Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry

Aspects of BCS to BEC “Crossover” as illustrated by fulleride superconductivity

Richard H. Squire, Norman Henry March

Published Jan 1, 2007• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract The pioneering works by Eagles, Leggett, and Nozieres/Schmitt‐Rink [Eagles, Phys Rev, 1969, 186, 456; Leggett, In: Modern Trends in the Theory of Condensed Matter, Springer‐Verlag: Berlin, 1980; Nozieres and Schmitt‐Rink, Low Temp Phys, 1985, 59, 980] (reviewed and augmented by Randeria [Randeria, Bose‐Einstein Condensation, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1995, p 255]) emphasize that in the limits of the models studied both at T = 0 and T ≠ 0, the “cross‐over” from a BCS‐type to a BEC‐type superconductor is continuous. The BCS and BEC “end points” seem to be well‐established. However, in the intermediate region—home to fulleride and high temperature superconductors—considerable extrapolation of the models must be done as there still is no exact theory. Yet, considerable current literature is devoted to what appears to be more “singular‐type phenomena” such as quantum critical points, “stripe” formation, insulator to superconductor phase transitions, loss of validity of the Fermi liquid theory, etc. Using a connection we have made with “cold” atom fermion‐boson crossover theory [Chen, Stajic, Levin, 2005, e‐print cond‐mat/0508603], we can establish that the resonance previously discussed [Squire and March, Int J Quant Chem, 2006, 106, 3343] is a result of the crossing of the fermion band by the boson band. While the ground state appears to remain continuous, the paired energy gap becomes transformed. We discuss features of the resonance and the experimentally observed pre‐formed “BEC Cooper pair” formation, essential to the boson‐fermion resonance theory. In addition some of the various singular phenomena discussed above can be put more into perspective. Finally, in both limits the relation of characteristic lengths to the inverse Fermi momentum is strongly emphasized, as is the role of the chemical potential near the pseudogap regime. © 2007 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2007

DOI
10.1002/qua.21445

Related papers

Does Fulleride Superconductivity Crossover Contain a Feshbach Resonance?

Richard H. Squire, Norman Henry March

The pioneering works by Eagles, Leggett, and Nozieres/Schmitt-Rink (reviewed and augmented by Randeria) emphasize that in the limits of the models studied both at T = 0 and, the cross-over from a BCS-type to a BEC-type superconductor is continuous. The BCS and BEC end points seem to be well-established. However, in the intermediate region, home to fulleride and high temperature superconductors, considerable extrapolation of the models must be done as there still is no exact theory. Yet, considerable current literature is devoted to what appears to be more singular-type phenomena such as quantum critical points, stripe formation, insulator to superconductor phase transitions, loss of validity of the Fermi liquid theory, etc. Using a connection we have made with cold atom Fermion-Boson crossover theory, we can establish that the resonance previously discussed is a result of the crossing of the Fermion band by the Boson band. While the ground and singly excited states appear to remain continuous, the collective modes due to the resonance transform the nature of the superconductivity. We discuss features of the resonance and the experimentally observed pre-formed BEC Cooper pair formation in fullerides, essential to the Boson-Fermion resonance theory. In addition some of the various singular phenomena discussed above can be put into perspective. PACS numbers: 61.48.+c, 74.20.-z, 81.05Tp

arXiv:cond-mat/0703816•Mar 30, 2007•1 citation

Crossover from BCS Theory to Bose–Einstein Condensation

Mohit Randeria

This article gives a detailed review of our current theoretical understanding of the crossover from cooperative Cooper pairing to independent bound-state formation and Bose–Einstein condensation in Fermi systems with increasing attractive interactions. Introduction There are two well-known paradigms for understanding the phenomena of superconductivity and superfluidity: (I) BCS theory [1], in which the normal state is a degenerate Fermi liquid that undergoes a pairing instability at a temperature T c ≪ ε f , the degeneracy scale. The formation of Cooper pairs and their condensation (macroscopic occupation of a single quantum state) both occur simultaneously at the transition temperature T c . (II) Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC) of bosons at a T c of the order of their degeneracy temperature. At a fundamental level these bosons (for example, 4 He or excitons) are invariably composite objects made up of an even number of fermions. The composite particles form at some very high temperature scale of the order of their dissociation temperature T dissoc , and these “pre-formed” bosons then condense at the BEC T c ≪ T dissoc . In most cases of experimental interest the system under consideration clearly falls into one category or the other. For instance, 3 He is a Fermi superfluid described by (I) whereas 4 He is a Bose superfluid (II). Essentially all cases of superconductivity in metals that we understand reasonably well are much closer to (I) than to (II), as evidenced by the existence of fermionic quasiparticles above T c .

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 6, 1995•159 citations

BEC, BCS and BCS-Bose Crossover Theories in Superconductors and Superfluids

MANUEL DE LLANO, Francisco J. Sevilla, M. A. Solís +1 more

For the Cooper/BCS model interaction in superconductors (SCs) it is shown: a) how BCS-Bose crossover picture transition temperatures Tc, defined self-consistently by both the gap and fermion-number equations, require unphysically large couplings to differ significantly from the Tc of ordinary BCS theory defined without the number equation since here the chemical potential is assumed equal to the Fermi energy; how although ignoring either hole- or electron-Cooper-pairs in the recent "complete boson-fermion model": b) one obtains the precise BCS gap equation for all temperatures T, but c) only half the zero-temperature BCS condensation energy emerges. Results (b) and (c) are also expected to hold for neutral-fermion superfluids (SFs)--such as liquid $^3$He, neutron matter and trapped ultra-cold fermion atomic gases--where the pair-forming two-fermion interaction of course differs from the Cooper/BCS one for SCs.

arXiv:cond-mat/0412418•Dec 16, 2004•0 citations

Comparative study of BCS-BEC crossover theories above Tc : The nature of the pseudogap in ultracold atomic Fermi gases

Chih-Chun Chien, Hao Guo, Yan He +1 more

This article presents a comparison of two finite-temperature BCS--Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) crossover theories above the transition temperature: Nozieres--Schmitt-Rink (NSR) theory and finite-$T$ extended BCS-Leggett theory. The comparison is cast in the form of numerical studies of the behavior of the fermionic spectral function both theoretically and as constrained by (primarily) radio frequency (rf) experiments. Both theories include pair fluctuations and exhibit pseudogap effects, although the nature of this pseudogap is very different. The pseudogap in finite-$T$ extended BCS-Leggett theory is found to follow a BCS-like dispersion which, in turn, is associated with a broadened BCS-like self-energy, rather more similar to what is observed in high-temperature superconductors (albeit, for a $d$-wave case). The fermionic quasiparticle dispersion is different in NSR theory and the damping is considerably larger. We argue that the two theories are appropriate in different temperature regimes with the BCS-Leggett approach being more suitable nearer to condensation. There should, in effect, be little difference at higher $T$ as the pseudogap becomes weaker and where the simplifying approximations used in the BCS-Leggett approach break down. On the basis of momentum-integrated rf studies of unpolarized gases, it would be difficult to distinguish which theory is the better one. A full comparison for polarized gases is not possible since it is claimed that there are inconsistencies in the NSR approach (not found in the BCS-Leggett scheme). Future experiments along the lines of momentum-resolved experiments look to be very promising in distinguishing the two theories.

arXiv:0910.3699•Physical Review A•Feb 24, 2010•47 citations

Applying BCS–BEC crossover theory to high-temperature superconductors and ultracold atomic Fermi gases (Review Article)

Q. Chen, K. Levin, J. Stajic

This review is written at the time of the twentieth anniversary of the discovery of high-temperature superconductors, which nearly coincides with the important discovery of the superfluid phases of ultracold trapped fermionic atoms. We show how these two subjects have much in common. Both have been addressed from the perspective of the BCS—Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC) crossover scenario, which is designed to treat short coherence length superfluids with transition temperatures which are “high” with respect to the Fermi energy. A generalized mean field treatment of BCS–BEC crossover at general temperatures T, based on the BCS–Leggett ground state, has met with remarkable success in the fermionic atomic systems. Here we summarize this success in the context of four different cold atom experiments, all of which provide indications, direct or indirect, for the existence of a pseudogap. This scenario also provides a physical picture of the pseudogap phase in the underdoped cuprates which is a central focus of high Tc research. We summarize successful applications of BCS–BEC crossover to key experiments in high Tc systems, including the phase diagram, specific heat, and vortex core STM data, along with the Nernst effect, and exciting recent data on the superfluid density in very underdoped samples.

arXiv:cond-mat/0508603•Low Temperature Physics•Apr 1, 2006•47 citations

BCS-to-BEC evolution details

Carlos A. R. Sá de Melo

Sá de Melo replies: I thank D. M. Eagles for his comments. My statement concerning the evolution from Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer to Bose–Einstein condensation superfluids was about clarity and not who was the first to propose the idea. Although I appreciate Eagles’s work, I still think that Anthony Leggett’s papers 1 are the clearest presentation on the topic up to 1980.In his very interesting book written in 1964, John Blatt describes the BEC theory of superconductivity and its relation to the BCS theory. 2 As he recounts, the possibility of pairing without superconductivity and Bose condensation of electron pairs at a lower temperature was suggested as early as 1946 by Richard Ogg Jr. In 1954 and subsequent years, Max Schafroth developed a firm theoretical framework for such pairing, but it was not supported by experimental evidence: No preformed pairs were found, and the BEC temperature was much too high for known superconductors. Blatt’s book thoroughly documents a clear connection between a variational, fixed-number ground state comprising antisymmetrized products of pair wavefunctions and the BCS equations that Eagles used in his 1969 paper. Eagles noticed that the BCS and number equations at zero temperature could be used to describe the evolution from BCS to BEC superconductivity in low-carrier-density thin films or bulk materials for fixed (and sufficiently strong) interaction and changing carrier density. However, Blatt’s main interest was in metals with high carrier densities. If one reads the full statement in the box entitled “Feshbach resonances” on page 47 of my article, it is clear that I am talking about changing interactions for fixed density and not changing density for fixed interactions. I do not think it is currently possible in any superconductor to control the interactions between fermions. Thus my statement is accurate.In many instances the change in carrier concentration in thin films or three-dimensional (bulk) systems is made via chemical doping, which may introduce disorder or distortions in the crystal structure and thus change the system in more than the desired way. I have serious doubts that ceramic samples of zirconium-doped strontium titanate described in Eagles’s letter indeed show the BCS-to-BEC evolution; the references provided do not offer clear evidence of such a phenomenon.Since cuprate superconductors are known to be quasi-2D and have d-wave pairing symmetry, the evolution from BCS to BEC superconductivity for sufficiently strong fixed interactions and changing carrier density would be accompanied by a topological quantum phase transition 3 and would not be a crossover as in the s-wave case. However, as much as I might want such a transition to be found for the cuprates, current experimental evidence shows that their normal state and superconducting properties are more complicated than simple BCS-to-BEC theories would predict.The beauty of the observation of the BCS-to-BEC evolution in ultracold atoms is that many of the materials difficulties encountered in standard condensed matter can be avoided and the tuning of the interaction for fixed low density can be controlled. However, one should keep an open mind that a similar realization may appear elsewhere. For instance, if carrier density could be controlled and changed continuously via electrostatic doping in good-quality thin films or at the surface of bulk low-carrier-density superconductors like some titanates or cuprates, then there is a good chance of observing the BCS-to-BEC evolution as a function of carrier density as envisioned by Eagles in 1969.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES << REFERENCES 1. A. J. Leggett, in Modern Trends in the Theory of Condensed Matter: Proceedings of the XVI Karpacz Winter School of Theoretical Physics, February 19-March 3, 1979, Karpacz, Poland, A. Pekalski, J. Przystawa, eds., Springer, New York (1980) Google Scholar A. J. Leggett, J. Phys. Colloq. 41, C7–19 (1980). https://doi.org/10.1051/jphyscol:1980704 , Google ScholarCrossref2. J. M. Blatt, Theory of Superconductivity, Academic Press, New York (1964). Google Scholar3. L. S. Borkowski, C. A. R. Sá de Melo, http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9810370v1 , Google Scholar R. D. Duncan, C. A. R. Sá de Melo, Phys. Rev. B 62, 9675 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.62.9675 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2009 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Aug 1, 2009•0 citations
Abstract The pioneering works by Eagles, Leggett, and Nozieres/Schmitt‐Rink [Eagles, Phys Rev, 1969, 186, 456; Leggett, In: Modern Trends in the Theory of Condensed Matter, Springer‐Verlag: Berlin, 1980; Nozieres and Schmitt‐Rink, Low Temp Phys, 1985, 59, 980] (reviewed and augmented by Randeria [Randeria, Bose‐Einstein Condensation, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1995, p 255]) emphasize that in the limits of the models studied both at T = 0 and T ≠ 0, the “cross‐over” from a BCS‐type to a BEC‐type superconductor is continuous. The BCS and BEC “end points” seem to be well‐established. However, in the intermediate region—home to fulleride and high temperature superconductors—considerable extrapolation of the models must be done as there still is no exact theory. Yet, considerable current literature is devoted to what appears to be more “singular‐type phenomena” such as quantum critical points, “stripe” formation, insulator to superconductor phase transitions, loss of validity of the Fermi liquid theory, etc. Using a connection we have made with “cold” atom fermion‐boson crossover theory [Chen, Stajic, Levin, 2005, e‐print cond‐mat/0508603], we can establish that the resonance previously discussed [Squire and March, Int J Quant Chem, 2006, 106, 3343] is a result of the crossing of the fermion band by the boson band. While the ground state appears to remain continuous, the paired energy gap becomes transformed. We discuss features of the resonance and the experimentally observed pre‐formed “BEC Cooper pair” formation, essential to the boson‐fermion resonance theory. In addition some of the various singular phenomena discussed above can be put more into perspective. Finally, in both limits the relation of characteristic lengths to the inverse Fermi momentum is strongly emphasized, as is the role of the chemical potential near the pseudogap regime. © 2007 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2007
The pioneering works by Eagles, Leggett, and Nozieres/Schmitt-Rink (reviewed and augmented by Randeria) emphasize that in the limits of the models studied both at T = 0 and, the cross-over from a BCS-type to a BEC-type superconductor is continuous. The BCS and BEC end points seem to be well-established. However, in the intermediate region, home to fulleride and high temperature superconductors, considerable extrapolation of the models must be done as there still is no exact theory. Yet, considerable current literature is devoted to what appears to be more singular-type phenomena such as quantum critical points, stripe formation, insulator to superconductor phase transitions, loss of validity of the Fermi liquid theory, etc. Using a connection we have made with cold atom Fermion-Boson crossover theory, we can establish that the resonance previously discussed is a result of the crossing of the Fermion band by the Boson band. While the ground and singly excited states appear to remain continuous, the collective modes due to the resonance transform the nature of the superconductivity. We discuss features of the resonance and the experimentally observed pre-formed BEC Cooper pair formation in fullerides, essential to the Boson-Fermion resonance theory. In addition some of the various singular phenomena discussed above can be put into perspective. PACS numbers: 61.48.+c, 74.20.-z, 81.05Tp
This article gives a detailed review of our current theoretical understanding of the crossover from cooperative Cooper pairing to independent bound-state formation and Bose–Einstein condensation in Fermi systems with increasing attractive interactions. Introduction There are two well-known paradigms for understanding the phenomena of superconductivity and superfluidity: (I) BCS theory [1], in which the normal state is a degenerate Fermi liquid that undergoes a pairing instability at a temperature T c ≪ ε f , the degeneracy scale. The formation of Cooper pairs and their condensation (macroscopic occupation of a single quantum state) both occur simultaneously at the transition temperature T c . (II) Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC) of bosons at a T c of the order of their degeneracy temperature. At a fundamental level these bosons (for example, 4 He or excitons) are invariably composite objects made up of an even number of fermions. The composite particles form at some very high temperature scale of the order of their dissociation temperature T dissoc , and these “pre-formed” bosons then condense at the BEC T c ≪ T dissoc . In most cases of experimental interest the system under consideration clearly falls into one category or the other. For instance, 3 He is a Fermi superfluid described by (I) whereas 4 He is a Bose superfluid (II). Essentially all cases of superconductivity in metals that we understand reasonably well are much closer to (I) than to (II), as evidenced by the existence of fermionic quasiparticles above T c .
For the Cooper/BCS model interaction in superconductors (SCs) it is shown: a) how BCS-Bose crossover picture transition temperatures Tc, defined self-consistently by both the gap and fermion-number equations, require unphysically large couplings to differ significantly from the Tc of ordinary BCS theory defined without the number equation since here the chemical potential is assumed equal to the Fermi energy; how although ignoring either hole- or electron-Cooper-pairs in the recent "complete boson-fermion model": b) one obtains the precise BCS gap equation for all temperatures T, but c) only half the zero-temperature BCS condensation energy emerges. Results (b) and (c) are also expected to hold for neutral-fermion superfluids (SFs)--such as liquid 3^33He, neutron matter and trapped ultra-cold fermion atomic gases--where the pair-forming two-fermion interaction of course differs from the Cooper/BCS one for SCs.
This article presents a comparison of two finite-temperature BCS--Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) crossover theories above the transition temperature: Nozieres--Schmitt-Rink (NSR) theory and finite-TTT extended BCS-Leggett theory. The comparison is cast in the form of numerical studies of the behavior of the fermionic spectral function both theoretically and as constrained by (primarily) radio frequency (rf) experiments. Both theories include pair fluctuations and exhibit pseudogap effects, although the nature of this pseudogap is very different. The pseudogap in finite-TTT extended BCS-Leggett theory is found to follow a BCS-like dispersion which, in turn, is associated with a broadened BCS-like self-energy, rather more similar to what is observed in high-temperature superconductors (albeit, for a ddd-wave case). The fermionic quasiparticle dispersion is different in NSR theory and the damping is considerably larger. We argue that the two theories are appropriate in different temperature regimes with the BCS-Leggett approach being more suitable nearer to condensation. There should, in effect, be little difference at higher TTT as the pseudogap becomes weaker and where the simplifying approximations used in the BCS-Leggett approach break down. On the basis of momentum-integrated rf studies of unpolarized gases, it would be difficult to distinguish which theory is the better one. A full comparison for polarized gases is not possible since it is claimed that there are inconsistencies in the NSR approach (not found in the BCS-Leggett scheme). Future experiments along the lines of momentum-resolved experiments look to be very promising in distinguishing the two theories.
This review is written at the time of the twentieth anniversary of the discovery of high-temperature superconductors, which nearly coincides with the important discovery of the superfluid phases of ultracold trapped fermionic atoms. We show how these two subjects have much in common. Both have been addressed from the perspective of the BCS—Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC) crossover scenario, which is designed to treat short coherence length superfluids with transition temperatures which are “high” with respect to the Fermi energy. A generalized mean field treatment of BCS–BEC crossover at general temperatures T, based on the BCS–Leggett ground state, has met with remarkable success in the fermionic atomic systems. Here we summarize this success in the context of four different cold atom experiments, all of which provide indications, direct or indirect, for the existence of a pseudogap. This scenario also provides a physical picture of the pseudogap phase in the underdoped cuprates which is a central focus of high Tc research. We summarize successful applications of BCS–BEC crossover to key experiments in high Tc systems, including the phase diagram, specific heat, and vortex core STM data, along with the Nernst effect, and exciting recent data on the superfluid density in very underdoped samples.
Sá de Melo replies: I thank D. M. Eagles for his comments. My statement concerning the evolution from Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer to Bose–Einstein condensation superfluids was about clarity and not who was the first to propose the idea. Although I appreciate Eagles’s work, I still think that Anthony Leggett’s papers 1 are the clearest presentation on the topic up to 1980.In his very interesting book written in 1964, John Blatt describes the BEC theory of superconductivity and its relation to the BCS theory. 2 As he recounts, the possibility of pairing without superconductivity and Bose condensation of electron pairs at a lower temperature was suggested as early as 1946 by Richard Ogg Jr. In 1954 and subsequent years, Max Schafroth developed a firm theoretical framework for such pairing, but it was not supported by experimental evidence: No preformed pairs were found, and the BEC temperature was much too high for known superconductors. Blatt’s book thoroughly documents a clear connection between a variational, fixed-number ground state comprising antisymmetrized products of pair wavefunctions and the BCS equations that Eagles used in his 1969 paper. Eagles noticed that the BCS and number equations at zero temperature could be used to describe the evolution from BCS to BEC superconductivity in low-carrier-density thin films or bulk materials for fixed (and sufficiently strong) interaction and changing carrier density. However, Blatt’s main interest was in metals with high carrier densities. If one reads the full statement in the box entitled “Feshbach resonances” on page 47 of my article, it is clear that I am talking about changing interactions for fixed density and not changing density for fixed interactions. I do not think it is currently possible in any superconductor to control the interactions between fermions. Thus my statement is accurate.In many instances the change in carrier concentration in thin films or three-dimensional (bulk) systems is made via chemical doping, which may introduce disorder or distortions in the crystal structure and thus change the system in more than the desired way. I have serious doubts that ceramic samples of zirconium-doped strontium titanate described in Eagles’s letter indeed show the BCS-to-BEC evolution; the references provided do not offer clear evidence of such a phenomenon.Since cuprate superconductors are known to be quasi-2D and have d-wave pairing symmetry, the evolution from BCS to BEC superconductivity for sufficiently strong fixed interactions and changing carrier density would be accompanied by a topological quantum phase transition 3 and would not be a crossover as in the s-wave case. However, as much as I might want such a transition to be found for the cuprates, current experimental evidence shows that their normal state and superconducting properties are more complicated than simple BCS-to-BEC theories would predict.The beauty of the observation of the BCS-to-BEC evolution in ultracold atoms is that many of the materials difficulties encountered in standard condensed matter can be avoided and the tuning of the interaction for fixed low density can be controlled. However, one should keep an open mind that a similar realization may appear elsewhere. For instance, if carrier density could be controlled and changed continuously via electrostatic doping in good-quality thin films or at the surface of bulk low-carrier-density superconductors like some titanates or cuprates, then there is a good chance of observing the BCS-to-BEC evolution as a function of carrier density as envisioned by Eagles in 1969.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES << REFERENCES 1. A. J. Leggett, in Modern Trends in the Theory of Condensed Matter: Proceedings of the XVI Karpacz Winter School of Theoretical Physics, February 19-March 3, 1979, Karpacz, Poland, A. Pekalski, J. Przystawa, eds., Springer, New York (1980) Google Scholar A. J. Leggett, J. Phys. Colloq. 41, C7–19 (1980). https://doi.org/10.1051/jphyscol:1980704 , Google ScholarCrossref2. J. M. Blatt, Theory of Superconductivity, Academic Press, New York (1964). Google Scholar3. L. S. Borkowski, C. A. R. Sá de Melo, http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9810370v1 , Google Scholar R. D. Duncan, C. A. R. Sá de Melo, Phys. Rev. B 62, 9675 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.62.9675 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2009 American Institute of Physics.