Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

An Objective-Ontological De-construction to Quantum Mechanics

Agus Budiyono

Published Dec 26, 2005• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In this paper we shall develop a hidden-beable theory which not only reproduce all the predictions of quantum mechanics but also gives an objective-ontological derivations to all postulates that give the foundation of the quantum mechanics. This is done by assuming that the state of a single system can be described completely by two complementary irreducible primitive realities: First is system's position and orientation which serve as local and explicit beables, and second is a new, hidden and global beable named "system's imaginability". System's imaginability is defined as degree of imagination attached to the system that it "could have" other states than it actually has. It is thus of ontological nature which refers to a single system, replacing the conventional epistemological concept of probability which tells the relative frequency of occurrence of various events in an ensemble of systems. We then derive a dynamical equation from which neglecting subquantum fluctuations of the order of \\hbar^2 will lead to the Schrodinger equation in configuration space. An objective measurement theory without observer is then developed, by introducing a new notion of "a controllable apparatus". The superposition principle, Dirac-von Neumann projection postulate and Born's probability rule will be given an objective derivation. Finally we shall prove that the new dynamics fits Einstein's locality postulate in a very simple manner.

Related papers

Undivided Reality of Beable-Knowledge Dynamics: On the Completion of the Classical and Quantum Mechanics

Agus Budiyono

We have developed a new dynamical theory that describes deterministic phenomena of very large scale of matter and the seemingly indeterministic experimental results on very small scale of matter in equal footing. This is done by introducing a new non-local ontological quantity, namely matter's knowledge on its own local position-beable. The matter's knowledge is given uniquely by a new non-local beable called "imaginability". The latter is an ontological concept giving a degree of imagination that the matter "could have" state than it actually has, replacing the conventional epistemological concept of probability. The classical objective notion of trajectories are given a new spirit. The classical mechanics turns out to its special case, whereas the Schrodinger's equation is recovered by neglecting sub-quantum fluctuations of the order of $\\hbar^2$. All the quantum mechanical results on spectrum of energy is confirmed. Furthermore, the Dirac-Von Newmann projection postulate is given a physical objective mechanism in term of a single experiment, and the Born's probability rule is given a derivation. Finally we show that our dynamical theory can be considered as a combination between the classical mechanics and the thermodynamics had it applies to a single particle.

•Oct 15, 2005•0 citations

A Mechanical-Topological Ontology as a Foundation for the Dirac Equation and the Postulates of Quantum Measurement

Conde, S.

The axiomatic foundations of quantum mechanics, while operationally successful, obscure the underlying physical reality. This work introduces a mechanical topological ontology intended to provide a causal basis for the theory. We propose a single postulate: that a fundamental fermion is the 0-dimensional boundary of a 1-dimensional, massive, string-like object topologically anchored to a dynamic vacuum field. From this postulate, we argue that the core structures of single-particle relativistic quantum mechanics can be understood as derivable theorems. First, we construct the object’s state space by identifying two independent, binary properties—a local, vibrational/topological duality (spin) and a global, orientational duality (matter/antimatter)—whose tensor product naturally yields the 4-component Dirac spinor. Second, we show that the requirement of relativistic consistency uniquely determines the algebraic operators (gamma matrices and their Clifford algebra) and the lowest-order dynamical law, leading to the Dirac equation as a theorem of consistency. Third, we demonstrate that the non-relativistic Schrödinger and Pauli equations emerge as its correct low-energy limits, where the quantum potential V (x) is identified with a local variation in the object’s rest mass. Finally, we argue that the foundational tenets of quantum measurement—the spin-1/2 property, the probabilistic Born rule, and the correlations of entanglement—can be reframed as necessary consequences of the object’s intrinsic topology and interaction mechanics. This framework thus offers a path toward demoting the axioms of quantum theory to derivable theorems, aiming to resolve its long-standing paradoxes by providing a clear and coherent physical picture.

•Nov 20, 2025•0 citations

The Structure of Physical Reality: A Modal Ontology of Quantum Mechanics

James Glenn-Anderson

The philosophical tradition has long sought an ineffable substratum of physical reality—something more fundamental than the world of appearances, prior to experience, the ground of all that is. Plato reached for it with his theory of forms. The attempt was genuine but the logic was inverted: mind was installed as the source of the fundamental, and the physical world was rendered derivative. This paper argues that quantum mechanics, read without presupposition and without the interpretive additions of the Copenhagen tradition, delivers precisely what the philosophical tradition was seeking—but with the arrow pointing in the opposite direction. The possibility space of quantum mechanics—the Hilbert space structure of the universal wave function, evolving unitarily under the Schrödinger equation, holistic in its composition, non-local in its correlations, geometric in its dynamics—is the genuine ineffable substratum: more fundamental than the classical world of appearances, prior to experience, the ground of all physical dispositions. Mind is not the source of this reality. It is the instrument through which this reality generates the appearance of a classical world. The modal ontology presented here holds that physical reality has a fundamentally modal structure. The microcosm is a universe of structured possibilities. The classical world is its emergent surface. Eigenvalues are its currency of contact with experience. The Schrödinger equation is the law of its rotation. Born rule probabilities are structurally grounded propensities—objective dispositional properties of the possibility structure, uniquely characterized by Gleason’s theorem as the only consistent probability measure on Hilbert space. The holism and non-locality enforced by the tensor product structure of composite systems are genuine structural features of physical reality, confirmed by Bell’s theorem and experiment. The Copenhagen tradition’s interpretive apparatus—collapse postulate, classical observer, Heisenberg cut, instrumentalism—is set aside, and the formalism is allowed to speak for itself. What it says is stranger, more precise, and more beautiful than two and a half millennia of philosophical tradition imagined. It has been saying it all along.

•Nov 15, 2026•0 citations

The Ontology of Probability in Quantum Mechanics

Nasiri Vatan Sadeq

Abstract This paper develops a metaphysical interpretation of quantum probability under the title Distributed Presence (DP). The central claim is that quantum probabilities should not be understood as measures of ignorance, nor merely as formal devices for predicting measurement outcomes, but as expressions of an objective mode of being: a system’s structured distribution of presence across mutually available channels of realization. On this view, a quantum system prior to measurement is neither fully actual in one determinate outcome nor reducible to a set of hidden definite properties. Rather, it exists in a non-binary mode, articulated by normalized presence fractions associated with the possible outcomes defined by a given interaction context. The Born rule is accordingly not replaced, but reinterpreted: the standard probability assignment is read as the operational expression of an underlying ontological distribution. The paper argues that this framework provides a unified reading of several familiar quantum features. Superposition is understood as a real distribution of presence rather than as epistemic indeterminacy; measurement is interpreted as single-channel actualization rather than as the physical destruction of alternatives; wave-particle duality is recast as the relation between distributed structure and localized realization; and quantum randomness is treated as intrinsic yet structurally constrained. The proposal remains fully compatible with the standard Hilbert-space formalism and introduces no hidden variables, additional collapse dynamics, or many-world branching. Its aim is interpretive rather than revisionary. Beyond its relevance to the foundations of quantum theory, DP is advanced as a contribution to the ontology of probability more broadly. It seeks to show how probability may be objective, physically meaningful, and ontologically basic without collapsing into determinism on the one hand or epistemicism on the other. In that sense, the paper offers a realist, single-world, structurally articulated account of quantum chance.

•May 30, 2026•0 citations

The measurement postulates of quantum mechanics are operationally redundant

Lluís Masanes, Thomas D. Galley, Markus P. Müller

Understanding the core content of quantum mechanics requires us to disentangle the hidden logical relationships between the postulates of this theory. Here we show that the mathematical structure of quantum measurements, the formula for assigning outcome probabilities (Born's rule) and the post-measurement state-update rule, can be deduced from the other quantum postulates, often referred to as "unitary quantum mechanics", and the assumption that ensembles on finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces are characterized by finitely many parameters. This is achieved by taking an operational approach to physical theories, and using the fact that the manner in which a physical system is partitioned into subsystems is a subjective choice of the observer, and hence should not affect the predictions of the theory. In contrast to other approaches, our result does not assume that measurements are related to operators or bases, it does not rely on the universality of quantum mechanics, and it is independent of the interpretation of probability.

arXiv:1811.11060•Nature Communications•Mar 25, 2019•72 citations

Standard quantum mechanics without observers

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

The Projection Postulate from Standard Quantum Mechanics relies fundamentally on measurements. But measurements implicitly suggest the existence of anthropocentric notions like measuring devices, which should rather emerge from the theory. This article proposes an alternative formulation of the Standard Quantum Mechanics, in which the Projection Postulate is replaced with a version in which measurements and observations are not assumed as fundamental. More precisely, the Wigner functions representing the quantum states on the phase space are required to be tightly constrained to regions of the classical coarse graining of the phase space. This ensures that states are quasiclassical at the macrolevel. Within a coarse-graining region, the time evolution of the Wigner functions representing the quantum system is required to obey the Liouville-von Neumann equation, the phase-space equivalent of the Schr\"odinger equation. The projection is postulated to happen when the system transitions from a coarse-graining region to others, by selecting one of them according to the Born rule, but without reference to a measurements. The connection with the standard formulation of Quantum Mechanics is explained, as well as the problems that the present formulation solves, in particular the Wigner's friend type of paradoxes. Experimental consequences and open problems of the proposed formulation are discussed.

arXiv:2008.04930•Physical Review A•Mar 25, 2021•8 citations
In this paper we shall develop a hidden-beable theory which not only reproduce all the predictions of quantum mechanics but also gives an objective-ontological derivations to all postulates that give the foundation of the quantum mechanics. This is done by assuming that the state of a single system can be described completely by two complementary irreducible primitive realities: First is system's position and orientation which serve as local and explicit beables, and second is a new, hidden and global beable named "system's imaginability". System's imaginability is defined as degree of imagination attached to the system that it "could have" other states than it actually has. It is thus of ontological nature which refers to a single system, replacing the conventional epistemological concept of probability which tells the relative frequency of occurrence of various events in an ensemble of systems. We then derive a dynamical equation from which neglecting subquantum fluctuations of the order of \hbar^2 will lead to the Schrodinger equation in configuration space. An objective measurement theory without observer is then developed, by introducing a new notion of "a controllable apparatus". The superposition principle, Dirac-von Neumann projection postulate and Born's probability rule will be given an objective derivation. Finally we shall prove that the new dynamics fits Einstein's locality postulate in a very simple manner.
We have developed a new dynamical theory that describes deterministic phenomena of very large scale of matter and the seemingly indeterministic experimental results on very small scale of matter in equal footing. This is done by introducing a new non-local ontological quantity, namely matter's knowledge on its own local position-beable. The matter's knowledge is given uniquely by a new non-local beable called "imaginability". The latter is an ontological concept giving a degree of imagination that the matter "could have" state than it actually has, replacing the conventional epistemological concept of probability. The classical objective notion of trajectories are given a new spirit. The classical mechanics turns out to its special case, whereas the Schrodinger's equation is recovered by neglecting sub-quantum fluctuations of the order of hbar2\\hbar^2hbar2. All the quantum mechanical results on spectrum of energy is confirmed. Furthermore, the Dirac-Von Newmann projection postulate is given a physical objective mechanism in term of a single experiment, and the Born's probability rule is given a derivation. Finally we show that our dynamical theory can be considered as a combination between the classical mechanics and the thermodynamics had it applies to a single particle.
The axiomatic foundations of quantum mechanics, while operationally successful, obscure the underlying physical reality. This work introduces a mechanical topological ontology intended to provide a causal basis for the theory. We propose a single postulate: that a fundamental fermion is the 0-dimensional boundary of a 1-dimensional, massive, string-like object topologically anchored to a dynamic vacuum field. From this postulate, we argue that the core structures of single-particle relativistic quantum mechanics can be understood as derivable theorems. First, we construct the object’s state space by identifying two independent, binary properties—a local, vibrational/topological duality (spin) and a global, orientational duality (matter/antimatter)—whose tensor product naturally yields the 4-component Dirac spinor. Second, we show that the requirement of relativistic consistency uniquely determines the algebraic operators (gamma matrices and their Clifford algebra) and the lowest-order dynamical law, leading to the Dirac equation as a theorem of consistency. Third, we demonstrate that the non-relativistic Schrödinger and Pauli equations emerge as its correct low-energy limits, where the quantum potential V (x) is identified with a local variation in the object’s rest mass. Finally, we argue that the foundational tenets of quantum measurement—the spin-1/2 property, the probabilistic Born rule, and the correlations of entanglement—can be reframed as necessary consequences of the object’s intrinsic topology and interaction mechanics. This framework thus offers a path toward demoting the axioms of quantum theory to derivable theorems, aiming to resolve its long-standing paradoxes by providing a clear and coherent physical picture.
The philosophical tradition has long sought an ineffable substratum of physical reality—something more fundamental than the world of appearances, prior to experience, the ground of all that is. Plato reached for it with his theory of forms. The attempt was genuine but the logic was inverted: mind was installed as the source of the fundamental, and the physical world was rendered derivative. This paper argues that quantum mechanics, read without presupposition and without the interpretive additions of the Copenhagen tradition, delivers precisely what the philosophical tradition was seeking—but with the arrow pointing in the opposite direction. The possibility space of quantum mechanics—the Hilbert space structure of the universal wave function, evolving unitarily under the Schrödinger equation, holistic in its composition, non-local in its correlations, geometric in its dynamics—is the genuine ineffable substratum: more fundamental than the classical world of appearances, prior to experience, the ground of all physical dispositions. Mind is not the source of this reality. It is the instrument through which this reality generates the appearance of a classical world. The modal ontology presented here holds that physical reality has a fundamentally modal structure. The microcosm is a universe of structured possibilities. The classical world is its emergent surface. Eigenvalues are its currency of contact with experience. The Schrödinger equation is the law of its rotation. Born rule probabilities are structurally grounded propensities—objective dispositional properties of the possibility structure, uniquely characterized by Gleason’s theorem as the only consistent probability measure on Hilbert space. The holism and non-locality enforced by the tensor product structure of composite systems are genuine structural features of physical reality, confirmed by Bell’s theorem and experiment. The Copenhagen tradition’s interpretive apparatus—collapse postulate, classical observer, Heisenberg cut, instrumentalism—is set aside, and the formalism is allowed to speak for itself. What it says is stranger, more precise, and more beautiful than two and a half millennia of philosophical tradition imagined. It has been saying it all along.
Abstract This paper develops a metaphysical interpretation of quantum probability under the title Distributed Presence (DP). The central claim is that quantum probabilities should not be understood as measures of ignorance, nor merely as formal devices for predicting measurement outcomes, but as expressions of an objective mode of being: a system’s structured distribution of presence across mutually available channels of realization. On this view, a quantum system prior to measurement is neither fully actual in one determinate outcome nor reducible to a set of hidden definite properties. Rather, it exists in a non-binary mode, articulated by normalized presence fractions associated with the possible outcomes defined by a given interaction context. The Born rule is accordingly not replaced, but reinterpreted: the standard probability assignment is read as the operational expression of an underlying ontological distribution. The paper argues that this framework provides a unified reading of several familiar quantum features. Superposition is understood as a real distribution of presence rather than as epistemic indeterminacy; measurement is interpreted as single-channel actualization rather than as the physical destruction of alternatives; wave-particle duality is recast as the relation between distributed structure and localized realization; and quantum randomness is treated as intrinsic yet structurally constrained. The proposal remains fully compatible with the standard Hilbert-space formalism and introduces no hidden variables, additional collapse dynamics, or many-world branching. Its aim is interpretive rather than revisionary. Beyond its relevance to the foundations of quantum theory, DP is advanced as a contribution to the ontology of probability more broadly. It seeks to show how probability may be objective, physically meaningful, and ontologically basic without collapsing into determinism on the one hand or epistemicism on the other. In that sense, the paper offers a realist, single-world, structurally articulated account of quantum chance.
Understanding the core content of quantum mechanics requires us to disentangle the hidden logical relationships between the postulates of this theory. Here we show that the mathematical structure of quantum measurements, the formula for assigning outcome probabilities (Born's rule) and the post-measurement state-update rule, can be deduced from the other quantum postulates, often referred to as "unitary quantum mechanics", and the assumption that ensembles on finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces are characterized by finitely many parameters. This is achieved by taking an operational approach to physical theories, and using the fact that the manner in which a physical system is partitioned into subsystems is a subjective choice of the observer, and hence should not affect the predictions of the theory. In contrast to other approaches, our result does not assume that measurements are related to operators or bases, it does not rely on the universality of quantum mechanics, and it is independent of the interpretation of probability.
The Projection Postulate from Standard Quantum Mechanics relies fundamentally on measurements. But measurements implicitly suggest the existence of anthropocentric notions like measuring devices, which should rather emerge from the theory. This article proposes an alternative formulation of the Standard Quantum Mechanics, in which the Projection Postulate is replaced with a version in which measurements and observations are not assumed as fundamental. More precisely, the Wigner functions representing the quantum states on the phase space are required to be tightly constrained to regions of the classical coarse graining of the phase space. This ensures that states are quasiclassical at the macrolevel. Within a coarse-graining region, the time evolution of the Wigner functions representing the quantum system is required to obey the Liouville-von Neumann equation, the phase-space equivalent of the Schr\"odinger equation. The projection is postulated to happen when the system transitions from a coarse-graining region to others, by selecting one of them according to the Born rule, but without reference to a measurements. The connection with the standard formulation of Quantum Mechanics is explained, as well as the problems that the present formulation solves, in particular the Wigner's friend type of paradoxes. Experimental consequences and open problems of the proposed formulation are discussed.