Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science

Nonseparability, Classical, and Quantum

Wayne C. Myrvold

Published Mar 4, 2011• 28 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This article examines the implications of the holonomy interpretation of classical electromagnetism. As has been argued by Richard Healey and Gordon Belot, classical electromagnetism on this interpretation evinces a form of nonseparability, something that otherwise might have been thought of as confined to nonclassical physics. Consideration of the differences between this classical nonseparability and quantum nonseparability shows that the nonseparability exhibited by the classical electromagnetism on the holonomy interpretation is closer to separability than might at first appear. 1 Introduction 2 Interpretations of Classical Electromagnetism 3 Quantum Nonseparability 4 The Holonomy Representation of the Classical Electromagnetic Field 5 Holonomy and Nonseparability: The Classical Electromagnetic Field 6 On Humean Supervenience 7 Conclusion

DOI
10.1093/bjps/axq036

Related papers

Bell's Theorem, Nonseparability, and Spacetime Individuation in Quantum Mechanics

Darrin W.S. Belousek

We first examine Howard's analysis of the Bell factorizability condition in terms of ‘separability’ and ‘locality’ and then consider his claims that the violations of Bell's inequality by the statistical predictions of quantum mechanics should be interpreted in terms of ‘nonseparability’ rather than ‘nonlocality’ and that ‘nonseparability’ implies the failure of spacetime as a principle of individuation for quantum-mechanical systems. We will argue that his argument for the first claim is less than compelling and that any argument for the second claim will be interpretation-dependent and, hence, not generally valid.

Philosophy of Science•Jan 1, 1999•4 citations

Quantum Nonseparability Without Nonlocality: A ψ-Ontic Holistic Account of Entangled Measurement

Everett X. Wang

The standard interpretation of quantum measurement on entangled systems holds that measuring one particle nonlocally collapses the wavefunction of its spacelike-separated partner. We argue that this conclusion rests on a false presupposition: that subsystems of entangled systems possess independent ontic states. If the global wavefunction is the sole ontic object (ψ-ontic holism), then for entangled systems, there is no "state of B" to be affected by measurement at A. Measurement is a local dynamical process-concretely modeled by continuous spontaneous localization-that destroys one local wavefunction component at the measurement site; the global state factorizes as a consequence, and subsystem ontology emerges for the first time. The transition of the distant particle's reduced density matrix from mixed to pure reflects this emergence of separability, not a physical change at the distant location. The framework satisfies no-signaling and embraces the contextuality required by the Kochen-Specker and GHZ theorems. We are explicit about its relation to Bell's theorem: Bell local causality (factorizability) fails, as it must in any empirically adequate theory, but the failure is confined to outcome independence and is identified with the nonseparability of the global ontic state, while parameter independence-and with it the locality of the dynamics-holds exactly. Decoherence provides the mechanism by which the global wavefunction factorizes and classical separability emerges. The apparent nonlocality of quantum mechanics is thus reinterpreted as nonseparability: the fundamental ontology is holistic, but the dynamics are local.

Entropy•Sep 9, 2026•0 citations

Classical theories and nonclassical theories as special cases of a more general theory

Dirk Aerts

We analyze the difference between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics. We come to the conclusion that this difference can be found in the nature of the observables that are considered for the physical system under consideration. Classical mechanics can only describe a certain kind of what we called ‘‘classical observable.’’ Quantum mechanics can only describe another kind of observable; it cannot describe, however, classical observables. To perform this analysis, we use a theory where every kind of observable can be treated and which is in a natural way a generalization of both classical and quantum mechanics. If in a study of a physical system in this theory we restrict ourselves to the classical observables, we rediscover classical mechanics as a kind of first study of the physical system, where all the nonclassical properties are hidden. If we find that this first study is too rough we can also study the nonclassical part of the physical system by a theory which is eventually quantum mechanics.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Oct 1, 1983•85 citations

Classical and quantum-mechanical phase-space distributions

T. Kiesel

We examine the notion of nonclassicality in terms of quasiprobability distributions. In particular, we not only ask if a specific quasiprobability can be interpreted as a classical probability density, but we also require that characteristic features of classical electrodynamics are resembled. We show that the only quasiprobabilities that correctly describe the superposition principle of classical electromagnetic fields are the $s$-parametrized quasiprobabilities. Furthermore, the Glauber-Sudarshan $P$ function is the only quantum-mechanical quasiprobability that is transformed at a classical attenuator in the same way as a classical probability distribution. This result strengthens the definition of nonclassicality in terms of the $P$ function, in contrast to possible definitions in terms of other quasiprobabilities.

arXiv:1303.4718•Physical Review A•Jun 21, 2013•11 citations

The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Problem

Bernard d’Espagnat

The difference between the conceptual framework of classical physics and that of quantum physics which is due to the nonseparability property of the latter theory is better understood in specific examples. This chapter uses some specific examples to test the validity, both in classical and in quantum mechanics, of two conceptual principles. First is Reality Principle . The very concept of a reality may be criticized by philosophically minded empiricists. A widespread opinion, however, is that somehow a physical reality does exist, which should not just amount to the talks we give about it. In their search for a criterion that would make it possible to recognize elements of reality, A. Einstein, B. Podolsky, and N. Rosen had to take such considerations into account. Second, Principle of the Separability of Mechanically Isolated Systems, one can easily guess that this second principle, which remains somewhat implicit in the work of Einstein and his colleagues may well be the source of insuperable difficulties.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•0 citations

On the Reality of Gauge Potentials

Richard Healey

Classically, a gauge potential was merely a convenient device for generating a corresponding gauge field. Quantum-mechanically, a gauge potential lays claim to independent status as a further feature of the physical situation. But whether this is a local or a global feature is not made any clearer by the variety of mathematical structures used to represent it. I argue that in the theory of electromagnetism (or a non-Abelian generalization) that describes quantum particles subject to a classical interaction, the gauge potential is best understood as a feature of the physical situation whose global character is most naturally represented by the holonomies of closed curves in space-time.

Philosophy of Science•Dec 1, 2001•57 citations
This article examines the implications of the holonomy interpretation of classical electromagnetism. As has been argued by Richard Healey and Gordon Belot, classical electromagnetism on this interpretation evinces a form of nonseparability, something that otherwise might have been thought of as confined to nonclassical physics. Consideration of the differences between this classical nonseparability and quantum nonseparability shows that the nonseparability exhibited by the classical electromagnetism on the holonomy interpretation is closer to separability than might at first appear. 1 Introduction 2 Interpretations of Classical Electromagnetism 3 Quantum Nonseparability 4 The Holonomy Representation of the Classical Electromagnetic Field 5 Holonomy and Nonseparability: The Classical Electromagnetic Field 6 On Humean Supervenience 7 Conclusion
We first examine Howard's analysis of the Bell factorizability condition in terms of ‘separability’ and ‘locality’ and then consider his claims that the violations of Bell's inequality by the statistical predictions of quantum mechanics should be interpreted in terms of ‘nonseparability’ rather than ‘nonlocality’ and that ‘nonseparability’ implies the failure of spacetime as a principle of individuation for quantum-mechanical systems. We will argue that his argument for the first claim is less than compelling and that any argument for the second claim will be interpretation-dependent and, hence, not generally valid.
The standard interpretation of quantum measurement on entangled systems holds that measuring one particle nonlocally collapses the wavefunction of its spacelike-separated partner. We argue that this conclusion rests on a false presupposition: that subsystems of entangled systems possess independent ontic states. If the global wavefunction is the sole ontic object (ψ-ontic holism), then for entangled systems, there is no "state of B" to be affected by measurement at A. Measurement is a local dynamical process-concretely modeled by continuous spontaneous localization-that destroys one local wavefunction component at the measurement site; the global state factorizes as a consequence, and subsystem ontology emerges for the first time. The transition of the distant particle's reduced density matrix from mixed to pure reflects this emergence of separability, not a physical change at the distant location. The framework satisfies no-signaling and embraces the contextuality required by the Kochen-Specker and GHZ theorems. We are explicit about its relation to Bell's theorem: Bell local causality (factorizability) fails, as it must in any empirically adequate theory, but the failure is confined to outcome independence and is identified with the nonseparability of the global ontic state, while parameter independence-and with it the locality of the dynamics-holds exactly. Decoherence provides the mechanism by which the global wavefunction factorizes and classical separability emerges. The apparent nonlocality of quantum mechanics is thus reinterpreted as nonseparability: the fundamental ontology is holistic, but the dynamics are local.
We analyze the difference between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics. We come to the conclusion that this difference can be found in the nature of the observables that are considered for the physical system under consideration. Classical mechanics can only describe a certain kind of what we called ‘‘classical observable.’’ Quantum mechanics can only describe another kind of observable; it cannot describe, however, classical observables. To perform this analysis, we use a theory where every kind of observable can be treated and which is in a natural way a generalization of both classical and quantum mechanics. If in a study of a physical system in this theory we restrict ourselves to the classical observables, we rediscover classical mechanics as a kind of first study of the physical system, where all the nonclassical properties are hidden. If we find that this first study is too rough we can also study the nonclassical part of the physical system by a theory which is eventually quantum mechanics.
We examine the notion of nonclassicality in terms of quasiprobability distributions. In particular, we not only ask if a specific quasiprobability can be interpreted as a classical probability density, but we also require that characteristic features of classical electrodynamics are resembled. We show that the only quasiprobabilities that correctly describe the superposition principle of classical electromagnetic fields are the sss-parametrized quasiprobabilities. Furthermore, the Glauber-Sudarshan PPP function is the only quantum-mechanical quasiprobability that is transformed at a classical attenuator in the same way as a classical probability distribution. This result strengthens the definition of nonclassicality in terms of the PPP function, in contrast to possible definitions in terms of other quasiprobabilities.
The difference between the conceptual framework of classical physics and that of quantum physics which is due to the nonseparability property of the latter theory is better understood in specific examples. This chapter uses some specific examples to test the validity, both in classical and in quantum mechanics, of two conceptual principles. First is Reality Principle . The very concept of a reality may be criticized by philosophically minded empiricists. A widespread opinion, however, is that somehow a physical reality does exist, which should not just amount to the talks we give about it. In their search for a criterion that would make it possible to recognize elements of reality, A. Einstein, B. Podolsky, and N. Rosen had to take such considerations into account. Second, Principle of the Separability of Mechanically Isolated Systems, one can easily guess that this second principle, which remains somewhat implicit in the work of Einstein and his colleagues may well be the source of insuperable difficulties.
Classically, a gauge potential was merely a convenient device for generating a corresponding gauge field. Quantum-mechanically, a gauge potential lays claim to independent status as a further feature of the physical situation. But whether this is a local or a global feature is not made any clearer by the variety of mathematical structures used to represent it. I argue that in the theory of electromagnetism (or a non-Abelian generalization) that describes quantum particles subject to a classical interaction, the gauge potential is best understood as a feature of the physical situation whose global character is most naturally represented by the holonomies of closed curves in space-time.