Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Measurement and the Real World

Aephraim M. Steinberg

Published Apr 18, 2012• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

While quantum measurement remains the central philosophical conundrum of quantum mechanics, it has recently grown into a respectable (read: experimental!) discipline as well. New perspectives on measurement have grown out of new technological possibilities, but also out of attempts to design systems for quantum information processing. I will present several examples of how our current ideas on quantum measurement go far beyond the usual textbook treatments, using examples from our entangled-photon and ultracold-atoms laboratories in Toronto. Topics will be drawn from weak measurement, 'interaction-free' measurement, Hardy's Paradox, measurement-induced quantum logic, and techniques for controlling and characterizing the coherence of quantum systems. The moral of the story will be that there are many different kinds of measurement strategies, with their own advantages and disadvantages; and that some things we have been taught not to even think about can actually be measured in a certain sense.

Related papers

Quantum Measurement Techniques: Modern Approaches and Trends

Aephraim M. Steinberg

While quantum measurement has long been seen as a deep philosophical conundrum, technological progress and new potential applications such as quantum information processing have turned it into a respectable experimental discipline as well. I will introduce a modern perspective on real-world quantum measurement, including the new paradigm of "weak measurement" and its (controversial) potential for addressing fundamental issues as well as for improving the precision of practical measurement.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

Quantum Measurements: a modern view for quantum optics experimentalists

Aephraim M. Steinberg

In these notes, based on lectures given as part of the Les Houches summer school on Quantum Optics and Nanophotonics in August, 2013, I have tried to give a brief survey of some important approaches and modern tendencies in quantum measurement. I wish it to be clear from the outset that I shy explicitly away from the "quantum measurement problem," and that the present treatment aims to elucidate the theory and practice of various ways in which measurements can, in light of quantum mechanics, be carried out; and various formalisms for describing them. While the treatment is by necessity largely theoretical, the emphasis is meant to be on an experimental "perspective" on measurement -- that is, to place the priority on the possibility of gaining information through some process, and then attempting to model that process mathematically and consider its ramifications, rather than stressing a particular mathematical definition as the {\it sine qua non} of measurement. The textbook definition of measurement as being a particular set of mathematical operations carried out on particular sorts of operators has been so well drilled into us that many have the unfortunate tendency of saying "that experiment can't be described by projections onto the eigenstates of a Hermitian operator, so it is not really a measurement," when of course any practitioner of an experimental science such as physics should instead say "that experiment allowed us to measure something, and if the standard theory of measurement does not describe it, the standard theory of measurement is incomplete." Idealisations are important, but when the real world breaks the approximations made in the theory, it is the theory which must be fixed, and not the real world.

arXiv:1406.5535•Jun 20, 2014•3 citations

Quantum metrology beyond quantum metrology: from measurements to new frontiers in quantum information science

Gabriele Bizzarri

Quantum mechanics has profoundly reshaped our knowledge of the physical world: a deep comprehension of the quantum nature of matter yielded to the so-called first quantum revolution, enabling transformative technologies ranging from lasers to semiconductor de- vices, being at the heart of the digital revolution characterizing the second half of the XXth century. Furthermore, the capability of manipulating and controlling individual quantum systems enabled a totally different working paradigm, obeying the logic im- posed by quantum physics, paving the way, at the end of the XXth and the beginning of the XXIst century, for the second quantum revolution. Modern quantum technologies, including quantum computation, quantum simulation, quantum metrology and quantum communication rely on peculiar quantum phenomena, such as superposition, entangle- ment and coherence to perform tasks beyond classical capabilities. This thesis proposes quantum metrology as a unifying conceptual and methodological framework to investigate problems lying at the intersection of fundamental quantum physics and quantum information science. More in detail, it addresses theoretical and experimental protocols to certify the presence of quantum correlations (namely, quantum steering), as well as to design secure sensing in quantum networks under realistic assump- tions. Moreover, it also suggest how tunable-strength measurement-based strategies can be used to extract information from complex systems even in seemingly inaccessible sce- narios. Overall, this thesis proposes quantum metrology as a framework through which the purest nature of information can be probed, certified and secured at the most fundamental level.

•May 8, 2026•0 citations

Measurements in Quantum Optics

U. Schilling

This thesis fathoms the possibilities and limitations of measurements in quantum optics. After a short introduction to the general aspects of measurements in quantum mechanics, it presents three examples of a measurement process in concrete applications to quantum optics. For one, while operators describing quantities of interest might have a simple theoretical form, it is often hard to actually implement a measurement of their expectation values experimentally. This situation is encountered in the first part which is devoted to the measurement of quantum statistical properties of a light beam. In contrast to classical optics, these statistics are not fully determined by first- and second-order correlations. Instead, higher-order correlations, usually described by non-Hermitian operators, are necessary to characterize the quantum state completely. A particular example is the N-photon Fock state, for which only a measurement of the Nth-order correlations allows for a full characterization. Here, we present a new method how to measure an important class of Nth-order correlations for arbitrary N in a single spatial mode with two polarizations with limited experimental resources. The second part is again centered around the realization of specific measurement operators for photon correlation measurements. However, in contrast to the previous chapter, these measurements are not an end in their own, but are designed to create specific quantum states as a consequence of the measurement process: A suitable measurement of photons emitted by a number of atoms allows to transfer the atoms into long-lived entangled states. We find that with this method it is possible to entangle two remote atomic qubits to an arbitrary and well-defined degree. Furthermore, we show how to generate two families of quantum states in an arbitrary number of remote atomic qubits: one family consists of all -- symmetric and non-symmetric -- total angular momentum eigenstates in N remote qubits, the other is a family of cluster states. It is also systematically investigated whether the technique of quantum state engineering by projective measurements allows for the creation of any arbitrary state. We find explicit solutions for the case of two and three qubits, while it is shown that no solution exist for N > 6. We conclude the section by proving that with some changes in the setup, this measurement-based quantum state engineering technique allows to create the same states among the scattered photons themselves rather than among the emitting atoms. The last part is devoted to the amount of information one is able to gain about a given system when performing a measurement. The corresponding limits of information are investigated at the example of the duality that arises in a two-way interferometer between the visibility of the interference pattern and the knowledge about the path of the interfering object. We show that there exist correlations between the phase difference the interfering object acquires on its way through the interferometer and the amount of which-way information retrievable from certain observables of the which-way detector. In this way, the which-way information becomes a phase-dependent quantity. In particular, we find that for certain values of the phase shift, the amount of extractable which-way information can be larger than allowed by phase-independent measurement. This property is put to use to find the optimal observable for the which-way detector readout in dependence on the phase of the interfering object. Following this strategy, we are able to gain more which-way information than previously thought possible.

•Oct 24, 2011•0 citations

Generalized Measurement and Post-selection in Optical Quantum Information

Jeff S. Lundeen

Post-selection is the selection of a subset of an ensemble based on a measurement on that ensemble. In the last few years, post-selection has taken on new importance as a mechanism to induce the optical nonlinearities required for quantum logic gates. I present experiments and theory that explore post-selection in photonic systems. I then go on to describe an experimental implementation of Hardy's Paradox, which is one of the three great thought-experiments about entanglement and correlations in quantum mechanics (the others being the EPR and GHZ "paradoxes"). In the place of the electron--positron annihilation in the original proposal, I apply, for the first time, a post-selection-based absorptive photon switch that coworkers and I had previously developed. Weak measurement promises to be an important technique for characterizing post-selected quantum systems during their evolution. The technique minimizes disturbance to the system and therefore can be used in situ. In a third experiment, I attempt to resolve a recent debate: Which is more fundamental--complementarity or the uncertainty principle? Specifically, can interference be destroyed by a which-path measurement without transferring momentum to the particle? This question is difficult to investigate as any measurement of the momentum transfer causes collapse, severely disturbing the system. I circumvent this problem with the technique of weak measurement and show that which-path measurements do indeed induce a momentum transfer as required by the uncertainty principle. First, I experimentally demonstrate effective nonlinear absorption between two single photons. I show that this photon-exchange effect can be understood as a post-selection induced nonlinearity similar to the one that occurs in Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. In a fourth experiment, I use the latter theory and return to Hardy's Paradox to perform the first weak measurement of an entangled system. I post-select on the paradoxical measurement result while weakly measuring a set of observables. The results are surprising in that they no longer conflict; they now satisfy a classical-logic truth-table. I then proceed to develop theoretically a new method for performing multiparticle weak measurements that is unique because it does not require single-particle-level interactions. This theory provides new insight into the importance of the imaginary component of the weak measurement result.

•Jan 1, 2006•5 citations

Experimental quantum measurement: New techniques and new applications

Aephraim M. Steinberg

Quantum information science has reinvigorated the study of quantum measurement, and created a new sense of urgency. I present several classes of ldquomeasurementrdquo and discuss their applications, their practical feasibility, and some outstanding theoretical issues.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations
While quantum measurement remains the central philosophical conundrum of quantum mechanics, it has recently grown into a respectable (read: experimental!) discipline as well. New perspectives on measurement have grown out of new technological possibilities, but also out of attempts to design systems for quantum information processing. I will present several examples of how our current ideas on quantum measurement go far beyond the usual textbook treatments, using examples from our entangled-photon and ultracold-atoms laboratories in Toronto. Topics will be drawn from weak measurement, 'interaction-free' measurement, Hardy's Paradox, measurement-induced quantum logic, and techniques for controlling and characterizing the coherence of quantum systems. The moral of the story will be that there are many different kinds of measurement strategies, with their own advantages and disadvantages; and that some things we have been taught not to even think about can actually be measured in a certain sense.
While quantum measurement has long been seen as a deep philosophical conundrum, technological progress and new potential applications such as quantum information processing have turned it into a respectable experimental discipline as well. I will introduce a modern perspective on real-world quantum measurement, including the new paradigm of "weak measurement" and its (controversial) potential for addressing fundamental issues as well as for improving the precision of practical measurement.
In these notes, based on lectures given as part of the Les Houches summer school on Quantum Optics and Nanophotonics in August, 2013, I have tried to give a brief survey of some important approaches and modern tendencies in quantum measurement. I wish it to be clear from the outset that I shy explicitly away from the "quantum measurement problem," and that the present treatment aims to elucidate the theory and practice of various ways in which measurements can, in light of quantum mechanics, be carried out; and various formalisms for describing them. While the treatment is by necessity largely theoretical, the emphasis is meant to be on an experimental "perspective" on measurement -- that is, to place the priority on the possibility of gaining information through some process, and then attempting to model that process mathematically and consider its ramifications, rather than stressing a particular mathematical definition as the {\it sine qua non} of measurement. The textbook definition of measurement as being a particular set of mathematical operations carried out on particular sorts of operators has been so well drilled into us that many have the unfortunate tendency of saying "that experiment can't be described by projections onto the eigenstates of a Hermitian operator, so it is not really a measurement," when of course any practitioner of an experimental science such as physics should instead say "that experiment allowed us to measure something, and if the standard theory of measurement does not describe it, the standard theory of measurement is incomplete." Idealisations are important, but when the real world breaks the approximations made in the theory, it is the theory which must be fixed, and not the real world.
Quantum mechanics has profoundly reshaped our knowledge of the physical world: a deep comprehension of the quantum nature of matter yielded to the so-called first quantum revolution, enabling transformative technologies ranging from lasers to semiconductor de- vices, being at the heart of the digital revolution characterizing the second half of the XXth century. Furthermore, the capability of manipulating and controlling individual quantum systems enabled a totally different working paradigm, obeying the logic im- posed by quantum physics, paving the way, at the end of the XXth and the beginning of the XXIst century, for the second quantum revolution. Modern quantum technologies, including quantum computation, quantum simulation, quantum metrology and quantum communication rely on peculiar quantum phenomena, such as superposition, entangle- ment and coherence to perform tasks beyond classical capabilities. This thesis proposes quantum metrology as a unifying conceptual and methodological framework to investigate problems lying at the intersection of fundamental quantum physics and quantum information science. More in detail, it addresses theoretical and experimental protocols to certify the presence of quantum correlations (namely, quantum steering), as well as to design secure sensing in quantum networks under realistic assump- tions. Moreover, it also suggest how tunable-strength measurement-based strategies can be used to extract information from complex systems even in seemingly inaccessible sce- narios. Overall, this thesis proposes quantum metrology as a framework through which the purest nature of information can be probed, certified and secured at the most fundamental level.
This thesis fathoms the possibilities and limitations of measurements in quantum optics. After a short introduction to the general aspects of measurements in quantum mechanics, it presents three examples of a measurement process in concrete applications to quantum optics. For one, while operators describing quantities of interest might have a simple theoretical form, it is often hard to actually implement a measurement of their expectation values experimentally. This situation is encountered in the first part which is devoted to the measurement of quantum statistical properties of a light beam. In contrast to classical optics, these statistics are not fully determined by first- and second-order correlations. Instead, higher-order correlations, usually described by non-Hermitian operators, are necessary to characterize the quantum state completely. A particular example is the N-photon Fock state, for which only a measurement of the Nth-order correlations allows for a full characterization. Here, we present a new method how to measure an important class of Nth-order correlations for arbitrary N in a single spatial mode with two polarizations with limited experimental resources. The second part is again centered around the realization of specific measurement operators for photon correlation measurements. However, in contrast to the previous chapter, these measurements are not an end in their own, but are designed to create specific quantum states as a consequence of the measurement process: A suitable measurement of photons emitted by a number of atoms allows to transfer the atoms into long-lived entangled states. We find that with this method it is possible to entangle two remote atomic qubits to an arbitrary and well-defined degree. Furthermore, we show how to generate two families of quantum states in an arbitrary number of remote atomic qubits: one family consists of all -- symmetric and non-symmetric -- total angular momentum eigenstates in N remote qubits, the other is a family of cluster states. It is also systematically investigated whether the technique of quantum state engineering by projective measurements allows for the creation of any arbitrary state. We find explicit solutions for the case of two and three qubits, while it is shown that no solution exist for N > 6. We conclude the section by proving that with some changes in the setup, this measurement-based quantum state engineering technique allows to create the same states among the scattered photons themselves rather than among the emitting atoms. The last part is devoted to the amount of information one is able to gain about a given system when performing a measurement. The corresponding limits of information are investigated at the example of the duality that arises in a two-way interferometer between the visibility of the interference pattern and the knowledge about the path of the interfering object. We show that there exist correlations between the phase difference the interfering object acquires on its way through the interferometer and the amount of which-way information retrievable from certain observables of the which-way detector. In this way, the which-way information becomes a phase-dependent quantity. In particular, we find that for certain values of the phase shift, the amount of extractable which-way information can be larger than allowed by phase-independent measurement. This property is put to use to find the optimal observable for the which-way detector readout in dependence on the phase of the interfering object. Following this strategy, we are able to gain more which-way information than previously thought possible.
Post-selection is the selection of a subset of an ensemble based on a measurement on that ensemble. In the last few years, post-selection has taken on new importance as a mechanism to induce the optical nonlinearities required for quantum logic gates. I present experiments and theory that explore post-selection in photonic systems. I then go on to describe an experimental implementation of Hardy's Paradox, which is one of the three great thought-experiments about entanglement and correlations in quantum mechanics (the others being the EPR and GHZ "paradoxes"). In the place of the electron--positron annihilation in the original proposal, I apply, for the first time, a post-selection-based absorptive photon switch that coworkers and I had previously developed. Weak measurement promises to be an important technique for characterizing post-selected quantum systems during their evolution. The technique minimizes disturbance to the system and therefore can be used in situ. In a third experiment, I attempt to resolve a recent debate: Which is more fundamental--complementarity or the uncertainty principle? Specifically, can interference be destroyed by a which-path measurement without transferring momentum to the particle? This question is difficult to investigate as any measurement of the momentum transfer causes collapse, severely disturbing the system. I circumvent this problem with the technique of weak measurement and show that which-path measurements do indeed induce a momentum transfer as required by the uncertainty principle. First, I experimentally demonstrate effective nonlinear absorption between two single photons. I show that this photon-exchange effect can be understood as a post-selection induced nonlinearity similar to the one that occurs in Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. In a fourth experiment, I use the latter theory and return to Hardy's Paradox to perform the first weak measurement of an entangled system. I post-select on the paradoxical measurement result while weakly measuring a set of observables. The results are surprising in that they no longer conflict; they now satisfy a classical-logic truth-table. I then proceed to develop theoretically a new method for performing multiparticle weak measurements that is unique because it does not require single-particle-level interactions. This theory provides new insight into the importance of the imaginary component of the weak measurement result.