Role of consciousness in two different cognitive tasks, apprehension and judgment
F. T. Arecchi
Abstract
Apprehension, common to humans and animals, lasts around 1 sec. .It can be explained in Bayesian terms, that is, by the formalism of classical physics. Judgment, that is, the connection between two apprehensions formalized in some language, is exclusive of humans. It violates the Leggett Garg Inequalities (LGI); this marks a quantum behaviour not describable by classical physics. LGI violation means that successive pieces of a discourse affect each other. A quantum formalism is necessary to describe the judgment.This however does not require a microphysical model, as done in some popular accounts. Awareness of apprenhensions has been taken to be consciousnes. We rather call consciousness (better, self-consciousness) only the fact that the same oneself supervises both apprehensions from the comparison of which the judgment emerges. As result, ethical and esthetical decisions can not be confined within the single apprehension, as pretended in the neuroapproaches . Decisions result from a repeated comparison that stops when conformity has been reached . Such a procedure is the modern reformulation of Thomas Aquinas’ adaequatio intellectus et rei.