Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Fermi liquid behaviour and mean field theories of high Tc superconductors

Ching Kit Chan

Published Jan 1, 2007• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This thesis studies two modern mean field theories of the t-J model for high Tc superconductors, namely the Slave-Boson Mean Field Theory and the Spinon-Dopon Mixing Mean Field Theory, from the view point of the traditional Fermi Liquid language. This study mainly focuses on whether the two mean field theories are consistent with Fermi Liquid behaviour in the underdoped regime of the superconducting and pseudogap phases of the t-J model. Historically, experimental results indicate that the superconducting phase can be well described by the conventional Fermi liquid-like quasiparticle picture; while the pseudogap phase exhibits non-trivial non-Fermi Liquid properties. This work aims at interpreting the pseudogap phase in a generalized Fermi Liquid framework and explaining why the simple quasiparticle picture works so well in the superconducting phase even in this strongly correlated superconducting system. Within the Gaussian approximation, we formally derived the Landau interaction in Fermi liquid theory, which serves as the key to classify the behaviour of the quasiparticles in different phases. It is found that the Slave-Boson Mean Field Theory describes the superconducting to the pseudogap phase transition as a transition with an interesting Landau parameter F1s changing from 1+F1s~x to 1+F1s=0, reflecting the occurrence of a quasiparticle instability. A new phase is proposed and its experimental consequences are discussed. On the other hand, we also find that the Spinon-Dopon Mixing Mean Field Theory can be understood in a conventional Fermi Liquid framework; even though quasiparticles in the theory carry larger charges. The issue of superfluid density is also clarified.

DOI
10.14711/thesis-b987295

Related papers

Fermi-liquid behavior and spin-charge separation in underdoped cuprates: Gaussian fluctuations in the U(1) slave-boson mean-field theory of the t−J model

Ching-Kit Chan, Tai Kai Ng

The Gaussian fluctuations in slave-boson mean-field theory of the $t\text{\ensuremath{-}}J$ model are analyzed in this paper in the low-doping regime where the superconducting to normal (pseudogap phase) transition is driven by vanishing of bose-condensation amplitude. By eliminating the boson and constraint fields exactly in the linear-response regime, we show that the Gaussian theory describes an unconventional Fermi liquid superconductor where the superconducting to normal transition is a new type of phase transition characterized by a change of Landau parameter from ${F}_{1}>\ensuremath{-}1$ in the superconducting phase to ${F}_{1}=\ensuremath{-}1$ in the pseudo-gap phase, corresponding to a state with spin-charge separation. The consequences of this proposal are discussed.

arXiv:cond-mat/0602479•Physical Review B•Nov 13, 2006•4 citations

Slave particle study of the strongly correlated electrons

Seyyed Mir Abolhassan Vaezi

Until three decades ago, our understanding of the condensed matter systems were based on two frameworks developed by Russian physicist Lev Landau: his theory of phase transition, and Fermi liquids. The Landau theory of phase transition and the Fermi liquid theory together, can successfully explain a wide range of phenomena from ferromagnetism and antiferromagnetism to the conventional superconductivity. However, in the last thirty years, many experiments including the fractional quantum Hall effect (QHE) have revolutionized our view of nature. For a system of electrons that is subject to a very strong interactions and/or strong correlations between electrons, these two frameworks may break down. There many phases of matter, e.g. spin liquids, that do not break any classical symmetry, but are separated by phase transition. These states has the so called topological order. Also, many of these states do not follow predictions of the Fermi liquid theory and have many exotic behaviors. A rather powerful technique to handle with these issues is the slave particle method. In the first part of this thesis, using a more general slave particle method we study the strongly correlated Hubbard model, whose ground state may represent a Fermi liquid state at two spatial dimensions. We study the phase diagram of this model and show that the gapped spin liquid can be realized on the both honeycomb and square lattices, within mean-field. We also investigate the effective low energy theory of these states. Some of them are subject to compact gauge fluctuations. We study instanton effect in them and show that instanton proliferation can destabilize some of them. Another interesting problem in which we are interested in is the copper based high temperature superconductors (HTSC). The parent state of cuprates materials (undoped case) is a Mott insulator whose ground state is proposed to be a spin liquid. Upon doping, many exotic phases appear, from high temperature superconductivity to the pseudogap phase with disjoint Fermi segments (Fermi arcs) instead of a closed Fermi surface, or the strange metal phase where the Fermi liquid theory breaks down and exhibits very unusual transport properties. The isotope effect in these materials is also very different from that of conventional superconductors. In the second part of this thesis we study the above mentioned problem in detail and explain them by appealing to the slave particle method.

•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Theoretical investigation of high-Tc cuprate superconductors using t-J model : transport properties

Xiangjun Xia

The U(1) slave-boson mean-field theory of the t - J model has been used by many authors as a starting point for the theoretical analysis of high - Tc cuprate superconductors. With suitable refinements, the theory can explain a lot of qualitative features of cuprates. However, the theory does not produce a correct description of the low-energy quasi-particle properties in the under-doped regime. There exist several possible schemes to resolve this difficulty, among them, one generalizes the U(1) theory to SU(2) formulation and the other introduces confinement between spinons and holons. In this thesis, we generalize the Landau transport equations of the U(1) slave-boson mean-field theory of the t - J model to the SU(2) formulation. We first generalize the SU(2) slave-boson mean-field theory to the time-dependent regime. After eliminating the boson and constraint fields exactly in the linear-response regime at zero-temperature, we obtain a set of transport equations for quasi-particles, which has a similar structure as the Landau transport equations for Fermi-liquid superconductors, with all the Landau parameters explicitly given except that besides the usual effective interaction in the particle-hole channel in Fermi-liquid theory, we find an effective interaction in the particle-particle channel, which reflects the SU(2) symmetry between particles and holes. The transport equation is SU(2) invariant at half-filling. Around q⃗ = 0, the electron density couples only to the transverse part of the external field and the quasi-particle charge is still of order x. Besides the SU(2) formulation approach, we also investigate spinon-holon confinement in the U(1) slave-boson theory. The optical and thermal conduc-tivities of U (1) slave-boson theory with confinement are calculated. For optical conductivity, we consider only the contributions from static impurities. The qualitative behavior of our results agrees with experimental results. However, to explain the experiments quantitatively, we need to study further the con-tributions from phonons. We found a phenomenological effective Hamiltonian for the quasi-particle Green's functions in the U(1) slave-boson theory with spinon-hoion confinement. Starting from this effective Hamiltonian, we exam-ine the thermal conductivity within the theory. In particular, we compare the thermal conductivity for four different situations: (i) the ordinary d-wave su-perconducting state with four Dirac Fermi points; (ii) the normal metal state with a half-pocket Fermi surface; (iii) the spinon-holon confinement supercon-ducting state with a half-pocket Fermi surface; (iv) BCS superconducting state with a half-pocket Fermi surface.

•Jan 1, 2005•0 citations

Vertices and vortices in high Tc superconductors

Mohammad Hadi Sharifzadeh Amin

This thesis is organized in two independent parts, in which I study two different aspects of high Tc superconductivity. The first part begins with an introduction aimed to briefly introduce some relevant experimental and theoretical works performed in recent years, that have helped us to think about cuprates the way we do now. Afterwards, I introduce Landau Fermi liquid theory in a standard text book way. The question of validity of Fermi liquid theory in 2-d is then raised and investigated by searching for singularities in Landau's /-function. I show that the interaction function between two quasiparticles whose momenta approach each other near a curved point of the Fermi surface, contains a 1-d singularity not strong enough to change the Fermi liquid behavior. On the other hand, inflection points provide 2-d singularities that have to be taken seriously in Fermi liquid considerations. I then introduce nearly antiferromagnetic Fermi liquid theory (NAFL), which is a phenomenological theory proposed to describe high Tc systems. I mainly focus on the self-consistency of the theory in calculations. I criticize the theory on the basis of overlooking the vertex corrections in the strong coupling calculations of the transition temperature Tc. I calculate the first vertex correction for an optimally doped system and show that it is of the same order of magnitude as the bare vertex. Migdal's theorem is therefore not valid and Eliashberg formalism is not applicable to this situation. The same conclusion is obtained even after inclusion of the quasiparticle residue Z to the calculation. The sign of the vertex correction is then considered. I show that the positive sign of the vertex correction for the optimally doped system requires a phase transition of some sort as the doping is decreased. Part II of the thesis is devoted to the vortex lattice properties of high Tc superconductors. I establish a method to study vortex lattice properties of d-wave superconductors based on a generalization of the London model. The method has the advantage of simplicity as well as having very few free parameters (one at most) compared to other methods. The generalized London free energy is obtained from an s-d mixing Ginsburg-Landau free energy and also from the microscopic theory of Gorkov. The generalized London equation is found to be analytic at high temperatures. At very low temperatures however nonanalyticities arise as a result of the nodes on the superconducting gap. I then present the results of our calculations of some measurable quantities, such as the vortex lattice geometry and the effective penetration depth (as denned in μSR experiments). Comparison between our results and different experimental data is then performed. Especially our prediction for the magnetic field dependence of the effective penetration depth at T = 0, which is recently observed in //SR experiments with excellent agreement, is discussed.

•Jan 1, 2009•1 citation

Landau transport equations in a slave-boson mean-field theory of the t−J model

Tai Kai Ng

In this paper we generalize slave-boson mean-field theory for $t\ensuremath{-}J$ model to the time-dependent regime, and derive transport equations for $t\ensuremath{-}J$ model, both in the normal and superconducting states. By eliminating the boson and constraint fields exactly at zero temperature in the linear-response regime we obtain a set of transport equations for physical electrons which have the same form as Landau transport equations for normal Fermi liquid and Fermi-liquid superconductor, respectively, with all Landau parameters explicitly given. Our theory can be viewed as a refined version of U(1) Gauge theory where all lattice effects are retained and strong correlation effects are reflected as strong Fermi-liquid interactions in the transport equation. Some experimental consequences are discussed.

arXiv:cond-mat/0305424•Physical Review B•Mar 24, 2004•9 citations

Aspects of spin-charge separation in high Tc cuprates

Don H. Kim

High Tc, cuprates have a number of features that are anomalous from the point of view of the conventional theory of metals, i.e. the Fermi liquid theory. These include the high Tc itself, the linear resistivity in optimally doped cuprates, the "spin gap" phenomena, and antiferromagnetic fluctuations. Some of the basic features of the high Tc, phase diagram can be readily understood from slave boson mean field theories of the t-J model that yield a variety of phases like the uRVB phase (strange metal), d-wave RVB phase (spin gap), and the superconducting phase. This thesis is concerned with improving this picture by considering important fluctuations around the mean fields. This leads to certain gauge theories in which neutral spin 1/2 fermions ("spinons") and charged spinless bosons ("holons") are coupled to gauge fields. If the gauge field is not "confining", the spin and charge degrees of freedom are separated to some extent, and an unconventional picture for transport and magnetic properties is expected. Following an introduction and overview, the first half of the main body of this thesis analyzes a simple model of a degenerate two-dimensional Bose liquid interacting with a fluctuating gauge field, with the goal of studying the charge degree of freedom in the cuprates. It is shown that the fluctuating gauge field efficiently destroys superfluidity even in the Bose degenerate regime. The nature of the resulting normal state is discussed in terms of the geometric properties of the imaginary-time paths of the bosons. Charge response functions are studied numerically (by path integral Monte Carlo methods); it is found that the transport scattering rate behaves as ... , consistent with the experiments on the cuprates in the normal state, and that the density correlations of our model resemble the charge correlations of the t-J model. The second half considers the magnetic properties of cuprates from the point of view of a gauge theory of spinons, with emphasis on the underdoped regime. Despite the spin gap, there is a substantial antiferromagnetic correlation in the underdoped cuprates, as evidenced by the q-space scan of Neutron scattering cross section and different temperature dependences of the Copper and Oxygen site relaxation rates, features which are not captured well by mean field theories. As a concrete illustration of the gauge-fluctuation restoration of the antiferromangetic correlation and the feasibility of the 1/N perturbation theory, a U(1) gauge theory of id Heisenberg spin chain is worked out exactly, and then perturbatively. The difference between the behavior of uniform and staggerd spin correlation functions is discussed in terms of conserved and nonconserved currents. The 1/N-perturbative treatment of the gauge theory in 2+1D (which can be motivated from the mean field Flux phase of the Heisnberg model) leads to a dynamical mass generation corresponding to an antiferromagnetic ordering, but it is argued that in a similar gauge theory with an additional coupling to a Bose (holon) field, symmetry breaking does not occur, but antiferromagnetic correlations are improved, which is the situation in the underdoped cuprates.

•Jan 1, 1998•0 citations
This thesis studies two modern mean field theories of the t-J model for high Tc superconductors, namely the Slave-Boson Mean Field Theory and the Spinon-Dopon Mixing Mean Field Theory, from the view point of the traditional Fermi Liquid language. This study mainly focuses on whether the two mean field theories are consistent with Fermi Liquid behaviour in the underdoped regime of the superconducting and pseudogap phases of the t-J model. Historically, experimental results indicate that the superconducting phase can be well described by the conventional Fermi liquid-like quasiparticle picture; while the pseudogap phase exhibits non-trivial non-Fermi Liquid properties. This work aims at interpreting the pseudogap phase in a generalized Fermi Liquid framework and explaining why the simple quasiparticle picture works so well in the superconducting phase even in this strongly correlated superconducting system. Within the Gaussian approximation, we formally derived the Landau interaction in Fermi liquid theory, which serves as the key to classify the behaviour of the quasiparticles in different phases. It is found that the Slave-Boson Mean Field Theory describes the superconducting to the pseudogap phase transition as a transition with an interesting Landau parameter F1s changing from 1+F1s~x to 1+F1s=0, reflecting the occurrence of a quasiparticle instability. A new phase is proposed and its experimental consequences are discussed. On the other hand, we also find that the Spinon-Dopon Mixing Mean Field Theory can be understood in a conventional Fermi Liquid framework; even though quasiparticles in the theory carry larger charges. The issue of superfluid density is also clarified.
The Gaussian fluctuations in slave-boson mean-field theory of the $t\text{\ensuremath{-}}J$ model are analyzed in this paper in the low-doping regime where the superconducting to normal (pseudogap phase) transition is driven by vanishing of bose-condensation amplitude. By eliminating the boson and constraint fields exactly in the linear-response regime, we show that the Gaussian theory describes an unconventional Fermi liquid superconductor where the superconducting to normal transition is a new type of phase transition characterized by a change of Landau parameter from ${F}_{1}>\ensuremath{-}1$ in the superconducting phase to ${F}_{1}=\ensuremath{-}1$ in the pseudo-gap phase, corresponding to a state with spin-charge separation. The consequences of this proposal are discussed.
Until three decades ago, our understanding of the condensed matter systems were based on two frameworks developed by Russian physicist Lev Landau: his theory of phase transition, and Fermi liquids. The Landau theory of phase transition and the Fermi liquid theory together, can successfully explain a wide range of phenomena from ferromagnetism and antiferromagnetism to the conventional superconductivity. However, in the last thirty years, many experiments including the fractional quantum Hall effect (QHE) have revolutionized our view of nature. For a system of electrons that is subject to a very strong interactions and/or strong correlations between electrons, these two frameworks may break down. There many phases of matter, e.g. spin liquids, that do not break any classical symmetry, but are separated by phase transition. These states has the so called topological order. Also, many of these states do not follow predictions of the Fermi liquid theory and have many exotic behaviors. A rather powerful technique to handle with these issues is the slave particle method. In the first part of this thesis, using a more general slave particle method we study the strongly correlated Hubbard model, whose ground state may represent a Fermi liquid state at two spatial dimensions. We study the phase diagram of this model and show that the gapped spin liquid can be realized on the both honeycomb and square lattices, within mean-field. We also investigate the effective low energy theory of these states. Some of them are subject to compact gauge fluctuations. We study instanton effect in them and show that instanton proliferation can destabilize some of them. Another interesting problem in which we are interested in is the copper based high temperature superconductors (HTSC). The parent state of cuprates materials (undoped case) is a Mott insulator whose ground state is proposed to be a spin liquid. Upon doping, many exotic phases appear, from high temperature superconductivity to the pseudogap phase with disjoint Fermi segments (Fermi arcs) instead of a closed Fermi surface, or the strange metal phase where the Fermi liquid theory breaks down and exhibits very unusual transport properties. The isotope effect in these materials is also very different from that of conventional superconductors. In the second part of this thesis we study the above mentioned problem in detail and explain them by appealing to the slave particle method.
The U(1) slave-boson mean-field theory of the t - J model has been used by many authors as a starting point for the theoretical analysis of high - Tc cuprate superconductors. With suitable refinements, the theory can explain a lot of qualitative features of cuprates. However, the theory does not produce a correct description of the low-energy quasi-particle properties in the under-doped regime. There exist several possible schemes to resolve this difficulty, among them, one generalizes the U(1) theory to SU(2) formulation and the other introduces confinement between spinons and holons. In this thesis, we generalize the Landau transport equations of the U(1) slave-boson mean-field theory of the t - J model to the SU(2) formulation. We first generalize the SU(2) slave-boson mean-field theory to the time-dependent regime. After eliminating the boson and constraint fields exactly in the linear-response regime at zero-temperature, we obtain a set of transport equations for quasi-particles, which has a similar structure as the Landau transport equations for Fermi-liquid superconductors, with all the Landau parameters explicitly given except that besides the usual effective interaction in the particle-hole channel in Fermi-liquid theory, we find an effective interaction in the particle-particle channel, which reflects the SU(2) symmetry between particles and holes. The transport equation is SU(2) invariant at half-filling. Around q⃗ = 0, the electron density couples only to the transverse part of the external field and the quasi-particle charge is still of order x. Besides the SU(2) formulation approach, we also investigate spinon-holon confinement in the U(1) slave-boson theory. The optical and thermal conduc-tivities of U (1) slave-boson theory with confinement are calculated. For optical conductivity, we consider only the contributions from static impurities. The qualitative behavior of our results agrees with experimental results. However, to explain the experiments quantitatively, we need to study further the con-tributions from phonons. We found a phenomenological effective Hamiltonian for the quasi-particle Green's functions in the U(1) slave-boson theory with spinon-hoion confinement. Starting from this effective Hamiltonian, we exam-ine the thermal conductivity within the theory. In particular, we compare the thermal conductivity for four different situations: (i) the ordinary d-wave su-perconducting state with four Dirac Fermi points; (ii) the normal metal state with a half-pocket Fermi surface; (iii) the spinon-holon confinement supercon-ducting state with a half-pocket Fermi surface; (iv) BCS superconducting state with a half-pocket Fermi surface.
This thesis is organized in two independent parts, in which I study two different aspects of high Tc superconductivity. The first part begins with an introduction aimed to briefly introduce some relevant experimental and theoretical works performed in recent years, that have helped us to think about cuprates the way we do now. Afterwards, I introduce Landau Fermi liquid theory in a standard text book way. The question of validity of Fermi liquid theory in 2-d is then raised and investigated by searching for singularities in Landau's /-function. I show that the interaction function between two quasiparticles whose momenta approach each other near a curved point of the Fermi surface, contains a 1-d singularity not strong enough to change the Fermi liquid behavior. On the other hand, inflection points provide 2-d singularities that have to be taken seriously in Fermi liquid considerations. I then introduce nearly antiferromagnetic Fermi liquid theory (NAFL), which is a phenomenological theory proposed to describe high Tc systems. I mainly focus on the self-consistency of the theory in calculations. I criticize the theory on the basis of overlooking the vertex corrections in the strong coupling calculations of the transition temperature Tc. I calculate the first vertex correction for an optimally doped system and show that it is of the same order of magnitude as the bare vertex. Migdal's theorem is therefore not valid and Eliashberg formalism is not applicable to this situation. The same conclusion is obtained even after inclusion of the quasiparticle residue Z to the calculation. The sign of the vertex correction is then considered. I show that the positive sign of the vertex correction for the optimally doped system requires a phase transition of some sort as the doping is decreased. Part II of the thesis is devoted to the vortex lattice properties of high Tc superconductors. I establish a method to study vortex lattice properties of d-wave superconductors based on a generalization of the London model. The method has the advantage of simplicity as well as having very few free parameters (one at most) compared to other methods. The generalized London free energy is obtained from an s-d mixing Ginsburg-Landau free energy and also from the microscopic theory of Gorkov. The generalized London equation is found to be analytic at high temperatures. At very low temperatures however nonanalyticities arise as a result of the nodes on the superconducting gap. I then present the results of our calculations of some measurable quantities, such as the vortex lattice geometry and the effective penetration depth (as denned in μSR experiments). Comparison between our results and different experimental data is then performed. Especially our prediction for the magnetic field dependence of the effective penetration depth at T = 0, which is recently observed in //SR experiments with excellent agreement, is discussed.
In this paper we generalize slave-boson mean-field theory for $t\ensuremath{-}J$ model to the time-dependent regime, and derive transport equations for $t\ensuremath{-}J$ model, both in the normal and superconducting states. By eliminating the boson and constraint fields exactly at zero temperature in the linear-response regime we obtain a set of transport equations for physical electrons which have the same form as Landau transport equations for normal Fermi liquid and Fermi-liquid superconductor, respectively, with all Landau parameters explicitly given. Our theory can be viewed as a refined version of U(1) Gauge theory where all lattice effects are retained and strong correlation effects are reflected as strong Fermi-liquid interactions in the transport equation. Some experimental consequences are discussed.
High Tc, cuprates have a number of features that are anomalous from the point of view of the conventional theory of metals, i.e. the Fermi liquid theory. These include the high Tc itself, the linear resistivity in optimally doped cuprates, the "spin gap" phenomena, and antiferromagnetic fluctuations. Some of the basic features of the high Tc, phase diagram can be readily understood from slave boson mean field theories of the t-J model that yield a variety of phases like the uRVB phase (strange metal), d-wave RVB phase (spin gap), and the superconducting phase. This thesis is concerned with improving this picture by considering important fluctuations around the mean fields. This leads to certain gauge theories in which neutral spin 1/2 fermions ("spinons") and charged spinless bosons ("holons") are coupled to gauge fields. If the gauge field is not "confining", the spin and charge degrees of freedom are separated to some extent, and an unconventional picture for transport and magnetic properties is expected. Following an introduction and overview, the first half of the main body of this thesis analyzes a simple model of a degenerate two-dimensional Bose liquid interacting with a fluctuating gauge field, with the goal of studying the charge degree of freedom in the cuprates. It is shown that the fluctuating gauge field efficiently destroys superfluidity even in the Bose degenerate regime. The nature of the resulting normal state is discussed in terms of the geometric properties of the imaginary-time paths of the bosons. Charge response functions are studied numerically (by path integral Monte Carlo methods); it is found that the transport scattering rate behaves as ... , consistent with the experiments on the cuprates in the normal state, and that the density correlations of our model resemble the charge correlations of the t-J model. The second half considers the magnetic properties of cuprates from the point of view of a gauge theory of spinons, with emphasis on the underdoped regime. Despite the spin gap, there is a substantial antiferromagnetic correlation in the underdoped cuprates, as evidenced by the q-space scan of Neutron scattering cross section and different temperature dependences of the Copper and Oxygen site relaxation rates, features which are not captured well by mean field theories. As a concrete illustration of the gauge-fluctuation restoration of the antiferromangetic correlation and the feasibility of the 1/N perturbation theory, a U(1) gauge theory of id Heisenberg spin chain is worked out exactly, and then perturbatively. The difference between the behavior of uniform and staggerd spin correlation functions is discussed in terms of conserved and nonconserved currents. The 1/N-perturbative treatment of the gauge theory in 2+1D (which can be motivated from the mean field Flux phase of the Heisnberg model) leads to a dynamical mass generation corresponding to an antiferromagnetic ordering, but it is argued that in a similar gauge theory with an additional coupling to a Bose (holon) field, symmetry breaking does not occur, but antiferromagnetic correlations are improved, which is the situation in the underdoped cuprates.