Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Optics Express

Contradiction within wave optics and its solution within a particle picture: comment

Xavier Délen, Marc Hanna, François Balembois, Patrick Georges, Fabien Bretenaker

Published Jan 26, 2016• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An error in the rationale presented in the paper "Contradiction within wave optics and its solution within a particle picture" by Altmann [Opt. Express 23, 3731 (2015)10.1364/OE.23.003731] is discussed.
DOI
10.1364/oe.24.002106

Related papers

Contradiction within wave optics and its solution within a particle picture: reply

Konrad Altmann

The comment on the paper "Contradiction within wave optics and its solution within a particle picture," [Opt. Express 23, 3731 (2015)10.1364/OE.23.003731] is discussed.

Optics Express•Jan 26, 2016•0 citations

A Comment on Maxwell's Resolution of the Wave/Particle Dilemma

Euan J. Squires

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 1989•1 citation

Embedding the photon with its relativistic mass as a particle into the electromagnetic wave

Konrad Altmann

The particle picture presented by the author in the paper "A particle picture of the optical resonator" [K. Altmann, ASSL 2014 Conference Paper ATu2A.29], which shows that the probability density of a photon propagating with a Gaussian wave can be computed by the use of a Schrödinger equation, is generalized to the case of a wave with arbitrary shape of the phase front. Based on a consideration of the changing propagation direction of the relativistic mass density propagating with the electromagnetic wave, a transverse force acting on the photon is derived. The expression obtained for this force makes it possible to show that the photon moves within a transverse potential that in combination with a Schrödinger equation allows to describe the transverse quantum mechanical motion of the photon by the use of matter wave theory, even though the photon has no rest mass. The obtained results are verified for the plane, the spherical, and the Gaussian wave. Additional verification could be provided also by the fact that the mathematical equation describing the Guoy phase shift could be derived from this particle picture in full agreement with wave optics. One more verification could be obtained by the fact that within the range of the validity of paraxial wave optics, Snell's law could also be derived from this particle picture. Numerical validation of the obtained results for the case of the general wave is under development.

Optics Express•Jan 12, 2018•4 citations

A Correction: Some Remarks Concerning Schrodinger's Wave Equation

Geo. D. Birkhoff

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Apr 1, 1933•0 citations

Quantum illumination using polarization-entangled photon pairs for enhanced object detection: comment

Artur Czerwiński, Jakub J. Borkowski

The paper [Opt. Express32, 40150 (2024)10.1364/OE.531674] investigates quantum illumination using polarization-entangled photon pairs for object detection in noisy environments. In this comment, we identify errors in the mathematical model for photon loss, particularly in the treatment of quantum entanglement under lossy channels. We show that the claimed robustness of polarization entanglement to photon loss contradicts established principles in quantum information theory, rendering the conclusions on detecting low-reflectivity objects unsupported.

arXiv:2411.14445•Optics Express•Apr 11, 2025•4 citations

A Note on the Particle-Wave Correspondence

Yih-Yuh Chen

Chinese Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1998•0 citations
The particle picture presented by the author in the paper "A particle picture of the optical resonator" [K. Altmann, ASSL 2014 Conference Paper ATu2A.29], which shows that the probability density of a photon propagating with a Gaussian wave can be computed by the use of a Schrödinger equation, is generalized to the case of a wave with arbitrary shape of the phase front. Based on a consideration of the changing propagation direction of the relativistic mass density propagating with the electromagnetic wave, a transverse force acting on the photon is derived. The expression obtained for this force makes it possible to show that the photon moves within a transverse potential that in combination with a Schrödinger equation allows to describe the transverse quantum mechanical motion of the photon by the use of matter wave theory, even though the photon has no rest mass. The obtained results are verified for the plane, the spherical, and the Gaussian wave. Additional verification could be provided also by the fact that the mathematical equation describing the Guoy phase shift could be derived from this particle picture in full agreement with wave optics. One more verification could be obtained by the fact that within the range of the validity of paraxial wave optics, Snell's law could also be derived from this particle picture. Numerical validation of the obtained results for the case of the general wave is under development.
The paper [Opt. Express32, 40150 (2024)10.1364/OE.531674] investigates quantum illumination using polarization-entangled photon pairs for object detection in noisy environments. In this comment, we identify errors in the mathematical model for photon loss, particularly in the treatment of quantum entanglement under lossy channels. We show that the claimed robustness of polarization entanglement to photon loss contradicts established principles in quantum information theory, rendering the conclusions on detecting low-reflectivity objects unsupported.