Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Two Notes on Quantum Conditions

John Hasbrouck Van Vleck

Published Dec 1, 1923• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Selection of coordinates for use in evaluating the Sommerfield quantum integrals.---It is well known that these coordinates need not necessarily satisfy Lagrange's equations, and a general criterion for the choice of such variables is given in the present paper, in which it is shown that all sets of $p$'s and $q$'s which (a) satisfy Hamilton's equations, (b) separate the variables, and (c) are of such a character that the average value of the kinetic energy is equal to that of $\frac{1}{2}\ensuremath{\Sigma}{1}^{n}{p}_{i}{\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{q}}_{i}$, will give the correct energy levels when employed in the quantum integrals $\ensuremath{\int}{p}_{i}d{q}_{i}={n}_{i}h$; ($i=1,2,\ensuremath{\cdots}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{},n$). This general class of coordinate systems includes as special cases the familiar normalized Schwarzschild angle variables and Lagrangian generalized coordinates which separate the variables.Combination of Hamilton's principle with Trkal's method for quantizing conditionally periodic systems is proposed which, like Hamilton's principle, determines the character of the motion permitted by the Newtonian dynamics, and in addition quantizes the orbits by specializing the constants of integration in accordance with the conventional quantum conditions. This variation principle includes formally in a single equation the results of classical dynamics and the Sommerfield quantum conditions, which together determine the sizes and shapes of electronic orbits. The principle is illustrated by an application to a non-linear oscillator in which the potential involves the second and fourth powers of the displacement from the equilibrium position.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.22.547

Related papers

Proposal for the Quantum Mechanical Orbit Equation

Yoshio Nishiyama

The orbit equation for the motion of a quantum in a potential is proposed by defining uniquely the quantum mechanical momentum from the Schrodinger wave equation of a one-particle system and using the Hamilton-Jacobi formalism. On this occasion it is necessary to introduce a new dynamical postulate, “initial condition”, which is independent of the quantization condition as well as of the Schrodinger wave equation. The momentum is determined in such a way that it is approximately equal to the corresponding classical mechanical momentum in the classical region of validity of the coordinates. The momentum in the non-classical region is in general very small in comparison with that in the classical region. The quantum-mechanical motion well corresponds to the classical motion. If a system is macroscopic, the motion of the particle is described by Newtonian mechanics and the quantization condition is of no validity. The “quantization of magnetic flux” derives from the quantization condition. It is closely related to the energy level structure of the atomic system. The above argument is applied to the scalar electromagnetic and sound wave equations to give the dynamical motion of a photon and a phonon without recourse to the so-called second quantization method.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Sep 1, 1965•0 citations

Periodic Orbits and Classical Quantization Conditions

Martin C. Gutzwiller

The relation between the solutions of the time-independent Schrödinger equation and the periodic orbits of the corresponding classical system is examined in the case where neither can be found by the separation of variables. If the quasiclassical approximation for the Green's function is integrated over the coordinates, a response function for the system is obtained which depends only on the energy and whose singularities give the approximate eigenvalues of the energy. This response function is written as a sum over all periodic orbits where each term has a phase factor containing the action integral and the number of conjugate points, as well as an amplitude factor containing the period and the stability exponent of the orbit. In terms of the approximate density of states per unit interval of energy, each stable periodic orbit is shown to yield a series of δ functions whose locations are given by a simple quantum condition: The action integral differs from an integer multiple of h by half the stability angle times ℏ. Unstable periodic orbits give a series of broadened peaks whose half-width equals the stability exponent times ℏ, whereas the location of the maxima is given again by a simple quantum condition. These results are applied to the anisotropic Kepler problem, i.e., an electron with an anisotropic mass tensor moving in a (spherically symmetric) Coulomb field. A class of simply closed, periodic orbits is found by a Fourier expansion method as in Hill's theory of the moon. They are shown to yield a well-defined set of levels, whose energy is compared with recent variational calculations of Faulkner on shallow bound states of donor impurities in semiconductors. The agreement is good for silicon, but only fair for the more anisotropic germanium.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1971•1,504 citations

Unified Variational Formulation of Classical and Quantum Dynamics. II

Edward M. Corson

In a previous article in this series [E. M. Corson, J. Math. Phys. 4, 42(1963); herein referred to as I], we showed that a new variational principle, of Lagrangian structure, includes Hamilton's principle as a unique derived consequent and encompasses both the classical and quantal definitions of ``state'' and the corresponding Lagrangian and Schrödinger equations of motion, respectively. In this theory, the essential difference between classical and quantal domains was shown to arise solely from the superadded postulates of determinism vs indeterminism; other than this, the two basic postulates may be reduced to (a) Newton's equations and (b) the new variation principle. It was shown that in the quantal domain, Schrödinger's equations obtain for the transition amplitudes (propagators) between pure eigenstates of homologous variables in configuration space, at different times, thus clearly implying all the results of conventional Hamiltonian-operator quantum formalism. In the present article we show that our variational formulation, under the familiar classical canonical transformation to momentum space, also automatically leads to the corresponding Schrödinger equations for the transition amplitudes between pure eigenstates of homologous variables in momentum space, at different times, the unitarity of the formalism and the reciprocal Fourier integral relations between coordinate and momentum representations. Thus we bridge a long-standing gap in theory and derive, uniquely and apparently for the first time, the basic quantum commutators (P.B.'s) which are postulated in the more familiar Hamiltonian theory.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Apr 1, 1963•1 citation

Quantization of Equations of Motion

Denis Kochan

The Classical Newton-Lagrange equations of motion represent the fundamental physical law of mechanics. Their traditional Lagrangian and/or Hamiltonian precursors when available are essential in the context of quantization. However, there are situations that lack Lagrangian and/or Hamiltonian settings. This paper discusses a description of classical dynamics and presents some irresponsible speculations about its quantization by introducing a certain canonical two-form ?. By its construction ? embodies kinetic energy and forces acting within the system (not their potential). A new type of variational principle employing differential two-form ? is introduced. Variation is performed over “umbilical surfaces“ instead of system histories. It provides correct Newton-Lagrange equations of motion. The quantization is inspired by the Feynman path integral approach. The quintessence is to rearrange it into an “umbilical world-sheet“ functional integral in accordance with the proposed variational principle. In the case of potential-generated forces, the new approach reduces to the standard quantum mechanics. As an example, Quantum Mechanics with friction is analyzed in detail.

Acta Polytechnica•Jan 2, 2007•4 citations

On the quantization of a theory arising from a variational principle for multiple integrals with application to born's electrodynamics

P. Weiss

Abstract The transition from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics has been formulated in various ways. But all these ways have the common feature that they use as starting point mechanics not in its Newtonian form, but in the form which it was given by Lagrange and Hamilton. The essence of this form consists in the fact that the differential equations are represented as Euler equations of a variational principle for v functions, the generalized coordinates, of one variable, the time. In its purely mathematical aspect the quantization method may, therefore, be regarded as a mode of taking certain notions and certain relations arising from a variational principle for several dependent and one independent variable and of giving them a new meaning.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Aug 1, 1936•20 citations

The Generalized Hamilton Principle and Non-Hermitian Quantum Theory

Xiang-Yao Wu, Ben-Shan Wu, Xiaojing Liu +6 more

Abstract The Hamilton principle is a variation principle describing the isolated and conservative systems, its Lagrange function is the difference between kinetic energy and potential energy. By Feynman path integration, we can obtain the Hermitian quantum theory, i.e., the standard Schrodinger equation. In this paper, we have generalized the Hamilton principle to the generalized Hamilton principle, which can describe the open system (mass or energy exchange systems) and nonconservative force systems or dissipative systems, and given the generalized Lagrange function, it has to do with the kinetic energy, potential energy and the work of nonconservative forces to do. With the Feynman path integration, we have given the non-Hermitian quantum theory of the nonconservative force systems. Otherwise, with the generalized Hamilton principle, we have given the generalized Hamiltonian for the particle exchanging heat with the outside world, which is the sum of kinetic energy, potential energy and thermal energy, and further given the equation of quantum thermodynamics. PACS: 03.65.-w, 05.70.Ce, 05.30.Rt

arXiv:2110.04524•Jun 30, 2021•0 citations
Selection of coordinates for use in evaluating the Sommerfield quantum integrals.---It is well known that these coordinates need not necessarily satisfy Lagrange's equations, and a general criterion for the choice of such variables is given in the present paper, in which it is shown that all sets of ppp's and qqq's which (a) satisfy Hamilton's equations, (b) separate the variables, and (c) are of such a character that the average value of the kinetic energy is equal to that of 12\ensuremathΣ1npiq\ifmmode˙\else˙\fii\frac{1}{2}\ensuremath{\Sigma}{1}^{n}{p}_{i}{\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{q}}_{i}21​\ensuremathΣ1npi​q\ifmmode˙\else˙\fi​i​, will give the correct energy levels when employed in the quantum integrals \ensuremath∫pidqi=nih\ensuremath{\int}{p}_{i}d{q}_{i}={n}_{i}h\ensuremath∫pi​dqi​=ni​h; (i=1,2,\ensuremath⋯\ifmmode⋅\else\textperiodcentered\fi\ifmmode⋅\else\textperiodcentered\fi,ni=1,2,\ensuremath{\cdots}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{},ni=1,2,\ensuremath⋯\ifmmode⋅\else\textperiodcentered\fi\ifmmode⋅\else\textperiodcentered\fi,n). This general class of coordinate systems includes as special cases the familiar normalized Schwarzschild angle variables and Lagrangian generalized coordinates which separate the variables.Combination of Hamilton's principle with Trkal's method for quantizing conditionally periodic systems is proposed which, like Hamilton's principle, determines the character of the motion permitted by the Newtonian dynamics, and in addition quantizes the orbits by specializing the constants of integration in accordance with the conventional quantum conditions. This variation principle includes formally in a single equation the results of classical dynamics and the Sommerfield quantum conditions, which together determine the sizes and shapes of electronic orbits. The principle is illustrated by an application to a non-linear oscillator in which the potential involves the second and fourth powers of the displacement from the equilibrium position.
The orbit equation for the motion of a quantum in a potential is proposed by defining uniquely the quantum mechanical momentum from the Schrodinger wave equation of a one-particle system and using the Hamilton-Jacobi formalism. On this occasion it is necessary to introduce a new dynamical postulate, “initial condition”, which is independent of the quantization condition as well as of the Schrodinger wave equation. The momentum is determined in such a way that it is approximately equal to the corresponding classical mechanical momentum in the classical region of validity of the coordinates. The momentum in the non-classical region is in general very small in comparison with that in the classical region. The quantum-mechanical motion well corresponds to the classical motion. If a system is macroscopic, the motion of the particle is described by Newtonian mechanics and the quantization condition is of no validity. The “quantization of magnetic flux” derives from the quantization condition. It is closely related to the energy level structure of the atomic system. The above argument is applied to the scalar electromagnetic and sound wave equations to give the dynamical motion of a photon and a phonon without recourse to the so-called second quantization method.
The relation between the solutions of the time-independent Schrödinger equation and the periodic orbits of the corresponding classical system is examined in the case where neither can be found by the separation of variables. If the quasiclassical approximation for the Green's function is integrated over the coordinates, a response function for the system is obtained which depends only on the energy and whose singularities give the approximate eigenvalues of the energy. This response function is written as a sum over all periodic orbits where each term has a phase factor containing the action integral and the number of conjugate points, as well as an amplitude factor containing the period and the stability exponent of the orbit. In terms of the approximate density of states per unit interval of energy, each stable periodic orbit is shown to yield a series of δ functions whose locations are given by a simple quantum condition: The action integral differs from an integer multiple of h by half the stability angle times ℏ. Unstable periodic orbits give a series of broadened peaks whose half-width equals the stability exponent times ℏ, whereas the location of the maxima is given again by a simple quantum condition. These results are applied to the anisotropic Kepler problem, i.e., an electron with an anisotropic mass tensor moving in a (spherically symmetric) Coulomb field. A class of simply closed, periodic orbits is found by a Fourier expansion method as in Hill's theory of the moon. They are shown to yield a well-defined set of levels, whose energy is compared with recent variational calculations of Faulkner on shallow bound states of donor impurities in semiconductors. The agreement is good for silicon, but only fair for the more anisotropic germanium.
In a previous article in this series [E. M. Corson, J. Math. Phys. 4, 42(1963); herein referred to as I], we showed that a new variational principle, of Lagrangian structure, includes Hamilton's principle as a unique derived consequent and encompasses both the classical and quantal definitions of ``state'' and the corresponding Lagrangian and Schrödinger equations of motion, respectively. In this theory, the essential difference between classical and quantal domains was shown to arise solely from the superadded postulates of determinism vs indeterminism; other than this, the two basic postulates may be reduced to (a) Newton's equations and (b) the new variation principle. It was shown that in the quantal domain, Schrödinger's equations obtain for the transition amplitudes (propagators) between pure eigenstates of homologous variables in configuration space, at different times, thus clearly implying all the results of conventional Hamiltonian-operator quantum formalism. In the present article we show that our variational formulation, under the familiar classical canonical transformation to momentum space, also automatically leads to the corresponding Schrödinger equations for the transition amplitudes between pure eigenstates of homologous variables in momentum space, at different times, the unitarity of the formalism and the reciprocal Fourier integral relations between coordinate and momentum representations. Thus we bridge a long-standing gap in theory and derive, uniquely and apparently for the first time, the basic quantum commutators (P.B.'s) which are postulated in the more familiar Hamiltonian theory.
The Classical Newton-Lagrange equations of motion represent the fundamental physical law of mechanics. Their traditional Lagrangian and/or Hamiltonian precursors when available are essential in the context of quantization. However, there are situations that lack Lagrangian and/or Hamiltonian settings. This paper discusses a description of classical dynamics and presents some irresponsible speculations about its quantization by introducing a certain canonical two-form ?. By its construction ? embodies kinetic energy and forces acting within the system (not their potential). A new type of variational principle employing differential two-form ? is introduced. Variation is performed over “umbilical surfaces“ instead of system histories. It provides correct Newton-Lagrange equations of motion. The quantization is inspired by the Feynman path integral approach. The quintessence is to rearrange it into an “umbilical world-sheet“ functional integral in accordance with the proposed variational principle. In the case of potential-generated forces, the new approach reduces to the standard quantum mechanics. As an example, Quantum Mechanics with friction is analyzed in detail.
Abstract The transition from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics has been formulated in various ways. But all these ways have the common feature that they use as starting point mechanics not in its Newtonian form, but in the form which it was given by Lagrange and Hamilton. The essence of this form consists in the fact that the differential equations are represented as Euler equations of a variational principle for v functions, the generalized coordinates, of one variable, the time. In its purely mathematical aspect the quantization method may, therefore, be regarded as a mode of taking certain notions and certain relations arising from a variational principle for several dependent and one independent variable and of giving them a new meaning.
Abstract The Hamilton principle is a variation principle describing the isolated and conservative systems, its Lagrange function is the difference between kinetic energy and potential energy. By Feynman path integration, we can obtain the Hermitian quantum theory, i.e., the standard Schrodinger equation. In this paper, we have generalized the Hamilton principle to the generalized Hamilton principle, which can describe the open system (mass or energy exchange systems) and nonconservative force systems or dissipative systems, and given the generalized Lagrange function, it has to do with the kinetic energy, potential energy and the work of nonconservative forces to do. With the Feynman path integration, we have given the non-Hermitian quantum theory of the nonconservative force systems. Otherwise, with the generalized Hamilton principle, we have given the generalized Hamiltonian for the particle exchanging heat with the outside world, which is the sum of kinetic energy, potential energy and thermal energy, and further given the equation of quantum thermodynamics. PACS: 03.65.-w, 05.70.Ce, 05.30.Rt