Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Information and Computation

On consistency of quantum theory and macroscopic objectivity

L. Lanz, Bassano Vacchini, O. Melsheimer

Published Dec 1, 2004• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We argue that the consistency problem between quantum theory and macroscopic objectivity must be placed inside a quantum description of macroscopic non-equilibrium systems. Resorting to thermodynamic concepts inside quantum field theory seems to be necessary.
DOI
10.26421/qic4.6-7-10

Related papers

Subdynamics as a mechanism for objective description

Ludovico Lanz, Olaf Melsheimer, Bassano Vacchini

The relationship between microsystems and macrosystems is considered in the context of quantum field formulation of statistical mechanics: it is argued that problems on foundations of quantum mechanics can be solved relying on this relationship. This discussion requires some improvement of non-equilibrium statistical mechanics which is briefly presented.

arXiv:quant-ph/9912058•Journal of Modern Optics•Oct 1, 2000•3 citations

AN OBJECTIVE BACKGROUND FOR QUANTUM THEORY RELYING ON THERMODYNAMIC CONCEPTS

L. Lanz, Bassano Vacchini

We come back to the rooting of quantum theory in an objectively given phenomenological context, as it was first sustained by Bohr and later taken by Ludwig as basic motivation of his axiomatic approach. It is shown that the question of compatibility of an objective phenomenological context with present day quantum theory can be answered in a positive way if also thermodynamic concepts are taken into account for a quantum description of macroscopic systems. A formalism is recalled accounting for non equilibrium thermodynamics, by introducing classical fields describing local equilibrium in the quantum field context. Also a non deterministic dynamical evolution of these classical fields appears as an important possibility, linked to the breakdown of the method appropriate for the deterministic case. In this connection a refinement of this method is indicated, which with some additional condition leads to the concept of microsystem and to quantum theory for particles interacting with a macrosystem.

Conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Historical Analysis and Open Questions•Jun 1, 2006•0 citations

Macro-objectivation: a challenge in quantum field theory

L. Lanz

Thermodynamics of irreversible processes is taken as the phenomenological starting point for the description of macroscopic systems in quantum mechanics and state parameters, which are amenable to be attributed an objective meaning, are introduced inside non relativistic quantum field theory when the macroscopic system is locally at equilibrium. Conditions for these state parameters to obey a deterministic time evolution are indicated and discussed. The formalism is developed also considering the case of more component systems and bound states. The situation in which the deterministic dynamics of the state parameters breaks down is also envisaged and it is argued that in this case a stochastic generalisation of the theory is called for. First attempts in this direction are outlined, naturally leading to a rooting of the concept of microsystem inside both quantum theory and an objective phenomenological context.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

Quantum theory as a theory of interactions between macroscopic systems which can be described objectively

Günther Ludwig

Erkenntnis•Nov 1, 1981•6 citations

Is quantum mechanics fundamentally consistent?

Frederic Harmand

•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Perspectives in and on Quantum Theory

Richard Healey

I take a pragmatist perspective on quantum theory. This is not a view of the world described by quantum theory. In this view quantum theory itself does not describe the physical world, nor our observatons, experiences or opinions of it. Instead, the theory offers reliable advice on when to expect an event of one kind or another, and on how strongly to expect each possible outcome of that event. The actual outcome is a perspectival fact: a fact relative to a physical context of assessment. Measurement outcomes and quantum states are both perspectival. By noticing that each must be relativized to an appropriate physical context one can resolve the measurement problem and the problem of nonlocal action. But if the outcome of a quantum measurement is not an absolute fact, then why shoud the statistics of such outcomes give us any objective reason to accept quantum theory? One can describe extensions of the scenario of Wigner's friend in which a statement expressing the outcome of a quantum measurement would be true relative to one such context but not relative to another. However, physical conditions in our world prevent us from realizing such scenarios. Since the outcome of every actual quantum measurement is certified at what is essentially a single context of assessment, the outcome relative to that context is an objective fact in the only sense that matters for science. We should accept quantum theory because the statistics these outcomes display are just those it leads us to expect.

quant-pharXiv:2604.02026•Foundations of Physics•Apr 3, 2026•3 citations
We come back to the rooting of quantum theory in an objectively given phenomenological context, as it was first sustained by Bohr and later taken by Ludwig as basic motivation of his axiomatic approach. It is shown that the question of compatibility of an objective phenomenological context with present day quantum theory can be answered in a positive way if also thermodynamic concepts are taken into account for a quantum description of macroscopic systems. A formalism is recalled accounting for non equilibrium thermodynamics, by introducing classical fields describing local equilibrium in the quantum field context. Also a non deterministic dynamical evolution of these classical fields appears as an important possibility, linked to the breakdown of the method appropriate for the deterministic case. In this connection a refinement of this method is indicated, which with some additional condition leads to the concept of microsystem and to quantum theory for particles interacting with a macrosystem.
Thermodynamics of irreversible processes is taken as the phenomenological starting point for the description of macroscopic systems in quantum mechanics and state parameters, which are amenable to be attributed an objective meaning, are introduced inside non relativistic quantum field theory when the macroscopic system is locally at equilibrium. Conditions for these state parameters to obey a deterministic time evolution are indicated and discussed. The formalism is developed also considering the case of more component systems and bound states. The situation in which the deterministic dynamics of the state parameters breaks down is also envisaged and it is argued that in this case a stochastic generalisation of the theory is called for. First attempts in this direction are outlined, naturally leading to a rooting of the concept of microsystem inside both quantum theory and an objective phenomenological context.
I take a pragmatist perspective on quantum theory. This is not a view of the world described by quantum theory. In this view quantum theory itself does not describe the physical world, nor our observatons, experiences or opinions of it. Instead, the theory offers reliable advice on when to expect an event of one kind or another, and on how strongly to expect each possible outcome of that event. The actual outcome is a perspectival fact: a fact relative to a physical context of assessment. Measurement outcomes and quantum states are both perspectival. By noticing that each must be relativized to an appropriate physical context one can resolve the measurement problem and the problem of nonlocal action. But if the outcome of a quantum measurement is not an absolute fact, then why shoud the statistics of such outcomes give us any objective reason to accept quantum theory? One can describe extensions of the scenario of Wigner's friend in which a statement expressing the outcome of a quantum measurement would be true relative to one such context but not relative to another. However, physical conditions in our world prevent us from realizing such scenarios. Since the outcome of every actual quantum measurement is certified at what is essentially a single context of assessment, the outcome relative to that context is an objective fact in the only sense that matters for science. We should accept quantum theory because the statistics these outcomes display are just those it leads us to expect.