Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Transactions on Communications

Breaking the Trapping Sets in LDPC Codes: Check Node Removal and Collaborative Decoding

Soonyoung Kang, Jaekyun J. Moon, Jeongseok Ha, Jinwoo Shin

Published Nov 5, 2015• 17 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Trapping sets strongly degrade performance of low-density parity check (LDPC) codes in the low-error-rate region. This creates significant difficulties for the deployment of LDPC codes to low-error-rate applications such as storage and wireless systems with no or limited retransmission options. We propose a novel technique for breaking trapping sets based on collaborative decoding that utilizes two different decoding modes. While the main decoding mode executes message passing based on the original parity check matrix of the corresponding LDPC code, the sub-decoding mode operates on a modified parity check matrix formed by removing a portion of check nodes in the factor graph representation of the given code. The modified parity check matrix is designed to promote a passing of correct information into erroneous variable nodes in the trapping set. Theoretical properties of the proposed trapping-set-breaking technique have been established based on the notion of the improved separation for the trapped variable nodes. Simulation results show that the proposed collaborative LDPC decoding scheme switching between the two decoding modes back and forth effectively breaks dominant trapping sets of various known types of regular and irregular LDPC codes.

DOI
10.1109/tcomm.2015.2498161

Related papers

A Modified Sum-Product Algorithm for Error Floor Reduction in LDPC Codes

Un-Hee Park, Dae-Sub Oh, Youngmin Kim +1 more

In this paper, a modified sum-product algorithm to correct bit errors captured within the trapping sets, which are produced in decoding of low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes, is proposed. Unlike the original sum-product algorithm, the proposed decoding method consists of two stages. Whether the main cause of decoding failure is the trapping sets or not is determined at the first stage. And the bit errors within the trapping sets are corrected at the second stage. In the modified algorithm, the set of failed check nodes and the transition patterns of hard-decision bits are exploited to search variable nodes in the trapping sets. After inverting information of the variable nodes, the sum-product algorithm is carried out to correct the bit errors. As a result of simulation, the proposed algorithm shows continuously improved error performance with increase in the signal-to-noise ratio. It is, therefore, considered that the modified sum-product algorithm significantly reduces or possibly eliminates the error floor in LDPC codes.

한국통신학회논문지•Jan 1, 2010•3 citations

Efficient Algorithm for Finding Dominant Trapping Sets of LDPC Codes

Mehdi Karimi, Amir H. Banihashemi

This paper presents an efficient algorithm for finding the dominant trapping sets of a low-density parity-check (LDPC) code. The algorithm can be used to estimate the error floor of LDPC codes or as a tool to design LDPC codes with low error floors. For regular codes, the algorithm is initiated with a set of short cycles as the input. For irregular codes, in addition to short cycles, variable nodes with low degree and cycles with low approximate cycle extrinsic message degree (ACE) are also used as the initial inputs. The initial inputs are then expanded recursively to dominant trapping sets of increasing size. At the core of the algorithm lies the analysis of the graphical structure of dominant trapping sets and the relationship of such structures to short cycles, low-degree variable nodes, and cycles with low ACE. The algorithm is universal in the sense that it can be used for an arbitrary graph and that it can be tailored to find a variety of graphical objects, such as absorbing sets and Zyablov-Pinsker trapping sets, known to dominate the performance of LDPC codes in the error floor region over different channels and for different iterative decoding algorithms. Simulation results on several LDPC codes demonstrate the accuracy and efficiency of the proposed algorithm. In particular, the algorithm is significantly faster than the existing search algorithms for dominant trapping sets.

arXiv:1108.4478•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Aug 3, 2012•113 citations

Deep-Learning for Breaking the Trapping Sets in Low-Density Parity-Check Codes

Seokju Han, Jieun Oh, Kyungmok Oh +1 more

In the low-error rate regime, message-passing (MP) decoding for low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes is known to have performance degradation due to trapping sets (TSs), which often limits the use of LDPC codes for applications with low target error rates like storage devices. This work proposes a novel deep-learning based decoding algorithm which is tailored for breaking TSs. In particular, when MP decoding fails due to TSs, there exist pairs of unsatisfied check nodes (CNs) which are connected through paths only with error variable nodes (VNs), i.e., VNs with erroneous hard-decision results. The proposed algorithm efficiently identifies the paths with error VNs between unsatisfied CNs with the aid of deep-learning techniques. Then, the decoding failures are resolved by repeating the MP decoding after re-initializing the channel outputs for the error VNs in the identified paths. In addition, by analyzing the behaviors of the deep-learning based algorithm, we propose a low-complexity algorithm, called adaptive-error-path (AEP) detector. Simulation results show that the proposed algorithms efficiently break the TSs and significantly improve the error-floor performance in the low error-rate regime.

IEEE Transactions on Communications•Mar 8, 2022•8 citations

Parity-Check Matrix Extension to Lower the Error Floors of Irregular LDPC Codes

Jianjun Mu, Xiaopeng Jiao, Jianguang LIU +1 more

Trapping sets have been identified as one of the main factors causing error floors of low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes at high SNR values. By adding several new rows to the original parity-check matrix, a novel method is proposed to eliminate small trapping sets in the LDPC code's Tanner graph. Based on this parity-check matrix extension, we design new codes with low error floors from the original irregular LDPC codes. Simulation results show that the proposed method can lower the error floors of irregular LDPC codes significantly at high SNR values over AWGN channels.

IEICE Transactions on Communications•Jan 1, 2011•2 citations

Controlling the Error Floors of the Low-Density Parity-Check Codes

Shuai Zhang

The goal of error control coding is to encode information in such a way, that in the event that errors occur during transmission over a noisy communication channel or during storage in an unreliable memory, the receiver can correct the errors and recover the original transmitted information. Low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes are a kind of high performance linear block code, which are already used in many recent communication systems. Information rates guaranteed by these codes approach the theoretical Shannon capacity limit. In addition, LDPC codes are now widely used in practice and included in many communication standards. Therefore study of these codes is very important and practical approaches to their design and decoding techniques are of great interest. There exist very good decoding algorithms for LDPC codes with respect to different channel models. However, LDPC codes suffer from the infamous error floor problem at high signal-to-noise ratios. This problem is attributed to the trapping sets by Richardson. It is shown that the dominant trapping sets of regular LDPC codes, so called absorption sets, undergo a two-phase dynamic behavior in the iterative message-passing decoding algorithm. We present a linear dynamic model for the iteration behavior of these sets. It can be seen that they undergo an initial geometric growth phase which stabilizes in a final bit-flipping behavior where the algorithm reaches a fixed point. Our analysis is shown to lead to very accurate numerical calculations of the error floor bit error rates down to error rates that are inaccessible by simulation. The topologies of the dominant absorption sets of two example codes, the IEEE 802.3an [2048,1723] regular (6,32) LDPC code and the Tanner [155,64,20] regular (3,5) LDPC code, are identified and tabulated by using topological features in combination with search algorithms, respectively. To make our analysis more complete, we provide more solid evidence showing that trapping sets are equivalent to absorption sets. In other words, we argue that absorption sets characterize all failure mechanisms. Some insights from our linear analysis can be borrowed to approach this problem. Another insight that this formula provides to us is the means to reduce the error floor, which is another important part of what we hoped to achieve by developing the formula in the first place. By allowing the log-likelihood ratios (LLRs) utilized by the message-passing decoding to grow bigger in precision length, the absorption sets as a trouble-causing structure will be successfully corrected. Therefore, the absorption sets, generically born with the code design, will no longer threaten the error correcting performance as long as the messages have enough room and time to grow. This translates to greater LLR clipping thresholds and more iterations, both of which are preset at the decoder. However, the actual settings are dependent on how much the subgraph of the dominant absorption set resembles that of a non-zero minimum-weight codeword, therefore the settings are empirical. In general more likeness in their topologies, the more effort it costs to correct the absorption set.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Decoding Quantum LDPC Codes using Collaborative Check Node Removal

Mainak Bhattacharyya, Ankur Raina

Fault tolerance in quantum protocols requires contributions from error-correcting codes and their suitable decoders. Quantum Low-Density Parity Check (QLDPC) codes are one of the most explored quantum codes that have good coding rate and efficient decoders. Iterative message passing-based decoders, although fast, fail to produce suitable success rates due to the colossal degeneracy and short cycles intrinsic to these codes. In this work we present a strategy to improve the performance of the Belief Propagation (BP) decoding, specifically the min-sum algorithm. We propose a collaborative decoding framework that integrates message passing with stabilizer check node removals. We further introduce the concept of ``qubit separation" and show that the improved decoding performance is directly related to the generation of highly separated trapped data qubits. To guide a more selective removal of check nodes that constrain the separation of the trapped data qubits, we introduce information measurements (IMs) for the data qubits and their adjacent stabilizer checks. We evaluate the performance of the proposed collaborative decoder on Generalized Hypergraph Product (GHP) codes and demonstrate that appropriate decoder configurations mitigate trapping sets in min-sum decoding without significant overhead.

arXiv:2501.08036•Jan 14, 2025•6 citations
Trapping sets strongly degrade performance of low-density parity check (LDPC) codes in the low-error-rate region. This creates significant difficulties for the deployment of LDPC codes to low-error-rate applications such as storage and wireless systems with no or limited retransmission options. We propose a novel technique for breaking trapping sets based on collaborative decoding that utilizes two different decoding modes. While the main decoding mode executes message passing based on the original parity check matrix of the corresponding LDPC code, the sub-decoding mode operates on a modified parity check matrix formed by removing a portion of check nodes in the factor graph representation of the given code. The modified parity check matrix is designed to promote a passing of correct information into erroneous variable nodes in the trapping set. Theoretical properties of the proposed trapping-set-breaking technique have been established based on the notion of the improved separation for the trapped variable nodes. Simulation results show that the proposed collaborative LDPC decoding scheme switching between the two decoding modes back and forth effectively breaks dominant trapping sets of various known types of regular and irregular LDPC codes.
In this paper, a modified sum-product algorithm to correct bit errors captured within the trapping sets, which are produced in decoding of low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes, is proposed. Unlike the original sum-product algorithm, the proposed decoding method consists of two stages. Whether the main cause of decoding failure is the trapping sets or not is determined at the first stage. And the bit errors within the trapping sets are corrected at the second stage. In the modified algorithm, the set of failed check nodes and the transition patterns of hard-decision bits are exploited to search variable nodes in the trapping sets. After inverting information of the variable nodes, the sum-product algorithm is carried out to correct the bit errors. As a result of simulation, the proposed algorithm shows continuously improved error performance with increase in the signal-to-noise ratio. It is, therefore, considered that the modified sum-product algorithm significantly reduces or possibly eliminates the error floor in LDPC codes.
This paper presents an efficient algorithm for finding the dominant trapping sets of a low-density parity-check (LDPC) code. The algorithm can be used to estimate the error floor of LDPC codes or as a tool to design LDPC codes with low error floors. For regular codes, the algorithm is initiated with a set of short cycles as the input. For irregular codes, in addition to short cycles, variable nodes with low degree and cycles with low approximate cycle extrinsic message degree (ACE) are also used as the initial inputs. The initial inputs are then expanded recursively to dominant trapping sets of increasing size. At the core of the algorithm lies the analysis of the graphical structure of dominant trapping sets and the relationship of such structures to short cycles, low-degree variable nodes, and cycles with low ACE. The algorithm is universal in the sense that it can be used for an arbitrary graph and that it can be tailored to find a variety of graphical objects, such as absorbing sets and Zyablov-Pinsker trapping sets, known to dominate the performance of LDPC codes in the error floor region over different channels and for different iterative decoding algorithms. Simulation results on several LDPC codes demonstrate the accuracy and efficiency of the proposed algorithm. In particular, the algorithm is significantly faster than the existing search algorithms for dominant trapping sets.
In the low-error rate regime, message-passing (MP) decoding for low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes is known to have performance degradation due to trapping sets (TSs), which often limits the use of LDPC codes for applications with low target error rates like storage devices. This work proposes a novel deep-learning based decoding algorithm which is tailored for breaking TSs. In particular, when MP decoding fails due to TSs, there exist pairs of unsatisfied check nodes (CNs) which are connected through paths only with error variable nodes (VNs), i.e., VNs with erroneous hard-decision results. The proposed algorithm efficiently identifies the paths with error VNs between unsatisfied CNs with the aid of deep-learning techniques. Then, the decoding failures are resolved by repeating the MP decoding after re-initializing the channel outputs for the error VNs in the identified paths. In addition, by analyzing the behaviors of the deep-learning based algorithm, we propose a low-complexity algorithm, called adaptive-error-path (AEP) detector. Simulation results show that the proposed algorithms efficiently break the TSs and significantly improve the error-floor performance in the low error-rate regime.
Trapping sets have been identified as one of the main factors causing error floors of low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes at high SNR values. By adding several new rows to the original parity-check matrix, a novel method is proposed to eliminate small trapping sets in the LDPC code's Tanner graph. Based on this parity-check matrix extension, we design new codes with low error floors from the original irregular LDPC codes. Simulation results show that the proposed method can lower the error floors of irregular LDPC codes significantly at high SNR values over AWGN channels.
The goal of error control coding is to encode information in such a way, that in the event that errors occur during transmission over a noisy communication channel or during storage in an unreliable memory, the receiver can correct the errors and recover the original transmitted information. Low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes are a kind of high performance linear block code, which are already used in many recent communication systems. Information rates guaranteed by these codes approach the theoretical Shannon capacity limit. In addition, LDPC codes are now widely used in practice and included in many communication standards. Therefore study of these codes is very important and practical approaches to their design and decoding techniques are of great interest. There exist very good decoding algorithms for LDPC codes with respect to different channel models. However, LDPC codes suffer from the infamous error floor problem at high signal-to-noise ratios. This problem is attributed to the trapping sets by Richardson. It is shown that the dominant trapping sets of regular LDPC codes, so called absorption sets, undergo a two-phase dynamic behavior in the iterative message-passing decoding algorithm. We present a linear dynamic model for the iteration behavior of these sets. It can be seen that they undergo an initial geometric growth phase which stabilizes in a final bit-flipping behavior where the algorithm reaches a fixed point. Our analysis is shown to lead to very accurate numerical calculations of the error floor bit error rates down to error rates that are inaccessible by simulation. The topologies of the dominant absorption sets of two example codes, the IEEE 802.3an [2048,1723] regular (6,32) LDPC code and the Tanner [155,64,20] regular (3,5) LDPC code, are identified and tabulated by using topological features in combination with search algorithms, respectively. To make our analysis more complete, we provide more solid evidence showing that trapping sets are equivalent to absorption sets. In other words, we argue that absorption sets characterize all failure mechanisms. Some insights from our linear analysis can be borrowed to approach this problem. Another insight that this formula provides to us is the means to reduce the error floor, which is another important part of what we hoped to achieve by developing the formula in the first place. By allowing the log-likelihood ratios (LLRs) utilized by the message-passing decoding to grow bigger in precision length, the absorption sets as a trouble-causing structure will be successfully corrected. Therefore, the absorption sets, generically born with the code design, will no longer threaten the error correcting performance as long as the messages have enough room and time to grow. This translates to greater LLR clipping thresholds and more iterations, both of which are preset at the decoder. However, the actual settings are dependent on how much the subgraph of the dominant absorption set resembles that of a non-zero minimum-weight codeword, therefore the settings are empirical. In general more likeness in their topologies, the more effort it costs to correct the absorption set.
Fault tolerance in quantum protocols requires contributions from error-correcting codes and their suitable decoders. Quantum Low-Density Parity Check (QLDPC) codes are one of the most explored quantum codes that have good coding rate and efficient decoders. Iterative message passing-based decoders, although fast, fail to produce suitable success rates due to the colossal degeneracy and short cycles intrinsic to these codes. In this work we present a strategy to improve the performance of the Belief Propagation (BP) decoding, specifically the min-sum algorithm. We propose a collaborative decoding framework that integrates message passing with stabilizer check node removals. We further introduce the concept of ``qubit separation" and show that the improved decoding performance is directly related to the generation of highly separated trapped data qubits. To guide a more selective removal of check nodes that constrain the separation of the trapped data qubits, we introduce information measurements (IMs) for the data qubits and their adjacent stabilizer checks. We evaluate the performance of the proposed collaborative decoder on Generalized Hypergraph Product (GHP) codes and demonstrate that appropriate decoder configurations mitigate trapping sets in min-sum decoding without significant overhead.