Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Random Error Models in Quantum Error Correction

Matthew Coudron, C. A. Pasternak

Published Jan 1, 2013• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We examine the performance of quantum error correcting codes subjected to random Haar distribution transformations of weight t. Rather than requiring correction of all errors, we require some high probability that a random error is corrected. We find that, for any integer i and arbitrarily high probability p < 1, there are codes which perfectly correct errors up to weight t and can correct errors up to weight t + i with probability at least p. We also find an analog to the quantum Hamming bound for the new error model. Lastly, we prove that codes generated from classical Reed-Muller codes can correct errors of weight up to 3d/4 with a probability approaching 1 as the length of the code increases, whereas they can only correct up to weight d/2 perfectly.

Related papers

Haar random codes attain the quantum Hamming bound, approximately

Fermi Ma, Xinyu Tan, John Wright

We study the error correcting properties of Haar random codes, in which a $K$-dimensional code space $\boldsymbol{C} \subseteq \mathbb{C}^N$ is chosen at random from the Haar distribution. Our main result is that Haar random codes can approximately correct errors up to the quantum Hamming bound, meaning that a set of $m$ Pauli errors can be approximately corrected so long as $mK \ll N$. This is the strongest bound known for any family of quantum error correcting codes (QECs), and continues a line of work showing that approximate QECs can significantly outperform exact QECs [LNCY97, CGS05, BGG24]. Our proof relies on a recent matrix concentration result of Bandeira, Boedihardjo, and van Handel.

arXiv:2510.07158•Oct 8, 2025•9 citations

Spectral Properties and Coding Transitions of Haar-Random Quantum Codes

Grace M. Sommers, J. Alexander Jacoby, Zack Weinstein +2 more

A quantum error-correcting code with a nonzero error threshold undergoes a mixed-state phase transition when the error rate reaches that threshold. We explore this phase transition for Haar-random quantum codes, in which the logical information is encoded in a random subspace of the physical Hilbert space. We focus on the spectrum of the encoded system density matrix as a function of the rate of uncorrelated, single-qudit errors. For low error rates, this spectrum consists of well-separated bands, representing errors of different weights. As the error rate increases, the bands for high-weight errors merge. The evolution of these bands with increasing error rate is well described by a simple analytic ansatz. Using this ansatz, as well as an explicit calculation, we show that the threshold for Haar-random quantum codes saturates the hashing bound, and thus coincides with that for random codes. For error rates that exceed the hashing bound, typical errors are uncorrectable, but postselected error correction remains possible until a much higher threshold. Postselection can in principle be implemented by projecting onto subspaces corresponding to low-weight errors, which remain correctable past the hashing bound.

arXiv:2510.07396•PRX Quantum•Apr 3, 2026•3 citations

Weight distribution of low-density periodic random errors and their correcting codes with error decoding probability

Letminthang Haokip, Pankaj Kumar Das

We present weight distribution of low-density periodic random errors in the space of all q-ary n-tuples along with the average Hamming weight of the error set. We also provide necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of linear codes correcting such error pattern. Examples of such codes are given. Finally, probability of decoding error of such codes over a binary symmetric channel is derived.

PRIKLADNAYa DISKRETNAYa MATEMATIKA•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

Trade-off between the tolerance of located and unlocated errors in nondegenrate quantum

Henry L. Haselgrove, Peter P. Rohde

In a recent study [Rohde et al., quant-ph/0603130 (2006)] of several quantum error correcting protocols designed for tolerance against qubit loss, it was shown that these protocols have the undesirable effect of magnifying the effects of depolarization noise. This raises the question of which general properties of quantum error-correcting codes might explain such an apparent trade-off between tolerance to located and unlocated error types. We extend the counting argument behind the well-known quantum Hamming bound to derive a bound on the weights of combinations of located and unlocated errors which are correctable by nondegenerate quantum codes. Numerical results show that the bound gives an excellent prediction to which combinations of unlocated and located errors can be corrected {\em with high probability} by certain large degenerate codes. The numerical results are explained partly by showing that the generalized bound, like the original, is closely connected to the information-theoretic quantity the {\em quantum coherent information}. However, we also show that as a measure of the exact performance of quantum codes, our generalized Hamming bound is provably far from tight.

arXiv:quant-ph/0605183•Quantum Information and Computation•May 1, 2008•6 citations

The Art of Error Correcting Coding

Robert H. Morelos-Zaragoza

Preface. Foreword. The ECC web site. 1. Introduction. 1.1 Error correcting coding: Basic concepts. 1.1.1 Block codes and convolutional codes. 1.1.2 Hamming distance, Hamming spheres and error correcting capability. 1.2 Linear block codes. 1.2.1 Generator and parity-check matrices. 1.2.2 The weight is the distance. 1.3 Encoding and decoding of linear block codes. 1.3.1 Encoding with G and H. 1.3.2 Standard array decoding. 1.3.3 Hamming spheres, decoding regions and the standard array. 1.4 Weight distribution and error performance. 1.4.1 Weight distribution and undetected error probability over a BSC. 1.4.2 Performance bounds over BSC, AWGN and fading channels. 1.5 General structure of a hard-decision decoder of linear codes. Problems. 2. Hamming, Golay and Reed-Muller codes. 2.1 Hamming codes. 2.1.1 Encoding and decoding procedures. 2.2 The binary Golay code. 2.2.1 Encoding. 2.2.2 Decoding. 2.2.3 Arithmetic decoding of the extended (24, 12, 8) Golay code. 2.3 Binary Reed-Muller codes. 2.3.1 Boolean polynomials and RM codes. 2.3.2 Finite geometries and majority-logic decoding. Problems. 3. Binary cyclic codes and BCH codes. 3.1 Binary cyclic codes. 3.1.1 Generator and parity-check polynomials. 3.1.2 The generator polynomial. 3.1.3 Encoding and decoding of binary cyclic codes. 3.1.4 The parity-check polynomial. 3.1.5 Shortened cyclic codes and CRC codes. 3.1.6 Fire codes. 3.2 General decoding of cyclic codes. 3.2.1 GF(2m) arithmetic. 3.3 Binary BCH codes. 3.3.1 BCH bound. 3.4 Polynomial codes. 3.5 Decoding of binary BCH codes. 3.5.1 General decoding algorithm for BCH codes. 3.5.2 The Berlekamp-Massey algorithm (BMA). 3.5.3 PGZ decoder. 3.5.4 Euclidean algorithm. 3.5.5 Chien search and error correction. 3.5.6 Errors-and-erasures decoding. 3.6 Weight distribution and performance bounds. 3.6.1 Error performance evaluation. Problems. 4. Nonbinary BCH codes: Reed-Solomon codes. 4.1 RS codes as polynomial codes. 4.2 From binary BCH to RS codes. 4.3 Decoding RS codes. 4.3.1 Remarks on decoding algorithms. 4.3.2 Errors-and-erasures decoding. 4.4 Weight distribution. Problems. 5. Binary convolutional codes. 5.1 Basic structure. 5.1.1 Recursive systematic convolutional codes. 5.1.2 Free distance. 5.2 Connections with block codes. 5.2.1 Zero-tail construction. 5.2.2 Direct-truncation construction. 5.2.3 Tail-biting construction. 5.2.4 Weight distributions. 5.3 Weight enumeration. 5.4 Performance bounds. 5.5 Decoding: Viterbi algorithm with Hamming metrics. 5.5.1 Maximum-likelihood decoding and metrics. 5.5.2 The Viterbi algorithm. 5.5.3 Implementation issues. 5.6 Punctured convolutional codes. 5.6.1 Implementation issues related to punctured convolutional codes. 5.6.2 RCPC codes. Problems. 6. Modifying and combining codes. 6.1 Modifying codes. 6.1.1 Shortening. 6.1.2 Extending. 6.1.3 Puncturing. 6.1.4 Augmenting, expurgating and lengthening. 6.2 Combining codes. 6.2.1 Time sharing of codes. 6.2.2 Direct sums of codes. 6.2.3 The |u|u + v|-construction and related techniques. 6.2.4 Products of codes. 6.2.5 Concatenated codes. 6.2.6 Generalized concatenated codes. 7. Soft-decision decoding. 7.1 Binary transmission over AWGN channels. 7.2 Viterbi algorithm with Euclidean metric. 7.3 Decoding binary linear block codes with a trellis. 7.4 The Chase algorithm. 7.5 Ordered statistics decoding. 7.6 Generalized minimum distance decoding. 7.6.1 Sufficient conditions for optimality. 7.7 List decoding. 7.8 Soft-output algorithms. 7.8.1 Soft-output Viterbi algorithm. 7.8.2 Maximum-a posteriori (MAP) algorithm. 7.8.3 Log-MAP algorithm. 7.8.4 Max-Log-MAP algorithm. 7.8.5 Soft-output OSD algorithm. Problems. 8. Iteratively decodable codes. 8.1 Iterative decoding. 8.2 Product codes. 8.2.1 Parallel concatenation: Turbo codes. 8.2.2 Serial concatenation. 8.2.3 Block product codes. 8.3 Low-density parity-check codes. 8.3.1 Tanner graphs. 8.3.2 Iterative hard-decision decoding: The bit-flip algorithm. 8.3.3 Iterative probabilistic decoding: Belief propagation. Problems. 9. Combining codes and digital modulation. 9.1 Motivation. 9.1.1 Examples of signal sets. 9.1.2 Coded modulation. 9.1.3 Distance considerations. 9.2 Trellis-coded modulation (TCM). 9.2.1 Set partitioning and trellis mapping. 9.2.2 Maximum-likelihood. 9.2.3 Distance considerations and error performance. 9.2.4 Pragmatic TCM and two-stage decoding. 9.3 Multilevel coded modulation. 9.3.1 Constructions and multistage decoding. 9.3.2 Unequal error protection with MCM. 9.4 Bit-interleaved coded modulation. 9.4.1 Gray mapping. 9.4.2 Metric generation: De-mapping. 9.4.3 Interleaving. 9.5 Turbo trellis-coded modulation. 9.5.1 Pragmatic turbo TCM. 9.5.2 Turbo TCM with symbol interleaving. 9.5.3 Turbo TCM with bit interleaving. Problems. Appendix A: Weight distributions of extended BCH codes. A.1 Length 8. A.2 Length 16. A.3 Length 32. A.4 Length 64. A.5 Length 128. Bibliography. Index.

Wiley eBooks•Mar 11, 2002•377 citations

Approximate quantum error correction, random codes, and quantum channel capacity

Rochus Klesse

We work out a theory of approximate quantum error correction that allows us to derive a general lower bound for the entanglement fidelity of a quantum code. The lower bound is given in terms of Kraus operators of the quantum noise. This result is then used to analyze the average error correcting performance of codes that are randomly drawn from unitarily invariant code ensembles. Our results confirm that random codes of sufficiently large block size are highly suitable for quantum error correction. Moreover, employing a lemma of Bennett, Shor, Smolin, and Thapliyal, we prove that random coding attains information rates of the regularized coherent information.

arXiv:quant-ph/0701102•Physical Review A•Jun 13, 2007•43 citations
We examine the performance of quantum error correcting codes subjected to random Haar distribution transformations of weight t. Rather than requiring correction of all errors, we require some high probability that a random error is corrected. We find that, for any integer i and arbitrarily high probability p < 1, there are codes which perfectly correct errors up to weight t and can correct errors up to weight t + i with probability at least p. We also find an analog to the quantum Hamming bound for the new error model. Lastly, we prove that codes generated from classical Reed-Muller codes can correct errors of weight up to 3d/4 with a probability approaching 1 as the length of the code increases, whereas they can only correct up to weight d/2 perfectly.
We study the error correcting properties of Haar random codes, in which a KKK-dimensional code space C⊆CN\boldsymbol{C} \subseteq \mathbb{C}^NC⊆CN is chosen at random from the Haar distribution. Our main result is that Haar random codes can approximately correct errors up to the quantum Hamming bound, meaning that a set of mmm Pauli errors can be approximately corrected so long as mK≪NmK \ll NmK≪N. This is the strongest bound known for any family of quantum error correcting codes (QECs), and continues a line of work showing that approximate QECs can significantly outperform exact QECs [LNCY97, CGS05, BGG24]. Our proof relies on a recent matrix concentration result of Bandeira, Boedihardjo, and van Handel.
A quantum error-correcting code with a nonzero error threshold undergoes a mixed-state phase transition when the error rate reaches that threshold. We explore this phase transition for Haar-random quantum codes, in which the logical information is encoded in a random subspace of the physical Hilbert space. We focus on the spectrum of the encoded system density matrix as a function of the rate of uncorrelated, single-qudit errors. For low error rates, this spectrum consists of well-separated bands, representing errors of different weights. As the error rate increases, the bands for high-weight errors merge. The evolution of these bands with increasing error rate is well described by a simple analytic ansatz. Using this ansatz, as well as an explicit calculation, we show that the threshold for Haar-random quantum codes saturates the hashing bound, and thus coincides with that for random codes. For error rates that exceed the hashing bound, typical errors are uncorrectable, but postselected error correction remains possible until a much higher threshold. Postselection can in principle be implemented by projecting onto subspaces corresponding to low-weight errors, which remain correctable past the hashing bound.
In a recent study [Rohde et al., quant-ph/0603130 (2006)] of several quantum error correcting protocols designed for tolerance against qubit loss, it was shown that these protocols have the undesirable effect of magnifying the effects of depolarization noise. This raises the question of which general properties of quantum error-correcting codes might explain such an apparent trade-off between tolerance to located and unlocated error types. We extend the counting argument behind the well-known quantum Hamming bound to derive a bound on the weights of combinations of located and unlocated errors which are correctable by nondegenerate quantum codes. Numerical results show that the bound gives an excellent prediction to which combinations of unlocated and located errors can be corrected {\em with high probability} by certain large degenerate codes. The numerical results are explained partly by showing that the generalized bound, like the original, is closely connected to the information-theoretic quantity the {\em quantum coherent information}. However, we also show that as a measure of the exact performance of quantum codes, our generalized Hamming bound is provably far from tight.
Preface. Foreword. The ECC web site. 1. Introduction. 1.1 Error correcting coding: Basic concepts. 1.1.1 Block codes and convolutional codes. 1.1.2 Hamming distance, Hamming spheres and error correcting capability. 1.2 Linear block codes. 1.2.1 Generator and parity-check matrices. 1.2.2 The weight is the distance. 1.3 Encoding and decoding of linear block codes. 1.3.1 Encoding with G and H. 1.3.2 Standard array decoding. 1.3.3 Hamming spheres, decoding regions and the standard array. 1.4 Weight distribution and error performance. 1.4.1 Weight distribution and undetected error probability over a BSC. 1.4.2 Performance bounds over BSC, AWGN and fading channels. 1.5 General structure of a hard-decision decoder of linear codes. Problems. 2. Hamming, Golay and Reed-Muller codes. 2.1 Hamming codes. 2.1.1 Encoding and decoding procedures. 2.2 The binary Golay code. 2.2.1 Encoding. 2.2.2 Decoding. 2.2.3 Arithmetic decoding of the extended (24, 12, 8) Golay code. 2.3 Binary Reed-Muller codes. 2.3.1 Boolean polynomials and RM codes. 2.3.2 Finite geometries and majority-logic decoding. Problems. 3. Binary cyclic codes and BCH codes. 3.1 Binary cyclic codes. 3.1.1 Generator and parity-check polynomials. 3.1.2 The generator polynomial. 3.1.3 Encoding and decoding of binary cyclic codes. 3.1.4 The parity-check polynomial. 3.1.5 Shortened cyclic codes and CRC codes. 3.1.6 Fire codes. 3.2 General decoding of cyclic codes. 3.2.1 GF(2m) arithmetic. 3.3 Binary BCH codes. 3.3.1 BCH bound. 3.4 Polynomial codes. 3.5 Decoding of binary BCH codes. 3.5.1 General decoding algorithm for BCH codes. 3.5.2 The Berlekamp-Massey algorithm (BMA). 3.5.3 PGZ decoder. 3.5.4 Euclidean algorithm. 3.5.5 Chien search and error correction. 3.5.6 Errors-and-erasures decoding. 3.6 Weight distribution and performance bounds. 3.6.1 Error performance evaluation. Problems. 4. Nonbinary BCH codes: Reed-Solomon codes. 4.1 RS codes as polynomial codes. 4.2 From binary BCH to RS codes. 4.3 Decoding RS codes. 4.3.1 Remarks on decoding algorithms. 4.3.2 Errors-and-erasures decoding. 4.4 Weight distribution. Problems. 5. Binary convolutional codes. 5.1 Basic structure. 5.1.1 Recursive systematic convolutional codes. 5.1.2 Free distance. 5.2 Connections with block codes. 5.2.1 Zero-tail construction. 5.2.2 Direct-truncation construction. 5.2.3 Tail-biting construction. 5.2.4 Weight distributions. 5.3 Weight enumeration. 5.4 Performance bounds. 5.5 Decoding: Viterbi algorithm with Hamming metrics. 5.5.1 Maximum-likelihood decoding and metrics. 5.5.2 The Viterbi algorithm. 5.5.3 Implementation issues. 5.6 Punctured convolutional codes. 5.6.1 Implementation issues related to punctured convolutional codes. 5.6.2 RCPC codes. Problems. 6. Modifying and combining codes. 6.1 Modifying codes. 6.1.1 Shortening. 6.1.2 Extending. 6.1.3 Puncturing. 6.1.4 Augmenting, expurgating and lengthening. 6.2 Combining codes. 6.2.1 Time sharing of codes. 6.2.2 Direct sums of codes. 6.2.3 The |u|u + v|-construction and related techniques. 6.2.4 Products of codes. 6.2.5 Concatenated codes. 6.2.6 Generalized concatenated codes. 7. Soft-decision decoding. 7.1 Binary transmission over AWGN channels. 7.2 Viterbi algorithm with Euclidean metric. 7.3 Decoding binary linear block codes with a trellis. 7.4 The Chase algorithm. 7.5 Ordered statistics decoding. 7.6 Generalized minimum distance decoding. 7.6.1 Sufficient conditions for optimality. 7.7 List decoding. 7.8 Soft-output algorithms. 7.8.1 Soft-output Viterbi algorithm. 7.8.2 Maximum-a posteriori (MAP) algorithm. 7.8.3 Log-MAP algorithm. 7.8.4 Max-Log-MAP algorithm. 7.8.5 Soft-output OSD algorithm. Problems. 8. Iteratively decodable codes. 8.1 Iterative decoding. 8.2 Product codes. 8.2.1 Parallel concatenation: Turbo codes. 8.2.2 Serial concatenation. 8.2.3 Block product codes. 8.3 Low-density parity-check codes. 8.3.1 Tanner graphs. 8.3.2 Iterative hard-decision decoding: The bit-flip algorithm. 8.3.3 Iterative probabilistic decoding: Belief propagation. Problems. 9. Combining codes and digital modulation. 9.1 Motivation. 9.1.1 Examples of signal sets. 9.1.2 Coded modulation. 9.1.3 Distance considerations. 9.2 Trellis-coded modulation (TCM). 9.2.1 Set partitioning and trellis mapping. 9.2.2 Maximum-likelihood. 9.2.3 Distance considerations and error performance. 9.2.4 Pragmatic TCM and two-stage decoding. 9.3 Multilevel coded modulation. 9.3.1 Constructions and multistage decoding. 9.3.2 Unequal error protection with MCM. 9.4 Bit-interleaved coded modulation. 9.4.1 Gray mapping. 9.4.2 Metric generation: De-mapping. 9.4.3 Interleaving. 9.5 Turbo trellis-coded modulation. 9.5.1 Pragmatic turbo TCM. 9.5.2 Turbo TCM with symbol interleaving. 9.5.3 Turbo TCM with bit interleaving. Problems. Appendix A: Weight distributions of extended BCH codes. A.1 Length 8. A.2 Length 16. A.3 Length 32. A.4 Length 64. A.5 Length 128. Bibliography. Index.
We work out a theory of approximate quantum error correction that allows us to derive a general lower bound for the entanglement fidelity of a quantum code. The lower bound is given in terms of Kraus operators of the quantum noise. This result is then used to analyze the average error correcting performance of codes that are randomly drawn from unitarily invariant code ensembles. Our results confirm that random codes of sufficiently large block size are highly suitable for quantum error correction. Moreover, employing a lemma of Bennett, Shor, Smolin, and Thapliyal, we prove that random coding attains information rates of the regularized coherent information.