Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Proceedings of the IEEE

The Quantum Limit to Moore's Law

James R. Powell

Published Jul 24, 2008• 155 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Moore's law has accurately predicted the growth of computing power from the increasing density of transistor devices on integrated circuit (IC) chips. Many believe this trend will continue indefinitely; however, quantum physics may define a future limit to electronic miniaturization and ever-increasing computing power. Heisenberg uncertainty in terms of the Compton wavelength of particle physics suggests such a boundary, even for anticipated advances in quantum computing. Moore's law has been a reliable predictor of the pace of electronic technology advancement; however, quantum physics may provide the ultimate limit to this mathematical model.

DOI
10.1109/jproc.2008.925411

Related papers

Quantum computers: where do we stand?

Giuliano Benenti, Giulio Casati

Q uantum mechanics has had an enormous technological and societal impact.To grasp this point, it is sufficient to cite the invention of the transistor, perhaps the most remarkable among the countless other applications of quantum mechanics.It is also easy to see the enormous impact of computers on everyday life.The importance of computers is such that it is appropriate to say that we are now living in the information age.This information revolution became possible thanks to the invention of the tran sistor, that is, thanks to the synergy between computer science and quantum physics.Today this synergy offers completely new opportunities and promises exciting advances in both funda mental science and technological application.We are referring here to the fact that quantum mechanics can be used to process and transmit information [1,2].Miniaturization provides us with an intuitive way of under standing why, in the near future, quantum laws will become important for computation.The electronics industry for com puters grows hand-in-hand with the decrease in size of integrated circuits.This miniaturization is necessary to increase computa tional power, that is, the number of floating-point operations per second (flops) a computer can perform.In the 1950's, electronic computers based on vacuum-tube technology were capable of performing approximately 103 floating-point operations per second, while nowadays there exist supercomputers whose power is greater than lOteraflops (1013 flops).As we have remarked, this enormous growth of computational power has been made possi ble owing to progress in m in ia tu riz a tio n , w hich m ay be quantified empirically in Moore's law.This law is the result of a remarkable observation made by Gordon Moore in 1965: the number of transistors on a single integrated-circuit chip doubles approximately every 18 24 months.This exponential growth has not yet saturated and Moore's law is still valid.At the present time the limit is approximately 108 transistors per chip and the typical size of circuit components is of the order of 100 nanometres.Extrapolating Moore's law, one would estimate that around the year 2020 we shall reach the atomic size for storing a single bit of inform atio n .At th a t p o in t, q u a n tu m effects will becom e unavoidably dominant.One should be aware that, besides quantum effects, other fac tors could bring Moore's law to an end.In the first place, there are economic considerations.Indeed, the cost of building fabri cation facilities to m an u factu re chips has also increased exponentially with time.Nevertheless, it is important to under stand the ultimate limitations set by quantum mechanics.Even though we might overcome economic barriers by means of tech nological breakthroughs, quantum physics sets fundamental limitations on the size of the circuit components.The first ques tion under debate is whether it would be more convenient to push References

Europhysics news•Jan 1, 2005•1 citation

Is there a Moore's law for quantum computing?

Olivier Ezratty

There is a common wisdom according to which many technologies can progress according to some exponential law like the empirical Moore's law that was validated for over half a century with the growth of transistors number in chipsets. As a still in the making technology with a lot of potential promises, quantum computing is supposed to follow the pack and grow inexorably to maturity. The Holy Grail in that domain is a large quantum computer with thousands of errors corrected logical qubits made themselves of thousands, if not more, of physical qubits. These would enable molecular simulations as well as factoring 2048 RSA bit keys among other use cases taken from the intractable classical computing problems book. How far are we from this? Less than 15 years according to many predictions. We will see in this paper that Moore's empirical law cannot easily be translated to an equivalent in quantum computing. Qubits have various figures of merit that won't progress magically thanks to some new manufacturing technique capacity. However, some equivalents of Moore's law may be at play inside and outside the quantum realm like with quantum computers enabling technologies, cryogeny and control electronics. Algorithms, software tools and engineering also play a key role as enablers of quantum computing progress. While much of quantum computing future outcomes depends on qubit fidelities, it is progressing rather slowly, particularly at scale. We will finally see that other figures of merit will come into play and potentially change the landscape like the quality of computed results and the energetics of quantum computing. Although scientific and technological in nature, this inventory has broad business implications, on investment, education and cybersecurity related decision-making processes.

arXiv:2303.15547•Mar 27, 2023•9 citations

Forecasting the Future Capacities of Superconducting Quantum Computers: Extending Moore's Law Through Machine Learning

Christopher Tam

Quantum computing has emerged as a promising technology that can perform certain tasks exponentially faster than classical computers.Despite the potential for quantum computers to revolutionize the field of computing, the development of fault-tolerant quantum computers remains a critical challenge.Moore's Law has accurately predicted the exponential growth in the capacity of classical computers, with transistor capacity doubling roughly every year.This prediction, established in the 1960s, held true until the early 2010s.However, the emergence of quantum computers raises questions about how to predict the rate of development these technologies.This work presents a novel approach using machine learning to extend classical Moore's Law into a quantum Moore's Law.Unlike previous attempts, which relied on limited quantum computer data, this model incorporates historical classical transistor data to predict qubit capacities.This thesis proposes a novel approach to forecasting the future capacities of superconducting qubits and gate speeds using machine learning.The proposed model builds upon Moore's Law and its predictions for the transistor capacity of classical computers.First, it establishes a polynomial relationship between the number of qubits and the number of classical transistors.Then, it trains a machine learning model to predict the number of classical transistors for future years.This prediction is used in conjunction with the established relationship to estimate the number of qubits for a given year.The same methodology is applied on data on the best achieved classical computations per second values to predict the speed of execution of quantum gates in the future.The findings indicate that the proposed model outperforms previously proposed methods in predicting qubit capacities, suggesting an improved method for predicting the future capacities of superconducting qubits and gate speeds based on the relationship between qubit and classical transistor capacities.Using a data-driven approach, the model can incorporate new data as quantum milestones are achieved.In this study, we present a novel approach to predicting the growth of quantum computing i by extending and evolving classical Moore's Law using machine learning.Our proposed model makes use of historical information on classical transistors to estimate recent qubit capacities more accurately than earlier studies, showing improved prediction accuracy in comparison to previous work.The proposed model provides valuable insight into the potential trajectory of quantum computing technology if Moore's Law continues to hold in this domain. Summary for Lay AudienceQuantum computing has the potential to revolutionize computing by performing tasks much faster than classical computers.However, developing fault-tolerant quantum computers is a major challenge.While Moore's Law accurately predicted the growth of classical computers, the emergence of quantum computers raises questions about how to predict their development.This study presents a novel approach that combines machine learning with historical classical transistor data to forecast the capacities of quantum computers.The proposed model establishes a relationship between the number of qubits and classical transistors and uses machine learning to predict future transistor capacities.This prediction is then used to estimate the number of qubits for a given year.The same approach is applied to predict the speed of quantum gate execution.The results show that this model outperforms previous methods, providing more accurate predictions of qubit capacities.By incorporating new data as quantum milestones are achieved, the model can continuously improve its predictions.This study offers valuable insights into the potential growth of quantum computing if Moore's Law continues to apply in this domain.The proposed model extends and evolves classical Moore's Law using machine learning, leveraging historical information on classical transistors to estimate recent qubit capacities more accurately.Overall, this approach provides a promising method for predicting the future capacities of superconducting qubits and gate speeds in quantum computing.

•Jul 24, 2023•0 citations

Electrons and nuclei get entangled

Jonathan Baugh, Raymond Laflamme

Every 18 months the number of transistors that can be packed onto a typical computer chip doubles. This is Moore's law – an empirical demonstration of our ingenuity to develop faster computers. Moore's law has held for the last 50 years, and if it holds for another 10 to 20 years then we will have created transistors that are the size of atoms. At this scale the classical laws of physics break down and are replaced by quantum mechanics.

Physics World•Jul 1, 2003•1 citation

Machine learning in quantum material

Mandeep Singh, Pawan Kumar Maurya, Manas Baiswar +2 more

In recent years, the tech world has seen a rapid shift toward quantum devices, in order to push the limits of classical technology. For decades, metal–oxide–semiconductor field-effect transistors (MOSFETs) have been the backbone of electronic systems, fueling remarkable advances in computing and data processing, largely thanks to Moore’s Law.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 15, 2025•0 citations

Innovations and Applications of Quantum Computing

Bhanu Prakash

Moore’s law will cease to be relevant once transistors are the size of electrons. Once this occurs, we will no longer be able to use silicon for technological advancement. However, breakthroughs will continue in the form of a sixth paradigm: a 3D molecular computing model such as quantum comput- ing. Some of the promising areas of quantum computing researched in this study are (i) algorithmic advancements - such as Shor’s, Grover’s, error correction, fault tolerance and other new algorithms; (ii) hardware - such as the quantum system architecture, circuit models, entanglement, superposition and no-cloning qubits; (iii) market segments - such as finance, healthcare, and chemistry; (iv) the supremacy established over classical computing; and (v) areas of applicability. Significant progress has been made in these areas in recent decades, and they have garnered immense interest, attention and the funding required to make good progress.

•Aug 9, 2021•1 citation
Moore's law has accurately predicted the growth of computing power from the increasing density of transistor devices on integrated circuit (IC) chips. Many believe this trend will continue indefinitely; however, quantum physics may define a future limit to electronic miniaturization and ever-increasing computing power. Heisenberg uncertainty in terms of the Compton wavelength of particle physics suggests such a boundary, even for anticipated advances in quantum computing. Moore's law has been a reliable predictor of the pace of electronic technology advancement; however, quantum physics may provide the ultimate limit to this mathematical model.
Q uantum mechanics has had an enormous technological and societal impact.To grasp this point, it is sufficient to cite the invention of the transistor, perhaps the most remarkable among the countless other applications of quantum mechanics.It is also easy to see the enormous impact of computers on everyday life.The importance of computers is such that it is appropriate to say that we are now living in the information age.This information revolution became possible thanks to the invention of the tran sistor, that is, thanks to the synergy between computer science and quantum physics.Today this synergy offers completely new opportunities and promises exciting advances in both funda mental science and technological application.We are referring here to the fact that quantum mechanics can be used to process and transmit information [1,2].Miniaturization provides us with an intuitive way of under standing why, in the near future, quantum laws will become important for computation.The electronics industry for com puters grows hand-in-hand with the decrease in size of integrated circuits.This miniaturization is necessary to increase computa tional power, that is, the number of floating-point operations per second (flops) a computer can perform.In the 1950's, electronic computers based on vacuum-tube technology were capable of performing approximately 103 floating-point operations per second, while nowadays there exist supercomputers whose power is greater than lOteraflops (1013 flops).As we have remarked, this enormous growth of computational power has been made possi ble owing to progress in m in ia tu riz a tio n , w hich m ay be quantified empirically in Moore's law.This law is the result of a remarkable observation made by Gordon Moore in 1965: the number of transistors on a single integrated-circuit chip doubles approximately every 18 24 months.This exponential growth has not yet saturated and Moore's law is still valid.At the present time the limit is approximately 108 transistors per chip and the typical size of circuit components is of the order of 100 nanometres.Extrapolating Moore's law, one would estimate that around the year 2020 we shall reach the atomic size for storing a single bit of inform atio n .At th a t p o in t, q u a n tu m effects will becom e unavoidably dominant.One should be aware that, besides quantum effects, other fac tors could bring Moore's law to an end.In the first place, there are economic considerations.Indeed, the cost of building fabri cation facilities to m an u factu re chips has also increased exponentially with time.Nevertheless, it is important to under stand the ultimate limitations set by quantum mechanics.Even though we might overcome economic barriers by means of tech nological breakthroughs, quantum physics sets fundamental limitations on the size of the circuit components.The first ques tion under debate is whether it would be more convenient to push References
There is a common wisdom according to which many technologies can progress according to some exponential law like the empirical Moore's law that was validated for over half a century with the growth of transistors number in chipsets. As a still in the making technology with a lot of potential promises, quantum computing is supposed to follow the pack and grow inexorably to maturity. The Holy Grail in that domain is a large quantum computer with thousands of errors corrected logical qubits made themselves of thousands, if not more, of physical qubits. These would enable molecular simulations as well as factoring 2048 RSA bit keys among other use cases taken from the intractable classical computing problems book. How far are we from this? Less than 15 years according to many predictions. We will see in this paper that Moore's empirical law cannot easily be translated to an equivalent in quantum computing. Qubits have various figures of merit that won't progress magically thanks to some new manufacturing technique capacity. However, some equivalents of Moore's law may be at play inside and outside the quantum realm like with quantum computers enabling technologies, cryogeny and control electronics. Algorithms, software tools and engineering also play a key role as enablers of quantum computing progress. While much of quantum computing future outcomes depends on qubit fidelities, it is progressing rather slowly, particularly at scale. We will finally see that other figures of merit will come into play and potentially change the landscape like the quality of computed results and the energetics of quantum computing. Although scientific and technological in nature, this inventory has broad business implications, on investment, education and cybersecurity related decision-making processes.
Quantum computing has emerged as a promising technology that can perform certain tasks exponentially faster than classical computers.Despite the potential for quantum computers to revolutionize the field of computing, the development of fault-tolerant quantum computers remains a critical challenge.Moore's Law has accurately predicted the exponential growth in the capacity of classical computers, with transistor capacity doubling roughly every year.This prediction, established in the 1960s, held true until the early 2010s.However, the emergence of quantum computers raises questions about how to predict the rate of development these technologies.This work presents a novel approach using machine learning to extend classical Moore's Law into a quantum Moore's Law.Unlike previous attempts, which relied on limited quantum computer data, this model incorporates historical classical transistor data to predict qubit capacities.This thesis proposes a novel approach to forecasting the future capacities of superconducting qubits and gate speeds using machine learning.The proposed model builds upon Moore's Law and its predictions for the transistor capacity of classical computers.First, it establishes a polynomial relationship between the number of qubits and the number of classical transistors.Then, it trains a machine learning model to predict the number of classical transistors for future years.This prediction is used in conjunction with the established relationship to estimate the number of qubits for a given year.The same methodology is applied on data on the best achieved classical computations per second values to predict the speed of execution of quantum gates in the future.The findings indicate that the proposed model outperforms previously proposed methods in predicting qubit capacities, suggesting an improved method for predicting the future capacities of superconducting qubits and gate speeds based on the relationship between qubit and classical transistor capacities.Using a data-driven approach, the model can incorporate new data as quantum milestones are achieved.In this study, we present a novel approach to predicting the growth of quantum computing i by extending and evolving classical Moore's Law using machine learning.Our proposed model makes use of historical information on classical transistors to estimate recent qubit capacities more accurately than earlier studies, showing improved prediction accuracy in comparison to previous work.The proposed model provides valuable insight into the potential trajectory of quantum computing technology if Moore's Law continues to hold in this domain. Summary for Lay AudienceQuantum computing has the potential to revolutionize computing by performing tasks much faster than classical computers.However, developing fault-tolerant quantum computers is a major challenge.While Moore's Law accurately predicted the growth of classical computers, the emergence of quantum computers raises questions about how to predict their development.This study presents a novel approach that combines machine learning with historical classical transistor data to forecast the capacities of quantum computers.The proposed model establishes a relationship between the number of qubits and classical transistors and uses machine learning to predict future transistor capacities.This prediction is then used to estimate the number of qubits for a given year.The same approach is applied to predict the speed of quantum gate execution.The results show that this model outperforms previous methods, providing more accurate predictions of qubit capacities.By incorporating new data as quantum milestones are achieved, the model can continuously improve its predictions.This study offers valuable insights into the potential growth of quantum computing if Moore's Law continues to apply in this domain.The proposed model extends and evolves classical Moore's Law using machine learning, leveraging historical information on classical transistors to estimate recent qubit capacities more accurately.Overall, this approach provides a promising method for predicting the future capacities of superconducting qubits and gate speeds in quantum computing.
Moore’s law will cease to be relevant once transistors are the size of electrons. Once this occurs, we will no longer be able to use silicon for technological advancement. However, breakthroughs will continue in the form of a sixth paradigm: a 3D molecular computing model such as quantum comput- ing. Some of the promising areas of quantum computing researched in this study are (i) algorithmic advancements - such as Shor’s, Grover’s, error correction, fault tolerance and other new algorithms; (ii) hardware - such as the quantum system architecture, circuit models, entanglement, superposition and no-cloning qubits; (iii) market segments - such as finance, healthcare, and chemistry; (iv) the supremacy established over classical computing; and (v) areas of applicability. Significant progress has been made in these areas in recent decades, and they have garnered immense interest, attention and the funding required to make good progress.