In this chapter we shall show that some simple results about correlations turn out to have very profound and puzzling consequences about the nature of the world, as it is described by quantum mechanics. Certain ideas that seem natural, and indeed almost inevitable, from the point of view of special relativity have consequences that are contradicted by quantum mechanics. The starting point of the investigation was an argument by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen in 1935, but it was not pursued until 30 years later, by J. S. Bell, who obtained much more significant results that had not been anticipated in any previous work. Bell's work has led to an interesting series of experiments, which have confirmed the numerical correctness of the predictions of QM, but have not made the implications of the results seem any less strange.
In this chapter we shall show that some simple results about correlations turn out to have very profound and puzzling consequences about the nature of the world, as it is described by quantum mechanics. Certain ideas that seem natural, and indeed almost inevitable, from the point of view of special relativity have consequences that are contradicted by quantum mechanics. The starting point of the investigation was an argument by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen in 1935, but it was not pursued until 30 years later, by J. S. Bell, who obtained much more significant results that had not been anticipated in any previous work. Bell’s work has led to an interesting series of experiments, which have confirmed the numerical correctness of the predictions of QM, but have not made the implications of the results seem any less strange.
The Bell theorem can take the form of several inequalities, as we have seen in §4.2. Moreover, since it was discovered, the theorem has stimulated the discovery of several other mathematical contradictions between the predictions of quantum mechanics and those of local realism. We review a few of them in this chapter: GHZ contradictions (§5.1) and their generalization (§5.2), Cabello's inequality (§5.3), and Hardy's impossibilities (§5.4). Finally, in §5.5, we discuss the notion of contextuality and introduce the BKS theorem. GHZ contradiction For many years, everyone thought that Bell had basically exhausted the subject by considering all really interesting situations, and that two-spin systems provided the most spectacular quantum violations of local realism. It therefore came as a surprise to many when in 1989 Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger (GHZ) showed that systems containing more than two correlated particles may actually exhibit even more dramatic violations of local realism [188, 189]. They involve a sign contradiction (100% violation) for perfect correlations, while the BCHSH inequalities are violated by about 40% (Cirelson bound) and deal with situations where the results of measurements are not completely correlated. In this section, we discuss three-particle systems, but generalizations to N particles are possible (§5.2). Derivation GHZ contradictions may occur in various systems, not necessarily involving spins. Initially, they were introduced in the context of entanglement swapping (§6.3.2) for four particles [188] or entanglement of three spinless particles [189].