Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

On a Proposal for Quantum Signalling

Padmanabhan Murali

Published Nov 1, 2015• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Present understanding of non-possibility of Quantum communication rests on analysis of possibility of signalling within a Quantum system. Is it possible to achieve signalling by a setup where the system is changed from one to another where the act of change serves as the signal and the change in the measurement probabilities would be detected and deciphered at the receiver end? A proposal is made where a variant of Delayed Choice Quantum Eraser experiment setup of Kim et al is used to achieve the same. The setup is also designed such that the speed of communication can be faster than light. NonLocality and Quantum communication Nonlocality is a feature of Quantum Mechanics that has been firmly established through experiments [Aspect et al, 1981] and well accepted now. Entangled particles separated by a distance still are part of one entity and when that entity changes state by a measurement in one part of it the change happens instantaneously across the domain the entity pervades. Is it possible to use this instantaneous state change to transmit information across at high speeds, faster than light (FTL)? This issue has been dealt with from the time the Einstein raised the EPR paradox [Einstein et al,1935] and has been claimed to be impossible and shown to be so by Peres, [Peres and Tenko, 2004] through the no-communication theorem which shows that any amount of signalling by Alice through measurements done at one end of the quantum system would not be sufficient for Bob to detect and decipher at the other end of the system. However the discussions in literature (as above) always deal with information transfer within a stable quantum system by making measurements at one end and analysing the possibility of detecting it at the other end. Peres and Tenko analyse a Quantum System S of mixed-state where Alice and Bob make measurements at their ends of the system. The authors derive the probability that Bob’s outcome is ν as

Related papers

Clocking the signal of entanglement

It is the tenet of quantum mechanics that Einstein rejected as “spooky action at a distance”: if two particles are entangled, then any tinkering with one can cause an instantaneous change in the other – no matter how far apart they may be. But what if quantum mechanics is not quite right – that the change is not instantaneous but instead prompted by a signal transmitted between the two entangled particles? Now an experiment in Switzerland has shown that if such a signal does exist, then it would have to travel at least at the speed of light, and probably thousands of times faster.

Physics World•Sep 1, 2008•0 citations

Is Faster-Than-Light Communication Possible?

Raymond W. Jensen

It is shown here using elementary quantum mechanics that a method exists for transmitting signals faster than the speed of light. The method relies on measurement of the uncertainty of momentum for one photon of each pair. The uncertainty is affected by whether momentum or position is measured for the partners, due to Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. For each pair the effect is instantaneous; so if the measurement of momentum uncertainty, done on one end, is distant from the momentum/position measurement switching done on the other end, then such behavior can be utilized for faster‐than‐light signaling.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2006•2 citations

Is Faster-Than-Light Communication Possible?

Raymond W. Jensen

Abstract. It is shown here using elementary quantum mechanics that a method exists for transmitting signals faster than the speed of light. The method relies on measurement of the uncertainty of momentum for one photon of each pair. The uncertainty is affected by whether momentum or position is measured for the partners, due to Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. For each pair the effect is instantaneous; so if the measurement of momentum uncertainty, done on one end, is distant from the momentum/position measurement switching done on the other end, then such behavior can be utilized for faster-than-light signaling.

•Mar 1, 2011•0 citations

Anomalous nonlocality of information masked in quantum correlations

Guang Ping He

Although information, strictly speaking, is not a physical entity, it generally requires physical entities as its carriers, e.g., writing it down on paper, encoding it with quantum particles, or transmitting it using electro-magnetic fields. And it seems natural that these carriers cannot travel faster than light. Here we reveal that if we use quantum correlations as the carrier of information (either quantum or classical), then it can display a kind of nonlocality, which bears both similarities to and distinctions from the nonlocality of physical particles. Notably, though superluminal signaling is still not allowed so that the special relativity is not violated, it is possible to select at our will whether to decode the information at one location, or to dispatch it to another location far away (i.e., to give up the chance of decoding the information and let it be decodable in somewhere else only) without needing the assistance of classical information, so that it occurs instantaneously without being limited by the speed of light. This phenomenon differs sharply from the nonlocality of physical particles that we once knew, where whether a particle can be detected in one location or another is governed by quantum uncertainty, which cannot be chosen freely.

quant-pharXiv:2604.16951•Apr 21, 2026•1 citation

The Bell-EPR Family of Experiments: A Fallacy at Best - A Sleight of Hand at Worst?

Sagar Kapadia

The Bell/EPR experiments are widely interpreted as supporting the no-signaling theorem inquantum entanglement by utilizing detector settings adjusted faster than light-travel timeto test locality [Aspect et al., 1982, Giustina et al., 2015]. This family of experiments, however, reveals a critical conceptual oversight: it presupposes faster-than-light (FTL) influencesas finite-speed propagation processes, rather than considering instantaneous state updatesinherent to non-local correlations as proposed in early quantum interpretations [Einsteinet al., 1935]. This assumption renders the timing of detector switches irrelevant, as entangled state correlations are established instantaneously upon state preparation. This paperelucidates this oversight, demonstrating that these experiments do not conclusively ruleout instantaneous transmission of information under all interpretations, thereby challengingtheir standard conclusions. We propose that new discrete-state experiments be designed tospecifically test for instantaneous state updates, advancing our understanding of quantumnon-locality

•Sep 27, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Interpretation of Faster Than Light Communication Via Entanglement Property of Two Particles

Mark Timothy Sheldrick

It is possible to use two particles (A and B) with entangled properties to transmit information at faster than light speeds. This can be done, not by trying to modulate the results of how particle A is measured, but by modulating whether particle A is measured or not measured. The effect of this modulating method is to place particle B in either a single value (but arbitrary) state or leave it in a superposition of states. It is then possible for the reciever of particle B to distinguish between these two states by the use of an appropriately designed interferometer. Such a device can be designed to produce an interference pattern only when particle B is in a superposition of values and a straight simple image when particle B has a single (arbitrary) defined value. Under the Copenhagen interpretation and existing experimental results, this method will produce a way of signalling fater than light. It will require the use of multiple entangled pairs of particles to effectively transmit a single bit of information. Under the Multi-Worlds Interpretation, it will not be so easy to communicate faster than light by this mechanism, as detector B will be detecting photon B as a superposition of values in both cases.

•Aug 1, 2014•0 citations
Present understanding of non-possibility of Quantum communication rests on analysis of possibility of signalling within a Quantum system. Is it possible to achieve signalling by a setup where the system is changed from one to another where the act of change serves as the signal and the change in the measurement probabilities would be detected and deciphered at the receiver end? A proposal is made where a variant of Delayed Choice Quantum Eraser experiment setup of Kim et al is used to achieve the same. The setup is also designed such that the speed of communication can be faster than light. NonLocality and Quantum communication Nonlocality is a feature of Quantum Mechanics that has been firmly established through experiments [Aspect et al, 1981] and well accepted now. Entangled particles separated by a distance still are part of one entity and when that entity changes state by a measurement in one part of it the change happens instantaneously across the domain the entity pervades. Is it possible to use this instantaneous state change to transmit information across at high speeds, faster than light (FTL)? This issue has been dealt with from the time the Einstein raised the EPR paradox [Einstein et al,1935] and has been claimed to be impossible and shown to be so by Peres, [Peres and Tenko, 2004] through the no-communication theorem which shows that any amount of signalling by Alice through measurements done at one end of the quantum system would not be sufficient for Bob to detect and decipher at the other end of the system. However the discussions in literature (as above) always deal with information transfer within a stable quantum system by making measurements at one end and analysing the possibility of detecting it at the other end. Peres and Tenko analyse a Quantum System S of mixed-state where Alice and Bob make measurements at their ends of the system. The authors derive the probability that Bob’s outcome is ν as
It is the tenet of quantum mechanics that Einstein rejected as “spooky action at a distance”: if two particles are entangled, then any tinkering with one can cause an instantaneous change in the other – no matter how far apart they may be. But what if quantum mechanics is not quite right – that the change is not instantaneous but instead prompted by a signal transmitted between the two entangled particles? Now an experiment in Switzerland has shown that if such a signal does exist, then it would have to travel at least at the speed of light, and probably thousands of times faster.
It is shown here using elementary quantum mechanics that a method exists for transmitting signals faster than the speed of light. The method relies on measurement of the uncertainty of momentum for one photon of each pair. The uncertainty is affected by whether momentum or position is measured for the partners, due to Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. For each pair the effect is instantaneous; so if the measurement of momentum uncertainty, done on one end, is distant from the momentum/position measurement switching done on the other end, then such behavior can be utilized for faster‐than‐light signaling.
Abstract. It is shown here using elementary quantum mechanics that a method exists for transmitting signals faster than the speed of light. The method relies on measurement of the uncertainty of momentum for one photon of each pair. The uncertainty is affected by whether momentum or position is measured for the partners, due to Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. For each pair the effect is instantaneous; so if the measurement of momentum uncertainty, done on one end, is distant from the momentum/position measurement switching done on the other end, then such behavior can be utilized for faster-than-light signaling.
Although information, strictly speaking, is not a physical entity, it generally requires physical entities as its carriers, e.g., writing it down on paper, encoding it with quantum particles, or transmitting it using electro-magnetic fields. And it seems natural that these carriers cannot travel faster than light. Here we reveal that if we use quantum correlations as the carrier of information (either quantum or classical), then it can display a kind of nonlocality, which bears both similarities to and distinctions from the nonlocality of physical particles. Notably, though superluminal signaling is still not allowed so that the special relativity is not violated, it is possible to select at our will whether to decode the information at one location, or to dispatch it to another location far away (i.e., to give up the chance of decoding the information and let it be decodable in somewhere else only) without needing the assistance of classical information, so that it occurs instantaneously without being limited by the speed of light. This phenomenon differs sharply from the nonlocality of physical particles that we once knew, where whether a particle can be detected in one location or another is governed by quantum uncertainty, which cannot be chosen freely.
The Bell/EPR experiments are widely interpreted as supporting the no-signaling theorem inquantum entanglement by utilizing detector settings adjusted faster than light-travel timeto test locality [Aspect et al., 1982, Giustina et al., 2015]. This family of experiments, however, reveals a critical conceptual oversight: it presupposes faster-than-light (FTL) influencesas finite-speed propagation processes, rather than considering instantaneous state updatesinherent to non-local correlations as proposed in early quantum interpretations [Einsteinet al., 1935]. This assumption renders the timing of detector switches irrelevant, as entangled state correlations are established instantaneously upon state preparation. This paperelucidates this oversight, demonstrating that these experiments do not conclusively ruleout instantaneous transmission of information under all interpretations, thereby challengingtheir standard conclusions. We propose that new discrete-state experiments be designed tospecifically test for instantaneous state updates, advancing our understanding of quantumnon-locality
It is possible to use two particles (A and B) with entangled properties to transmit information at faster than light speeds. This can be done, not by trying to modulate the results of how particle A is measured, but by modulating whether particle A is measured or not measured. The effect of this modulating method is to place particle B in either a single value (but arbitrary) state or leave it in a superposition of states. It is then possible for the reciever of particle B to distinguish between these two states by the use of an appropriately designed interferometer. Such a device can be designed to produce an interference pattern only when particle B is in a superposition of values and a straight simple image when particle B has a single (arbitrary) defined value. Under the Copenhagen interpretation and existing experimental results, this method will produce a way of signalling fater than light. It will require the use of multiple entangled pairs of particles to effectively transmit a single bit of information. Under the Multi-Worlds Interpretation, it will not be so easy to communicate faster than light by this mechanism, as detector B will be detecting photon B as a superposition of values in both cases.