Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Journal of Physics

Current density and continuity in discretized models

Timothy B. Boykin, Mathieu Luisier, Gerhard Klimeck

Published Jul 21, 2010• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Discrete approaches have long been used in numerical modelling of physical systems in both research and teaching. Discrete versions of the Schrödinger equation employing either one or several basis functions per mesh point are often used by senior undergraduates and beginning graduate students in computational physics projects. In studying discrete models, students can encounter conceptual difficulties with the representation of the current and its divergence because different finite-difference expressions, all of which reduce to the current density in the continuous limit, measure different physical quantities. Understanding these different discrete currents is essential and requires a careful analysis of the current operator, the divergence of the current and the continuity equation. Here we develop point forms of the current and its divergence valid for an arbitrary mesh and basis. We show that in discrete models currents exist only along lines joining atomic sites (or mesh points). Using these results, we derive a discrete analogue of the divergence theorem and demonstrate probability conservation in a purely localized-basis approach.

DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/31/5/010

Related papers

The Discretized Momentum Operator

Timothy B. Boykin

Discrete versions of continuous models are central to numerical calculations in physics and engineering. A very common problem in setting up a discrete model is how to handle derivatives. There are, for example, three common approximations for the first derivative, and each embeds different properties in the discrete model. Discretizing continuous expressions simplified using rules of calculus is especially problematic, since many different discretizations can stand for the same continuous expression depending on the stage of simplification at which the discretization is carried out. The problems are resolved by requiring that the discrete model satisfies discrete versions of the properties satisfied by the continuous original. We illustrate by using some examples from undergraduate-level one-dimensional quantum mechanics.

The Physics Educator•Jun 1, 2019•0 citations

Obtaining the Probability Vector Current Density in Canonical Quantum Mechanics by Linear Superposition

Steven Kenneth Kauffmann

The quantum mechanics status of the probability vector current density has long seemed to be marginal. On one hand no systematic prescription for its construction is provided, and the special examples of it that are obtained for particular types of Hamiltonian operator could conceivably be attributed to happenstance. On the other hand this concept's key physical interpretation as local average particle flux, which flows from the equation of continuity that it is supposed to satisfy in conjunction with the probability scalar density, has been claimed to breach the uncertainty principle. Given the dispiriting impact of that claim, we straightaway point out that the subtle directional nature of the uncertainty principle makes it consistent with the measurement of local average particle flux. We next focus on the fact that the unique closed-form linear-superposition quantization of any classical Hamiltonian function yields in tandem the corresponding unique linear-superposition closed-form divergence of the probability vector current density. Because the probability vector current density is linked to the quantum physics only through the occurrence of its divergence in the equation of continuity, it is theoretically most appropriate to construct this vector field exclusively from its divergence -- analysis of the best-known "textbook" special example of a probability vector current density shows that it is thus constructed. That special example in fact leads to the physically interesting "Ehrenfest subclass" of probability vector current densities, which are closely related to their classical peers.

arXiv:1302.1086•Feb 2, 2013•0 citations

On Galilei Invariance of Continuity Equation

V. Boyko

Depending on definition of ρ (density) and j = (j1, . . . , jn) (current), we can construct essentially different quantum mechanics with different equations of motion, which are distinct from classical linear Schrodinger, Klein–Gordon–Fock, and Dirac equations. At the beginning we study a symmetry of the continuity equation considering (ρ, j) as dependent variables related by (1). Theorem 1 [1]. The invariance algebra of equation (1) is an infinite-dimensional algebra with basis operators

•Jan 1, 2000•0 citations

Mathematical aspects of quantum charge transport and current fluctuations

Sven Bachmann

The study of electrical currents in a regime where a description as a continuous flow fails and the particle nature becomes important, but where notions such as particle density or currents continue to be meaningful, will be at the heart of the present dissertation. Given such a mesoscopic system through which electrons flow, either actively through quantum pumping or passively due to a potential difference, we investigate quantities such as transferred charge, noise, current fluctuations, and relations between them. More generally we shall examine the statistics of particle transport. All discussions will concentrate on compact devices transferring charge between two one-dimensional reservoirs (the leads) of independent electrons. Firstly, we consider the generating function of the moments of transferred charge and we prove that it is given by the determinant of a single-particle operator. It is formally equivalent to a formula of Lesovik and Levitov, but is shown to be well-defined in the situations under consideration, whereas the former is not, in general. The mechanism leading to regularization is typical for mesoscopic systems: we consider a limiting case that reveals the fundamental structure of the problem. In fact, as suited for an open system, the leads contain an infinite number of charges. It follows mathematically that the second quantization ought to be carried out upon the Fermi sea and not upon the vacuum, a procedure known as the GNS construction. We shall rely heavily on operator algebraic techniques. The set of observables, the C*-algebra of canonical anticommutation relations, admits different representations for systems in the thermodynamic limit, which are described by their reduced one-particle density matrix. An important question will be the existence of operators such as the charge or the time evolution in a given representation, which induce so-called Bogoliubov transformations. These prerequisites at hand, we shall pose the problem of counting statistics clearly, prove that the regularized determinant emerges naturally, and show that it describes the transport of integer charges with non-negative probabilities. Secondly, we introduce a model of instantaneous scattering in which various examples can be computed explicitely. In particular, we show that the above theorem applies for scattering through a smoothly operating pump over a finite time interval. We also exhibit situations where the propagator does exist but the generating function is ambiguous. In a more computational approach, we then turn to the relation of individual moments of transferred charge to current correlators. It turns out that the former can indeed be expressed as integrals of the latter over time, provided the current operators are ordered according to Matthews’ T∗ ordering. It is given by first arranging the charge operators according to their time indices, and only then taking the time derivatives, which induce contact terms whose singular support lies along time coincidences. We shall give two derivations of this result, because the first one is transparent, and the second one is related to contradictory computations in the literature where the system is considered to be measured by an external spin. In the model of constant instantaneous scattering, we then argue from the Lesovik-Levitov determinant that the transport can be interpreted in terms of a binomial process in the long time limit. In a parallel computation, we concentrate on the third cumulant as defined by integration of current correlators and show how the contact terms of the T∗ ordering play an essential role in providing the expected binomial result, too. To close this thesis, we suggest an algebraic framework that lays the foundations for a rigorous discussion of the Casimir effect. The problem of infinites arising in the comparison of two physical situations for a bosonic field is interpreted as the non-equivalence of states on the algebra of canonical commutation relations. We exhibit sufficient conditions on the one-particle Hamiltonians which ensure that the Casimir energy is finite and give an expression for it. We discuss its formal equivalence with the result obtained from the standard mode summing method.

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

Relativistic Schrödinger equation and probability currents for free particles

David Carfì

In this work, we start from the problem of quantizing the relativistic Hamiltonian of a free massive particle (rest mass different from 0), a problem exceptionally difficult in the standard approaches to quantum mechanics. In fact, in tempered distribution state space, we find the natural way to define the relativistic Hamiltonian operator and its associated Schrödinger equation The existence of a linear continuous Hermitian operator associated with the Einstein's Hamiltonian of a free particle, defined on the entire tempered distribution space, automatically implies the conservation of Born probability flux (which doesn't mean the conservation of particles number, rather it implies the conservation of the total relativistic energy of the solution wave). We, then, deduce the continuity equation for the Born probability density and study some its different (but equivalent) expressions. We determine some possible forms of probability currents and flux velocity fields associated with the particle evolution. We provide the relativistic invariant expression for both Schrödinger equation and probability flux continuity equations.

Proceedings of the International Geometry Center•Jan 13, 2024•3 citations

Finite-size localization scenarios in condensation transitions

Gabriele Gotti, Stefano Iubini, Paolo Politi

We consider the phenomenon of condensation of a globally conserved quantity $H={\ensuremath{\sum}}_{i=1}^{N}{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{i}$ distributed on $N$ sites, occurring when the density $h=H/N$ exceeds a critical density ${h}_{c}$. We numerically study the dependence of the participation ratio ${Y}_{2}=\ensuremath{\langle}{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{i}^{2}\ensuremath{\rangle}/(N{h}^{2})$ on the size $N$ of the system and on the control parameter $\ensuremath{\delta}=(h\ensuremath{-}{h}_{c})$, for various models: (i) a model with two conservation laws, derived from the discrete nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation; (ii) the continuous version of the zero-range process class, for different forms of the function $f(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ defining the factorized steady state. Our results show that various localization scenarios may appear for finite $N$ and close to the transition point. These scenarios are characterized by the presence or the absence of a minimum of ${Y}_{2}$ when plotted against $N$ and by an exponent $\ensuremath{\gamma}\ensuremath{\ge}2$ defined through the relation ${N}^{*}\ensuremath{\simeq}{\ensuremath{\delta}}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\gamma}}$, where ${N}^{*}$ separates the delocalized region ($N\ensuremath{\ll}{N}^{*}$, ${Y}_{2}$ vanishes with increasing $N$) from the localized region ($N\ensuremath{\gg}{N}^{*}$, ${Y}_{2}$ is approximately constant). We finally compare our results with the structure of the condensate obtained through the single-site marginal distribution.

arXiv:2010.11138•Physical review. E•May 25, 2021•13 citations
Discrete approaches have long been used in numerical modelling of physical systems in both research and teaching. Discrete versions of the Schrödinger equation employing either one or several basis functions per mesh point are often used by senior undergraduates and beginning graduate students in computational physics projects. In studying discrete models, students can encounter conceptual difficulties with the representation of the current and its divergence because different finite-difference expressions, all of which reduce to the current density in the continuous limit, measure different physical quantities. Understanding these different discrete currents is essential and requires a careful analysis of the current operator, the divergence of the current and the continuity equation. Here we develop point forms of the current and its divergence valid for an arbitrary mesh and basis. We show that in discrete models currents exist only along lines joining atomic sites (or mesh points). Using these results, we derive a discrete analogue of the divergence theorem and demonstrate probability conservation in a purely localized-basis approach.
Discrete versions of continuous models are central to numerical calculations in physics and engineering. A very common problem in setting up a discrete model is how to handle derivatives. There are, for example, three common approximations for the first derivative, and each embeds different properties in the discrete model. Discretizing continuous expressions simplified using rules of calculus is especially problematic, since many different discretizations can stand for the same continuous expression depending on the stage of simplification at which the discretization is carried out. The problems are resolved by requiring that the discrete model satisfies discrete versions of the properties satisfied by the continuous original. We illustrate by using some examples from undergraduate-level one-dimensional quantum mechanics.
The quantum mechanics status of the probability vector current density has long seemed to be marginal. On one hand no systematic prescription for its construction is provided, and the special examples of it that are obtained for particular types of Hamiltonian operator could conceivably be attributed to happenstance. On the other hand this concept's key physical interpretation as local average particle flux, which flows from the equation of continuity that it is supposed to satisfy in conjunction with the probability scalar density, has been claimed to breach the uncertainty principle. Given the dispiriting impact of that claim, we straightaway point out that the subtle directional nature of the uncertainty principle makes it consistent with the measurement of local average particle flux. We next focus on the fact that the unique closed-form linear-superposition quantization of any classical Hamiltonian function yields in tandem the corresponding unique linear-superposition closed-form divergence of the probability vector current density. Because the probability vector current density is linked to the quantum physics only through the occurrence of its divergence in the equation of continuity, it is theoretically most appropriate to construct this vector field exclusively from its divergence -- analysis of the best-known "textbook" special example of a probability vector current density shows that it is thus constructed. That special example in fact leads to the physically interesting "Ehrenfest subclass" of probability vector current densities, which are closely related to their classical peers.
The study of electrical currents in a regime where a description as a continuous flow fails and the particle nature becomes important, but where notions such as particle density or currents continue to be meaningful, will be at the heart of the present dissertation. Given such a mesoscopic system through which electrons flow, either actively through quantum pumping or passively due to a potential difference, we investigate quantities such as transferred charge, noise, current fluctuations, and relations between them. More generally we shall examine the statistics of particle transport. All discussions will concentrate on compact devices transferring charge between two one-dimensional reservoirs (the leads) of independent electrons. Firstly, we consider the generating function of the moments of transferred charge and we prove that it is given by the determinant of a single-particle operator. It is formally equivalent to a formula of Lesovik and Levitov, but is shown to be well-defined in the situations under consideration, whereas the former is not, in general. The mechanism leading to regularization is typical for mesoscopic systems: we consider a limiting case that reveals the fundamental structure of the problem. In fact, as suited for an open system, the leads contain an infinite number of charges. It follows mathematically that the second quantization ought to be carried out upon the Fermi sea and not upon the vacuum, a procedure known as the GNS construction. We shall rely heavily on operator algebraic techniques. The set of observables, the C*-algebra of canonical anticommutation relations, admits different representations for systems in the thermodynamic limit, which are described by their reduced one-particle density matrix. An important question will be the existence of operators such as the charge or the time evolution in a given representation, which induce so-called Bogoliubov transformations. These prerequisites at hand, we shall pose the problem of counting statistics clearly, prove that the regularized determinant emerges naturally, and show that it describes the transport of integer charges with non-negative probabilities. Secondly, we introduce a model of instantaneous scattering in which various examples can be computed explicitely. In particular, we show that the above theorem applies for scattering through a smoothly operating pump over a finite time interval. We also exhibit situations where the propagator does exist but the generating function is ambiguous. In a more computational approach, we then turn to the relation of individual moments of transferred charge to current correlators. It turns out that the former can indeed be expressed as integrals of the latter over time, provided the current operators are ordered according to Matthews’ T∗ ordering. It is given by first arranging the charge operators according to their time indices, and only then taking the time derivatives, which induce contact terms whose singular support lies along time coincidences. We shall give two derivations of this result, because the first one is transparent, and the second one is related to contradictory computations in the literature where the system is considered to be measured by an external spin. In the model of constant instantaneous scattering, we then argue from the Lesovik-Levitov determinant that the transport can be interpreted in terms of a binomial process in the long time limit. In a parallel computation, we concentrate on the third cumulant as defined by integration of current correlators and show how the contact terms of the T∗ ordering play an essential role in providing the expected binomial result, too. To close this thesis, we suggest an algebraic framework that lays the foundations for a rigorous discussion of the Casimir effect. The problem of infinites arising in the comparison of two physical situations for a bosonic field is interpreted as the non-equivalence of states on the algebra of canonical commutation relations. We exhibit sufficient conditions on the one-particle Hamiltonians which ensure that the Casimir energy is finite and give an expression for it. We discuss its formal equivalence with the result obtained from the standard mode summing method.
In this work, we start from the problem of quantizing the relativistic Hamiltonian of a free massive particle (rest mass different from 0), a problem exceptionally difficult in the standard approaches to quantum mechanics. In fact, in tempered distribution state space, we find the natural way to define the relativistic Hamiltonian operator and its associated Schrödinger equation The existence of a linear continuous Hermitian operator associated with the Einstein's Hamiltonian of a free particle, defined on the entire tempered distribution space, automatically implies the conservation of Born probability flux (which doesn't mean the conservation of particles number, rather it implies the conservation of the total relativistic energy of the solution wave). We, then, deduce the continuity equation for the Born probability density and study some its different (but equivalent) expressions. We determine some possible forms of probability currents and flux velocity fields associated with the particle evolution. We provide the relativistic invariant expression for both Schrödinger equation and probability flux continuity equations.
We consider the phenomenon of condensation of a globally conserved quantity $H={\ensuremath{\sum}}_{i=1}^{N}{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{i}$ distributed on NNN sites, occurring when the density h=H/Nh=H/Nh=H/N exceeds a critical density hc{h}_{c}hc​. We numerically study the dependence of the participation ratio ${Y}_{2}=\ensuremath{\langle}{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{i}^{2}\ensuremath{\rangle}/(N{h}^{2})$ on the size NNN of the system and on the control parameter $\ensuremath{\delta}=(h\ensuremath{-}{h}_{c})$, for various models: (i) a model with two conservation laws, derived from the discrete nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation; (ii) the continuous version of the zero-range process class, for different forms of the function $f(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ defining the factorized steady state. Our results show that various localization scenarios may appear for finite NNN and close to the transition point. These scenarios are characterized by the presence or the absence of a minimum of Y2{Y}_{2}Y2​ when plotted against NNN and by an exponent $\ensuremath{\gamma}\ensuremath{\ge}2$ defined through the relation ${N}^{*}\ensuremath{\simeq}{\ensuremath{\delta}}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\gamma}}$, where N∗{N}^{*}N∗ separates the delocalized region ($N\ensuremath{\ll}{N}^{*}$, Y2{Y}_{2}Y2​ vanishes with increasing NNN) from the localized region ($N\ensuremath{\gg}{N}^{*}$, Y2{Y}_{2}Y2​ is approximately constant). We finally compare our results with the structure of the condensate obtained through the single-site marginal distribution.