Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bohmian Trajectories of the Two-Electron Helium Atom

Jeff Timko

Published Jan 17, 2008• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

We introduce the de Broglie-Bohm causal interpreation of quantum mechanics and compare it to the standard interpretation of quantum mechanics, the Copenhagen interpretation. We examine the possibility of experimentally distinguishing between the two theories, as well as the potential for the causal interpretation to more easily bridge the gap between the physics of the quantum and classical worlds. We then use the causal interpretation to construct a deterministic model of the helium atom in which the two electrons move along trajectories through space and time about a stationary nucleus. The dynamics are governed by the non-relativistic Schrödinger equation and the spin vectors of both electrons are assumed to be constant along their respective trajectories. We examine the Bohmian trajectories associated with (approximations to) eigenstates of the helium Hamiltonian as well as the trajectories associated with some non-eigenstates. We also compute an approximation to the ground state energy of the helium atom using a representation of the helium wavefunction in terms of hydrogenic eigenfunctions which is motivated by a perturbation approach.

Related papers

The de Broglie-Bohm Causal Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics and its Application to some Simple Systems

Caroline Colijn

The de Broglie-Bohm causal interpretation of quantum mechanics is discussed, and applied to the hydrogen atom in several contexts. Prominent critiques of the causal program are noted and responses are given; it is argued that the de Broglie-Bohm theory is of notable interest to physics. Using the causal theory, electron trajectories are found for the conventional Schrödinger, Pauli and Dirac hydrogen eigenstates. In the Schrödinger case, an additional term is used to account for the spin; this term was not present in the original formulation of the theory but is necessary for the theory to be embedded in a relativistic formulation. In the Schrödinger, Pauli and Dirac cases, the eigenstate trajectories are shown to be circular, with electron motion revolving around the z-axis. Electron trajectories are also found for the 1s-2p0 transition problem under the Schrödinger equation; it is shown that the transition can be characterized by a comparison of the trajectory to the relevant eigenstate trajectories. The structures of the computed trajectories are relevant to the question of the possible evolution of a quantum distribution towards the standard quantum distribution (quantum equilibrium); this process is known as quantum relaxation. The transition problem is generalized to include all possible transitions in hydrogen stimulated by semi-classical radiation, and all of the trajectories found are examined in light of their implications for the evolution of the distribution to the standard distribution. Several promising avenues for future research are discussed.

•Jan 1, 2003•2 citations

Harmonizing de Broglie-Bohm’s Causal Interpretation with the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

A. N. Khondker

The non-relativistic quantum theory has been interpreted causally by de Broglie, David Bohm, and others, where a quantum entity is viewed as a particle with a definite position and momentum. This interpretation contrasts with the Copenhagen orthodox interpretation, which conveys uncertainty through the commutator relationship between position and momentum operators. This is further exacerbated by the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation, which uses no operators corresponding to these observables. We reconcile these opposing viewpoints by introducing mathematical nonlinear transforms in Bohmian mechanics for the momentum observable. While these nonlinear operator-like transforms cannot be easily represented as matrices in the Hilbert space, we show that they can be utilized in the de Broglie-Bohm interpretations of quantum theory.

arXiv:2504.18930•Journal of Nonlinear Mathematical Physics•Oct 20, 2025•1 citation

De Broglie-Bohmova interpretacija kvantne mehanike

Doris Todorović

The de Broglie–Bohm interpretation (Bohmian mechanics, hidden-variables theory, causal interpretation or pilot-wave theory) is one of the interpretations of quantum mechanics which opposes to the claim of standard interpretation on the completeness of description of the state of quantummechanical system, that description in Bohmian mechanics is completed by defining positions of the particles of the system i.e. hidden variables and their dynamics. These facts are the basis of motivation for the introduction of a new theory that can describe dubious axiomatic requirements of standard interpretation. The presented theory is deterministic and explicitly nonlocal. Originators of Bohmian mechanics were L. de Broglie (1927.) and D. Bohm (1952.) who presented mathematically more general and conceptual elaborate formulation. Along with the historical overview, a note is given about the main properties of the theory, such as the issue of nonlocality and hidden variables. The aim of this paper is to present and explain the main ideas and properties of the theory as well as to give a systematic overview of present and historical mathematical construction of the theory and most of all to discuss implications of de Broglie–Bohm theory on the ontology of quantum-mechanical picture, showcasing examples of the equivalency of the description of a free particle as a propagation of the plane wave in space or as the ensemble of the trajectories and of the spreading of the Gaussian wave packet. The main example of the obvious conceptual clashing of the interpretations is presented: the double-slit experiment, with a detailed examination of the Bohmian mechanics’ predictions using presented formalism on the two double-slit experiment. The graphs of trajectories for given examples are obtained.

•Sep 11, 2019•0 citations

Deterministic chaos and the de Broglie-Bohm causal interpretation of quantum mechanics

R.W. Valentine

In this thesis, properties of particle trajectories associated with the de Broglie-Bohm causal interpretation of quantum mechanics are studied. These trajectories are shown to exhibit deterministic chaos and adiabatic invariance under certain conditions. The very basic elements of the causal interpretation are presented in the first chapter. These include the equations of motion for the particle and the quantum potential. A brief discussion of the philosophically agreeable features of the theory is also included. In Chapter 2, properties of chaotic systems are studied. We define deterministic chaos for a flow and present methods for calculating the maximum Lyapunov exponent. The properties of the different types of systems and the conditions that lead to chaos in these systems are analyzed. We study in detail the specific example of the two-dimensional harmonic oscillator in Chapter 3. We find that different types of trajectories include those which are periodic and chaotic. The necessary conditions for obtaining chaos are determined for a superposition of stationary states. Systems which are qualitatively similar to the harmonic oscillator are covered in Chapter 4. These include the two-dimensional infinite well, an infinite well bisected by a finite barrier, and a Rydberg atom in an external electromagnetic field. In Chapter 5, the effect of a spin 1/2 wavefunction is considered. The causal equations of motion for a spin 1/2 particle are introduced. We find that chaotic trajectories are easily obtained. The causal analogue of the geometric phase is defined in Chapter 6. This phase is shown to be an adiabatic invariant for periodic trajectories. We define the geometric frequency for both periodic and aperiodic trajectories. Finally, in Chapter 7 we examine trajectories associated with stationary states. We define necessary conditions for chaos to arise in the trajectories. The properties of entangled boson and fermion systems are analyzed.

•Jan 1, 1996•0 citations

Spin-dependent Bohm trajectories associated with an electronic transition in hydrogen

Caroline Colijn, Edward R. Vrscay

The de Broglie–Bohm causal theory of quantum mechanics with spin-dependence is used to determine electron trajectories when a hydrogen atom is subjected to (semiclassical) radiation. The transition between the 1s ground state and the 2p 0 state is examined. It is found that transitions can be identified along Bohm trajectories. The trajectories lie on invariant hyperboloid surfaces of revolution in R 3 . The energy along the trajectories is also discussed in relation to the hydrogen energy eigenvalues.

arXiv:quant-ph/0304203•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Apr 8, 2003•15 citations

Bohmian Trajectories Within Hilbert Space Based Quantum Mechanics. Solution of the Measurement Problem

Tulsi Dass

de Broglie-Bohm theory (dBBT), treating quantum particles as point objects moving along well defined (Bohmian) trajectories, offers an appealing solution of the measurement problem in quantum mechanics; it has, however, problems relating to spin, relativity and lack of proper integration with the Hilbert space based framework. In this work, we present a consistent formalism which has the traditional state-observable framework integrated with the desirable features of dBBT. We adopt ensemble interpretation for the Schrodinger wave function $ψ$. Given a Schrodinger wave function $ψ$, we use its value $ψ_0$ at some fixed time (say, $t = 0$) to define the probability measure $|ψ_0|^2 {\rm d}x$ on the system configuration space $M$ ($=\mathbb{R}^n$). On the resulting probability space $\mathcal{M}_0$, we introduce a stochastic process $ξ(t)$ corresponding to the Heisenberg position operator $X_H(t)$ such that, in the Heisenberg state $|ψ_h\rangle$ corresponding to $ψ_0$, the expectation value of $X_H(t)$ equals that of $ξ(t)$ in $\mathcal{M}_0$. This condition leads to the de Broglie-Bohm guidance equation for the sample paths of the process $ξ(t)$ which are, therefore, Bohmian trajectories supposedly representing time-evolutions of individual members of the $ψ_0$-ensemble. Stochastic processes and Bohmian trajectories corresponding to observables with discrete eigenvalues (in particular spin) are treated by extending the configuration space to the spectral space of the commutative algebra obtained by adding appropriate discrete observables to the position observables. Pauli's equation is treated as an example. A straightforward derivation of von Neumann's projection rule employing the Schrodinger-Bohm evolution of individual systems along their Bohmian trajectories is given. Some comments on the potential application of the formalism developed here to quantum mechanics of the universe are included.

quant-pharXiv:2512.07007•International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Dec 9, 2025•0 citations
We introduce the de Broglie-Bohm causal interpreation of quantum mechanics and compare it to the standard interpretation of quantum mechanics, the Copenhagen interpretation. We examine the possibility of experimentally distinguishing between the two theories, as well as the potential for the causal interpretation to more easily bridge the gap between the physics of the quantum and classical worlds. We then use the causal interpretation to construct a deterministic model of the helium atom in which the two electrons move along trajectories through space and time about a stationary nucleus. The dynamics are governed by the non-relativistic Schrödinger equation and the spin vectors of both electrons are assumed to be constant along their respective trajectories. We examine the Bohmian trajectories associated with (approximations to) eigenstates of the helium Hamiltonian as well as the trajectories associated with some non-eigenstates. We also compute an approximation to the ground state energy of the helium atom using a representation of the helium wavefunction in terms of hydrogenic eigenfunctions which is motivated by a perturbation approach.
The de Broglie-Bohm causal interpretation of quantum mechanics is discussed, and applied to the hydrogen atom in several contexts. Prominent critiques of the causal program are noted and responses are given; it is argued that the de Broglie-Bohm theory is of notable interest to physics. Using the causal theory, electron trajectories are found for the conventional Schrödinger, Pauli and Dirac hydrogen eigenstates. In the Schrödinger case, an additional term is used to account for the spin; this term was not present in the original formulation of the theory but is necessary for the theory to be embedded in a relativistic formulation. In the Schrödinger, Pauli and Dirac cases, the eigenstate trajectories are shown to be circular, with electron motion revolving around the z-axis. Electron trajectories are also found for the 1s-2p0 transition problem under the Schrödinger equation; it is shown that the transition can be characterized by a comparison of the trajectory to the relevant eigenstate trajectories. The structures of the computed trajectories are relevant to the question of the possible evolution of a quantum distribution towards the standard quantum distribution (quantum equilibrium); this process is known as quantum relaxation. The transition problem is generalized to include all possible transitions in hydrogen stimulated by semi-classical radiation, and all of the trajectories found are examined in light of their implications for the evolution of the distribution to the standard distribution. Several promising avenues for future research are discussed.
The non-relativistic quantum theory has been interpreted causally by de Broglie, David Bohm, and others, where a quantum entity is viewed as a particle with a definite position and momentum. This interpretation contrasts with the Copenhagen orthodox interpretation, which conveys uncertainty through the commutator relationship between position and momentum operators. This is further exacerbated by the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation, which uses no operators corresponding to these observables. We reconcile these opposing viewpoints by introducing mathematical nonlinear transforms in Bohmian mechanics for the momentum observable. While these nonlinear operator-like transforms cannot be easily represented as matrices in the Hilbert space, we show that they can be utilized in the de Broglie-Bohm interpretations of quantum theory.
The de Broglie–Bohm interpretation (Bohmian mechanics, hidden-variables theory, causal interpretation or pilot-wave theory) is one of the interpretations of quantum mechanics which opposes to the claim of standard interpretation on the completeness of description of the state of quantummechanical system, that description in Bohmian mechanics is completed by defining positions of the particles of the system i.e. hidden variables and their dynamics. These facts are the basis of motivation for the introduction of a new theory that can describe dubious axiomatic requirements of standard interpretation. The presented theory is deterministic and explicitly nonlocal. Originators of Bohmian mechanics were L. de Broglie (1927.) and D. Bohm (1952.) who presented mathematically more general and conceptual elaborate formulation. Along with the historical overview, a note is given about the main properties of the theory, such as the issue of nonlocality and hidden variables. The aim of this paper is to present and explain the main ideas and properties of the theory as well as to give a systematic overview of present and historical mathematical construction of the theory and most of all to discuss implications of de Broglie–Bohm theory on the ontology of quantum-mechanical picture, showcasing examples of the equivalency of the description of a free particle as a propagation of the plane wave in space or as the ensemble of the trajectories and of the spreading of the Gaussian wave packet. The main example of the obvious conceptual clashing of the interpretations is presented: the double-slit experiment, with a detailed examination of the Bohmian mechanics’ predictions using presented formalism on the two double-slit experiment. The graphs of trajectories for given examples are obtained.
In this thesis, properties of particle trajectories associated with the de Broglie-Bohm causal interpretation of quantum mechanics are studied. These trajectories are shown to exhibit deterministic chaos and adiabatic invariance under certain conditions. The very basic elements of the causal interpretation are presented in the first chapter. These include the equations of motion for the particle and the quantum potential. A brief discussion of the philosophically agreeable features of the theory is also included. In Chapter 2, properties of chaotic systems are studied. We define deterministic chaos for a flow and present methods for calculating the maximum Lyapunov exponent. The properties of the different types of systems and the conditions that lead to chaos in these systems are analyzed. We study in detail the specific example of the two-dimensional harmonic oscillator in Chapter 3. We find that different types of trajectories include those which are periodic and chaotic. The necessary conditions for obtaining chaos are determined for a superposition of stationary states. Systems which are qualitatively similar to the harmonic oscillator are covered in Chapter 4. These include the two-dimensional infinite well, an infinite well bisected by a finite barrier, and a Rydberg atom in an external electromagnetic field. In Chapter 5, the effect of a spin 1/2 wavefunction is considered. The causal equations of motion for a spin 1/2 particle are introduced. We find that chaotic trajectories are easily obtained. The causal analogue of the geometric phase is defined in Chapter 6. This phase is shown to be an adiabatic invariant for periodic trajectories. We define the geometric frequency for both periodic and aperiodic trajectories. Finally, in Chapter 7 we examine trajectories associated with stationary states. We define necessary conditions for chaos to arise in the trajectories. The properties of entangled boson and fermion systems are analyzed.
The de Broglie–Bohm causal theory of quantum mechanics with spin-dependence is used to determine electron trajectories when a hydrogen atom is subjected to (semiclassical) radiation. The transition between the 1s ground state and the 2p 0 state is examined. It is found that transitions can be identified along Bohm trajectories. The trajectories lie on invariant hyperboloid surfaces of revolution in R 3 . The energy along the trajectories is also discussed in relation to the hydrogen energy eigenvalues.
de Broglie-Bohm theory (dBBT), treating quantum particles as point objects moving along well defined (Bohmian) trajectories, offers an appealing solution of the measurement problem in quantum mechanics; it has, however, problems relating to spin, relativity and lack of proper integration with the Hilbert space based framework. In this work, we present a consistent formalism which has the traditional state-observable framework integrated with the desirable features of dBBT. We adopt ensemble interpretation for the Schrodinger wave function ψψψ. Given a Schrodinger wave function ψψψ, we use its value ψ0ψ_0ψ0​ at some fixed time (say, t=0t = 0t=0) to define the probability measure ∣ψ0∣2dx|ψ_0|^2 {\rm d}x∣ψ0​∣2dx on the system configuration space MMM (=Rn=\mathbb{R}^n=Rn). On the resulting probability space M0\mathcal{M}_0M0​, we introduce a stochastic process ξ(t)ξ(t)ξ(t) corresponding to the Heisenberg position operator XH(t)X_H(t)XH​(t) such that, in the Heisenberg state ∣ψh⟩|ψ_h\rangle∣ψh​⟩ corresponding to ψ0ψ_0ψ0​, the expectation value of XH(t)X_H(t)XH​(t) equals that of ξ(t)ξ(t)ξ(t) in M0\mathcal{M}_0M0​. This condition leads to the de Broglie-Bohm guidance equation for the sample paths of the process ξ(t)ξ(t)ξ(t) which are, therefore, Bohmian trajectories supposedly representing time-evolutions of individual members of the ψ0ψ_0ψ0​-ensemble. Stochastic processes and Bohmian trajectories corresponding to observables with discrete eigenvalues (in particular spin) are treated by extending the configuration space to the spectral space of the commutative algebra obtained by adding appropriate discrete observables to the position observables. Pauli's equation is treated as an example. A straightforward derivation of von Neumann's projection rule employing the Schrodinger-Bohm evolution of individual systems along their Bohmian trajectories is given. Some comments on the potential application of the formalism developed here to quantum mechanics of the universe are included.