Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of Physics

Combining relativity and quantum mechanics: Schrödinger's interpretation of ψ

Asım Orhan Barut

Published Jan 1, 1988• 29 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/bf01882875

Related papers

Fundamentals of Quantum Mechanics Theory and Practice

Ismail Abbas

Quantum mechanics is the newest science and should therefore be the most precise, but unfortunately, it's quite the opposite. If you don't understand quantum mechanics, ask yourself if I'm right, because others don't either. The field of experimental quantum mechanics is so vast and confusing that its theoretical practitioners will always have to adopt new explanations from their own context to conform to the facts of quantum mechanics. Quantum mechanics was created in the early 20th century to establish mathematical and physical laws or rules for subatomic objects subject to an external potential field in order to explain so-called quantum systems. Studying the spatiotemporal evolution of a quantum system, defined as a microscopic subatomic system of low energy density subjected to a potential field, external or internal, is a rather complex subject. However, in 1927, the well-known Schrödinger PDE, valid for infinite free space subject to Dirichlet boundary conditions, was introduced. Schrödinger's PDE must be complemented by the Bohr/Copenhagen interpretation of the wave function Ψ involving the rules of quantum systems of instantaneous entanglement and superposition. We all know that the Schrödinger equation is incomplete because it lives and operates in the incomplete space R^4 and therefore the wave function Ψ is incomplete in itself and cannot be defined as scalar, a vector, nor a tensor. The complex wave function Ψ has never been properly defined. Moreover, the Schrödinger PDE is not Lorentz invariant and is not compatible with the special theory of relativity, and is obviously even less so with the general theory of relativity. However, quantum mechanics has come a long way, both in theory and practice, since 1927, nearly a century ago. This long journey has added even more illogical and confusing properties to the Ψ wave function, such as causality and wave function collapse. Many attempts have been made over the last century to reform the Schrödinger equation, the most notable being to combine it with the general theory of relativity, but all these attempts have been in vain. The breakthrough came in 2020-2024 [2,3,4], when the author of this article claimed to replace the classical Schrödinger equation Ψ with the PDE for its square Ψ^2, which is logical and physical. Ψ^2 is needed to express the quantum energy density flux (U(x,y,z,t) = Ψ^2 (x,y,z,t)) and we therefore propose a new Schrödinger equation for Ψ^2 which should have the form of the energy density diffusion PDE such as that of thermal conduction. Equation 3 should be supplemented by the advanced artificial intelligence proposed by the author [5,6]. Comparing Schrödinger's classical PDE of 1927 with the PDE proposed for Ψ^2 in 2020 shows that we currently have two different or distinct theories of quantum mechanics! Which one is more theoretically true and more practically useful? This is the purpose of this article.

•Jun 5, 2025•0 citations

Schrödinger and the interpretation of quantum mechanics

Fritz Rohrlich

Foundations of Physics•Dec 1, 1987•5 citations

Reasons and consequences for the combination of quantum and classical theory

Runsheng Tu

From the fact that many people are dedicated to the quantization of gravity, it can be seen that people crave the integration of quantum theory and macroscopic theory. Let's first combine quantum mechanics with classical mechanics to gain insightful experiences. The citation introduces the Schrödinger-Tu equation, which has gravitational potential energy and can describe macroscopic objects. Several successful computational examples related to atoms and molecules using the combination of quantum and classical methods for use were listed. The wave mechanics representation method of classical mechanics laws has been derived. This indicates that quantum mechanics and classical mechanics can be compatible and coexist. There is still much evidence to suggest that the Schrödinger equation (SE) cannot exclude classical mechanical laws: The mass m in the SE can be large enough to bring the described object into the macroscopic range; Steady state SE is the Tψ+Vψ=Eψ, a combination of the wave function ψ and the expression T+V=E in classical mechanics; The potential energy function in the SE can originate from macroscopic force fields; F=ma and the SE can be converted to each other; Completed electron diffraction experiments that exhibit both wave and particle characteristics simultaneously. Important conceptual changes can drive the renewal of physics. The shift from quantum and classical incompatibility to compatibility is an important conceptual change that can lead to the birth of general wave mechanics.

Brazilian Journal of Science•Jul 20, 2026•0 citations

The Schrödinger Realization of Quantum Mechanics

Daniel R. Bes

Graduate texts in physics•Sep 19, 2011•0 citations

The Only Real Probabilities in Quantum Mechanics

Nancy Delaney Cartwright

Position probabilities play a privileged role in the interpretation of quantum mechanics. The quantum wave function (usually designated “Ψ(r)’) cannot itself represent a physical quantity, because it is complex valued. Its square — |Ψ(r)|2 — however, is real; and it is |Ψ(r)|2 which is the fundamental interpreted quantity of the theory. Schrödinger, who originated wave mechanics, interpreted |Ψ(r)|2 as the density of a charged particle; but this suggestion was inadequate. A principal reason is that, for most physical systems, |Ψ(r)|2 spreads out in time, whereas particles themselves do not. Schrödinger's interpretation was replaced by Born who introduced probabilities into quantum mechanics. Born urged that |Ψ(r)|2 represents not the density of the system in space, but rather a probability density. This is almost universally how quantum mechanics is taught today: |Ψ(r)|2 gives the probability that a system in state Ψ(r) is located at r.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1978•5 citations

Quantum mechanics and relativity

L. E. Ballentine

American Journal of Physics•Jul 1, 1992•1 citation
Quantum mechanics is the newest science and should therefore be the most precise, but unfortunately, it's quite the opposite. If you don't understand quantum mechanics, ask yourself if I'm right, because others don't either. The field of experimental quantum mechanics is so vast and confusing that its theoretical practitioners will always have to adopt new explanations from their own context to conform to the facts of quantum mechanics. Quantum mechanics was created in the early 20th century to establish mathematical and physical laws or rules for subatomic objects subject to an external potential field in order to explain so-called quantum systems. Studying the spatiotemporal evolution of a quantum system, defined as a microscopic subatomic system of low energy density subjected to a potential field, external or internal, is a rather complex subject. However, in 1927, the well-known Schrödinger PDE, valid for infinite free space subject to Dirichlet boundary conditions, was introduced. Schrödinger's PDE must be complemented by the Bohr/Copenhagen interpretation of the wave function Ψ involving the rules of quantum systems of instantaneous entanglement and superposition. We all know that the Schrödinger equation is incomplete because it lives and operates in the incomplete space R^4 and therefore the wave function Ψ is incomplete in itself and cannot be defined as scalar, a vector, nor a tensor. The complex wave function Ψ has never been properly defined. Moreover, the Schrödinger PDE is not Lorentz invariant and is not compatible with the special theory of relativity, and is obviously even less so with the general theory of relativity. However, quantum mechanics has come a long way, both in theory and practice, since 1927, nearly a century ago. This long journey has added even more illogical and confusing properties to the Ψ wave function, such as causality and wave function collapse. Many attempts have been made over the last century to reform the Schrödinger equation, the most notable being to combine it with the general theory of relativity, but all these attempts have been in vain. The breakthrough came in 2020-2024 [2,3,4], when the author of this article claimed to replace the classical Schrödinger equation Ψ with the PDE for its square Ψ^2, which is logical and physical. Ψ^2 is needed to express the quantum energy density flux (U(x,y,z,t) = Ψ^2 (x,y,z,t)) and we therefore propose a new Schrödinger equation for Ψ^2 which should have the form of the energy density diffusion PDE such as that of thermal conduction. Equation 3 should be supplemented by the advanced artificial intelligence proposed by the author [5,6]. Comparing Schrödinger's classical PDE of 1927 with the PDE proposed for Ψ^2 in 2020 shows that we currently have two different or distinct theories of quantum mechanics! Which one is more theoretically true and more practically useful? This is the purpose of this article.
From the fact that many people are dedicated to the quantization of gravity, it can be seen that people crave the integration of quantum theory and macroscopic theory. Let's first combine quantum mechanics with classical mechanics to gain insightful experiences. The citation introduces the Schrödinger-Tu equation, which has gravitational potential energy and can describe macroscopic objects. Several successful computational examples related to atoms and molecules using the combination of quantum and classical methods for use were listed. The wave mechanics representation method of classical mechanics laws has been derived. This indicates that quantum mechanics and classical mechanics can be compatible and coexist. There is still much evidence to suggest that the Schrödinger equation (SE) cannot exclude classical mechanical laws: The mass m in the SE can be large enough to bring the described object into the macroscopic range; Steady state SE is the Tψ+Vψ=Eψ, a combination of the wave function ψ and the expression T+V=E in classical mechanics; The potential energy function in the SE can originate from macroscopic force fields; F=ma and the SE can be converted to each other; Completed electron diffraction experiments that exhibit both wave and particle characteristics simultaneously. Important conceptual changes can drive the renewal of physics. The shift from quantum and classical incompatibility to compatibility is an important conceptual change that can lead to the birth of general wave mechanics.
Position probabilities play a privileged role in the interpretation of quantum mechanics. The quantum wave function (usually designated “Ψ(r)’) cannot itself represent a physical quantity, because it is complex valued. Its square — |Ψ(r)|2 — however, is real; and it is |Ψ(r)|2 which is the fundamental interpreted quantity of the theory. Schrödinger, who originated wave mechanics, interpreted |Ψ(r)|2 as the density of a charged particle; but this suggestion was inadequate. A principal reason is that, for most physical systems, |Ψ(r)|2 spreads out in time, whereas particles themselves do not. Schrödinger's interpretation was replaced by Born who introduced probabilities into quantum mechanics. Born urged that |Ψ(r)|2 represents not the density of the system in space, but rather a probability density. This is almost universally how quantum mechanics is taught today: |Ψ(r)|2 gives the probability that a system in state Ψ(r) is located at r.