Entanglement is at the heart of quantum mechanics. The nonlocal correlations that can be obtained from space-time separated measurements on an entangled state are a central feature which provably distinguish it from local theories. This dissertation studies entanglement through a computational viewpoint. We develop new insights into the complex nature of entanglement by studying its role in multiplayer games, in which cooperating, but non-communicating, players interact with a referee in an attempt to win a pre-specified game. On the one hand, the nonlocal correlations that entanglement allows may enable players using it to develop new colluding strategies, defeating previously secure protocols. On the other, the richness of this new resource may also be exploited in order to design new protocols, providing solutions to problems previously deemed impossible. We explore both aspects of this dual nature of entanglement, putting limits on its strength while at the same time showing how it can be put to profit to solve new computational problems. A major unresolved question on the computational complexity of multiplayer entangled games is the power of MIP*, the class of languages having entangled multi-prover interactive proofs: how does it relate to its purely classical analogue MIP, which was completely characterized through the fundamental equation MIP=NEXP? Since the players may use entanglement to increase their odds at colluding against the verifier, MIP* could potentially be a much weaker class than MIP. Indeed, for a long time it has been an open question whether two entangled provers are more useful than a single prover. In this thesis we resolve this question by showing that the class of languages having multiprover interactive proofs with entangled provers is at least as large as its classical counterpart: NEXP is included in MIP*. At the heart of this result is an analysis of the multilinearity test of Babai, Fortnow, and Lund in the presence of entanglement. The fact that this test remains sound gives a systematic way for a verifier to impose strong limits on the ability of entangled provers to collude against the verifier.Gap amplification is a fundamental primitive in the study of classical multiplayer games. While sequential repetition of a game always decreases the prover's maximum success probability at an exponential rate, the fact that parallel repetition also achieves a gap amplification is a highly non-trivial fact. We show that gap amplification can be performed in parallel even in the presence of entanglement between the provers. We adapt a technique which was originally introduced by Feige and Kilian and results in a polynomial rate of amplification.The phenomenon of monogamy of entanglement states, in first approximation, that if two parties are maximally entangled then they cannot simultaneously be entangled with a third party. We use this phenomenon in two distinct results. In the first, we show that the bits generated in our randomness-expansion protocol are certifiably random even from the point of view of a quantum adversary who may share prior entanglement with the provers. In addition, we prove the security against quantum adversaries of a randomness-efficient extractor construction originally due to Trevisan. This lets us transform the high-entropy bits that are generated in our protocol into ones that are almost indistinguishable from uniform by any adversary. More generally, we show how the monogamy of entanglement can be exploited to design multi-prover interactive proof systems that are partially entanglement-resistant. Quantitative bounds on the monogamy of entanglement have generally been elusive, and the analysis of our protocol demonstrates such a bound in a new context. The nonlocal correlations that can be created by entangled players provide a statistical means of differentiating them from classical, unentangled players. This is the main idea behind Bell inequalities, the violation of which demonstrates the nonlocality of quantum mechanics. We show how this phenomenon may be exploited to design a protocol in which the bits produced by successful players necessarily contain a large quantity of fresh randomness. The presence of randomness is guaranteed irrespective of the provers' actual strategy, as long as the sole constraint of no signaling is respected. Hence a statistical certification for the presence of randomness, a feat easily seen to be impossible to achieve classically. In order to manipulate the random bits produced in our protocol, and make them useful in cryptography, we give the first proof of security of a poly-logarithmic seed extractor secure against quantum adversaries. To achieve this we adapt the reconstruction paradigm originally introduced by Trevisan to the quantum setting. We study other ways in which entanglement may be used in interactive proof systems by also allowing a quantum interaction between the referee and the players. We show that, using entanglement, the class of QMIP* proof systems can be parallelized to only three rounds of interaction, and made public-coin, a property that does not hold in the absence of entanglement between the provers.
Entanglement is at the heart of quantum mechanics. The nonlocal correlations that can be obtained from space-time separated measurements on an entangled state are a central feature which provably distinguish it from local theories. This dissertation studies entanglement through a computational viewpoint. We develop new insights into the complex nature of entanglement by studying its role in multiplayer games, in which cooperating, but non-communicating, players interact with a referee in an attempt to win a pre-specified game. On the one hand, the nonlocal correlations that entanglement allows may enable players using it to develop new colluding strategies, defeating previously secure protocols. On the other, the richness of this new resource may also be exploited in order to design new protocols, providing solutions to problems previously deemed impossible. We explore both aspects of this dual nature of entanglement, putting limits on its strength while at the same time showing how it can be put to profit to solve new computational problems. A major unresolved question on the computational complexity of multiplayer entangled games is the power of MIP*, the class of languages having entangled multi-prover interactive proofs: how does it relate to its purely classical analogue MIP, which was completely characterized through the fundamental equation MIP=NEXP? Since the players may use entanglement to increase their odds at colluding against the verifier, MIP* could potentially be a much weaker class than MIP. Indeed, for a long time it has been an open question whether two entangled provers are more useful than a single prover. In this thesis we resolve this question by showing that the class of languages having multiprover interactive proofs with entangled provers is at least as large as its classical counterpart: NEXP is included in MIP*. At the heart of this result is an analysis of the multilinearity test of Babai, Fortnow, and Lund in the presence of entanglement. The fact that this test remains sound gives a systematic way for a verifier to impose strong limits on the ability of entangled provers to collude against the verifier.Gap amplification is a fundamental primitive in the study of classical multiplayer games. While sequential repetition of a game always decreases the prover's maximum success probability at an exponential rate, the fact that parallel repetition also achieves a gap amplification is a highly non-trivial fact. We show that gap amplification can be performed in parallel even in the presence of entanglement between the provers. We adapt a technique which was originally introduced by Feige and Kilian and results in a polynomial rate of amplification.The phenomenon of monogamy of entanglement states, in first approximation, that if two parties are maximally entangled then they cannot simultaneously be entangled with a third party. We use this phenomenon in two distinct results. In the first, we show that the bits generated in our randomness-expansion protocol are certifiably random even from the point of view of a quantum adversary who may share prior entanglement with the provers. In addition, we prove the security against quantum adversaries of a randomness-efficient extractor construction originally due to Trevisan. This lets us transform the high-entropy bits that are generated in our protocol into ones that are almost indistinguishable from uniform by any adversary. More generally, we show how the monogamy of entanglement can be exploited to design multi-prover interactive proof systems that are partially entanglement-resistant. Quantitative bounds on the monogamy of entanglement have generally been elusive, and the analysis of our protocol demonstrates such a bound in a new context. The nonlocal correlations that can be created by entangled players provide a statistical means of differentiating them from classical, unentangled players. This is the main idea behind Bell inequalities, the violation of which demonstrates the nonlocality of quantum mechanics. We show how this phenomenon may be exploited to design a protocol in which the bits produced by successful players necessarily contain a large quantity of fresh randomness. The presence of randomness is guaranteed irrespective of the provers' actual strategy, as long as the sole constraint of no signaling is respected. Hence a statistical certification for the presence of randomness, a feat easily seen to be impossible to achieve classically. In order to manipulate the random bits produced in our protocol, and make them useful in cryptography, we give the first proof of security of a poly-logarithmic seed extractor secure against quantum adversaries. To achieve this we adapt the reconstruction paradigm originally introduced by Trevisan to the quantum setting. We study other ways in which entanglement may be used in interactive proof systems by also allowing a quantum interaction between the referee and the players. We show that, using entanglement, the class of QMIP* proof systems can be parallelized to only three rounds of interaction, and made public-coin, a property that does not hold in the absence of entanglement between the provers.
Quantum entanglement, and the resulting peculiar non-classical correlations are one of the most counter-intuitive aspects of quantum mechanics.
The formalism of interactive games from computational complexity theory provides a useful framework in which to understand the power of entanglement. In an interactive game, a verifier interacts with a number of infinitely powerful provers who are allowed to share quantum entanglement but otherwise can't communicate. The ability of the verifier to extract useful information from the provers, whom he does not trust, provides an interesting measure of the ability of the provers to coordinate using their shared entanglement. Two particular interactive games we'll look at are Magic Square and 3SAT.
The Magic Square game is the iconic example of a game where two classical provers cannot perfectly coordinate their strategies using shared randomness, but quantum provers with shared entanglement can win with probability 1. We show that by adding an extra prover, we disallow perfect cheating. For 3SAT with three provers we also show that perfect cheating is not possible.
We then generalize the results for Magic Square and 3SAT by looking at non-commuting provers, a superset of entangled provers (communication is allowed, but operators applied by different provers must commute). Using this method, we obtain a generalized Tsirelson inequality that we apply to the Magic Square. Hence, we are able to give provably optimal strategies for the general Magic Square with n players. We also recover a similar result for 3SAT as with entangled provers, and we improve on it by showing that the gap is inverse exponential in the input size.
The no-signaling principle, which forbids faster than light communication, is a fundamental constraint on the non-local correlations resulting from quantum entanglement. However, no-signaling allows distributions that are more general than those arising from quantum mechanics. In particular, using a specific unit of general non-local correlation (the Popescu-Rohlich box), we show that there are classes that are equal to NEXP classically, but collapse to AM once such correlations are allowed. We also show that MIP where the verifier only looks at the XOR of the answers collapses to PSPACE. For the second approach, we show that by writing general non-local correlations as linear constraints, MIP is included in EXP under such correlations (vs NEXP classically).
We can extend these results to entangled quantum provers, by formulating an artificial MIP-like class built on a promise problem, that classically is equal to NEXP, but that also collapses to AM when quantum correlations are present.
We prove a strong limitation on the ability of entangled provers to collude in a multiplayer game. Our main result is the first nontrivial lower bound on the class MIP* of languages having multi-prover interactive proofs with entangled provers, namely MIP* contains NEXP, the class of languages decidable in non-deterministic exponential time. While Babai, Fort now, and Lund (Computational Complexity 1991) proved the celebrated equality MIP = NEXP in the absence of entanglement, ever since the introduction of the class MIP* it was open whether shared entanglement between the provers could weaken or strengthen the computational power of multi-prover interactive proofs. Our result shows that it does not weaken their computational power: MIP* contains MIP. At the heart of our result is a proof that Babai, Fort now, and Lund's multilinearity test is sound even in the presence of entanglement between the provers, and our analysis of this test could be of independent interest. As a byproduct we show that the correlations produced by any entangled strategy which succeeds in the multilinearity test with high probability can always be closely approximated using shared randomness alone.
Quantum computing is the study of what we can and cannot do with quantum computers: computers operating based on the laws of quantum mechanics. This thesis is a collection of seven papers, dealing with three aspects of quantum computing: non-locality, cryptography and complexity.
Nonlocality. Quantum nonlocality refers to the fact that, using a resource called quantum entanglement, two participants who are physically separated and unable to communicate can exhibit correlations that cannot be produced without entanglement. This gives rise to nonlocal games, which are multi-player cooperative games for which quantum players (who share entanglement) have an advantage over classical players (who share only classical information). A pseudo-telepathy game is a special case of a nonlocal game for which quantum players have a perfect winning strategy. The first paper in this thesis, On the power of non-local boxes, is a study of quantum correlations (which are non-signalling, i.e. they do not allow faster-than-light communication), as well as superquantum correlations (which are also non-signalling, but stronger than those predicted by quantum mechanics). We consider the simulation of pseudo-telepathy winning strategies with the nonlocal box (which can be seen as the most basic superquantum correlation), revealing that nonlocality and entanglement are different resources. Before our work, it was common to equate these two notions. The second paper, Classical, quantum and non-signalling resources in bipartite games, shows that the problem of deciding if a fixed game has a perfect classical winning strategy is NP-complete, while deciding if a perfect strategy exists with superquantum correlations is in P. We also establish links with the Bell-Kochen-Specker theorem, orthogonality graphs and two-prover interactive proofs.
Quantum nonlocality is a phenomenon that we can, in theory, witness in the laboratory. Many experiments have been performed, but none so far have simultaneously closed all experimental loopholes. There is currently a substantial scientific effort to achieve the perfect laboratory experiment. Yet not all experimental setups are created equally: the third and fourth paper of this thesis, Entanglement swapping, light cones and elements of reality and On the logical structure of Bell theorems, show that recent proposals have classical explanations, and thus do nothing to aid in our comprehension of the quantum world. This work is scientifically valuable, since it tells us that we should not invest in the proposed lines of research.
Classical and quantum cryptography. The groundbreaking work of Peter Shor in 1995 established that quantum computers can efficiently factor large integers, thus rendering most modern cryptographic systems insecure. But what quantum computers break, they also fix: Bennett and Brassard had already given in 1984 a protocol for key distribution whose security is based only on the laws of quantum mechanics.
In a world with quantum computers, it seems like the only way to ensure perfect security in cryptographic tasks is to do away with computational assumptions (such as the apparent difficulty of factoring): this is the realm of information-theoretic security. In the fifth paper of this thesis, Information-theoretic security without an honest majority we give protocols to accomplish a series of six private distributed tasks (in particular, vote and anonymous message transmission), while ensuring information-theoretic security. Then, in Anonymous quantum communication, we give a protocol which, within a group, allows a sender to transfer a quantum message to a receiver ofhis choosing. The protocol ensures information-theoretic anonymity for the sender and the receiver as well as information-theoretic privacy for the message.
Complexity in the measurement-based model. Finally, in Parallelizing quantum circuits, we study the depth complexity of quantum circuits, giving an automated technique for the parrallelization of quantum circuits. The development of parallel (low-depth) quantum circuits seems almost essential if we wish to implement quantum algorithms in the near future with available technology. Quantum information is usually unstable, hence we can only operate on it for a very short period of time. Parallel circuits maximize the use of this fragile quantum information. Our method is based on the recent paradigm for quantum computing called the measurement-based model.
Key words: quantum information processing, pseudo-telepathy, nonlocal boxes, Bell's theorem, multi-party computation, information-theoretic security, anonymity, quantum depth complexity, measurement-based quantum computing, measurement calculus.
A team of students has been given a challenging physics exam: find the ground energy of a complicated, n-spin system. Even if they succeed, how can the examiners be sure that their answer is correct without physically measuring all n spins of the ground state, or worse, having to read a description of the 2n components of its wavefunction? The main result of this thesis is a protocol such that, if the examiners are allowed to separately interrogate multiple students, they can be confident that the students possess the n-spin ground state as well as learn its energy to high precision, after exchanging just O(log(n)) bits of classical communication with the students! The protocol and its analysis combine classical computer science techniques for efficiently checking proofs with Bell inequalities. Stated more formally, the main result of this thesis is a multi-prover interactive proof protocol, in which a classical verifier exchanging only O(log(n)) bits of classical communication with 7 untrusted, entangled provers can certify that they share between them an encoding of an n-qubit quantum state Ib), and estimate its energy under a local Hamiltonian H to high (1/ poly(n)) precision. As a consequence, we show that, under poly-time randomized reductions, it is QMA-hard to estimate the entangled value of a nonlocal game up to constant error, proving the quantum entangled games PCP conjecture of Fitzsimons and Vidick. Our main technical innovations are two constructions of robust self-tests for entanglement: two-player nonlocal games where to succeed with probability E-close to 1, the players must share a state that is [delta] = poly([epsilon])-close in trace distance to n EPR pairs. These tests are robust in that [delta] is independent of the number n of EPR pairs being tested. Our techniques draw heavily on the original, "algebraic" proof of the PCP theorem in classical complexity theory, and in particular, each of our robust self-tests is based on a classical locally-testable error correcting code: the first on the Hadamard code and the associated linearity test of Blum, Luby, and Rubinfeld, and the second on Reed-Muller code and the associated low-degree test of Raz and Safra.
We study multiprover interactive proof systems. The power of classical multiprover interactive proof systems, in which the provers do not share entanglement, was characterized in a famous work by Babai, Fortnow, and Lund (Computational Complexity 1991), whose main result was the equality MIP = NEXP. The power of quantum multiprover interactive proof systems, in which the provers are allowed to share entanglement, has proven to be much more difficult to characterize. The best known lower-bound on MIP* is NEXP ⊆ MIP* due to Ito and Vidick (FOCS 2012). As for upper bounds, MIP* could be as large as RE, the class of recursively enumerable languages. The main result of this work is the inclusion NEEXP = NTIME[22poly(n)] ⊆ MIP*. This is an exponential improvement over the prior lower bound and shows that proof systems with entangled provers are at least exponentially more powerful than classical provers. In our protocol the verifier delegates a classical, exponentially large MIP protocol for NEEXP to two entangled provers: the provers obtain their exponentially large questions by measuring their shared state, and use a classical PCP to certify the correctness of their exponentially-long answers. For the soundness of our protocol, it is crucial that each player should not only sample its own question correctly but also avoid performing measurements that would reveal the other player's sampled question. We ensure this by commanding the players to perform a complementary measurement, relying on the Heisenberg uncertainty principle to prevent the forbidden measurements from being performed.
The field of quantum computing investigates the extent to which one can design a quantum system that outperforms all known classical hardware at a certain task.But, to what extent can a human being, capable only (perhaps) of classical computation and of observing classical bit-string messages, verify that a quantum device in their possession is performing the task that they wish?This is a fundamental question about the nature of quantum mechanics, and the extent to which humans can harness it in a trustworthy manner.It is also a natural and important consideration when quantum devices may be used to perform sensitive cryptographic tasks which have no known efficient classical witness of correctness (Quantum Key Distribution, and Randomness Expansion are two examples of such tasks).It is remarkable that any quantum behavior at all can be tested by a verifier under such a constraint, without trusting any other quantum mechanical device in the process!But, intriguingly, when there are two or more quantum provers available in an interactive proof, there exist protocols to verify many interesting and useful quantum tasks in this setting.This thesis investigates multi-prover interactive proofs for verifying quantum behavior, and focuses on the stringent testing scenario in which the verifier in the interactive proof is completely classical as described above.It resolves the question of the maximum attainable expansion rate of a randomness expansion protocol by providing an adaptive randomness expansion protocol that achieves an arbitrary, or infinite rate of randomness expansion [29].Secondly it presents a new rigidity result for the parallel repeated magic square game [24], which provides some improvements on previous rigidity results that play a pivotal role in existing interactive proofs for entangled provers, QKD, and randomness expansion results.This new rigidity result may be useful for improving such interactive proofs in the future.The second half of this thesis investigates the problem of bounding the role of quantum The further I go the more I value what my parents' example has taught me, not about science, but about life.I love you Mom and Dad.My deep gratitude goes to my advisor, Peter Shor, for guidance in research throughout graduate school, and for supporting my own research endeavors.During a PhD a student's mind is full of many different considerations, both scientific and logistical.Peter's advice is an invaluable way to refocus on the heart of the research problem at hand and, with stunning consistency, to learn something amazing and new.During my PhD I have had the privilege of collaborating with many talented researchers and good friends.What would the exploration process be without people share ideas with, and fellow researchers with which to share the thrill of discovery?Many thanks to my collaborators (listed here in no particular order)!I can only hope to continue to have such great collaborations again in the future: