Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Canadian Journal of Physics

Nonresonant corrections and limits for the accuracy of the frequency measurements in modern hydrogen experiments

Leonti N Labzowsky, Gavriil Schedrin, Dmitry A. Solovyev, G. Plunien

Published May 1, 2007• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The theory of the nonresonant corrections, defining the limits of accuracy for the frequency measurements in resonance experiments, is generalized to the situation when the excitation of an atomic state is governed by one Hamiltonian Ĥin and the decay of the excited state is governed by another Hamiltonian Ĥout. The description developed here corresponds to the experimental conditions realized in most accurate modern resonance-frequency measurements of the 2s–1s transition in hydrogen. Two different variants of the theoretical description of the resonance experiments, referred to as "statistical" and "coherent" scenarios, are discussed. The criterion of how to define which scenario should be attributed to a particular resonance experiment is shown. The in and (or) out quantum electrodynamic formalism referring to different asymptotic Hamiltonians is applied. A value of 10–5 Hz, obtained for the accuracy limit in the 1s–2s experiment within the "coherent" scenario, is not so far from the accuracy already achieved experimentally (46 Hz). The accuracy limits for the Lyman-alpha frequency measurements for a "coherent" type of experiment are also obtained and shown to be comparable with recent experimental accuracy.PACS Nos.: 06.20.Jr, 31.10.+z, 32.30Bv

DOI
10.1139/p07-014

Related papers

Nonresonant effects in one- and two-photon transitions

Ulrich D. Jentschura, Peter J. Mohr

We investigate nonresonant contributions to resonant Rayleigh-scattering cross sections of atoms. The problematic nonresonant contributions set a limit to the accuracy to which atomic spectra determine energy levels. We discuss the off-resonance effects in one-photon transitions. We also show that off-resonance contributions for the 1S–2S two-photon transition in atomic hydrogen are negligible at current and projected levels of experimental accuracy. The possibility of a differential measurement for the detection of off-resonance effects in one-photon transitions in atomic hydrogen is discussed. PACS Nos.: 31.15-p, 12.20Ds

arXiv:physics/0110053•Canadian Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 2002•51 citations

Angular correlations in two-photon spectroscopy of hydrogen

A. Anikin, Timur A. Zalialiutdinov, Dmitry A. Solovyev

In the present paper, we consider nonresonant corrections to $2s\text{\ensuremath{-}}ns/nd$ transition frequencies in hydrogen for the experiments based on two-photon spectroscopy. A detailed study of angular correlations of quantum interference effects within the framework of rigorous quantum electrodynamics is given. Closed expressions for the resonant two-photon-scattering cross sections on an atomic level with dependence on all atomic quantum numbers including fine and hyperfine structure are derived. These expressions are applied for the description of experiments based on two-photon spectroscopy with fixing of incident (outgoing) photon polarizations. We demonstrate that, for certain experimental geometries, nonresonant corrections could be significant for the determination of Rydberg constant and proton charge radius.

arXiv:2012.12536•Physical Review A•Feb 26, 2021•8 citations

The 1S → 2S two-photon transition rate in atomic hydrogen

Shifang Li, Edward S. Fry

Theoretical calculations for the 1S → 2S two- photon transition rate in atomic hydrogen are reviewed. They are compared with two experiments via the saturation effects that are observed when three-photon ionization is enhanced by two- photon resonance with the metastable 2S state. There is a significant disagreement between theoretical and experimental results. The disagreement is illustrated by determining the transition rate as a function of intensity for experimental laser profiles: (1) using parameters that give rates in agreement with experimental data, and (2) using theoretical values for the parameters. Finally, experiments that would involve direct observation of the 2S metastable state are considered. It is shown that single-longitudinal-mode laser experiments would provide an accurate measurement of the Rabi frequency for this transition and yield a definitive value for the rate. A Monte Carlo simulation method is used to consider practical effects associated with such an experiment, for example, chirp and ASE noise in the laser. Also, simulations of the multiphoton ionization process in multimode and wide band laser fields are presented.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1991•0 citations

Quantum Field Theory Description of the Hydrogen Lyman α Transition: From QED to the Bohr–Maxwell Correspondence

Daniel Scretching

This paper presents a quantum-field-theoretic formulation of the hydrogen 2p → 1s Lyman-α transition, replacing the semiclassical Bohr–Maxwell description with the modern framework of quantum electrodynamics. The initial and final bound-electron states are described by the Dirac equation in the proton’s Coulomb field, with the Schrödinger equation recovered as the leading nonrelativistic limit. The electromagnetic radiation field is quantized, and photon emission is generated by the QED interaction Hamiltonian. The transition amplitude is evaluated from the atomic current and quantized electromagnetic field, leading through Fermi’s golden rule to the spontaneous-emission rate and Einstein coefficient A₂₁. Energy and momentum conservation require the emitted photon to carry the atomic transition energy, including the small correction associated with proton recoil. At leading order, the Lyman-α photon has ΔE ≈ 10.2 eV, ν ≈ 2.47 × 10¹⁵ Hz, and λ ≈ 121.6 nm. In the electric-dipole approximation, the field-theoretic calculation reduces to the standard matrix element of the interaction Hamiltonian H_int = −μ·E, thereby connecting QED directly to the transition dipole moment, oscillator strength, Einstein A coefficient, and radiative lifetime. The calculation reproduces the accepted numerical results for hydrogen while identifying their origin in the coupling between the quantized electron field and the quantized electromagnetic field. The paper also explains how classical electrodynamics is recovered from QED. Maxwell’s equations govern the expectation values of the electromagnetic-field operators in the appropriate classical-field limit, particularly for coherent states containing many photons. A single spontaneously emitted Lyman-α photon, however, remains a genuinely quantum excitation rather than a classical electromagnetic wave. Leading corrections beyond the nonrelativistic Coulomb approximation are then considered, including relativistic fine structure, the Lamb shift, and atomic recoil. The resulting treatment provides a rigorous bridge from the historical Bohr model and Schrödinger wave mechanics to Dirac theory and full QED, verifying the Lyman-α energy, frequency, wavelength, transition probability, and radiative decay structure within a unified quantum-field framework.

•Jul 12, 2026•0 citations

Theory of the cold collision frequency shift in 1S-2S spectroscopy of Bose-Einstein-condensed and non-condensed hydrogen

Crispin W. Gardiner, Ashton S. Bradley

We show that a correct formulation of the cold collision frequency shift for two photon spectroscopy of Bose-condensed and cold non-Bose-condensed hydrogen is consistent with experimental data. Our treatment includes transport and inhomogeneity into the theory of a non-condensed gas, which causes substantial changes in the cold collision frequency shift for the ordinary thermal gas, as a result of the very high frequency (3.9 kHz) of the transverse trap mode. For the condensed gas, we find substantial corrections arise from the inclusion of quasiparticles, whose number is very large because of the very low frequency (10.2 Hz) of the longitudinal trap mode. These two effects together account for the apparent absence of a `factor of two' between the two possibilities. Our treatment considers only the Doppler-free measurements, but could be extended to Doppler-sensitive measurements. For Bose-condensed hydrogen, we predict a characteristic `foot' extending into higher detunings than can arise from the condensate alone, as a result of a correct treatment of the statistics of thermal quasiparticles.

arXiv:cond-mat/0108451•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Nov 23, 2001•2 citations

Multiphoton quantum interference in precision spectroscopic experiments

Dmitry A. Solovyev, Timur A. Zalialiutdinov, A. Anikin +1 more

Modern resonance spectroscopic experiments on the measurement of transition frequencies in atoms have reached a level where a meticulous description of all aspects of the studied processes has become obligatory. The precision achieved has led to the fact that the determination of the transition frequency on the basis of measured data is substantially refined by theoretical treatment of the observed spectral line profile. Thus, a large impact of effects arising beyond the resonance approximation, in particular due to the effect of quantum interference, is found experimentally. We show that the picture becomes even more complicated when the observed spectral line profile is ``identified'' with one of the processes---emission or absorption. An accurate determination of the transition frequency requires a description of the absorption line profile inseparable from the emission process, and vice versa. The theoretical aspects discussed in this paper create prerequisites for more accurate experiments.

arXiv:2311.12606•Physical Review A•May 2, 2024•3 citations
The theory of the nonresonant corrections, defining the limits of accuracy for the frequency measurements in resonance experiments, is generalized to the situation when the excitation of an atomic state is governed by one Hamiltonian Ĥin and the decay of the excited state is governed by another Hamiltonian Ĥout. The description developed here corresponds to the experimental conditions realized in most accurate modern resonance-frequency measurements of the 2s–1s transition in hydrogen. Two different variants of the theoretical description of the resonance experiments, referred to as "statistical" and "coherent" scenarios, are discussed. The criterion of how to define which scenario should be attributed to a particular resonance experiment is shown. The in and (or) out quantum electrodynamic formalism referring to different asymptotic Hamiltonians is applied. A value of 10–5 Hz, obtained for the accuracy limit in the 1s–2s experiment within the "coherent" scenario, is not so far from the accuracy already achieved experimentally (46 Hz). The accuracy limits for the Lyman-alpha frequency measurements for a "coherent" type of experiment are also obtained and shown to be comparable with recent experimental accuracy.PACS Nos.: 06.20.Jr, 31.10.+z, 32.30Bv
We investigate nonresonant contributions to resonant Rayleigh-scattering cross sections of atoms. The problematic nonresonant contributions set a limit to the accuracy to which atomic spectra determine energy levels. We discuss the off-resonance effects in one-photon transitions. We also show that off-resonance contributions for the 1S–2S two-photon transition in atomic hydrogen are negligible at current and projected levels of experimental accuracy. The possibility of a differential measurement for the detection of off-resonance effects in one-photon transitions in atomic hydrogen is discussed. PACS Nos.: 31.15-p, 12.20Ds
In the present paper, we consider nonresonant corrections to $2s\text{\ensuremath{-}}ns/nd$ transition frequencies in hydrogen for the experiments based on two-photon spectroscopy. A detailed study of angular correlations of quantum interference effects within the framework of rigorous quantum electrodynamics is given. Closed expressions for the resonant two-photon-scattering cross sections on an atomic level with dependence on all atomic quantum numbers including fine and hyperfine structure are derived. These expressions are applied for the description of experiments based on two-photon spectroscopy with fixing of incident (outgoing) photon polarizations. We demonstrate that, for certain experimental geometries, nonresonant corrections could be significant for the determination of Rydberg constant and proton charge radius.
Theoretical calculations for the 1S → 2S two- photon transition rate in atomic hydrogen are reviewed. They are compared with two experiments via the saturation effects that are observed when three-photon ionization is enhanced by two- photon resonance with the metastable 2S state. There is a significant disagreement between theoretical and experimental results. The disagreement is illustrated by determining the transition rate as a function of intensity for experimental laser profiles: (1) using parameters that give rates in agreement with experimental data, and (2) using theoretical values for the parameters. Finally, experiments that would involve direct observation of the 2S metastable state are considered. It is shown that single-longitudinal-mode laser experiments would provide an accurate measurement of the Rabi frequency for this transition and yield a definitive value for the rate. A Monte Carlo simulation method is used to consider practical effects associated with such an experiment, for example, chirp and ASE noise in the laser. Also, simulations of the multiphoton ionization process in multimode and wide band laser fields are presented.
This paper presents a quantum-field-theoretic formulation of the hydrogen 2p → 1s Lyman-α transition, replacing the semiclassical Bohr–Maxwell description with the modern framework of quantum electrodynamics. The initial and final bound-electron states are described by the Dirac equation in the proton’s Coulomb field, with the Schrödinger equation recovered as the leading nonrelativistic limit. The electromagnetic radiation field is quantized, and photon emission is generated by the QED interaction Hamiltonian. The transition amplitude is evaluated from the atomic current and quantized electromagnetic field, leading through Fermi’s golden rule to the spontaneous-emission rate and Einstein coefficient A₂₁. Energy and momentum conservation require the emitted photon to carry the atomic transition energy, including the small correction associated with proton recoil. At leading order, the Lyman-α photon has ΔE ≈ 10.2 eV, ν ≈ 2.47 × 10¹⁵ Hz, and λ ≈ 121.6 nm. In the electric-dipole approximation, the field-theoretic calculation reduces to the standard matrix element of the interaction Hamiltonian H_int = −μ·E, thereby connecting QED directly to the transition dipole moment, oscillator strength, Einstein A coefficient, and radiative lifetime. The calculation reproduces the accepted numerical results for hydrogen while identifying their origin in the coupling between the quantized electron field and the quantized electromagnetic field. The paper also explains how classical electrodynamics is recovered from QED. Maxwell’s equations govern the expectation values of the electromagnetic-field operators in the appropriate classical-field limit, particularly for coherent states containing many photons. A single spontaneously emitted Lyman-α photon, however, remains a genuinely quantum excitation rather than a classical electromagnetic wave. Leading corrections beyond the nonrelativistic Coulomb approximation are then considered, including relativistic fine structure, the Lamb shift, and atomic recoil. The resulting treatment provides a rigorous bridge from the historical Bohr model and Schrödinger wave mechanics to Dirac theory and full QED, verifying the Lyman-α energy, frequency, wavelength, transition probability, and radiative decay structure within a unified quantum-field framework.
We show that a correct formulation of the cold collision frequency shift for two photon spectroscopy of Bose-condensed and cold non-Bose-condensed hydrogen is consistent with experimental data. Our treatment includes transport and inhomogeneity into the theory of a non-condensed gas, which causes substantial changes in the cold collision frequency shift for the ordinary thermal gas, as a result of the very high frequency (3.9 kHz) of the transverse trap mode. For the condensed gas, we find substantial corrections arise from the inclusion of quasiparticles, whose number is very large because of the very low frequency (10.2 Hz) of the longitudinal trap mode. These two effects together account for the apparent absence of a `factor of two' between the two possibilities. Our treatment considers only the Doppler-free measurements, but could be extended to Doppler-sensitive measurements. For Bose-condensed hydrogen, we predict a characteristic `foot' extending into higher detunings than can arise from the condensate alone, as a result of a correct treatment of the statistics of thermal quasiparticles.
Modern resonance spectroscopic experiments on the measurement of transition frequencies in atoms have reached a level where a meticulous description of all aspects of the studied processes has become obligatory. The precision achieved has led to the fact that the determination of the transition frequency on the basis of measured data is substantially refined by theoretical treatment of the observed spectral line profile. Thus, a large impact of effects arising beyond the resonance approximation, in particular due to the effect of quantum interference, is found experimentally. We show that the picture becomes even more complicated when the observed spectral line profile is ``identified'' with one of the processes---emission or absorption. An accurate determination of the transition frequency requires a description of the absorption line profile inseparable from the emission process, and vice versa. The theoretical aspects discussed in this paper create prerequisites for more accurate experiments.