Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comment on “Application of partition density-functional theory to one-dimensional models”

Peter D. T. A. Elliott, Daniel S. Jensen, Adam Wasserman, Kieron Burke

Published Feb 12, 2014• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Partition density-functional theory is a formally exact method for solving the ground-state electronic structure problem. It operates by dividing the system into noninteracting fragments along with a global effective potential, which, when solved to self-consistency, yields the exact energy and density (as the sum of the fragment densities) of the interacting system. A recent paper [Phys. Rev. A 86, 012504 (2012)] questions the uniqueness of the fragment occupations and fragment densities. We demonstrate that their analysis is incorrect. We describe some of the technical details of partition density-functional calculations and discuss the relationship to other embedding schemes.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.89.026501

Related papers

Reply to Comment on "Self-Consistent-Field Method for Correlated Many-Electron Systems with an Entropic Cumulant Energy", arXiv2202.05532v1

Jian Wang, Evert Jan Baerends

Recently we proposed an information entropy based method for electronic structure calculations within the density-matrix functional theory(DMFT) (Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001), dubbed as $i$-DMFT. Comments have been raised regarding the accuracy of the one-particle density-matrix compared to that from the wave function, and the universality of the functional. We address these questions and the problematic case of HeH$^+$.

arXiv:2207.02616•Jul 6, 2022•2 citations

Local Potential Functional Embedding Theory: A Self-Consistent Flavor of Density Functional Theory for Lattices without Density Functionals

Sajanthan Sekaran, Matthieu Saubanère, Emmanuel Fromager

Quantum embedding is a divide and conquer strategy that aims at solving the electronic Schrödinger equation of sizeable molecules or extended systems. We establish in the present work a clearer and in-principle-exact connection between density matrix embedding theory (DMET) and density-functional theory (DFT) within the simple but nontrivial one-dimensional Hubbard model. For that purpose, we use our recent reformulation of single-impurity DMET as a Householder transformed density-matrix functional embedding theory (Ht-DMFET). On the basis of well-identified density-functional approximations, a self-consistent local potential functional embedding theory (LPFET) is formulated and implemented. Combining both LPFET and DMET numerical results with our formally exact density-functional embedding theory reveals that a single statically embedded impurity can in principle describe the density-driven Mott–Hubbard transition, provided that a complementary density-functional correlation potential (which is neglected in both DMET and LPFET) exhibits a derivative discontinuity (DD) at half filling. The extension of LPFET to multiple impurities (which would enable to circumvent the modeling of DDs) and its generalization to quantum chemical Hamiltonians are left for future work.

arXiv:2202.08071•Computation•Mar 18, 2022•16 citations

Comment on "Self-Consistent-Field Method for Correlated Many-Electron Systems with an Entropic Cumulant Energy"

Lexin Ding, Julia Liebert, Christian Schilling

In [Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001 (2022)] a novel ground state method was proposed. It has been suggested that this $i$-DMFT would be a method within one-particle reduced density matrix functional theory (DMFT), capable of describing accurately molecules at various geometries with an information-theoretical nature. We reassess this work and its suggestions from a conceptual and practical point of view, leading to the following conclusions: i) A method which assigns to each molecule $\mathcal{M}$ its own functional $\mathcal{F}_{\!\mathcal{M}}$ is not a functional theory (striking violation of "universality") ii) even for the simplest systems $i$-DMFT yields incorrect one-particle reduced density matrices and iii) the use of an information-theoretical concept to describe molecular dissociation limits was not essential. The latter insight may help to fix the deficiency of $i$-DMFT to not reproduce correctly the smaller occupation numbers and thus to not recover the important dynamic correlations.

arXiv:2202.05532•Feb 11, 2022•8 citations

Model Hamiltonians in density functional theory

Paola Gori‐Giorgi, Julien Toulouse, Andreas Savin B

The formalism of Kohn and Sham uses a specific (model) hamiltonian which highly simplifies the many-electron problem to that of noninteracting fermions. The theorem of Hohenberg and Kohn tells us that, for a given ground state density, this hamiltonian is unique. In principle, this density can be chosen as that of the real, interacting system. To obtain the energy, or other properties of the real system, approximations are needed. Working with non interacting fermions is an important simplification, but it may be easier to produce approximations with different choices of the model hamiltonian. The feature that the exact density is (ideally) reproduced can be kept in the newly defined fictitious systems. Using model hamiltonians having the same form as the physical one, that is, being built of one- and two-body operators, allows to approach the physical hamiltonian arbitrarily close, and thus a systematic reduction of the approximations.

arXiv:cond-mat/0605174•CRM proceedings & lecture notes•Jun 20, 2007•0 citations

Strong electron correlation from partition density functional theory

Yi Shi, Yuming Shi, Adam Wasserman

Standard approximations for the exchange-correlation functional in Kohn-Sham density functional theory (KS-DFT) typically lead to unacceptably large errors when applied to strongly correlated electronic systems. Partition-DFT (PDFT) is a formally exact reformulation of KS-DFT in which the ground-state density and energy of a system are obtained through self-consistent calculations on isolated fragments, with a partition energy representing inter-fragment interactions. Here, we show how typical errors of the local density approximation (LDA) in KS-DFT can be largely suppressed through a simple approximation, the multi-fragment overlap approximation (MFOA), for the partition energy in PDFT. Our method is illustrated on simple models of one-dimensional strongly correlated linear hydrogen chains. The MFOA, when used in combination with the LDA for the fragments, improves LDA dissociation curves of hydrogen chains and produces results that are comparable to those of spin-unrestricted LDA, but without breaking the spin symmetry. MFOA also induces a correction to the LDA electron density that partially captures the correct density dimerization in strongly correlated hydrogen chains. Moreover, with an additional correction to the partition energy that is specific to the one-dimensional LDA, the approximation is shown to produce dissociation energies in quantitative agreement with calculations based on the density matrix renormalization group method.

arXiv:2309.04571•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 12, 2023•3 citations

Introduction

H. Eschrig

Density functional theory provides a powerful tool for computations of the quantum state of atoms, molecules and solids, and of ab-initio molecular dynamics. It was conceived in its initial naïve and approximative version by Thomas and Fermi immediately after the foundation of quantum mechanics, in 1927. Just thirty years ago, in the middle of the sixties, Hohenberg, Kohn and Sham on the one hand established a logically rigorous density functional theory of the quantum groundstate on the basis of quantum mechanics, and on the other hand, guided by this construction, introduced an approximative explicit theory called the local-density approximation, which for computations of the quantum groundstate of many-particle systems proved to be superior to both Thomas-Fermi and Hartree-Fock theories. From that time on, density functional theory has grown vastly in popularity, and a flood of computational work in molecular and solid state physics has been the result. Motivated by its success, there has been always a tendency to widen the fields of application of density functional theory, and in these developments, some points which were left somewhat obscure in the basic theory, were brought into focus from time to time. This led in the early eighties to a deepening of the logical basis, essentially by Levy and Lieb, and finally Lieb gave the basic theory a form of final mathematical rigour. Since that treatment, however, is based on the tools of modern convex functional analysis, its implications only gradually became known to the many people who apply density functional theory. A thorough treatment of the dependence on particle number on the basis of Lieb’s theory is given for the first time in the present text.

Teubner-Texte zur Physik•Jan 1, 1996•0 citations
Partition density-functional theory is a formally exact method for solving the ground-state electronic structure problem. It operates by dividing the system into noninteracting fragments along with a global effective potential, which, when solved to self-consistency, yields the exact energy and density (as the sum of the fragment densities) of the interacting system. A recent paper [Phys. Rev. A 86, 012504 (2012)] questions the uniqueness of the fragment occupations and fragment densities. We demonstrate that their analysis is incorrect. We describe some of the technical details of partition density-functional calculations and discuss the relationship to other embedding schemes.
Recently we proposed an information entropy based method for electronic structure calculations within the density-matrix functional theory(DMFT) (Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001), dubbed as iii-DMFT. Comments have been raised regarding the accuracy of the one-particle density-matrix compared to that from the wave function, and the universality of the functional. We address these questions and the problematic case of HeH+^++.
Quantum embedding is a divide and conquer strategy that aims at solving the electronic Schrödinger equation of sizeable molecules or extended systems. We establish in the present work a clearer and in-principle-exact connection between density matrix embedding theory (DMET) and density-functional theory (DFT) within the simple but nontrivial one-dimensional Hubbard model. For that purpose, we use our recent reformulation of single-impurity DMET as a Householder transformed density-matrix functional embedding theory (Ht-DMFET). On the basis of well-identified density-functional approximations, a self-consistent local potential functional embedding theory (LPFET) is formulated and implemented. Combining both LPFET and DMET numerical results with our formally exact density-functional embedding theory reveals that a single statically embedded impurity can in principle describe the density-driven Mott–Hubbard transition, provided that a complementary density-functional correlation potential (which is neglected in both DMET and LPFET) exhibits a derivative discontinuity (DD) at half filling. The extension of LPFET to multiple impurities (which would enable to circumvent the modeling of DDs) and its generalization to quantum chemical Hamiltonians are left for future work.
In [Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001 (2022)] a novel ground state method was proposed. It has been suggested that this iii-DMFT would be a method within one-particle reduced density matrix functional theory (DMFT), capable of describing accurately molecules at various geometries with an information-theoretical nature. We reassess this work and its suggestions from a conceptual and practical point of view, leading to the following conclusions: i) A method which assigns to each molecule M\mathcal{M}M its own functional F ⁣M\mathcal{F}_{\!\mathcal{M}}FM​ is not a functional theory (striking violation of "universality") ii) even for the simplest systems iii-DMFT yields incorrect one-particle reduced density matrices and iii) the use of an information-theoretical concept to describe molecular dissociation limits was not essential. The latter insight may help to fix the deficiency of iii-DMFT to not reproduce correctly the smaller occupation numbers and thus to not recover the important dynamic correlations.
The formalism of Kohn and Sham uses a specific (model) hamiltonian which highly simplifies the many-electron problem to that of noninteracting fermions. The theorem of Hohenberg and Kohn tells us that, for a given ground state density, this hamiltonian is unique. In principle, this density can be chosen as that of the real, interacting system. To obtain the energy, or other properties of the real system, approximations are needed. Working with non interacting fermions is an important simplification, but it may be easier to produce approximations with different choices of the model hamiltonian. The feature that the exact density is (ideally) reproduced can be kept in the newly defined fictitious systems. Using model hamiltonians having the same form as the physical one, that is, being built of one- and two-body operators, allows to approach the physical hamiltonian arbitrarily close, and thus a systematic reduction of the approximations.
Standard approximations for the exchange-correlation functional in Kohn-Sham density functional theory (KS-DFT) typically lead to unacceptably large errors when applied to strongly correlated electronic systems. Partition-DFT (PDFT) is a formally exact reformulation of KS-DFT in which the ground-state density and energy of a system are obtained through self-consistent calculations on isolated fragments, with a partition energy representing inter-fragment interactions. Here, we show how typical errors of the local density approximation (LDA) in KS-DFT can be largely suppressed through a simple approximation, the multi-fragment overlap approximation (MFOA), for the partition energy in PDFT. Our method is illustrated on simple models of one-dimensional strongly correlated linear hydrogen chains. The MFOA, when used in combination with the LDA for the fragments, improves LDA dissociation curves of hydrogen chains and produces results that are comparable to those of spin-unrestricted LDA, but without breaking the spin symmetry. MFOA also induces a correction to the LDA electron density that partially captures the correct density dimerization in strongly correlated hydrogen chains. Moreover, with an additional correction to the partition energy that is specific to the one-dimensional LDA, the approximation is shown to produce dissociation energies in quantitative agreement with calculations based on the density matrix renormalization group method.
Density functional theory provides a powerful tool for computations of the quantum state of atoms, molecules and solids, and of ab-initio molecular dynamics. It was conceived in its initial naïve and approximative version by Thomas and Fermi immediately after the foundation of quantum mechanics, in 1927. Just thirty years ago, in the middle of the sixties, Hohenberg, Kohn and Sham on the one hand established a logically rigorous density functional theory of the quantum groundstate on the basis of quantum mechanics, and on the other hand, guided by this construction, introduced an approximative explicit theory called the local-density approximation, which for computations of the quantum groundstate of many-particle systems proved to be superior to both Thomas-Fermi and Hartree-Fock theories. From that time on, density functional theory has grown vastly in popularity, and a flood of computational work in molecular and solid state physics has been the result. Motivated by its success, there has been always a tendency to widen the fields of application of density functional theory, and in these developments, some points which were left somewhat obscure in the basic theory, were brought into focus from time to time. This led in the early eighties to a deepening of the logical basis, essentially by Levy and Lieb, and finally Lieb gave the basic theory a form of final mathematical rigour. Since that treatment, however, is based on the tools of modern convex functional analysis, its implications only gradually became known to the many people who apply density functional theory. A thorough treatment of the dependence on particle number on the basis of Lieb’s theory is given for the first time in the present text.