We show that Heisenberg quantization of a system of two identical particles in one dimension recently proposed by Leinaas and Myrheim leads to the family of 1D fractional statistics introduced by Polychronakos in terms of Schrödinger quantization.
We show that the algebraic quantization method of Heisenberg and the analytical method of Schrödinger are not necessarily equivalent when applied to systems of identical particles. Heisenberg quantization is a natural approach, but inherently more ambiguous and difficult than Schrödinger quantization. We apply the Heisenberg method to the examples of two identical particles in one and two dimensions, and relate the results to the so-called fractional statistics known from Schrödinger quantization. For two particles in d dimensions we look for linear, Hermitian representations of the symplectic Lie algebra sp(d, R). The boson and fermion representations are special cases, but there exist other representations. In one dimension there is a continuous interpolation between boson and fermion systems, different from the interpolation found in Schrödinger quantization. In two dimensions we find representations that can be realized in terms of multicomponent wave functions on a three-dimensional space, but we have no clear physical interpretation of these representations, which include extra degrees of freedom compared to the classical system.
The equivalence of a quantum system of particles interacting with a two-body inverse square potential to a system of noninteracting particles obeying 1D fractional statistics (1D anyons), stated by Polychronakos for particles on a line, is studied for the cases where the interacting system is placed (i) into a harmonic potential on a line, and (ii) on a ring, with imposing periodic boundary conditions. In the first case, reducibility of the interacting system to the Calogero system is used to explore the statistical distribution for free 1D anyons. On a ring, the thermodynamic limit is discussed in terms of the thermodynamic (asymptotic) Bethe ansatz. Yang and Yang’s integral equation is treated in this case as describing the statistical mechanics of free 1D anyons. It gives a functional equation for the statistical distribution of 1D anyons consistent with the harmonic potential approach. We show that on a ring of a finite circumference, a system of two free 1D anyons is equivalent to a system of two particles interacting with an inverse sine square potential (the Sutherland system). We also discuss the relation to the statistical mechanics of free anyons in 2+1 dimensions.