Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields

Approximate measurement in quantum mechanics. II

Abner Shimony

Published Apr 15, 1974• 34 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An approximate measurement procedure of the following type is considered: (i) An initial eigenstate of the object observable leads to a final statistical operator of the object plus apparatus describing a mixture of exact eigenstates of the apparatus observable; (ii) almost all the statistical weight of the mixture is assigned to eigenstates associated with one eigenvalue of the apparatus observable, which is uniquely determined by the initial value of the object observable. It is proved that each of a large class of initial states of the object leads to a final statistical operator which does not describe any mixture of exact eigenstates of the apparatus observable. The analysis also yields a proof of a theorem on measurement stated by Fine.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.9.2321

Related papers

Approximate measurement in quantum mechanics. I

Mary H. Fehrs, Abner Shimony

This is the first of two papers showing that the quantum problem of measurement remains unsolved even when the initial state of the apparatus is described by a statistical operator and when the results of measurement have a small probability of being erroneous. A realistic treatment of the measurement of observables of microscopic objects (e.g., the position or the spin of an electron) by means of observables of macroscopic apparatus (e.g., the position of a spot on a photographic plate) requires the consideration of errors. The first paper considers measurement procedures of the following type: An initial eigenstate of the object observable leads to a final statistical operator of the object plus apparatus which describes a mixture of "approximate" eigenstates of the apparatus observable. It is proved that each of a large class of initial states leads to a final statistical operator which does not describe any mixture containing even one "approximate" eigenstate of the apparatus observable.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Apr 15, 1974•5 citations

Approximate measurement in quantum mechanics

Mary H. Fehrs

This is the first of two papers showing that the quantum problem of measurement remains unsolved even when the initial state of the apparatus is described by a statistical operator and when the results of measurement have a small probability of being erroneous. A realistic treatment of the measurement of observables of microscopic objects (e.g., the position or the spin of an electron) by means of observables of macroscopic apparatus (e.g., the position of a spot on a photographic plate) requires the consideration of errors. The first paper considers measurement procedures of the following type: An initial eigenstate of the object observable leads to a final statistical operator of the object plus apparatus which describes a mixture of “approximate” eigenstates of the apparatus observable. It is proved that each of a large class of initial states leads to a final statistical operator which does not describe any mixture containing even one “approximate” eigenstate of the apparatus observable.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1993•1 citation

Insolubility of the Quantum Measurement Problem

Arthur I. Fine

The problem of whether a measurement interaction can leave the joint object-apparatus system in a mixture of states, in each state of which the apparatus's observable displays a definite value, is set within the most general quantum-theoretic framework for treating measurements. It is shown that the question posed by this problem admits only a negative answer. Some schemes for approximating the true object-apparatus state by means of such mixtures are examined. It is argued that such schemes constitute fundamental changes in the interpretation of quantum theory.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Dec 15, 1970•145 citations

Theory of Measurement: A Note on Conceptual Foundation of Quantum Mechanics

Yutaka Toyozawa

Theory of measurement is presented which is based on the statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics. The reduction of wave packet is ascribed to undue comparison of the state of an ensemble before measurement and the state of an individual system after measurement. By studying the evolution of statistical operators for subsystems and composite systems comprising an object, a measuring apparatus and an observer, one can definitely locate where the measurement is done, thus negating the principle of psycho-physical parallelism due to von Neumann. Time needed for measurement is also discussed. The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen state is described as an eigenstate of correlation. The argument lends support to the standpoint that the physical state of a system is to be represented by the statistical operator, not by the wave function, in the conceptual foundation of quantum mechanics.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Feb 1, 1992•2 citations

Probabilistic Interpretation and the Quantum Theory of Measurement. II

Ziro Maki

A general theory of quantum-mechanical measurement is presented. It is shown that some general conditions should be satisfied for any apparatus to carry out the ideal measurement, and the reduction of state is an inevitable consequence of the action of such an apparatus. The statistical operator (in weak sense) is defined uniquely for ensembles prepared with respect to the measured observables, without recourse to the expectation value hypothesis. The probabilistic interpretation (the Born ansatz) comes out as a natural explanation of physical contents of the statistical operator after the measurement, rather than an axiomatic presumption of quantum mechanics.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Oct 1, 1989•8 citations

Analysis of the Quantum Mechanical Measurement Process

Eugene Paul Wigner, Mutsuo M. Yanase

The quantum mechanical measurement process is analysed in detail, especially from the group theoretical point of view. The first three chapters review the results obtained before briefly. In §1, the classical theory of measurement, originated by von Neumann, is birefly described. The importance of considering more general schemes of measurements than the original one is, however, emphasized. In §2, the role of conservation laws, in imposing limitations on the possibility of measurements, is discussed. Accurately measurable quantities are defined in this context. In §3, the role of conservation laws is further analysed. It is shown that the conserved quantity of the apparatus cannot be used for a “pointer reading.” The following two chapters discuss the nature of the exactly measurable quantities. In §4, exactly measurable quantities are explicitly determined. It is shown that the measurement of projection operators in the Hilbert space of the object which commute with the operators of the restricted Poincaré group give all the information on the states of the object that can be obtained by accurate measurements. In §5, the measurement on objects which are composed of more than one particle is discussed. The last chapter, §6, deals with approximately measurable quantities, but no complete estimate of the unavoidable inaccuracy of the measurement of these is obtained. It also contains some concluding remarks.

Annals of the Japan Association for Philosophy of Science•Jan 1, 1973•2 citations
An approximate measurement procedure of the following type is considered: (i) An initial eigenstate of the object observable leads to a final statistical operator of the object plus apparatus describing a mixture of exact eigenstates of the apparatus observable; (ii) almost all the statistical weight of the mixture is assigned to eigenstates associated with one eigenvalue of the apparatus observable, which is uniquely determined by the initial value of the object observable. It is proved that each of a large class of initial states of the object leads to a final statistical operator which does not describe any mixture of exact eigenstates of the apparatus observable. The analysis also yields a proof of a theorem on measurement stated by Fine.
This is the first of two papers showing that the quantum problem of measurement remains unsolved even when the initial state of the apparatus is described by a statistical operator and when the results of measurement have a small probability of being erroneous. A realistic treatment of the measurement of observables of microscopic objects (e.g., the position or the spin of an electron) by means of observables of macroscopic apparatus (e.g., the position of a spot on a photographic plate) requires the consideration of errors. The first paper considers measurement procedures of the following type: An initial eigenstate of the object observable leads to a final statistical operator of the object plus apparatus which describes a mixture of "approximate" eigenstates of the apparatus observable. It is proved that each of a large class of initial states leads to a final statistical operator which does not describe any mixture containing even one "approximate" eigenstate of the apparatus observable.
This is the first of two papers showing that the quantum problem of measurement remains unsolved even when the initial state of the apparatus is described by a statistical operator and when the results of measurement have a small probability of being erroneous. A realistic treatment of the measurement of observables of microscopic objects (e.g., the position or the spin of an electron) by means of observables of macroscopic apparatus (e.g., the position of a spot on a photographic plate) requires the consideration of errors. The first paper considers measurement procedures of the following type: An initial eigenstate of the object observable leads to a final statistical operator of the object plus apparatus which describes a mixture of “approximate” eigenstates of the apparatus observable. It is proved that each of a large class of initial states leads to a final statistical operator which does not describe any mixture containing even one “approximate” eigenstate of the apparatus observable.
The problem of whether a measurement interaction can leave the joint object-apparatus system in a mixture of states, in each state of which the apparatus's observable displays a definite value, is set within the most general quantum-theoretic framework for treating measurements. It is shown that the question posed by this problem admits only a negative answer. Some schemes for approximating the true object-apparatus state by means of such mixtures are examined. It is argued that such schemes constitute fundamental changes in the interpretation of quantum theory.
Theory of measurement is presented which is based on the statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics. The reduction of wave packet is ascribed to undue comparison of the state of an ensemble before measurement and the state of an individual system after measurement. By studying the evolution of statistical operators for subsystems and composite systems comprising an object, a measuring apparatus and an observer, one can definitely locate where the measurement is done, thus negating the principle of psycho-physical parallelism due to von Neumann. Time needed for measurement is also discussed. The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen state is described as an eigenstate of correlation. The argument lends support to the standpoint that the physical state of a system is to be represented by the statistical operator, not by the wave function, in the conceptual foundation of quantum mechanics.
A general theory of quantum-mechanical measurement is presented. It is shown that some general conditions should be satisfied for any apparatus to carry out the ideal measurement, and the reduction of state is an inevitable consequence of the action of such an apparatus. The statistical operator (in weak sense) is defined uniquely for ensembles prepared with respect to the measured observables, without recourse to the expectation value hypothesis. The probabilistic interpretation (the Born ansatz) comes out as a natural explanation of physical contents of the statistical operator after the measurement, rather than an axiomatic presumption of quantum mechanics.
The quantum mechanical measurement process is analysed in detail, especially from the group theoretical point of view. The first three chapters review the results obtained before briefly. In §1, the classical theory of measurement, originated by von Neumann, is birefly described. The importance of considering more general schemes of measurements than the original one is, however, emphasized. In §2, the role of conservation laws, in imposing limitations on the possibility of measurements, is discussed. Accurately measurable quantities are defined in this context. In §3, the role of conservation laws is further analysed. It is shown that the conserved quantity of the apparatus cannot be used for a “pointer reading.” The following two chapters discuss the nature of the exactly measurable quantities. In §4, exactly measurable quantities are explicitly determined. It is shown that the measurement of projection operators in the Hilbert space of the object which commute with the operators of the restricted Poincaré group give all the information on the states of the object that can be obtained by accurate measurements. In §5, the measurement on objects which are composed of more than one particle is discussed. The last chapter, §6, deals with approximately measurable quantities, but no complete estimate of the unavoidable inaccuracy of the measurement of these is obtained. It also contains some concluding remarks.