Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Canadian Journal of Physics

Coherent-state path integral operator ordering, and regularization: A simple example

L. C. Lew Yan Voon

Published Oct 1, 1991• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For a restricted class of potential problems, the Feynman path integral in the coordinate representation circumvents operator-ordering ambiguities. We will show that, in the coherent-state representation, the traditional continuum time path integral cannot resolve this issue. Using a simple solvable model, we carry out a careful analysis of the continuum limit with regularization. The latter is found to be necessary to address the operator-ordering issue.

DOI
10.1139/p91-183

Related papers

Selecta from a Life-Long Obsession with Path Integrals

John R. Klauder, Christopher Casenas Bernido, M. Victoria Carpio-Bernido

The definition and interpretation of canonical, phase space path integrals has evolved over many years to achieve a form that now admits a correct and rigorous formulation, which is also covariant under canonical coordinate transformations. Such formulations involve coherent state representations, which, in their modern version, were originally introduced as an alternative tool to construct phase space path integrals. Moreover, coherent state representations lead to physical interpretations that are more natural than those afforded by more traditional representations. Suitable continuous time regularization procedures lead to a covariant phase space path integral formulation that greatly clarifies the vague phrase that canonical quantization requires Cartesian coordinates.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Hubbard–Stratonovich transformation and consistent ordering in the coherent state path integral: insights from stochastic calculus

Adam Rançon

Abstract Recently, doubts have been cast on the validity of the continuous-time coherent state path integral. This has led to controversies regarding the correct way of performing calculations with path integrals, and to several alternative definitions of what should be their continuous limit. Furthermore, the issue of a supposedly proper ordering of the Hamiltonian operator, entangled with the continuous-time limit, has led to considerable confusion in the literature. Since coherent state path integrals are at the basis of the modern formulation of many-body quantum theory, it should be laid on solid foundations. Here, we show that the issues raised above are coming from the illegitimate use of the (standard) rules of calculus, which are not necessarily valid in path integrals. This is well known in the context of stochastic equations, in particular in their path integral formulation. This insight allows for solving these issues and addressing the correspondence between the various orderings at the level of the path integral. We also use this opportunity to address the proper calculation of a functional determinant in the presence of a Hubbard–Stratonovich field, which shares in the controversies.

arXiv:1906.02571•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 17, 2020•8 citations

Numerical mathematics of Feynman path integrals and the operator ordering problem

T. Gregory Dewey

Infinitesimal propagators have been used in quantum-mechanical problems to establish ordering rules for classical quantities. Ambiguities arise in operator ordering as a result of the freedom of choice in evaluating the classical action over a short-time interval. The primitive quadrature rule employed in a short-time propagator establishes the quantum system associated with the classical Hamiltonian. Normal propagators are constructed from products of infinitesimal propagators and represent a compound quadrature in which the path is broken into line segments and a separate quadrature rule is applied to each line segment. It is demonstrated for Hamiltonians involving the vector potential that higher-order quadratures of the infinitesimal propagator all give a unique and proper ordering. Similarly, Hamiltonians that are products of powers of position x and momentum p, i.e., ${\mathit{p}}^{\mathit{l}}$${\mathit{x}}^{\mathit{m}}$, show some preference for Born-Jordon ordering as higher quadrature rules are applied. Unique orderings can be obtained in some cases by solving for the normal propagator. This is done for the Hamiltonian ${\mathit{p}}^{\mathit{l}}$${\mathit{x}}^{\mathit{m}}$ by using a Fourier representation for the phase-space propagator. This formalism requires that both the momentum and position coordinates be represented by Fourier series. These results show that care must be taken when generating quantum-mechanical operators by using primitive quadrature rules in conjunction with a short-time propagator. These ambiguities are eliminated when the compound quadrature is performed to generate the normal propagator.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1990•5 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Coherent-state path integrals in the continuum’”

G. Kordas, S. I. Mistakidis, A. I. Karanikas

In this Reply we briefly clarify the main points of our method to construct coherent-state path integrals in the continuum and we reply to the critique raised by in the preceding Comment by Kochetov [Phys. Rev. A 99, 026101 (2019)]. By using definite examples, we prove that our approach is capable of resolving the inconsistencies accompanying the standard coherent-state path-integral representation of interacting systems.

Physical Review A•Feb 13, 2019•4 citations

Breakdown of the Coherent State Path Integral: Two Simple Examples

Justin H. Wilson, Victor M. Galitski

We show how the time-continuous coherent state path integral breaks down for both the single-site Bose-Hubbard model and the spin-path integral. Specifically, when the Hamiltonian is quadratic in a generator of the algebra used to construct coherent states, the path integral fails to produce correct results following from an operator approach. As suggested by previous authors, we note that the problems do not arise in the time-discretized version of the path integral.

arXiv:1012.1328•Physical Review Letters•Mar 16, 2011•42 citations

An investigation of coherent state path integrals as applied to a harmonic oscillator and a single spin

L. C. Lew Yan Voon

In this project two steps involved in the handling of path integrals are reexamined in detail for coherent state path integals. They concern the continuum limit approximation and the regularization of the formal path integrals. Restricting oneself to the harmonic oscillator, the technique of time splitting is used to set up the coherent state path integrals and the proper way to pass to the continuum limit is demonstrated. The manipulation of these path integrals calls for regularization procedures and the validity of discrete, Riemann zeta function and 'derivative' regularization methods is observed. A modification to a fermionic theory is briefly mentioned and, finally, the above results are implemented in writing down a path integral for a single spin.

•Jan 1, 2010•2 citations
For a restricted class of potential problems, the Feynman path integral in the coordinate representation circumvents operator-ordering ambiguities. We will show that, in the coherent-state representation, the traditional continuum time path integral cannot resolve this issue. Using a simple solvable model, we carry out a careful analysis of the continuum limit with regularization. The latter is found to be necessary to address the operator-ordering issue.
The definition and interpretation of canonical, phase space path integrals has evolved over many years to achieve a form that now admits a correct and rigorous formulation, which is also covariant under canonical coordinate transformations. Such formulations involve coherent state representations, which, in their modern version, were originally introduced as an alternative tool to construct phase space path integrals. Moreover, coherent state representations lead to physical interpretations that are more natural than those afforded by more traditional representations. Suitable continuous time regularization procedures lead to a covariant phase space path integral formulation that greatly clarifies the vague phrase that canonical quantization requires Cartesian coordinates.
Abstract Recently, doubts have been cast on the validity of the continuous-time coherent state path integral. This has led to controversies regarding the correct way of performing calculations with path integrals, and to several alternative definitions of what should be their continuous limit. Furthermore, the issue of a supposedly proper ordering of the Hamiltonian operator, entangled with the continuous-time limit, has led to considerable confusion in the literature. Since coherent state path integrals are at the basis of the modern formulation of many-body quantum theory, it should be laid on solid foundations. Here, we show that the issues raised above are coming from the illegitimate use of the (standard) rules of calculus, which are not necessarily valid in path integrals. This is well known in the context of stochastic equations, in particular in their path integral formulation. This insight allows for solving these issues and addressing the correspondence between the various orderings at the level of the path integral. We also use this opportunity to address the proper calculation of a functional determinant in the presence of a Hubbard–Stratonovich field, which shares in the controversies.
Infinitesimal propagators have been used in quantum-mechanical problems to establish ordering rules for classical quantities. Ambiguities arise in operator ordering as a result of the freedom of choice in evaluating the classical action over a short-time interval. The primitive quadrature rule employed in a short-time propagator establishes the quantum system associated with the classical Hamiltonian. Normal propagators are constructed from products of infinitesimal propagators and represent a compound quadrature in which the path is broken into line segments and a separate quadrature rule is applied to each line segment. It is demonstrated for Hamiltonians involving the vector potential that higher-order quadratures of the infinitesimal propagator all give a unique and proper ordering. Similarly, Hamiltonians that are products of powers of position x and momentum p, i.e., pl{\mathit{p}}^{\mathit{l}}plxm{\mathit{x}}^{\mathit{m}}xm, show some preference for Born-Jordon ordering as higher quadrature rules are applied. Unique orderings can be obtained in some cases by solving for the normal propagator. This is done for the Hamiltonian pl{\mathit{p}}^{\mathit{l}}plxm{\mathit{x}}^{\mathit{m}}xm by using a Fourier representation for the phase-space propagator. This formalism requires that both the momentum and position coordinates be represented by Fourier series. These results show that care must be taken when generating quantum-mechanical operators by using primitive quadrature rules in conjunction with a short-time propagator. These ambiguities are eliminated when the compound quadrature is performed to generate the normal propagator.
In this project two steps involved in the handling of path integrals are reexamined in detail for coherent state path integals. They concern the continuum limit approximation and the regularization of the formal path integrals. Restricting oneself to the harmonic oscillator, the technique of time splitting is used to set up the coherent state path integrals and the proper way to pass to the continuum limit is demonstrated. The manipulation of these path integrals calls for regularization procedures and the validity of discrete, Riemann zeta function and 'derivative' regularization methods is observed. A modification to a fermionic theory is briefly mentioned and, finally, the above results are implemented in writing down a path integral for a single spin.