Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Il Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. B/Il Nuovo cimento B

Indistinguishability of particles and complementarity in statistical thermodynamics

D. Neri

Published Jun 1, 1987• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/bf02726578

Related papers

Statistical Equivalence and Particle Indistinguishability

Bernard H. Lavenda

Physics Essays•Jun 1, 1992•0 citations

On the relation between thermodynamical and statistical entropy: The origin of the N!

S. Di Matteo

The division by N! in the expression of statistical entropy is usually justified to students by the statement that classical particles should be counted as indistinguishable. Sometimes, quantum indistinguishability is invoked to explain it. In this paper, we try to clarify the issue starting from Clausius thermodynamical entropy and deriving from it Boltzmann statistical entropy for the ideal gas. This approach appears interesting for two reasons: Firstly, it provides a direct heuristic link between thermodynamical and statistical expressions of entropy that is missing in the usual approach. In second place, it explicitly reminds that also statistical entropy is defined with respect to a reference state, chosen to be the quantum-mechanical (T=0) ground state of the N-particles in a box. Both factors $h^{3N}$ and $N!$ at the denominator of the statistical entropy are a consequence of the quantum nature of the reference state: in particular, the $N!$ is not related to the particle identity, but to the identity of the boundary conditions on the quantum-mechanical ground-state momenta, and to a general statistical maximization principle. The introduction of a reference state also allows to reinterpret the standard case of two mixing gases.

arXiv:2305.13513•May 22, 2023•0 citations

Colloquium: Quantum information processing with ensembles of identical particles

Matteo Piccolini, Marcin Karczewski, Jin-Shi Xu +5 more

Identical particles underpin most quantum technologies, but the role of indistinguishability in these processes extends far beyond the symmetrization of many-particle states. This Colloquium presents a unified operational perspective on how particle identity, indistinguishability, exchange statistics, and many-particle interference can instead be harnessed as resources for quantum information processing. We first clarify the notions of entanglement and indistinguishability for identical particles, emphasizing their dependence on the accessible measurements and information. We then review how spatial overlap, multiparticle interference, and path identity enable the generation, extraction, protection, and distillation of coherence and entanglement. Their applications to quantum metrology and imaging, state discrimination, teleportation, entanglement swapping, and quantum cloning are examined. Finally, we discuss the thermodynamic role of indistinguishability, from the Gibbs paradox to quantum thermal machines and statistics-driven engines. Across these settings, indistinguishability emerges as a controllable, task-dependent resource whose benefits are determined by state preparation, exchange statistics, interference, and measurement constraints.

quant-pharXiv:2610.40852•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

Principles of classical statistical mechanics: A perspective from the notion of complementarity

L. Velázquez

arXiv:1203.1479•Annals of Physics•Mar 17, 2012•23 citations

Comment on “The Gibbs paradox and the distinguishability of identical particles,” by M. A. M. Versteegh and D. Dieks [Am. J. Phys. 79, 741–746 (2011)]

David S. Corti

We revisit recent discussions concerning the Gibbs paradox—the apparent discrepancy between the entropy change upon mixing identical gases as evaluated from the statistical mechanics of classical distinguishable particles and macroscopic thermodynamics. Contrary to what is often stated, we show that thermodynamics does not require this entropy of mixing to be zero. A zero value follows from the implicit assumption that the identical gas particles are indistinguishable. If the identical particles are explicitly assumed to be distinguishable, thermodynamics yields the same entropy of mixing as classical statistical mechanics.

American Journal of Physics•Jan 20, 2012•7 citations

Bosonic statistics enhance Maxwell's demon in photonic experiment

Malaquias Correa Anguita, Sara Marzban, William F. Braasch +4 more

Maxwell's demon elucidates the value of information in thermodynamics, using measurement and feedback: he evolves an equilibrated gas into a nonequilibrium state, from which one might extract work. The demon can evolve the system farther from equilibrium, on average, if the particles obey Bose-Einstein statistics than if they are distinguishable. We experimentally support this decade-and-a-half-old prediction by comparing indistinguishable with distinguishable photons. We use a fully programmable linear-optics platform, whose local photon statistics were shown recently to behave thermally. Our demon nondestructively measures the number of photons in a subset of the modes. Guided by the outcome, he conditionally interchanges the measured and unmeasured modes. This interchange creates a positive temperature difference between a mode in a particular subset and a mode in the other. The temperature difference is greater, on average, if the photons are indistinguishable. This result bolsters a long-standing prediction about the interplay among thermodynamics, information, and quantum particle statistics. Additionally, this work suggests a thermodynamic means of weakly validating boson-sampling platforms.

quant-pharXiv:2602.11276•Feb 13, 2026•0 citations
The division by N! in the expression of statistical entropy is usually justified to students by the statement that classical particles should be counted as indistinguishable. Sometimes, quantum indistinguishability is invoked to explain it. In this paper, we try to clarify the issue starting from Clausius thermodynamical entropy and deriving from it Boltzmann statistical entropy for the ideal gas. This approach appears interesting for two reasons: Firstly, it provides a direct heuristic link between thermodynamical and statistical expressions of entropy that is missing in the usual approach. In second place, it explicitly reminds that also statistical entropy is defined with respect to a reference state, chosen to be the quantum-mechanical (T=0) ground state of the N-particles in a box. Both factors h3Nh^{3N}h3N and N!N!N! at the denominator of the statistical entropy are a consequence of the quantum nature of the reference state: in particular, the N!N!N! is not related to the particle identity, but to the identity of the boundary conditions on the quantum-mechanical ground-state momenta, and to a general statistical maximization principle. The introduction of a reference state also allows to reinterpret the standard case of two mixing gases.
Identical particles underpin most quantum technologies, but the role of indistinguishability in these processes extends far beyond the symmetrization of many-particle states. This Colloquium presents a unified operational perspective on how particle identity, indistinguishability, exchange statistics, and many-particle interference can instead be harnessed as resources for quantum information processing. We first clarify the notions of entanglement and indistinguishability for identical particles, emphasizing their dependence on the accessible measurements and information. We then review how spatial overlap, multiparticle interference, and path identity enable the generation, extraction, protection, and distillation of coherence and entanglement. Their applications to quantum metrology and imaging, state discrimination, teleportation, entanglement swapping, and quantum cloning are examined. Finally, we discuss the thermodynamic role of indistinguishability, from the Gibbs paradox to quantum thermal machines and statistics-driven engines. Across these settings, indistinguishability emerges as a controllable, task-dependent resource whose benefits are determined by state preparation, exchange statistics, interference, and measurement constraints.
We revisit recent discussions concerning the Gibbs paradox—the apparent discrepancy between the entropy change upon mixing identical gases as evaluated from the statistical mechanics of classical distinguishable particles and macroscopic thermodynamics. Contrary to what is often stated, we show that thermodynamics does not require this entropy of mixing to be zero. A zero value follows from the implicit assumption that the identical gas particles are indistinguishable. If the identical particles are explicitly assumed to be distinguishable, thermodynamics yields the same entropy of mixing as classical statistical mechanics.
Maxwell's demon elucidates the value of information in thermodynamics, using measurement and feedback: he evolves an equilibrated gas into a nonequilibrium state, from which one might extract work. The demon can evolve the system farther from equilibrium, on average, if the particles obey Bose-Einstein statistics than if they are distinguishable. We experimentally support this decade-and-a-half-old prediction by comparing indistinguishable with distinguishable photons. We use a fully programmable linear-optics platform, whose local photon statistics were shown recently to behave thermally. Our demon nondestructively measures the number of photons in a subset of the modes. Guided by the outcome, he conditionally interchanges the measured and unmeasured modes. This interchange creates a positive temperature difference between a mode in a particular subset and a mode in the other. The temperature difference is greater, on average, if the photons are indistinguishable. This result bolsters a long-standing prediction about the interplay among thermodynamics, information, and quantum particle statistics. Additionally, this work suggests a thermodynamic means of weakly validating boson-sampling platforms.