Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Chinese Optics Letters

Uncertainty, certainty,and and relativity (Invited Paper)

Francis T. S. Yu

Published Jan 1, 2016• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

One of the most fascinating principles in quantum mechanics must be Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, which can be briefly stated as follows: every physical observation cannot be precisely determined without some degree of error or uncertainty. And it is by no means can one use the principle within the limit of certainty region, as will be shown in this Letter. Two of the most important pillars in modern physics must be Einstein’s relativity theory and Schr dinger’s contribution to quantum mechanics. Yet, there is a profound connection between these discoveries by means of the uncertainty relationship, in which we shown that the observation of a high-speed object is conceivable if the speed of the observer keeps up with object’s speed.

DOI
10.3788/col201614.010002

Related papers

Wave-mechanical uncertainty and speed limitations

Panos A. Ligomenides

Modern science is eliminating the old, unrealistic approach to experimental errors. The Heisenberg principle of uncertainty has effected a fundamental change in the scientific attitude toward experimental errors and toward the degree of exactness in stating physical laws. Quantum physics has brought about the realization that a measurement or a mere observation at the quantum level perturbs the observed system in such a way that corrections cannot be made for the ``loading'' effect of the measuring instrument. There is something more basic and fundamental to our limitations in measurements than the lack of perfection in experimental planning and equipment. This article examines the types of uncertainty in measurements or observations. The interest then focuses on the fundamental importance of the relation between experimental uncertainty in measuring, observing, or in any way identifying a physical quantity, and the energy required to accomplish this in a certain allotted interval of time. This last relation has a direct bearing on the speed limitations of measurements.

IEEE Spectrum•Feb 1, 1967•5 citations

An analysis and explanation of the uncertainty principle

Nezameddin Faghih

This paper presents a mathematical approach, based on the spectral analysis and Fourier transformation to derive the principle of uncertainty. The approach presented in this paper is found to be different from those appeared so far in the literature. It shows that the uncertainty principle is, in fact, an aliasing phenomenon and emerges merely from the quantization effect. The concept of ‘certainty’ is also introduced and discussed. It is shown that observation rates higher than the speed of a particle are the only possible approaches to the absence of uncertainty in the measurements of the observable quantities ofthe entity. This would imply that for particles travelling at the velocity of light, data acquisition rates higher than the speed of light should be required. Therefore, the uncertainty principle is related to the theory of relativity and exists so far as the velocity of light poses as an upperlimit universal constant. Otherwise, it would render to ‘certainty’ if our observation abilities could escalade at rates above the speed of light. This is to say that the uncertainty can be an inherent intrinsic property grounded in the universal speed limitation, which also subdues our observation abilities too; else demanding challenges on Einstein’s definition of simultaneity, and hence its consequences, has to be expected.

Journal of Interdisciplinary Mathematics•Jun 1, 1999•0 citations

The Uncertainty Principle: Limits of Knowledge

One of the most profound and unsettling discoveries of the twentieth century is that nature imposes fundamental limits on what we can know about the physical world. This is the essence of the Uncertainty Principle , formulated by Werner Heisenberg in 1927 [Heisenberg (1927)]. The principle states that certain pairs of physical properties cannot be known simultaneously with arbitrary precision. The most famous example is that the more precisely we know a particle's position, the less precisely we can know its momentum, and vice versa as shown in Fig. 12.1. This is not a limitation of our measuring instruments or experimental technique—it is a fundamental property of nature itself at the quantum scale.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations

W. Heisenberg's Measurement Uncertainty Principle and A. Einstein's General Theory of Relativity

Thierry Periat

In exposing his uncertainty principle, W. Heisenberg has pointed out the fact that positions and speeds form two separate and independent sets of observables. He also suggested that infinitesimal variations of energies and lapses of times were following a similar logic. Unfortunately, there is up to now no operator representing the time and, at least at a technical level, this absence is blocking the progression of any development for the second pair. Whatever the interpretation of that principle is, a fact is that it introduces a finite limit for the relative variations of these pairs. The situations realizing the minimum value of a product between both elements of a given pair are labeled as “quantum limit”. And this is the information on which I build my theoretical proposition. Following a well-known and accepted principle affirming that the laws of physics must be the same everywhere, I look for technical circumstances allowing to go further on that road. Concretely, that quantum limit must be the same for two observers, wherever they stay in the world. I consider the simplest transposition of Heisenberg’ suggested interdependence between the elements of the pair (delta energy, delta lapse of time) in a simple one-dimensional world. And I ask me where, in the arsenal of formulas and laws of physics, I can find a plausible manner to introduce these ingredients softly.

•Nov 1, 2020•0 citations

Incompatibility between Einstein's general relativity and Heisenberg's uncertainty principle

Alexandre Georges

Are General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics incompatible?Each in their world, that of the infinitely large and that of the infinitely small, they did not seem to interfere as long as they avoided each other.However, it is their fundamental oppositions that prevent the scientific community from achieving a unification of physics.The proposal of this paper is to provide a mathematical proof of incompatibility, beyond the fact that they have fundamentally different principles, between the foundations of General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics, namely, the deformation of the space-time geometry and the Uncertainty Principle.It will thus be possible to provide an absolute limitation in establishing a unifying theory of physics, if any.Moreover, while respecting the conditions fixed by the Uncertainty Principle, it will be tempted to determine with accuracy and simultaneity, the position and the speed of a nonrelativistic particle, by application of relativistic principles and bypassing the problems raised by such an operation.The Uncertainty Principle as stated by Werner Heisenberg will be then, in the light of observations made on the measurement of the time dilatation and in accordance with its own terms, refuted by the present.

Physics Essays•Sep 1, 2018•3 citations

Light and information

Francis T. S. Yu

Light is not just the major source of energy that supports life and it is also a very viable information carrier. In this article, we showed that there is an intimate relationship between information and light as a carrier. We discussed the Uncertainty Principle of Heisenberg as related to information, in which we showed that every bit of information (or quanta of light) is limited by an unit cell of information and it is associated with a cost of entropy. Examples are given within the limit and beyond the Uncertainty Principle. We have shown that time and frequency resolutions cannot be observed simultaneously and yet the imaging can also be obtained within the limit of Certainty! We have further shown a crucial connection between the uncertainty principle and the relativity theory of Einstein, in which we see that very high speed object is conceivable to be detected at the expensed of the observation speed.

Optical Memory and Neural Networks•Oct 1, 2015•0 citations
One of the most fascinating principles in quantum mechanics must be Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, which can be briefly stated as follows: every physical observation cannot be precisely determined without some degree of error or uncertainty. And it is by no means can one use the principle within the limit of certainty region, as will be shown in this Letter. Two of the most important pillars in modern physics must be Einstein’s relativity theory and Schr dinger’s contribution to quantum mechanics. Yet, there is a profound connection between these discoveries by means of the uncertainty relationship, in which we shown that the observation of a high-speed object is conceivable if the speed of the observer keeps up with object’s speed.
Modern science is eliminating the old, unrealistic approach to experimental errors. The Heisenberg principle of uncertainty has effected a fundamental change in the scientific attitude toward experimental errors and toward the degree of exactness in stating physical laws. Quantum physics has brought about the realization that a measurement or a mere observation at the quantum level perturbs the observed system in such a way that corrections cannot be made for the ``loading'' effect of the measuring instrument. There is something more basic and fundamental to our limitations in measurements than the lack of perfection in experimental planning and equipment. This article examines the types of uncertainty in measurements or observations. The interest then focuses on the fundamental importance of the relation between experimental uncertainty in measuring, observing, or in any way identifying a physical quantity, and the energy required to accomplish this in a certain allotted interval of time. This last relation has a direct bearing on the speed limitations of measurements.
This paper presents a mathematical approach, based on the spectral analysis and Fourier transformation to derive the principle of uncertainty. The approach presented in this paper is found to be different from those appeared so far in the literature. It shows that the uncertainty principle is, in fact, an aliasing phenomenon and emerges merely from the quantization effect. The concept of ‘certainty’ is also introduced and discussed. It is shown that observation rates higher than the speed of a particle are the only possible approaches to the absence of uncertainty in the measurements of the observable quantities ofthe entity. This would imply that for particles travelling at the velocity of light, data acquisition rates higher than the speed of light should be required. Therefore, the uncertainty principle is related to the theory of relativity and exists so far as the velocity of light poses as an upperlimit universal constant. Otherwise, it would render to ‘certainty’ if our observation abilities could escalade at rates above the speed of light. This is to say that the uncertainty can be an inherent intrinsic property grounded in the universal speed limitation, which also subdues our observation abilities too; else demanding challenges on Einstein’s definition of simultaneity, and hence its consequences, has to be expected.
One of the most profound and unsettling discoveries of the twentieth century is that nature imposes fundamental limits on what we can know about the physical world. This is the essence of the Uncertainty Principle , formulated by Werner Heisenberg in 1927 [Heisenberg (1927)]. The principle states that certain pairs of physical properties cannot be known simultaneously with arbitrary precision. The most famous example is that the more precisely we know a particle's position, the less precisely we can know its momentum, and vice versa as shown in Fig. 12.1. This is not a limitation of our measuring instruments or experimental technique—it is a fundamental property of nature itself at the quantum scale.
In exposing his uncertainty principle, W. Heisenberg has pointed out the fact that positions and speeds form two separate and independent sets of observables. He also suggested that infinitesimal variations of energies and lapses of times were following a similar logic. Unfortunately, there is up to now no operator representing the time and, at least at a technical level, this absence is blocking the progression of any development for the second pair. Whatever the interpretation of that principle is, a fact is that it introduces a finite limit for the relative variations of these pairs. The situations realizing the minimum value of a product between both elements of a given pair are labeled as “quantum limit”. And this is the information on which I build my theoretical proposition. Following a well-known and accepted principle affirming that the laws of physics must be the same everywhere, I look for technical circumstances allowing to go further on that road. Concretely, that quantum limit must be the same for two observers, wherever they stay in the world. I consider the simplest transposition of Heisenberg’ suggested interdependence between the elements of the pair (delta energy, delta lapse of time) in a simple one-dimensional world. And I ask me where, in the arsenal of formulas and laws of physics, I can find a plausible manner to introduce these ingredients softly.
Are General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics incompatible?Each in their world, that of the infinitely large and that of the infinitely small, they did not seem to interfere as long as they avoided each other.However, it is their fundamental oppositions that prevent the scientific community from achieving a unification of physics.The proposal of this paper is to provide a mathematical proof of incompatibility, beyond the fact that they have fundamentally different principles, between the foundations of General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics, namely, the deformation of the space-time geometry and the Uncertainty Principle.It will thus be possible to provide an absolute limitation in establishing a unifying theory of physics, if any.Moreover, while respecting the conditions fixed by the Uncertainty Principle, it will be tempted to determine with accuracy and simultaneity, the position and the speed of a nonrelativistic particle, by application of relativistic principles and bypassing the problems raised by such an operation.The Uncertainty Principle as stated by Werner Heisenberg will be then, in the light of observations made on the measurement of the time dilatation and in accordance with its own terms, refuted by the present.
Light is not just the major source of energy that supports life and it is also a very viable information carrier. In this article, we showed that there is an intimate relationship between information and light as a carrier. We discussed the Uncertainty Principle of Heisenberg as related to information, in which we showed that every bit of information (or quanta of light) is limited by an unit cell of information and it is associated with a cost of entropy. Examples are given within the limit and beyond the Uncertainty Principle. We have shown that time and frequency resolutions cannot be observed simultaneously and yet the imaging can also be obtained within the limit of Certainty! We have further shown a crucial connection between the uncertainty principle and the relativity theory of Einstein, in which we see that very high speed object is conceivable to be detected at the expensed of the observation speed.