Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Entropy and Indistinguishability

David Hestenes

Published Jul 1, 1970• 45 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is argued that the principle of indistinguishability of identical particles is a necessary condition for consistency between experimental and statistical descriptions of a many-particle system. Therefore, it is not a special feature of quantum theory, and its use is perfectly justified in classical statistical mechanics.
DOI
10.1119/1.1976480

Related papers

The Gibbs paradox and the physical criteria for indistinguishability of identical particles

C. S. Unnikrishnan

Gibbs paradox in the context of statistical mechanics addresses the issue of additivity of entropy of mixing gases. The usual discussion attributes the paradoxical situation to classical distinguishability of identical particles and credits quantum theory for enabling indistinguishability of identical particles to solve the problem. We argue that indistinguishability of identical particles is already a feature in classical mechanics and this is clearly brought out when the problem is treated in the language of information and associated entropy. We pinpoint the physical criteria for indistinguishability that is crucial for the treatment of the Gibbs’ problem and the consistency of its solution with conventional thermodynamics. Quantum mechanics provides a quantitative criterion, not possible in the classical picture, for the degree of indistinguishability in terms of visibility of quantum interference, or overlap of the states as pointed out by von Neumann, thereby endowing the entropy expression with mathematical continuity and physical reasonableness.

arXiv:1811.03967•International Journal of Quantum Information•Aug 18, 2016•2 citations

The fraction of “all different” combinations: Justifying the semiclassical partition function

Ralph F. Baierlein

Modern statistical mechanics directly acknowledges the indistinguishability of identical particles, a characteristically quantum property. Under laboratory conditions such that classical physics ought to suffice for most purposes, the indistinguishability is often incorporated by a judicious division by N!. This paper explores a common justification for that procedure—and finds it wanting. Nonetheless, the procedure is valid, but for a different reason.

American Journal of Physics•Apr 1, 1997•3 citations

IDENTICAL PARTICLES ARE INHERENTLY INDISTINGUISHABLE

The preceding development has been specifically restricted to systems of identical indistinguishable particles, but no further conditions were imposed on the particles or their microstates. The relations derived in Chapter 8 are therefore equally applicable to systems of identical particles in both classical and quantum mechanics, provided the particles are regarded as indistinguishable . As discussed in the Preface and Introduction, it is our firm conviction that identical particles, by their very nature, are indeed inherently and unconditionally indistinguishable. If that proposition is accepted, the relations of Chapter 8 combine with the results of previous chapters to provide a unified general statistical formalism which applies to both classical and quantum particles. However, the appealing simplicity of this picture is undermined by the widespread misconception that identical classical particles are distinguishable, at least in principle, and must be treated as such. In this section we discuss the apparent origins and rationale for this unfortunate misconception in an attempt to reconstruct and rectify the fallacious notions on which it is based.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 22, 2017•0 citations

Classical Particle Indistinguishability, Precisely

James Wills

I present a new perspective on the meaning of indistinguishability of classical particles. This leads to a solution to the problem in statistical mechanics of justifying the inclusion of a factor N! in a probability distribution over the phase space of N indistinguishable classical particles.

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Apr 15, 2021•2 citations

Anyons for anyone

Frank A. Wilczek

Quantum mechanics gives a sharp new meaning to the concept of indenticalness or indistinguishability, which is not present in classical physics. Its tangible manifestation is in the existence of special "effective interactions" or "statistical forces" between exactly identical particles, that do not exist between particles which are merely very similar.

Physics World•Jan 1, 1991•4 citations

The Gibbs Paradox. About the paradox and the indistinguishability of identical particles

S.C. van Berkum

The Gibbs Paradox is an important question in thermodynamics. In this thesis I search for a solution for the paradox from a classical, philosophical and quantum mechanical point of view. A common way to solve the Gibbs Paradox is by using the reduced entropy. However, this definition of entropy should not be interpreted as an argument for the indistinguishability of identical particles, because all other particles which have unique trajectories through space-time are distinguishable in principle. The Gibbs paradox could be solved in a few ways, but each solution has certain constrains.

•May 26, 2014•0 citations
Gibbs paradox in the context of statistical mechanics addresses the issue of additivity of entropy of mixing gases. The usual discussion attributes the paradoxical situation to classical distinguishability of identical particles and credits quantum theory for enabling indistinguishability of identical particles to solve the problem. We argue that indistinguishability of identical particles is already a feature in classical mechanics and this is clearly brought out when the problem is treated in the language of information and associated entropy. We pinpoint the physical criteria for indistinguishability that is crucial for the treatment of the Gibbs’ problem and the consistency of its solution with conventional thermodynamics. Quantum mechanics provides a quantitative criterion, not possible in the classical picture, for the degree of indistinguishability in terms of visibility of quantum interference, or overlap of the states as pointed out by von Neumann, thereby endowing the entropy expression with mathematical continuity and physical reasonableness.
The preceding development has been specifically restricted to systems of identical indistinguishable particles, but no further conditions were imposed on the particles or their microstates. The relations derived in Chapter 8 are therefore equally applicable to systems of identical particles in both classical and quantum mechanics, provided the particles are regarded as indistinguishable . As discussed in the Preface and Introduction, it is our firm conviction that identical particles, by their very nature, are indeed inherently and unconditionally indistinguishable. If that proposition is accepted, the relations of Chapter 8 combine with the results of previous chapters to provide a unified general statistical formalism which applies to both classical and quantum particles. However, the appealing simplicity of this picture is undermined by the widespread misconception that identical classical particles are distinguishable, at least in principle, and must be treated as such. In this section we discuss the apparent origins and rationale for this unfortunate misconception in an attempt to reconstruct and rectify the fallacious notions on which it is based.
The Gibbs Paradox is an important question in thermodynamics. In this thesis I search for a solution for the paradox from a classical, philosophical and quantum mechanical point of view. A common way to solve the Gibbs Paradox is by using the reduced entropy. However, this definition of entropy should not be interpreted as an argument for the indistinguishability of identical particles, because all other particles which have unique trajectories through space-time are distinguishable in principle. The Gibbs paradox could be solved in a few ways, but each solution has certain constrains.