Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics World

Light beats quantum mechanics

John Jeffers

Published Nov 1, 2000• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The mathematics of quantum theory is based on operators rather than numbers. In optics this simple fact allows statistical quantities, such as the fluctuations in the electric field of a light beam, to be smaller than is allowed by classical physics. Experiments that measure these quantities can generally be divided into two types, depending on whether they measure the wave or the particle properties of light. This is in line with the "complementarity principle" of quantum mechanics, which states that the wave and particle aspects of a system cannot be observed at the same time.

DOI
10.1088/2058-7058/13/11/28

Related papers

Phenomenological Theory of Laser Beam Fluctuations and Beam Mixing

L. Mandeļ

The paper contains a quantum theoretical analysis of laser beam fluctuations and of the light beat experiments with two lasers. With the help of experimental results on photon counting fluctuations in a single-mode laser field, some correlation properties of the field are derived. It is shown that the correlation equations are satisfied by states of the field which are much more general than "coherent" states. The equations lead directly to the spectral density of the intensity operator in the light beat experiments, which can be obtained from photoelectric measurements. The resulting expression is practically identical to that found by Forrester for light having thermal statistical properties. The reasons for this are discussed by a comparison of the corresponding probability distributions of photon counts and of the classical wave amplitude.

Physical Review•May 10, 1965•32 citations

Illusion or reality: The measurement process in quantum optics

Axel Schenzle

Whereas a measurement in the domain of classical physics merely collects information on the examined object, measurements on the microscopic scale unavoidably leave their traces on the measured system. Experiments with single atoms and few photons contribute to our understanding of this fundamental property of quantum mechanics.

Contemporary Physics•Jul 1, 1996•11 citations

To Principles of Quantum Mechanics Development

Dmitri Yerchuck, Alla Dovlatova, F. N. Borovik +2 more

New insight on the principles of the quantum physics development is given. The quite different behavior of quantum microworld mechanical systems in comparison with classical mechanical macroworld systems is attributed to the drastical change of the role of the gravitation field on the dynamics of microworld mechanical systems, for which it seems to be vanishing in com- parison with the role of the gravitation field on the dynamics of macroworld mechanical systems, for which it is decisive. The conclusion on the status of the second main postulate of quantum mechanics is given. Its formulation in all textbooks has to be represented in the form of the proved statement, since the hypothesis of Schrödinger on the existence of the field scalar function, being to be observable quantity, just charge density, is strictly mathematically proved. It is shown, that the field scalar function, being to be the solution of the corresponding nonstationary in general case Schrödinger equation and being to be the function the only of coordinates and time, actually describes the state of the atomic system, more strictly its corpuscular aspect. The atomic system is considered from the positions of the field theory, that is, it is the association of elementary particles with corresponding fields. The given fields being to be the media for the particles’ propagation are responsible for the wave aspect in the characteristic of atomic systems. The wave aspect is described by the independent scalar wave-function which was also introduced in quantum physics by Schrödinger, althogh the given fact seems to be unknown to the wide circle of the readers. The second main postulate being to be mathematically strictly grounded in Schrödinger formulation of quantum nechanics, in the popular probabilistic form of quantum nechanics cannot be proved for the general case, although the probabilistic theatise, proposed by Born is true in a number of special cases, quite correctly indicated by Dirac. The possible ways of the development of quantum theory, based on clear understanding of the origin of corpuscular-wave dualism and based on the fundamental both now mathemtically grounded main postulates are analysed.

arXiv:1407.2603•International Journal of Physics•Sep 5, 2014•2 citations

Critique of Quantum Optical Experimental Refutations of Bohr’s Principle of Complementarity, of the Wootters–Zurek Principle of Complementarity, and of the Particle–Wave Duality Relation

P. N. Kaloyerou

arXiv:1408.4061•Foundations of Physics•Nov 17, 2015•8 citations

Shedding light (and dark) on quantum probabilities

Steven K. Blau

A tenet of quantum mechanics is, in principle, testable with the double-slit experiment, thanks to classically nonsensical light paths. A tenet of quantum mechanics is, in principle, testable with the double-slit experiment, thanks to classically nonsensical light paths.

Physics Today•Apr 27, 2017•0 citations

A probabilistic view of wave-particle duality for single photons

Andrea Aiello

One of the most puzzling consequences of interpreting quantum mechanics in terms of concepts borrowed from classical physics, is the so-called wave-particle duality. Usually, wave-particle duality is illustrated in terms of complementarity between path distinguishability and fringe visibility in interference experiments. In this work, we instead propose a new type of complementarity, that between the continuous nature of waves and the discrete character of particles. Using the probabilistic methods of quantum field theory, we show that the simultaneous measurement of the wave amplitude and the number of photons in the same beam of light is, under certain circumstances, prohibited by the laws of quantum mechanics. Our results suggest that the concept of “interferometric duality'' could be eventually replaced by the more general one of “continuous-discrete duality''.

arXiv:2303.15185•Quantum•Oct 11, 2023•3 citations
The mathematics of quantum theory is based on operators rather than numbers. In optics this simple fact allows statistical quantities, such as the fluctuations in the electric field of a light beam, to be smaller than is allowed by classical physics. Experiments that measure these quantities can generally be divided into two types, depending on whether they measure the wave or the particle properties of light. This is in line with the "complementarity principle" of quantum mechanics, which states that the wave and particle aspects of a system cannot be observed at the same time.
The paper contains a quantum theoretical analysis of laser beam fluctuations and of the light beat experiments with two lasers. With the help of experimental results on photon counting fluctuations in a single-mode laser field, some correlation properties of the field are derived. It is shown that the correlation equations are satisfied by states of the field which are much more general than "coherent" states. The equations lead directly to the spectral density of the intensity operator in the light beat experiments, which can be obtained from photoelectric measurements. The resulting expression is practically identical to that found by Forrester for light having thermal statistical properties. The reasons for this are discussed by a comparison of the corresponding probability distributions of photon counts and of the classical wave amplitude.
New insight on the principles of the quantum physics development is given. The quite different behavior of quantum microworld mechanical systems in comparison with classical mechanical macroworld systems is attributed to the drastical change of the role of the gravitation field on the dynamics of microworld mechanical systems, for which it seems to be vanishing in com- parison with the role of the gravitation field on the dynamics of macroworld mechanical systems, for which it is decisive. The conclusion on the status of the second main postulate of quantum mechanics is given. Its formulation in all textbooks has to be represented in the form of the proved statement, since the hypothesis of Schrödinger on the existence of the field scalar function, being to be observable quantity, just charge density, is strictly mathematically proved. It is shown, that the field scalar function, being to be the solution of the corresponding nonstationary in general case Schrödinger equation and being to be the function the only of coordinates and time, actually describes the state of the atomic system, more strictly its corpuscular aspect. The atomic system is considered from the positions of the field theory, that is, it is the association of elementary particles with corresponding fields. The given fields being to be the media for the particles’ propagation are responsible for the wave aspect in the characteristic of atomic systems. The wave aspect is described by the independent scalar wave-function which was also introduced in quantum physics by Schrödinger, althogh the given fact seems to be unknown to the wide circle of the readers. The second main postulate being to be mathematically strictly grounded in Schrödinger formulation of quantum nechanics, in the popular probabilistic form of quantum nechanics cannot be proved for the general case, although the probabilistic theatise, proposed by Born is true in a number of special cases, quite correctly indicated by Dirac. The possible ways of the development of quantum theory, based on clear understanding of the origin of corpuscular-wave dualism and based on the fundamental both now mathemtically grounded main postulates are analysed.
One of the most puzzling consequences of interpreting quantum mechanics in terms of concepts borrowed from classical physics, is the so-called wave-particle duality. Usually, wave-particle duality is illustrated in terms of complementarity between path distinguishability and fringe visibility in interference experiments. In this work, we instead propose a new type of complementarity, that between the continuous nature of waves and the discrete character of particles. Using the probabilistic methods of quantum field theory, we show that the simultaneous measurement of the wave amplitude and the number of photons in the same beam of light is, under certain circumstances, prohibited by the laws of quantum mechanics. Our results suggest that the concept of “interferometric duality'' could be eventually replaced by the more general one of “continuous-discrete duality''.