Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Essays

Instantaneous Relativistic Action‐at‐a‐Distance

N. Vivian Pope, Anthony D. Osborne

Published Sep 1, 1992• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is popularly believed that there is some strange disparity between quantum physics and physics generally, that whereas ordinary physical interaction takes time to travel, at speeds up to the finite limit c, quantum interaction (action-at-a-distance) is instantaneous, regardless of distance. We shall demonstrate that there is nothing paradoxical about this situation, by proposing a new phenomenalistic approach to relativity in which the 'photon' ceases to be a space-travelling action-capsule and becomes, instead, an irreducible element of those informational timesequences out of which the phenomena of distance and motion are observationally projected.

DOI
10.4006/1.3029001

Related papers

Relativistic Quantum Dynamics: A non-traditional perspective on space, time, particles, fields, and action-at-a-distance

Eugene V. Stefanovich

This book is an attempt to build a consistent relativistic quantum theory of interacting particles. In the first part of the book "Quantum electrodynamics" we follow rather traditional approach to particle physics. Our discussion proceeds systematically from the principle of relativity and postulates of quantum measurements to the renormalization in quantum electrodynamics. In the second part of the book "Quantum theory of particles" this traditional approach is reexamined. We find that formulas of special relativity should be modified to take into account particle interactions. We also suggest reinterpreting quantum field theory in the language of physical "dressed" particles. This formulation eliminates the need for renormalization and opens up a new way for studying dynamical and bound state properties of quantum interacting systems. The developed theory is applied to realistic physical objects and processes including the energy spectrum of the hydrogen atom, the decay law of moving unstable particles, and the electric field of relativistic electron beams. These results force us to take a fresh look at some core issues of modern particle theories, in particular, the Minkowski space-time unification, the role of quantum fields and renormalization as well as the alleged impossibility of action-at-a-distance. A new perspective on these issues is suggested. It can help to solve the old problem of theoretical physics -- a consistent unification of relativity and quantum mechanics.

arXiv:physics/0504062•Apr 8, 2005•36 citations

Clocking the signal of entanglement

It is the tenet of quantum mechanics that Einstein rejected as “spooky action at a distance”: if two particles are entangled, then any tinkering with one can cause an instantaneous change in the other – no matter how far apart they may be. But what if quantum mechanics is not quite right – that the change is not instantaneous but instead prompted by a signal transmitted between the two entangled particles? Now an experiment in Switzerland has shown that if such a signal does exist, then it would have to travel at least at the speed of light, and probably thousands of times faster.

Physics World•Sep 1, 2008•0 citations

On the Appearance of Action at a Distance

L.G. van Willigenburg, Andrew Laidlaw

Abstract After forty years of EPR experiments, it appears on the face of the experimental facts that one of the oldest ideas in Physics has been falsified, namely the retarded interaction paradigm, the notion that long range interactions between quanta, or equivalently causal influences between point events, are mediated by physical entities - fields, particles or “causal influences” in general - that travel through space from one point to the other at or below the characteristic velocity, c. A critical examination of this basic idea shows it to be unsatisfactory in all respects. An alternative is then proposed that satisfies both causality and local action, “distributed action”, which is germane to local realist field models of the quanta, where matter and energy extend in space and interact locally and causally at all locations where they overlap. Bell Inequalities cannot be derived in this context because, with distributed fieldfield interactions, spacelike separation of events does not guarantee the fundamental “no influence” assumption from which all the various Bell Inequalities are derived. Distributed action thus explains what appears to us as instantaneous action at a distance. PACS: 03.65.Ud 03.75.-b

•Aug 1, 2023•1 citation

Action at a distance and causality in quantum theory

Jerome Blackman

The relation between quantum theory and special relativity is peculiar. On the one hand it is close and essential. Steven Weinberg [1], for example, takes the position that the standard model is an inevitable consequence of the marriage of the two theories. On the other, the action at a distance implied by the famous paper by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen [2] is certainly contrary to the implications of special relativity in spite of the fact that it does not allow transmission of information. The setting of quantum theory is a Hilbert spaceH and a path inH whose development in time is governed by a one parameter group of unitary transformations while the setting for special relativity can be thought of as Minkowski space with the time development not absolute, but dependent on the inertial system of the observer. The problem is to show how these two very different viewpoints can be reconciled in a way that includes an explanation of the "action at a distance" conundrum.

arXiv:1310.7438•Oct 28, 2013•0 citations

Albert’s discontent

Albert Einstein did not like quantum mechanics. He never believed in the underlying principles of the theory. He thought they were too radical. Given that Einstein was the genius behind some of the most radical ideas in 20th-century physics, one should probably take his rejection of quantum mechanics seriously. After all, when it came to scientific innovation, Albert was a pretty open-minded guy. His 1905 theory of special relativity incorporated some very strange concepts. To begin with, it proposed that nothing could travel faster than the speed of light. In addition, it claimed that rulers become shorter, clocks tick slower and objects become heavier whenever they travel close to the speed of light. It even suggested that many of the qualities of everyday objects (such as length, duration and mass) are not defined in absolute terms, but instead depend on the relative speed of the observer and the object. To most people in 1905, these were pretty wild ideas, but to Einstein's thinking they were perfectly reasonable. Quantum mechanics, on the other hand, was way too strange for his taste.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 20, 2026•0 citations

BECOMING AS A BRIDGE BETWEEN QUANTUM MECHANICS AND RELATIVITY

Avshalom C. Elitzur, Shahar Dolev

Time’s apparent “flow” is often dismissed in physical theory. We propose to take it as a real property of reality and show how the addition of this assumption to physics’ prevailing postulate yields a new framework within which relativity and quantum theories are in harmony with one another.

Endophysics, Time, Quantum and the Subjective•Oct 1, 2005•24 citations
It is popularly believed that there is some strange disparity between quantum physics and physics generally, that whereas ordinary physical interaction takes time to travel, at speeds up to the finite limit c, quantum interaction (action-at-a-distance) is instantaneous, regardless of distance. We shall demonstrate that there is nothing paradoxical about this situation, by proposing a new phenomenalistic approach to relativity in which the 'photon' ceases to be a space-travelling action-capsule and becomes, instead, an irreducible element of those informational timesequences out of which the phenomena of distance and motion are observationally projected.
This book is an attempt to build a consistent relativistic quantum theory of interacting particles. In the first part of the book "Quantum electrodynamics" we follow rather traditional approach to particle physics. Our discussion proceeds systematically from the principle of relativity and postulates of quantum measurements to the renormalization in quantum electrodynamics. In the second part of the book "Quantum theory of particles" this traditional approach is reexamined. We find that formulas of special relativity should be modified to take into account particle interactions. We also suggest reinterpreting quantum field theory in the language of physical "dressed" particles. This formulation eliminates the need for renormalization and opens up a new way for studying dynamical and bound state properties of quantum interacting systems. The developed theory is applied to realistic physical objects and processes including the energy spectrum of the hydrogen atom, the decay law of moving unstable particles, and the electric field of relativistic electron beams. These results force us to take a fresh look at some core issues of modern particle theories, in particular, the Minkowski space-time unification, the role of quantum fields and renormalization as well as the alleged impossibility of action-at-a-distance. A new perspective on these issues is suggested. It can help to solve the old problem of theoretical physics -- a consistent unification of relativity and quantum mechanics.
It is the tenet of quantum mechanics that Einstein rejected as “spooky action at a distance”: if two particles are entangled, then any tinkering with one can cause an instantaneous change in the other – no matter how far apart they may be. But what if quantum mechanics is not quite right – that the change is not instantaneous but instead prompted by a signal transmitted between the two entangled particles? Now an experiment in Switzerland has shown that if such a signal does exist, then it would have to travel at least at the speed of light, and probably thousands of times faster.
Abstract After forty years of EPR experiments, it appears on the face of the experimental facts that one of the oldest ideas in Physics has been falsified, namely the retarded interaction paradigm, the notion that long range interactions between quanta, or equivalently causal influences between point events, are mediated by physical entities - fields, particles or “causal influences” in general - that travel through space from one point to the other at or below the characteristic velocity, c. A critical examination of this basic idea shows it to be unsatisfactory in all respects. An alternative is then proposed that satisfies both causality and local action, “distributed action”, which is germane to local realist field models of the quanta, where matter and energy extend in space and interact locally and causally at all locations where they overlap. Bell Inequalities cannot be derived in this context because, with distributed fieldfield interactions, spacelike separation of events does not guarantee the fundamental “no influence” assumption from which all the various Bell Inequalities are derived. Distributed action thus explains what appears to us as instantaneous action at a distance. PACS: 03.65.Ud 03.75.-b
The relation between quantum theory and special relativity is peculiar. On the one hand it is close and essential. Steven Weinberg [1], for example, takes the position that the standard model is an inevitable consequence of the marriage of the two theories. On the other, the action at a distance implied by the famous paper by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen [2] is certainly contrary to the implications of special relativity in spite of the fact that it does not allow transmission of information. The setting of quantum theory is a Hilbert spaceH and a path inH whose development in time is governed by a one parameter group of unitary transformations while the setting for special relativity can be thought of as Minkowski space with the time development not absolute, but dependent on the inertial system of the observer. The problem is to show how these two very different viewpoints can be reconciled in a way that includes an explanation of the "action at a distance" conundrum.
Albert Einstein did not like quantum mechanics. He never believed in the underlying principles of the theory. He thought they were too radical. Given that Einstein was the genius behind some of the most radical ideas in 20th-century physics, one should probably take his rejection of quantum mechanics seriously. After all, when it came to scientific innovation, Albert was a pretty open-minded guy. His 1905 theory of special relativity incorporated some very strange concepts. To begin with, it proposed that nothing could travel faster than the speed of light. In addition, it claimed that rulers become shorter, clocks tick slower and objects become heavier whenever they travel close to the speed of light. It even suggested that many of the qualities of everyday objects (such as length, duration and mass) are not defined in absolute terms, but instead depend on the relative speed of the observer and the object. To most people in 1905, these were pretty wild ideas, but to Einstein's thinking they were perfectly reasonable. Quantum mechanics, on the other hand, was way too strange for his taste.