Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bose-Einstein versus Maxwell-Boltzmann distributions

P. Enders, Ahornallee Senzig

Published Jan 1, 2011• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

The reply by Sands & Dunning-Davies [3] to my paper [1] is acknowledged concerning the distribution functions. Keywords: Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution, Bose-Einstein distribution, classical ensembles, state functions In my paper ‘Are there physical systems obeying the Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics?’[1] I have written down the well-known probabilities of the 4 possible results of one fair toss of 2 fair coins according to the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB), Bose-Einstein (BE) and Fermi-Dirac (FD) statistics. The two results coin 1 = head, coin 2 = tail and coin 2 = head, coin 1 = tail are counting as different in MB and as one and the same in BE and in FD. Then, I have quoted Gibbs [2], that the interchange of two © 2011 C. Roy Keys Inc. — http://redshift.vif.comApeiron, Vol. 18, No. 1, January 2011 16

Related papers

Distribution Functions in Physics and Mathematics Why Fermi–Dirac and Bose–Einstein Balance Equations are not Distributions from an Axiomatic Perspective

Pascal Moser

The term ‘Verteilungsfunktion’ (distribution function) is used in physics as a semantic container for at least four ontologically distinct mathematical objects: proper probability density functions (PDFs), probability mass functions (PMFs), expectation values of occu-pation numbers, and phase-space measure densities. This conflation arose historically because the statistical mechanics of Boltzmann, Maxwell, Fermi, Dirac and Bose predates Kolmogorov’s axiomatic probability theory (1933) by decades; no systematic back-mapping was ever performed. The central finding concerns the Fermi–Dirac and Bose–Einstein functions specifically: they are not merely mislabeled — they are relative measurements, bounded observable expectation values ⟨nk⟩-normalised against their capacity. Each of the five objects routinely called a ‘distribution function’ is audited against the Kolmogorov taxonomy: the Maxwell–Boltzmann speed distribution is a proper PDF that is merely mislabeled; the Boltzmann canonical distribution is a genuine probability measure; the Boltzmann-transport phase-space density is normalised toNrather than to unity; and the Fermi–Dirac and Bose–Einstein functions are occupation-number expectation values that acquire physical meaning only as convolution kernels against the density of states. A short supporting section shows that this is not an accident of two particular formulas. One elementary theorem establishes that a bounded occupation of capacityMunder Boltz-mann weighting with an additive constraint yields⟨n⟩M= −d ln ZM/dx; atM=1 this is exactly the logistic function, and at M→∞it diverges. Fermi–Dirac and Bose–Einstein are therefore the two branches of a single construction, which is why the first is bounded in [0, 1]and the second admits no bounded normalisation at all. The same unit-capacity form appears outside physics wherever a bounded quantity accumulates additive evidence, which suggests that such objects are best read as relative measurements against a capacity rather than as distributions. The paper reconstructs the historical sequence that produced the terminological divergence and proposes notational conventions to restore conceptual clarity in pedagogy and literature. Keywords: probability density function, distribution function, Fermi–Dirac, Bose–Einstein, Maxwell–Boltzmann, Kolmogorov, Jaynes, ontology, statistical mechanics, probability theory, quantum statistics, foundations of physics,philosophy of science, physics education, information theory, thermodynamics.

•Aug 3, 2026•0 citations

Modification of Fermi-Dirac/Bose-Einstein Distributions Based on Pure State Entropy?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In a previous note (1) we argued that for a wavefunction W(x,t)= Sum over n an exp(iEnt) Wn(x), the entropy for a particle in a box with infinite potential walls from (2) is: S/(-k)= Sum over n |anan| ln |anan| ((1)) and should be modified to: S/(-k)= Sum over n |anan| ln|anan| + |anan| Sp(n,L) + |anan| Sx(L) ((2)) where Sp and Sx are the pure state momentum and spatial entropies i.e Sp/-k = Integral dp an(p)an(p) ln|an(p)an(p)| and Sx/(-k) = Integral dx W*n(x)Wn(x) ln[Wn*Wn|. In (2) the Clausius relationship: dQ/T = dS is used where dQ = Sum over n En d|anan| and T is temperature to find an expression for |anan|. In general this would be: |anan| = exp(-En/T) , but with ((2)) we find: |anan| = exp(-En/kT) exp(-1-B(n)) ((3)) where B(n)= Sp(n)+Sx. L portions form Sp and Sx cancel so there is no L dependence, L being the size of the box. Given the different form ((3)) we suggest that the Fermi-Dirac (FD) and Bose-Einstein (BE) distributions may change if one uses the grand partition function approach. For example, exp(-ni ei/kT) is replaced by: exp(-ni ei/kT) exp(-ni(1+B(n)). This leads to changes in the FD and BD distributions: zexp(-Ei/kT)exp(-1-B(i) / [1 +/- exp(-u/kT) exp(-ei/kT) exp(-1-B(i))] where z=exp(u/kT), u being the chemical potential. In the high n limit B(n)--> constant (3) so the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) distribution remains unchanged. The MB distribution has been verified to high precision and so modifications related to 1+B(n) might have been noticed had B(n) remained a function of n.

•Feb 7, 2022•0 citations

Boltzmann, Gibbs, and Darwin-Fowler Approaches in Parastatistics

Roberto Leon Ponczek, C. C. Yan

There are essentially three methods used in equilibrium statistical mechanics, namely, the Boltzmann method of identifying the equilibrium sta te with the most probable one; the Gibbs ensemble method of postulating a canonical distribution; and the Darwin-Fowler method' of identifying the equilibrium state with the average state. Most textbooks on statis tical mechanics include discussions of the first two methods. The in clusion into the text of the last method, which schrudinger2 seems to advocate, is less usual . The equivalence of those methods is usual 1 y demonstrated for the i deal Boltzmann, Bose - Einstein, and Fermi-Dirac sta tistics. However, the equivalence is not guaranteed when the methodsare applied to different statistics such as parastatistics3, where eachener gy leve1 can afford up to some number k of particles, and can be regar ded as a generalization of the above mentioned statistics. It seems desirable to confirm t he equivalence of those methods for parastatistics. In most textbooks however discussions on parastatistics are r ather rare.

Revista brasileira de fisica•Jan 1, 1976•0 citations

Statistics of mesoscopic ensembles of bosons and fermions

В. А. Алексеев

Equilibrium distribution functions are obtained for boson and fermion ensembles with a limited number of particles. It is shown that the number-of-particle distribution functions in different quantum states are statistically dependent; this dependence disappears only for a large number of particles in the ensemble. The distributions are transformed into the Boltzmann distribution at a high temperature and into the Bose-Einstein and Fermi-Dirac distributions for a large number of particles in the ensemble.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Jun 1, 2011•4 citations

Classical model of intermediate statistics

G. Kaniadakis

In this work we present a classical kinetic model of intermediate statistics. In the case of Brownian particles we show that the Fermi-Dirac (FD) and Bose-Einstein (BE) distributions can be obtained, just as the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) distribution, as steady states of a classical kinetic equation that intrinsically takes into account an exclusion-inclusion principle. In our model the intermediate statistics are obtained as steady states of a system of coupled nonlinear kinetic equations, where the coupling constants are the transmutational potentials ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\eta}}}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\kappa}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\kappa}}\ensuremath{'}}$. We show that, besides the FD-BE intermediate statistics extensively studied from the quantum point of view, we can also study the MB-FD and MB-BE ones. Moreover, our model allows us to treat the three-state mixing FD-MB-BE intermediate statistics. For boson and fermion mixing in a D-dimensional space, we obtain a family of FD-BE intermediate statistics by varying the transmutational potential ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\eta}}}_{\mathrm{BF}}$. This family contains, as a particular case, when ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\eta}}}_{\mathrm{B}\mathrm{F}=0}$, the quantum statistics recently proposed by L. Wu, Z. Wu, and J. Sun [Phys. Lett. A 170, 280 (1992)]. When we consider the two-dimensional FD-BE statistics, we derive an analytic expression of the fraction of fermions. When the temperature T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}, the system is composed by an equal number of bosons and fermions, regardless of the value of ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\eta}}}_{\mathrm{BF}}$. On the contrary, when T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0, ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\eta}}}_{\mathrm{BF}}$ becomes important and, according to its value, the system can be completely bosonic or fermionic, or composed both by bosons and fermions.

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Jun 1, 1994•13 citations

A Note on the Partition Function for Systems of Independent Particles

Douglas Ike Ford

The N-particle Bose-Einstein and Fermi-Dirac canonical partition functions are expressed explicitly in terms of the single-particle partition function. The nature of the approximations made in using corrected Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics is thereby made more obvious. A recurrence relation is developed to facilitate calculations using the exact partition function.

American Journal of Physics•Feb 1, 1971•12 citations
The reply by Sands & Dunning-Davies [3] to my paper [1] is acknowledged concerning the distribution functions. Keywords: Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution, Bose-Einstein distribution, classical ensembles, state functions In my paper ‘Are there physical systems obeying the Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics?’[1] I have written down the well-known probabilities of the 4 possible results of one fair toss of 2 fair coins according to the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB), Bose-Einstein (BE) and Fermi-Dirac (FD) statistics. The two results coin 1 = head, coin 2 = tail and coin 2 = head, coin 1 = tail are counting as different in MB and as one and the same in BE and in FD. Then, I have quoted Gibbs [2], that the interchange of two © 2011 C. Roy Keys Inc. — http://redshift.vif.comApeiron, Vol. 18, No. 1, January 2011 16
The term ‘Verteilungsfunktion’ (distribution function) is used in physics as a semantic container for at least four ontologically distinct mathematical objects: proper probability density functions (PDFs), probability mass functions (PMFs), expectation values of occu-pation numbers, and phase-space measure densities. This conflation arose historically because the statistical mechanics of Boltzmann, Maxwell, Fermi, Dirac and Bose predates Kolmogorov’s axiomatic probability theory (1933) by decades; no systematic back-mapping was ever performed. The central finding concerns the Fermi–Dirac and Bose–Einstein functions specifically: they are not merely mislabeled — they are relative measurements, bounded observable expectation values ⟨nk⟩-normalised against their capacity. Each of the five objects routinely called a ‘distribution function’ is audited against the Kolmogorov taxonomy: the Maxwell–Boltzmann speed distribution is a proper PDF that is merely mislabeled; the Boltzmann canonical distribution is a genuine probability measure; the Boltzmann-transport phase-space density is normalised toNrather than to unity; and the Fermi–Dirac and Bose–Einstein functions are occupation-number expectation values that acquire physical meaning only as convolution kernels against the density of states. A short supporting section shows that this is not an accident of two particular formulas. One elementary theorem establishes that a bounded occupation of capacityMunder Boltz-mann weighting with an additive constraint yields⟨n⟩M= −d ln ZM/dx; atM=1 this is exactly the logistic function, and at M→∞it diverges. Fermi–Dirac and Bose–Einstein are therefore the two branches of a single construction, which is why the first is bounded in [0, 1]and the second admits no bounded normalisation at all. The same unit-capacity form appears outside physics wherever a bounded quantity accumulates additive evidence, which suggests that such objects are best read as relative measurements against a capacity rather than as distributions. The paper reconstructs the historical sequence that produced the terminological divergence and proposes notational conventions to restore conceptual clarity in pedagogy and literature. Keywords: probability density function, distribution function, Fermi–Dirac, Bose–Einstein, Maxwell–Boltzmann, Kolmogorov, Jaynes, ontology, statistical mechanics, probability theory, quantum statistics, foundations of physics,philosophy of science, physics education, information theory, thermodynamics.
In a previous note (1) we argued that for a wavefunction W(x,t)= Sum over n an exp(iEnt) Wn(x), the entropy for a particle in a box with infinite potential walls from (2) is: S/(-k)= Sum over n |anan| ln |anan| ((1)) and should be modified to: S/(-k)= Sum over n |anan| ln|anan| + |anan| Sp(n,L) + |anan| Sx(L) ((2)) where Sp and Sx are the pure state momentum and spatial entropies i.e Sp/-k = Integral dp an(p)an(p) ln|an(p)an(p)| and Sx/(-k) = Integral dx W*n(x)Wn(x) ln[Wn*Wn|. In (2) the Clausius relationship: dQ/T = dS is used where dQ = Sum over n En d|anan| and T is temperature to find an expression for |anan|. In general this would be: |anan| = exp(-En/T) , but with ((2)) we find: |anan| = exp(-En/kT) exp(-1-B(n)) ((3)) where B(n)= Sp(n)+Sx. L portions form Sp and Sx cancel so there is no L dependence, L being the size of the box. Given the different form ((3)) we suggest that the Fermi-Dirac (FD) and Bose-Einstein (BE) distributions may change if one uses the grand partition function approach. For example, exp(-ni ei/kT) is replaced by: exp(-ni ei/kT) exp(-ni(1+B(n)). This leads to changes in the FD and BD distributions: zexp(-Ei/kT)exp(-1-B(i) / [1 +/- exp(-u/kT) exp(-ei/kT) exp(-1-B(i))] where z=exp(u/kT), u being the chemical potential. In the high n limit B(n)--> constant (3) so the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) distribution remains unchanged. The MB distribution has been verified to high precision and so modifications related to 1+B(n) might have been noticed had B(n) remained a function of n.
There are essentially three methods used in equilibrium statistical mechanics, namely, the Boltzmann method of identifying the equilibrium sta te with the most probable one; the Gibbs ensemble method of postulating a canonical distribution; and the Darwin-Fowler method' of identifying the equilibrium state with the average state. Most textbooks on statis tical mechanics include discussions of the first two methods. The in clusion into the text of the last method, which schrudinger2 seems to advocate, is less usual . The equivalence of those methods is usual 1 y demonstrated for the i deal Boltzmann, Bose - Einstein, and Fermi-Dirac sta tistics. However, the equivalence is not guaranteed when the methodsare applied to different statistics such as parastatistics3, where eachener gy leve1 can afford up to some number k of particles, and can be regar ded as a generalization of the above mentioned statistics. It seems desirable to confirm t he equivalence of those methods for parastatistics. In most textbooks however discussions on parastatistics are r ather rare.
Equilibrium distribution functions are obtained for boson and fermion ensembles with a limited number of particles. It is shown that the number-of-particle distribution functions in different quantum states are statistically dependent; this dependence disappears only for a large number of particles in the ensemble. The distributions are transformed into the Boltzmann distribution at a high temperature and into the Bose-Einstein and Fermi-Dirac distributions for a large number of particles in the ensemble.
In this work we present a classical kinetic model of intermediate statistics. In the case of Brownian particles we show that the Fermi-Dirac (FD) and Bose-Einstein (BE) distributions can be obtained, just as the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) distribution, as steady states of a classical kinetic equation that intrinsically takes into account an exclusion-inclusion principle. In our model the intermediate statistics are obtained as steady states of a system of coupled nonlinear kinetic equations, where the coupling constants are the transmutational potentials ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\eta}}}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\kappa}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\kappa}}\ensuremath{'}}$. We show that, besides the FD-BE intermediate statistics extensively studied from the quantum point of view, we can also study the MB-FD and MB-BE ones. Moreover, our model allows us to treat the three-state mixing FD-MB-BE intermediate statistics. For boson and fermion mixing in a D-dimensional space, we obtain a family of FD-BE intermediate statistics by varying the transmutational potential ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\eta}}}_{\mathrm{BF}}$. This family contains, as a particular case, when ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\eta}}}_{\mathrm{B}\mathrm{F}=0}$, the quantum statistics recently proposed by L. Wu, Z. Wu, and J. Sun [Phys. Lett. A 170, 280 (1992)]. When we consider the two-dimensional FD-BE statistics, we derive an analytic expression of the fraction of fermions. When the temperature T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}, the system is composed by an equal number of bosons and fermions, regardless of the value of ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\eta}}}_{\mathrm{BF}}$. On the contrary, when T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0, ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\eta}}}_{\mathrm{BF}}$ becomes important and, according to its value, the system can be completely bosonic or fermionic, or composed both by bosons and fermions.