Quantum nonseparability is central to most philosophical puzzles related to quantum mechanics. Yet, it is not an exclusive property of quantum mechanics, as it is also found in theoretical generalizations thereof. Investigating the implications of quantum nonseparability in a broader context could shed a new light on the conceptual problems in quantum physics. This work focuses on an operational theory called the process matrix formalism that generalizes quantum mechanics by relaxing the assumption of a well-defined causal structure. That broader theoretical context allows for the existence of quantum processes that are causally nonseparable, i.e. for which there is no definite global causal order among its interacting elements. Therefore, this notion of causal nonseparability somehow extends the notion of entanglement to the geometry of spacetime.
We first examine Howard's analysis of the Bell factorizability condition in terms of ‘separability’ and ‘locality’ and then consider his claims that the violations of Bell's inequality by the statistical predictions of quantum mechanics should be interpreted in terms of ‘nonseparability’ rather than ‘nonlocality’ and that ‘nonseparability’ implies the failure of spacetime as a principle of individuation for quantum-mechanical systems. We will argue that his argument for the first claim is less than compelling and that any argument for the second claim will be interpretation-dependent and, hence, not generally valid.
An information-theoretic inequality analogous to the well-known result of Bell [Physics 1, 195 (1964)] is formulated using the concept of information distance. This inequality, like Bell's, is true for all local-hidden-variable theories, but not for quantum mechanics. The metric space structure of this new inequality suggests a reformulation of familiar Bell inequalities in terms of a ``covariance distance.'' Quantum nonseparability can be demonstrated through violations of these inequalities even in cases where the correlation between two systems is extremely weak. The connection between nonseparability and complementarity is also briefly discussed in this paper.