Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Analysis

Why you don't want to get in the box with Schrodinger's cat

David Papineau

Published Jan 1, 2003• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

By way of an example, Lewis imagines your being invited to join Schrodinger’s cat in its box for an hour. This box will either fill up with deadly poison fumes or not, depending on whether or not some radioactive atom decays, the probability of decay within an hour being 50%. The invitation is accompanied with some further incentive to comply (Lewis sets it up so there is a significant chance of some pretty bad but not life-threatening punishment if you don’t get in the box). Lewis argues that the many minds theory implies that you should get in the box with the cat, despite this making it 50% likely you will die.

DOI
10.1093/analys/63.1.51

Related papers

Quantum largesse

In 1935 Erwin Schrödinger proposed a thought experiment to show the absurd consequences of applying quantum mechanics to everyday objects. Schrödinger imagined placing a cat in a box, along with a vial of deadly poison that is connected to a radioactive atom. If the atom decays, it releases the poison and kills the cat. When the box is closed we do not know if the atom has decayed or not, which means that it can be in a "superposition" of two states (decayed and non-decayed) at the same time. Therefore, protested Schrödinger, the cat can be both dead and alive at the same time – which is clearly absurd. There was obviously, he thought, some boundary between the microscopic world of atoms and quantum mechanics, and the macroscopic world of cats and classical mechanics.

Physics World•Aug 1, 2000•0 citations

Schrödinger's Box, the Archives, and You

Gabriela Radulescu

Schrodinger's conceptual model of probable described a closed box containing a cat and a vial filled with a radioactive, poisonous substance. Only if one atom decayed and emitted an electron, the vial would break. The chances that this would happen and the cat would die or that it would not and the cat would continue to live are 50-50. What does this mean? In the everyday world of common reality there is no such thing as a half-dead or half-alive cat, irrespective of the presence of an observer. In quantum physics, however, either both probabilities (of a dead cat and of a living cat) contain equal (in separate worlds), or neither holds valid unless the observer opens the box and allows one of them to crystallize into reality. In the quantum world, the cat is neither dead nor alive, but somehow lying in an indeterminate state until

Archives of Dermatology•Jan 1, 1986•0 citations

Schrodinger's Cat at Hand

Barbara A. B. Seiders

Letters from: [ Andras Malnasi Csizmadia and Achilles J. Sanchez ][1] [ Randy Morse ][1] [ Barbara A. B. Seiders ][1] [ Paul C. S. Hoaken ][1] [ Andrew Ahlgren ][1] When the Schrodinger cat paradox was first proposed in 1935, it was difficult to envision an experimental system in which to model Schrodinger's experiment. But C. Monroe et al. describe such a system in their research article “A ‘Schrodinger cat’ superposition state of an atom” ([24 May, p. 1131][2]). In an accompanying Research News article ([24 May, p. 1101][3]), Gary Taubes writes > … Erwin Schrodinger described a cat shut up in what he called a “diabolical device”: a closed box also containing a small amount of a radioactive substance. Over the course of an hour, the radioactive substance has a 50-50 chance of decaying. If it does, the decay is detected by a counter, which shatters a flask of deadly acid, killing the cat. If it doesn't, the cat lives. But for the experiment to be a true paradox, the box must contain only one radioactive atom, as specified by Schrodinger. If there are numerous atoms in the box, it is a statistical certainty that at least one atom (but we cannot know which one) will decay in the course of the experiment, and the unfortunate cat will undoubtedly be killed. If, on the other hand, there is only one or very few atoms in the box, we will not know whether the cat is dead or alive. # {#article-title-2} As a naive molecular biologist, I am perplexed by one facet of the problem of Schrodinger's cat as it is usually presented. Why can't the cat be considered an observer and therefore remove the uncertainty about its own life or death status? # {#article-title-3} My 12-year-old daughter Phoebe is a student of quantum paradoxes, but she was concerned about an error in the illustration accompanying the Research News article with regard to feline anatomy. Presumably, even Schrodinger's cat would have foreleg “elbows,” not “knees.” # {#article-title-4} The title of the Research News article “Schizophrenic atom doubles as Schrodinger's cat—or kitten” perpetuates a misconception about schizophrenia—which is nothing like split personality—and trivializes a potentially disabling mental disorder. # {#article-title-5} “Kitten,” as used by Taubes, seems needlessly macroscopic as a metaphor for a single trapped atom. How about “Schrodinger's furball”? [1]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.273.5277.857e [2]: /lookup/volpage/273/1131 [3]: /lookup/volpage/273/1101

Science•Aug 16, 1996•2 citations

Schrodinger’s Cat in the Time Domain

Eran Sinbar

Schrodinger’s cat describes a paradox in which a cat is located in a sealed black box with a poison sealed capsule inside it. Radioactive source decays and emits radiation, which activates a Geiger counter, The Geiger counter generates a signal to release poison from the capsule and kill the cat. Since the decay of a radioactive source is a random sub atomic event, based on quantum mechanics we can only derive a probability-based assumption on the exact time that the decay of the radioactive atom will occur. The Copenhagen interpretation says that until an observer opens the box, the entire system is in superposition and the cat is both dead and alive. In this paper, I will show that we can extrapolate this superposition paradox also to the time domain and the entropy level of the system.

•Feb 1, 2020•0 citations

Predicting the Fate of Schrodinger's Cat

James D. Stein

We describe a simple experiment in which a radioactive atom in a box decays in unit time with probability equal to ½, but such that the probability of a correct prediction of whether or not the atom decays is greater than ½.

•Feb 23, 2018•1 citation

The ins and outs of Schrodinger's cat box: a response to Papineau

Paul Tappenden

The so-called many-worlds or many-minds interpretations of quantum mechancis, derived from the work of Hugh Everett III (1957), continue to have a very mixed reception among the well-informed, partly because of the theories' weirdness. Peter Lewis (2000) has argued that an important class of these interpretations have the extraordinary implication that a subject confronted by apparently life-threatening situations involving quantum measurement should be fully confident of having future experience. David Papineau (2003) has attempted to block Lewis's argument and I shall argue that the attempt fails.

Analysis•Mar 16, 2004•6 citations
By way of an example, Lewis imagines your being invited to join Schrodinger’s cat in its box for an hour. This box will either fill up with deadly poison fumes or not, depending on whether or not some radioactive atom decays, the probability of decay within an hour being 50%. The invitation is accompanied with some further incentive to comply (Lewis sets it up so there is a significant chance of some pretty bad but not life-threatening punishment if you don’t get in the box). Lewis argues that the many minds theory implies that you should get in the box with the cat, despite this making it 50% likely you will die.
In 1935 Erwin Schrödinger proposed a thought experiment to show the absurd consequences of applying quantum mechanics to everyday objects. Schrödinger imagined placing a cat in a box, along with a vial of deadly poison that is connected to a radioactive atom. If the atom decays, it releases the poison and kills the cat. When the box is closed we do not know if the atom has decayed or not, which means that it can be in a "superposition" of two states (decayed and non-decayed) at the same time. Therefore, protested Schrödinger, the cat can be both dead and alive at the same time – which is clearly absurd. There was obviously, he thought, some boundary between the microscopic world of atoms and quantum mechanics, and the macroscopic world of cats and classical mechanics.
Schrodinger's conceptual model of probable described a closed box containing a cat and a vial filled with a radioactive, poisonous substance. Only if one atom decayed and emitted an electron, the vial would break. The chances that this would happen and the cat would die or that it would not and the cat would continue to live are 50-50. What does this mean? In the everyday world of common reality there is no such thing as a half-dead or half-alive cat, irrespective of the presence of an observer. In quantum physics, however, either both probabilities (of a dead cat and of a living cat) contain equal (in separate worlds), or neither holds valid unless the observer opens the box and allows one of them to crystallize into reality. In the quantum world, the cat is neither dead nor alive, but somehow lying in an indeterminate state until
Letters from: [ Andras Malnasi Csizmadia and Achilles J. Sanchez ][1] [ Randy Morse ][1] [ Barbara A. B. Seiders ][1] [ Paul C. S. Hoaken ][1] [ Andrew Ahlgren ][1] When the Schrodinger cat paradox was first proposed in 1935, it was difficult to envision an experimental system in which to model Schrodinger's experiment. But C. Monroe et al. describe such a system in their research article “A ‘Schrodinger cat’ superposition state of an atom” ([24 May, p. 1131][2]). In an accompanying Research News article ([24 May, p. 1101][3]), Gary Taubes writes > … Erwin Schrodinger described a cat shut up in what he called a “diabolical device”: a closed box also containing a small amount of a radioactive substance. Over the course of an hour, the radioactive substance has a 50-50 chance of decaying. If it does, the decay is detected by a counter, which shatters a flask of deadly acid, killing the cat. If it doesn't, the cat lives. But for the experiment to be a true paradox, the box must contain only one radioactive atom, as specified by Schrodinger. If there are numerous atoms in the box, it is a statistical certainty that at least one atom (but we cannot know which one) will decay in the course of the experiment, and the unfortunate cat will undoubtedly be killed. If, on the other hand, there is only one or very few atoms in the box, we will not know whether the cat is dead or alive. # {#article-title-2} As a naive molecular biologist, I am perplexed by one facet of the problem of Schrodinger's cat as it is usually presented. Why can't the cat be considered an observer and therefore remove the uncertainty about its own life or death status? # {#article-title-3} My 12-year-old daughter Phoebe is a student of quantum paradoxes, but she was concerned about an error in the illustration accompanying the Research News article with regard to feline anatomy. Presumably, even Schrodinger's cat would have foreleg “elbows,” not “knees.” # {#article-title-4} The title of the Research News article “Schizophrenic atom doubles as Schrodinger's cat—or kitten” perpetuates a misconception about schizophrenia—which is nothing like split personality—and trivializes a potentially disabling mental disorder. # {#article-title-5} “Kitten,” as used by Taubes, seems needlessly macroscopic as a metaphor for a single trapped atom. How about “Schrodinger's furball”? [1]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.273.5277.857e [2]: /lookup/volpage/273/1131 [3]: /lookup/volpage/273/1101
Schrodinger’s cat describes a paradox in which a cat is located in a sealed black box with a poison sealed capsule inside it. Radioactive source decays and emits radiation, which activates a Geiger counter, The Geiger counter generates a signal to release poison from the capsule and kill the cat. Since the decay of a radioactive source is a random sub atomic event, based on quantum mechanics we can only derive a probability-based assumption on the exact time that the decay of the radioactive atom will occur. The Copenhagen interpretation says that until an observer opens the box, the entire system is in superposition and the cat is both dead and alive. In this paper, I will show that we can extrapolate this superposition paradox also to the time domain and the entropy level of the system.
The so-called many-worlds or many-minds interpretations of quantum mechancis, derived from the work of Hugh Everett III (1957), continue to have a very mixed reception among the well-informed, partly because of the theories' weirdness. Peter Lewis (2000) has argued that an important class of these interpretations have the extraordinary implication that a subject confronted by apparently life-threatening situations involving quantum measurement should be fully confident of having future experience. David Papineau (2003) has attempted to block Lewis's argument and I shall argue that the attempt fails.