Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

The Principally Weak Points of the Currently Usual Mathematical Tools and Self-inconsistence in Quantum Theory

Nguyen Vinh Quang, Guillaume Adenier, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, PEKKA J. LAHTI, Vladimir I. Man’ko, Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen

Published Jan 1, 2007• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is explicitly shown the weak points (being not rigorous) in the reasoning of Dirac, of Landau, of Von Neumann, of Weyl, of Fadeev and of others, deriving many fundamental relations, which later became classical and are being commonly used in Quantum Theory up to now. It is because of their derivations were made when functional analysis was not yet sufficiently developed. Those weak points are of two following reasons:1. Unbounded property of the physical operators is not yet paid by attention.2. The “Dirac delta function” defined by Dirac is not always distinguished clearly with the Dirac distribution defined by Schwartz and with the generalized functions defined by Gel'fand.Particularly, the formulation of the closure relation by using equality of the functionals is not rigorous. Consequently, it is necessary to improve Quantum Theory.

DOI
10.1063/1.2827328

Related papers

Conventional Quantum Theory: Fundamentals

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

The aim of this chapter is to present (in a compact way) the fundamentals of conventional quantum theory. We select the for- mulation of QM as an axiomatic theory in the complete accordance with the Hilbert’s program on axiomatization of physical theories. We remark that the first step toward the present formulation of QM was done in the seminal work of Hilbert, Nordheim, and von Neumann [112]. This work was substantially extended, completed, and clarified in the book of von Neumann [296]. Another version of the rigorous mathematical approach to QM was presented in the book of Dirac [74]. From the mathematical viewpoint, the main difference between the approaches of von Neumann and Dirac is that the first one is based on the theory of self-adjoint operators in complex Hilbert space and the second one is based on the theory of self-adjoint operators acting (by using the modern mathematical terminology) in rigged Hilbert spaces. This theory operates with generalized eigenvectors belonging to the spaces of distributions. Although the von Neumann’s formalization of QM became dominant in quantum mathematical physics, the Dirac’s formalization is widely used in the works on the physical level of rigorousness. Moreover, the Dirac’s terminology, bra-and ket- vectors, became the standard for quantum information theory. However, since quantum information is based on the castrated version of QM, namely, QM in finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces, the so-called n-qubit spaces, the basic tool of the Dirac’s formalism, usage of generalized eigenvectors, is useless (since in the finite- dimensional case everything is reduced to manipulation with matrices). During the last 80 years, there were written hundreds of books on QM enlightening its foundational aspects. Unfortunately, the majority of these writings advertise exotic (and some of them really esoteric) views on QM and, in particular, on interpretation of the wave function. They are full of such terms as the collapse of the wave function, quantumnonlocality, manyworlds, thewave function of universe, the preparation of Schro¨dinger cats, influence of the future on the past, quantum teleportation. Of course, manipulations with such terminology create an atmosphere of mystery and a feeling that something unusual and impossible can happen. And this atmosphere plays a positive role in attracting young people to QM and especially to quantum foundations.

•Mar 19, 2014•0 citations

Dirac Formalism and Symmetry Problems in Quantum Mechanics. I. General Dirac Formalism

Jean-Pierre Antoine

Dirac's bra and ket formalism is investigated and incorporated into a complete mathematical theory. First the axiomatic foundations of quantum mechanics and von Neumann's spectral theory of observables are reviewed and several inadequacies are pointed out. These defects then are remedied by extending the usual Hilbert space to a rigged Hilbert space as introduced by Gel'fand, i.e., a triplet Φ⊂H⊂Φ′ where H is a Hilbert space, Φ a dense subspace of H provided with a new (finer) topology, Φ′ the dual of Φ. It is shown that this mathematical structure, together with the Schwartz nuclear theorem, allows us to reproduce Dirac's formalism in a completely rigorous way, without losing its transparency; this makes the theory easier to handle. The temporal evolution of the system and the wave equation are considered. Finally the probabilistic interpretation and the physical aspects of the theory are discussed; Φ is identified with the set of all physically accessible states of the system, Φ′ with the set of all possible experiments (apparatus) to which it can be subjected; this provides a direct connection with Feynman's formulation of quantum mechanics.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 1969•149 citations

Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics

Fumitomo Maeda

Although• quantum mechanics has achieved great success in the explanation of physical phenomena, the mathematics used in quantum mechanics is not rigorous.Unrigorous treatments occur in the case of continuous spectrum.In a Hilbert • space, let A be a self-adjoint operator.When we define the eigenvalue and the eigenelement by the ' ' relation Af=J.f, (1) ' ' h d -. -f(q)=).f(q)2m dq has solutions 2,ri f(q)=ce"Aq for any ;.., But these are not quadratically integrable.E. Hellinger and H. Weyi< 0 have already investigated the problem of continuous spectrum and introduced the " eigendifferential."But they are concerned with a special problem, i. e. bounded quadratic forms and solutions of differential equation.In respect of generality, they do not satisfy.< 2 > E. Fues< 3 > and some other writers<" have used this conception " eigendifferential " in quantum mechanics.But the treatments are either complicated or not rigorous.J. v. Neumann< 5 > has proved that in Hilbert space, for any selfadjoint operator A, there exists a resolution of identity E(;..) such that Af= J:and he has applied this theory to quantum mechanics.Although his theory gave a rigorous mathematical foundation to quantum mechanics, it did not give any interpretation to the representation theory of Dirac's form.Recently I investigated the "theory of vector-valued set functions."This theory removes the difficulties in the treatement of continuous spectrum, and gives a rigorous interpretation to the representation theory.< 5 > The vector-valued set function q(U) is a function of set U, and its functional value is an element (vector) in the Hilbert ,space, (1) E. Hellinger [l], 231-271.H. Weyl [1], 238-251.(2) T. Carlemann used this conception "eigendifferential" in the treatise of singular integral equations.Cf.T. Carlemann [1].(3) E. Fues [1], 295-303.(4) For example, L. de Broglie [2], 140-159.(5) J. v. Neumann [1], 53-121.(6) F. Maeda [2], [5], [6].A summary of the theory of vector-valued set functions is given in the first part Qf the present paper.(1) G. Temple has formulated a principle of quantum theory in which projective operators are given priority over self-adjoint operators.(C(.G. Temple [1)).But. the .whole discussion differs from that of my present paper.

Hiroshima Mathematical Journal•Jan 1, 1937•50 citations

Dirac's bra-ket notation and the notion of a quantum state

Arianna Borrelli

The relationship between physical notions and the structures expressing them is an issue of primary importance the history and philosophy of pre-modern natural philosophy and of modern science. Historical evidence suggests that, when investigating the relationship between physics and mathematics, one should pay attention to the material, sensually perceivable forms mediating it: spoken or written words, drawings, artefacts, descriptions of experimental set-ups or, as the case discussed the present paper, symbolic notation. The reason for this is that, historically, physical notions and their expressions have very often been developed as one, and only distinguished from each other at a later stage. This was for example the case with what we today regard as mathematical and classical mechanics, which were developed the course of the eighteenth century as the discipline of the analysis of motion. When considered from a later point of view, both the physical notions and the concepts involved historical developments appear as being in flux, vague, and, as far as the side is concerned, non-rigorous. In such cases, verbal description, mechanical artefacts or symbols do not simply mediate between physical notions and structures, as might be the case at a later stage, but represent both of them one, allowing the historical actors to construct and manipulate physical-mathematical meaning by following, at times, their physical reasoning and, at times, their criteria of rigour. The history of quantum mechanics offers many examples of how new physics and new mathematics can emerge as one, with symbolic notation playing a central role shaping both. Among the many creators of quantum theory, Paul Dirac was particularly sensitive to questions of notation:

•Jan 1, 2010•3 citations

Unified Dirac-Von Neumann Formulation of Quantum Mechanics. I. Mathematical Theory

A. R. Marlow

In this paper the results from various areas of mathematical research which are necessary for a consistent unification of the Dirac and von Neumann formulations of quantum mechanics are collected and presented as a single synthesis. For this purpose, direct integral decompositions of Hilbert space must be introduced into Dirac's formulation of spectral theory and representation theory; true unit vectors in the direct integral decomposition spaces replace unnormalizable vectors of infinite length. It then becomes clear that families of modified Dirac projection operators are simply related to the Radon-Nikodym derivative of von Neumann spectral measures. In terms of these mathematical preliminaries a second paper will present the more physical aspects of the resulting unified formulation of quantum mechanics.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jun 1, 1965•13 citations

Çeşitli kuantum sistemleri için Gel'fand üçlü uzay yapısının kurulması

Onur Genç

Kuantum mekaniğinin matematiksel yapısı matrisler ve diferansiyel işlemcilere dayanmaktadır. Bu işlemcilerin etki ettikleri vektör uzayı genellikle Hilbert uzayı olarak seçilmektedir. Ancak Hilbert uzayı, kuantum fiziğinin yaygın olarak kullanılan formülasyonu olan Dirac formülasyonu ve Dirac delta-fonksiyonunun tanımlanması için gerekli matematiksel alt yapıyı sağlayamamaktadır. Dirac formülasyonunun ve delta-fonksiyonunun matematiksel yapısını oluşturmak amacıyla, I. M Gelfand ve N. Ya. Vilenkin 1964 yılında, L. Schwartz tarafından geliştirilen dağılımlar teorisini geliştirerek Gel'fand üçlü uzay yapısını oluşturmuşlardır. Bu tezde, H. S. Green tarafından kuantum mekaniksel işlemcilerin spektrum ve özvektörlerinin bulunmasında kullanılan faktorizasyon yöntemi kullanılarak, çeşitli kuantum mekaniksel sistemlerin Gel'fand üçlü yapılarının elde edilebileceği gösterilmiştir. Örnek olarak, harmonik salınıcı ve sonsuz kuyu sistemlerinin Gel'fand üçlü uzay yapısı elde edilmiştir. Ayrıca, sonuç kısmında sonsuz kuyu potansiyelinde vektör uzayı olarak Hilbert uzayı seçildiğinde enerjinin karesi ve belirsizlik hesaplarında ortaya çıkan tutarsızlığın, Gel'fand üçlü yapısı seçildiğinde ortadan kaldırılabileceği gösterilmiştir. The mathematical structure of quantum mechanics depends on matrices and differential operators. The space which these operators act on is chosen as Hilbert space usually. However, the Hilbert space cannot provide the necessary mathematical structure which is needed to define the Dirac formulation and Dirac's delta-function used in quantum mechanics generally. In 1964 I. M Gelfand and N. Ya. Vilenkin invented the Gel'fand triplets by developing the distribution theory developed by L. Schwartz in order to create the mathematical structure of Dirac formulation and Dirac's delta-function. In this thesis, it has been represented that Gel'fand triplets of various quantum mechanical systems can be achieved by using the factorization method which is used by H. S. Green to determine the spectrum and eigenvectors of quantum mechanical operators. For example, the Gel'fand triplets of harmonic oscillator and infinite potential well has been achieved. Besides that, the fact that the inconsistency that arises during the calculation of energy squared and uncertainty when the Hilbert space is chosen as vector space can be removed if Gel'fand triplets are chosen.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations
It is explicitly shown the weak points (being not rigorous) in the reasoning of Dirac, of Landau, of Von Neumann, of Weyl, of Fadeev and of others, deriving many fundamental relations, which later became classical and are being commonly used in Quantum Theory up to now. It is because of their derivations were made when functional analysis was not yet sufficiently developed. Those weak points are of two following reasons:1. Unbounded property of the physical operators is not yet paid by attention.2. The “Dirac delta function” defined by Dirac is not always distinguished clearly with the Dirac distribution defined by Schwartz and with the generalized functions defined by Gel'fand.Particularly, the formulation of the closure relation by using equality of the functionals is not rigorous. Consequently, it is necessary to improve Quantum Theory.
The aim of this chapter is to present (in a compact way) the fundamentals of conventional quantum theory. We select the for- mulation of QM as an axiomatic theory in the complete accordance with the Hilbert’s program on axiomatization of physical theories. We remark that the first step toward the present formulation of QM was done in the seminal work of Hilbert, Nordheim, and von Neumann [112]. This work was substantially extended, completed, and clarified in the book of von Neumann [296]. Another version of the rigorous mathematical approach to QM was presented in the book of Dirac [74]. From the mathematical viewpoint, the main difference between the approaches of von Neumann and Dirac is that the first one is based on the theory of self-adjoint operators in complex Hilbert space and the second one is based on the theory of self-adjoint operators acting (by using the modern mathematical terminology) in rigged Hilbert spaces. This theory operates with generalized eigenvectors belonging to the spaces of distributions. Although the von Neumann’s formalization of QM became dominant in quantum mathematical physics, the Dirac’s formalization is widely used in the works on the physical level of rigorousness. Moreover, the Dirac’s terminology, bra-and ket- vectors, became the standard for quantum information theory. However, since quantum information is based on the castrated version of QM, namely, QM in finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces, the so-called n-qubit spaces, the basic tool of the Dirac’s formalism, usage of generalized eigenvectors, is useless (since in the finite- dimensional case everything is reduced to manipulation with matrices). During the last 80 years, there were written hundreds of books on QM enlightening its foundational aspects. Unfortunately, the majority of these writings advertise exotic (and some of them really esoteric) views on QM and, in particular, on interpretation of the wave function. They are full of such terms as the collapse of the wave function, quantumnonlocality, manyworlds, thewave function of universe, the preparation of Schro¨dinger cats, influence of the future on the past, quantum teleportation. Of course, manipulations with such terminology create an atmosphere of mystery and a feeling that something unusual and impossible can happen. And this atmosphere plays a positive role in attracting young people to QM and especially to quantum foundations.
Dirac's bra and ket formalism is investigated and incorporated into a complete mathematical theory. First the axiomatic foundations of quantum mechanics and von Neumann's spectral theory of observables are reviewed and several inadequacies are pointed out. These defects then are remedied by extending the usual Hilbert space to a rigged Hilbert space as introduced by Gel'fand, i.e., a triplet Φ⊂H⊂Φ′ where H is a Hilbert space, Φ a dense subspace of H provided with a new (finer) topology, Φ′ the dual of Φ. It is shown that this mathematical structure, together with the Schwartz nuclear theorem, allows us to reproduce Dirac's formalism in a completely rigorous way, without losing its transparency; this makes the theory easier to handle. The temporal evolution of the system and the wave equation are considered. Finally the probabilistic interpretation and the physical aspects of the theory are discussed; Φ is identified with the set of all physically accessible states of the system, Φ′ with the set of all possible experiments (apparatus) to which it can be subjected; this provides a direct connection with Feynman's formulation of quantum mechanics.
Although• quantum mechanics has achieved great success in the explanation of physical phenomena, the mathematics used in quantum mechanics is not rigorous.Unrigorous treatments occur in the case of continuous spectrum.In a Hilbert • space, let A be a self-adjoint operator.When we define the eigenvalue and the eigenelement by the ' ' relation Af=J.f, (1) ' ' h d -. -f(q)=).f(q)2m dq has solutions 2,ri f(q)=ce"Aq for any ;.., But these are not quadratically integrable.E. Hellinger and H. Weyi< 0 have already investigated the problem of continuous spectrum and introduced the " eigendifferential."But they are concerned with a special problem, i. e. bounded quadratic forms and solutions of differential equation.In respect of generality, they do not satisfy.< 2 > E. Fues< 3 > and some other writers<" have used this conception " eigendifferential " in quantum mechanics.But the treatments are either complicated or not rigorous.J. v. Neumann< 5 > has proved that in Hilbert space, for any selfadjoint operator A, there exists a resolution of identity E(;..) such that Af= J:and he has applied this theory to quantum mechanics.Although his theory gave a rigorous mathematical foundation to quantum mechanics, it did not give any interpretation to the representation theory of Dirac's form.Recently I investigated the "theory of vector-valued set functions."This theory removes the difficulties in the treatement of continuous spectrum, and gives a rigorous interpretation to the representation theory.< 5 > The vector-valued set function q(U) is a function of set U, and its functional value is an element (vector) in the Hilbert ,space, (1) E. Hellinger [l], 231-271.H. Weyl [1], 238-251.(2) T. Carlemann used this conception "eigendifferential" in the treatise of singular integral equations.Cf.T. Carlemann [1].(3) E. Fues [1], 295-303.(4) For example, L. de Broglie [2], 140-159.(5) J. v. Neumann [1], 53-121.(6) F. Maeda [2], [5], [6].A summary of the theory of vector-valued set functions is given in the first part Qf the present paper.(1) G. Temple has formulated a principle of quantum theory in which projective operators are given priority over self-adjoint operators.(C(.G. Temple [1)).But. the .whole discussion differs from that of my present paper.
The relationship between physical notions and the structures expressing them is an issue of primary importance the history and philosophy of pre-modern natural philosophy and of modern science. Historical evidence suggests that, when investigating the relationship between physics and mathematics, one should pay attention to the material, sensually perceivable forms mediating it: spoken or written words, drawings, artefacts, descriptions of experimental set-ups or, as the case discussed the present paper, symbolic notation. The reason for this is that, historically, physical notions and their expressions have very often been developed as one, and only distinguished from each other at a later stage. This was for example the case with what we today regard as mathematical and classical mechanics, which were developed the course of the eighteenth century as the discipline of the analysis of motion. When considered from a later point of view, both the physical notions and the concepts involved historical developments appear as being in flux, vague, and, as far as the side is concerned, non-rigorous. In such cases, verbal description, mechanical artefacts or symbols do not simply mediate between physical notions and structures, as might be the case at a later stage, but represent both of them one, allowing the historical actors to construct and manipulate physical-mathematical meaning by following, at times, their physical reasoning and, at times, their criteria of rigour. The history of quantum mechanics offers many examples of how new physics and new mathematics can emerge as one, with symbolic notation playing a central role shaping both. Among the many creators of quantum theory, Paul Dirac was particularly sensitive to questions of notation:
In this paper the results from various areas of mathematical research which are necessary for a consistent unification of the Dirac and von Neumann formulations of quantum mechanics are collected and presented as a single synthesis. For this purpose, direct integral decompositions of Hilbert space must be introduced into Dirac's formulation of spectral theory and representation theory; true unit vectors in the direct integral decomposition spaces replace unnormalizable vectors of infinite length. It then becomes clear that families of modified Dirac projection operators are simply related to the Radon-Nikodym derivative of von Neumann spectral measures. In terms of these mathematical preliminaries a second paper will present the more physical aspects of the resulting unified formulation of quantum mechanics.
Kuantum mekaniğinin matematiksel yapısı matrisler ve diferansiyel işlemcilere dayanmaktadır. Bu işlemcilerin etki ettikleri vektör uzayı genellikle Hilbert uzayı olarak seçilmektedir. Ancak Hilbert uzayı, kuantum fiziğinin yaygın olarak kullanılan formülasyonu olan Dirac formülasyonu ve Dirac delta-fonksiyonunun tanımlanması için gerekli matematiksel alt yapıyı sağlayamamaktadır. Dirac formülasyonunun ve delta-fonksiyonunun matematiksel yapısını oluşturmak amacıyla, I. M Gelfand ve N. Ya. Vilenkin 1964 yılında, L. Schwartz tarafından geliştirilen dağılımlar teorisini geliştirerek Gel'fand üçlü uzay yapısını oluşturmuşlardır. Bu tezde, H. S. Green tarafından kuantum mekaniksel işlemcilerin spektrum ve özvektörlerinin bulunmasında kullanılan faktorizasyon yöntemi kullanılarak, çeşitli kuantum mekaniksel sistemlerin Gel'fand üçlü yapılarının elde edilebileceği gösterilmiştir. Örnek olarak, harmonik salınıcı ve sonsuz kuyu sistemlerinin Gel'fand üçlü uzay yapısı elde edilmiştir. Ayrıca, sonuç kısmında sonsuz kuyu potansiyelinde vektör uzayı olarak Hilbert uzayı seçildiğinde enerjinin karesi ve belirsizlik hesaplarında ortaya çıkan tutarsızlığın, Gel'fand üçlü yapısı seçildiğinde ortadan kaldırılabileceği gösterilmiştir. The mathematical structure of quantum mechanics depends on matrices and differential operators. The space which these operators act on is chosen as Hilbert space usually. However, the Hilbert space cannot provide the necessary mathematical structure which is needed to define the Dirac formulation and Dirac's delta-function used in quantum mechanics generally. In 1964 I. M Gelfand and N. Ya. Vilenkin invented the Gel'fand triplets by developing the distribution theory developed by L. Schwartz in order to create the mathematical structure of Dirac formulation and Dirac's delta-function. In this thesis, it has been represented that Gel'fand triplets of various quantum mechanical systems can be achieved by using the factorization method which is used by H. S. Green to determine the spectrum and eigenvectors of quantum mechanical operators. For example, the Gel'fand triplets of harmonic oscillator and infinite potential well has been achieved. Besides that, the fact that the inconsistency that arises during the calculation of energy squared and uncertainty when the Hilbert space is chosen as vector space can be removed if Gel'fand triplets are chosen.