical laws are invariant under changes in the way that the world is labeled. This Principle of Decompositional Equivalence is formalized, and shown to forbid finite experimental demonstrations that given pointer states |p1> and |p2> refer to the same physical system S. It is then shown that any extra-theoretical assumption that given pointer states |p1> and |p2> with indistinguishable coefficients in a Schmidt basis for the universe refer to the same physical system S is stronger than the assumption of classicality. Standard interpretations of quantum mechanics make such as assumption in analyzing measurement; hence they are logically inconsistent.
Operational decomposition has been introduced within the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF) as the structural process through which observation establishes the operational assignment of the latent structure within the observable and hidden domains. However, once multiple observations independently establish their respective operational decompositions, an important question arises: why do these independently established operational assignments remain mutually coherent rather than producing incompatible operational realities? In the present work, we address this problem by introducing the Global Consistency Rule (GCR) for operational decomposition. The GCR states that independently established operational decompositions need not be identical, but their mutual relations must satisfy common consistency conditions that preserve the coherence of operational reality. From this perspective, Relational Access Symmetry (RAS) is interpreted as an ideal relational consistency principle governing the organization of observational structures, whereas Access Transformation Symmetry (ATS) provides the operational consistency realized among physically accessible decompositions. Together, these complementary principles provide the structural basis of the GCR and constrain operational decomposition without eliminating its observational and accessibility dependence. The present formulation does not modify the mathematical formalism or empirical predictions of quantum mechanics. Instead, it provides a structural interpretation of why independently established operational decompositions can differ while remaining mutually coherent. The proposed framework therefore extends the IOF from a theory describing the establishment of operational decomposition to one in which the admissible relationships among multiple operational decompositions are explicitly constrained by a global consistency rule, allowing them to collectively constitute a coherent operational reality.
A recent concept in theoretical physics, motivated in string duality and M-theory, is the notion that not all quantum theories arise from quantising a classical system. Also, a given quantum model may possess more than just one classical limit. In view of these developments, we analyse some general properties that quantum mechanics must satisfy, if it is not to be formulated as a quantisation of a given classical mechanics. Instead, our approach to quantum mechanics is modelled on a statement that is close in spirit to the equivalence principle of general relativity, thus bearing a strong resemblance with the equivalence principle of quantum mechanics formulated by Faraggi-Matone.