Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Electronic Notes in Theoretical Computer Science

A Spectral Order for Infinite Dimensional Quantum Spaces

Joe Mashburn

Published Apr 1, 2007• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In 2002 Coecke and Martin created a Bayesian order for the finite dimensional spaces of classical states in physics and used this to define a similar order, the spectral order on the finite dimensional quantum states. These orders gave the spaces a structure similar to that of a domain. This allows for measuring information content of states and for determining which partial states are approximations of which pure states. In a previous paper the author extended the Bayesian order to infinite dimensional spaces of classical states. The order on infinite dimensional spaces retains many of the characteristics important to physics, but loses the domain theoretic structure. It becomes impossible to measure information content in the same way that it is done for the finite dimensional spaces, and the sense of approximation is lost. In this paper, we will use the Bayesian order to define a spectral order on the infinite dimensional spaces of quantum states.

DOI
10.1016/j.entcs.2007.02.038

Related papers

A spectral order for infinite-dimensional quantum spaces

Joe Mashburn

In this paper we extend the spectral order of Coecke and Martin to infinite-dimensional quantum states. Many properties present in the finite-dimensional case are preserved, but some of the most important are lost. The order is constructed and its properties analysed. Most of the useful measurements of information content are lost. Shannon entropy is defined on only a part of the model, and that part is not a closed subset of the model. The finite parts of the lattices used by Birkhoff and von Neumann as models for classical and quantum logic appear as subsets of the models for infinite classical and quantum states.

Mathematical Structures in Computer Science•Jul 10, 2012•0 citations

A partial order on classical and quantum states

Arka Bandyopadhyay

In this work we extend the work done by Bob Coecke and Keye Martin in their paper “Partial Order on Classical States and Quantum States (2003)”. We review basic notions involving elementary domain theory, the set of probability measures on a finite set {a1, a2, ..., an}, which we identify with the standard (n-1)-simplex ∆n and Shannon Entropy. We consider partial orders on ∆n, which have the Entropy Reversal Property (ERP) : elements lower in the order have higher (Shannon) entropy or equivalently less information . The ERP property is important because of its applications in quantum information theory. We define a new partial order on ∆n, called Stochastic Order , using the well-known concept of majorization order and show that it has the ERP property and is also a continuous domain. In contrast, the bayesian order on ∆n defined by Coecke and Martin has the ERP property but is not continuous.

Civil War Book Review•Jul 6, 2011•2 citations

Infinite dimensionality of the post-processing order of measurements on a general state space

Yui Kuramochi

Abstract For a partially ordered set ( S , ⪯), the order (monotone) dimension is the minimum cardinality of total orders (respectively, real-valued order monotone functions) on S that characterize the order ⪯. In this paper we consider an arbitrary generalized probabilistic theory and the set of finite-outcome measurements on it, which can be described by effect-valued measures, equipped with the classical post-processing orders. We prove that the order and order monotone dimensions of the post-processing order are (countably) infinite if the state space is not a singleton (and is separable in the norm topology). This result gives a negative answer to the open question for quantum measurements posed in (Guff et al 2021 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 54 225301). We also consider the quantum post-processing relation of channels with a fixed input quantum system described by a separable Hilbert space H and show that the order (monotone) dimension is countably infinite when dim H ⩾ 2 .

arXiv:2111.14129•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Oct 12, 2022•0 citations

Fundamental limits upon the measurement of state vectors

K. R. W. Jones

Using the Shannon information theory and the Bayesian methodology for inverting quantum data [K. R. W. Jones, Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 207, 140 (1991)] we prove a fundamental bound upon the measurability of finite-dimensional quantum states. To do so we imagine a thought experiment for the quantum communication of a pure state \ensuremath{\psi}, known to one experimenter, to his colleague via the transmission of N identical copies of it in the limit of zero temperature. Initial information available to the second experimenter is merely that of the allowed manifold of superpositions upon which the chosen \ensuremath{\psi} may lie. Her efforts to determine it, in an optimal way, subject to the fundamental constraints imposed by quantum noise, define a statistical uncertainty principle. This limits the accuracy with which \ensuremath{\psi} can be measured according to the number N of transmitted copies. The general result is illustrated in the physically realizable case of polarized photons.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1994•75 citations

A qualitative approach to quantum probability

Ehud Lehrer, Eran Shmaya

A likelihood order is defined over linear subspaces of a finite dimensional Hilbert space. The question arises as to when such an order can be represented by a quantum probability. We introduce a few behaviorally plausible axioms that provide the answer in two cases: pure state and uniform measure. The general problem is answered by using duality-like conditions. The general problem of characterizing the partial orders that admit a quantum representation by behaviorally justified axioms remains open.

arXiv:quant-ph/0503066•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Mar 14, 2006•12 citations

Mathematics of quantum mechanics II: infinite dimension

Michel Le Bellac

In Chapter 4 we saw that the canonical commutation relations force us to use a space of states of infinite dimension, in which rigor would require the use of advanced mathematical tools. Fortunately, physicists generally need only to carry the results for finite dimension over to infinite dimension with some simple modifications which we shall indicate here, without embarking on sophisticated mathematics. Nevertheless, it is useful to be aware of the lapses in rigor which are customarily made in physics in order to avoid possible unpleasant surprises. The objective of this chapter is, on the one hand, to present some concrete examples illustrating the new features which arise in infinite dimension and, on the other, to give the rules for practical calculations, in particular to write down the spectral decomposition of Hermitian and unitary operators. The mathematics we use is a bit more detailed than commonly found in most quantum mechanics textbooks. The reader interested purely in the practical aspects can proceed directly to Section 7.3, where the results essential for later on are summarized. Hilbert spaces Definitions The space of states of quantum mechanics is a Hilbert space ℌ, which in general is of infinite dimension. The axiomatic definition of a Hilbert space is the following. It is a vector space which, for the needs of quantum mechanics, is defined on complex numbers. The vectors of this space are denoted |ϕ〉. […]

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 23, 2006•0 citations
In 2002 Coecke and Martin created a Bayesian order for the finite dimensional spaces of classical states in physics and used this to define a similar order, the spectral order on the finite dimensional quantum states. These orders gave the spaces a structure similar to that of a domain. This allows for measuring information content of states and for determining which partial states are approximations of which pure states. In a previous paper the author extended the Bayesian order to infinite dimensional spaces of classical states. The order on infinite dimensional spaces retains many of the characteristics important to physics, but loses the domain theoretic structure. It becomes impossible to measure information content in the same way that it is done for the finite dimensional spaces, and the sense of approximation is lost. In this paper, we will use the Bayesian order to define a spectral order on the infinite dimensional spaces of quantum states.
In this paper we extend the spectral order of Coecke and Martin to infinite-dimensional quantum states. Many properties present in the finite-dimensional case are preserved, but some of the most important are lost. The order is constructed and its properties analysed. Most of the useful measurements of information content are lost. Shannon entropy is defined on only a part of the model, and that part is not a closed subset of the model. The finite parts of the lattices used by Birkhoff and von Neumann as models for classical and quantum logic appear as subsets of the models for infinite classical and quantum states.
In this work we extend the work done by Bob Coecke and Keye Martin in their paper “Partial Order on Classical States and Quantum States (2003)”. We review basic notions involving elementary domain theory, the set of probability measures on a finite set {a1, a2, ..., an}, which we identify with the standard (n-1)-simplex ∆n and Shannon Entropy. We consider partial orders on ∆n, which have the Entropy Reversal Property (ERP) : elements lower in the order have higher (Shannon) entropy or equivalently less information . The ERP property is important because of its applications in quantum information theory. We define a new partial order on ∆n, called Stochastic Order , using the well-known concept of majorization order and show that it has the ERP property and is also a continuous domain. In contrast, the bayesian order on ∆n defined by Coecke and Martin has the ERP property but is not continuous.
Abstract For a partially ordered set ( S , ⪯), the order (monotone) dimension is the minimum cardinality of total orders (respectively, real-valued order monotone functions) on S that characterize the order ⪯. In this paper we consider an arbitrary generalized probabilistic theory and the set of finite-outcome measurements on it, which can be described by effect-valued measures, equipped with the classical post-processing orders. We prove that the order and order monotone dimensions of the post-processing order are (countably) infinite if the state space is not a singleton (and is separable in the norm topology). This result gives a negative answer to the open question for quantum measurements posed in (Guff et al 2021 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 54 225301). We also consider the quantum post-processing relation of channels with a fixed input quantum system described by a separable Hilbert space H and show that the order (monotone) dimension is countably infinite when dim H ⩾ 2 .
Using the Shannon information theory and the Bayesian methodology for inverting quantum data [K. R. W. Jones, Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 207, 140 (1991)] we prove a fundamental bound upon the measurability of finite-dimensional quantum states. To do so we imagine a thought experiment for the quantum communication of a pure state \ensuremath{\psi}, known to one experimenter, to his colleague via the transmission of N identical copies of it in the limit of zero temperature. Initial information available to the second experimenter is merely that of the allowed manifold of superpositions upon which the chosen \ensuremath{\psi} may lie. Her efforts to determine it, in an optimal way, subject to the fundamental constraints imposed by quantum noise, define a statistical uncertainty principle. This limits the accuracy with which \ensuremath{\psi} can be measured according to the number N of transmitted copies. The general result is illustrated in the physically realizable case of polarized photons.
A likelihood order is defined over linear subspaces of a finite dimensional Hilbert space. The question arises as to when such an order can be represented by a quantum probability. We introduce a few behaviorally plausible axioms that provide the answer in two cases: pure state and uniform measure. The general problem is answered by using duality-like conditions. The general problem of characterizing the partial orders that admit a quantum representation by behaviorally justified axioms remains open.
In Chapter 4 we saw that the canonical commutation relations force us to use a space of states of infinite dimension, in which rigor would require the use of advanced mathematical tools. Fortunately, physicists generally need only to carry the results for finite dimension over to infinite dimension with some simple modifications which we shall indicate here, without embarking on sophisticated mathematics. Nevertheless, it is useful to be aware of the lapses in rigor which are customarily made in physics in order to avoid possible unpleasant surprises. The objective of this chapter is, on the one hand, to present some concrete examples illustrating the new features which arise in infinite dimension and, on the other, to give the rules for practical calculations, in particular to write down the spectral decomposition of Hermitian and unitary operators. The mathematics we use is a bit more detailed than commonly found in most quantum mechanics textbooks. The reader interested purely in the practical aspects can proceed directly to Section 7.3, where the results essential for later on are summarized. Hilbert spaces Definitions The space of states of quantum mechanics is a Hilbert space ℌ, which in general is of infinite dimension. The axiomatic definition of a Hilbert space is the following. It is a vector space which, for the needs of quantum mechanics, is defined on complex numbers. The vectors of this space are denoted |ϕ〉. […]